Top-rated water heater pros.

Get matched with top water heater pros in New Berlin, WI

There are 21 highly-rated local water heater pros.

TRUSTED BY NEW BERLIN, WI HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.6
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon152
    Verified water heater services reviews

Water heater pros in New Berlin

Avatar for Mr. Holland's Home Services LLC

Mr. Holland's Home Services LLC

W204N16635 JACKSON DR
4.36(
238
)
Approved Pro

Mr. Holland's Home Services LLC

W204N16635 JACKSON DR
4.36(
238
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
364 local quotes requested
28 years of experience

As the trusted neighborhood HVAC service team in Milwaukee, Mr. Holland’s Home Services is committed to running their business based on five important principles: care, empathy, and trust, being always available, outworking the competition, quality workmanship, and using their “find a way” method. By keeping these five principles in mind, the business is able to deliver nothing less than excellent work when it comes to heating, air conditioning, and indoor air quality services. The professional team at Mr. Holland’s Home Services always gets the job done right. They never cut corners and are respectful of a customer’s property. Additionally, Mr. Holland’s takes their community involvement seriously; that they have a personal responsibility to help the people in their community, not just through quality services but also through the endless support they give to organizations and charities throughout Milwaukee and even outside the country. To learn more about Mr. Holland’s Home Services, please visit the company website or call the office today.

"I realize this is a long review. I’m not usually one to leave a review (good or bad), but this company absolutely disgusted me. Here’s why. I will never again use or recommend this company. I was caught in the “1,000 year flood” that knocked out my furnace control circuit board. I knew this, and was on the phone 9:30AM SUNDAY (8/10/25) morning explaining that’s the ONLY part I need. Was assured that a tech would get to me that day. I called all day every couple hours and there was zero movement. Come to find out the call service they use can’t see the cases and notes that the main office enters. Big blunder there. My last call was around 8:30PM. The person on the phone tells me that my appointment EXPIRED?!? Now I’m mad. I asked for the manager to call me back because this is unacceptable. They tell me I’ll hear from her within 48 hours. Called Monday morning (8/11/25), gave all the details from Sunday. The main office can see the notes and all my calls. Told them the exact part I need and they again told me someone will get to me as techs are out until 10PM. I still called back every 3 hours or so looking for updates. No one could give them to me. They keep telling me my “standing” in line is valid for an “emergency service”. Called every few hours with no movement. The tech actually called me personally later that night and asked if he can come now, that would have been a $199 “emergency service call” since it was after hours. I asked if he even had the part on the truck, and he didn’t. So why would he even want to come? I denied that service call while he confirmed with his boss and the distributor that they had a board in stock and put it on Will Call for me, and the tech will be there in the morning to install it (Tuesday 8/12/25). Tuesday morning comes, and my power goes out at 8:44AM per the WE Energies text message I got. The tech calls me shortly after and says he will be going to pick up the board and be to my house. I told him about the power and he said there wouldn’t be much use to come with no power. Makes sense. I told him I’ll call the main office the second it comes back on. I got the text of power restored at 3:34PM. I was on the phone with Mr Hollands at 3:35PM. After all this…they tell me the soonest a tech can get to me is THURSDAY EVENING. What. The. ****. They told me I was on the waitlist for cancellations and I could slot in earlier if possible. I asked if the person on the phone with me (Gabriel) to call me the next morning (Wednesday 8/13/25) with some sort of status. He assured me he would call me by 9AM. He didn’t. I called the office AGAIN at 9AM Wednesday morning. At this point I still haven’t heard from the customer relations manager (Danielle). Turns out she’s off on Wednesdays. I spoke to another sales person that actually got me moved from Thursday evening to Thursday morning. They FINALLY get to my house Thursday morning, replace the board and everything works. Since it was sewer water that knocked out the board I wanted to be sure the inside of the unit was clean. I asked what I had to do to get inside the unit and he showed me, but also said that if I were to do it I would “void the warranty” and it would be $199 for him to do it. Since Mr Hollands installed the system literally LAST YEAR (July 2024) I accepted that keeping the warranty was probably for the best. BUT. Now that I paid $199 for Mr Hollands to clean the inside, I literally watched the tech remove 6 screws then use MY shopvac, MY bleach, MY rags….why did I pay $200 for that?!? As of writing this, 8/21/25. I still have not heard from this Danielle person. 8 business days later, when I was assured I would hear back in 48 hours. I am EXTREMELY disgusted at the way I was treated, lied to, and hung up on by this company. Never again will I be calling them. I advise you to do the same."

Andrew R on August 2025

As the trusted neighborhood HVAC service team in Milwaukee, Mr. Holland’s Home Services is committed to running their business based on five important principles: care, empathy, and trust, being always available, outworking the competition, quality workmanship, and using their “find a way” method. By keeping these five principles in mind, the business is able to deliver nothing less than excellent work when it comes to heating, air conditioning, and indoor air quality services. The professional team at Mr. Holland’s Home Services always gets the job done right. They never cut corners and are respectful of a customer’s property. Additionally, Mr. Holland’s takes their community involvement seriously; that they have a personal responsibility to help the people in their community, not just through quality services but also through the endless support they give to organizations and charities throughout Milwaukee and even outside the country. To learn more about Mr. Holland’s Home Services, please visit the company website or call the office today.

"I realize this is a long review. I’m not usually one to leave a review (good or bad), but this company absolutely disgusted me. Here’s why. I will never again use or recommend this company. I was caught in the “1,000 year flood” that knocked out my furnace control circuit board. I knew this, and was on the phone 9:30AM SUNDAY (8/10/25) morning explaining that’s the ONLY part I need. Was assured that a tech would get to me that day. I called all day every couple hours and there was zero movement. Come to find out the call service they use can’t see the cases and notes that the main office enters. Big blunder there. My last call was around 8:30PM. The person on the phone tells me that my appointment EXPIRED?!? Now I’m mad. I asked for the manager to call me back because this is unacceptable. They tell me I’ll hear from her within 48 hours. Called Monday morning (8/11/25), gave all the details from Sunday. The main office can see the notes and all my calls. Told them the exact part I need and they again told me someone will get to me as techs are out until 10PM. I still called back every 3 hours or so looking for updates. No one could give them to me. They keep telling me my “standing” in line is valid for an “emergency service”. Called every few hours with no movement. The tech actually called me personally later that night and asked if he can come now, that would have been a $199 “emergency service call” since it was after hours. I asked if he even had the part on the truck, and he didn’t. So why would he even want to come? I denied that service call while he confirmed with his boss and the distributor that they had a board in stock and put it on Will Call for me, and the tech will be there in the morning to install it (Tuesday 8/12/25). Tuesday morning comes, and my power goes out at 8:44AM per the WE Energies text message I got. The tech calls me shortly after and says he will be going to pick up the board and be to my house. I told him about the power and he said there wouldn’t be much use to come with no power. Makes sense. I told him I’ll call the main office the second it comes back on. I got the text of power restored at 3:34PM. I was on the phone with Mr Hollands at 3:35PM. After all this…they tell me the soonest a tech can get to me is THURSDAY EVENING. What. The. ****. They told me I was on the waitlist for cancellations and I could slot in earlier if possible. I asked if the person on the phone with me (Gabriel) to call me the next morning (Wednesday 8/13/25) with some sort of status. He assured me he would call me by 9AM. He didn’t. I called the office AGAIN at 9AM Wednesday morning. At this point I still haven’t heard from the customer relations manager (Danielle). Turns out she’s off on Wednesdays. I spoke to another sales person that actually got me moved from Thursday evening to Thursday morning. They FINALLY get to my house Thursday morning, replace the board and everything works. Since it was sewer water that knocked out the board I wanted to be sure the inside of the unit was clean. I asked what I had to do to get inside the unit and he showed me, but also said that if I were to do it I would “void the warranty” and it would be $199 for him to do it. Since Mr Hollands installed the system literally LAST YEAR (July 2024) I accepted that keeping the warranty was probably for the best. BUT. Now that I paid $199 for Mr Hollands to clean the inside, I literally watched the tech remove 6 screws then use MY shopvac, MY bleach, MY rags….why did I pay $200 for that?!? As of writing this, 8/21/25. I still have not heard from this Danielle person. 8 business days later, when I was assured I would hear back in 48 hours. I am EXTREMELY disgusted at the way I was treated, lied to, and hung up on by this company. Never again will I be calling them. I advise you to do the same."

Andrew R on August 2025


Avatar for Badger Water LLC

Badger Water LLC

1001 N Page St
4.83(
6
)
Approved Pro

Badger Water LLC

1001 N Page St
4.83(
6
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
55 local quotes requested

Badger Water is family owned and operated. We have been in business for over 40 years. We are proud to provide service within 24 hours, if not immediately. Badger Water employees provide prompt, efficient and friendly service. Contact Badger Water today for a water analysis and the lowest prices for all your water needs.

"Fast! Very knowledgable."

Kevin H on November 2024

Badger Water is family owned and operated. We have been in business for over 40 years. We are proud to provide service within 24 hours, if not immediately. Badger Water employees provide prompt, efficient and friendly service. Contact Badger Water today for a water analysis and the lowest prices for all your water needs.

"Fast! Very knowledgable."

Kevin H on November 2024


Avatar for Premier Water Heaters

Premier Water Heaters

5.00(
17
)
Approved Pro

Premier Water Heaters

5.00(
17
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
189 local quotes requested

Here at Premier Water Heaters, we specialize in water heater installations. We take a very unique "no markup" approach to our water heaters, which helps keep our installations very affordable (usually at least $300.00 less than our competition). We also offer a "You buy it, we install it" option, which can save our customers even more money. Locally owned and operated, we have serviced the Southeast Wisconsin area for over 25 years. We run daily routes in the Milwaukee / Waukesha / Racine / Kenosha area as well as the Madison / Janesville / Beloit area. Please check out our customer reviews... They literally tell our whole story! Customer satisfaction has always been our primary concern, so be sure to give us a call today! (262)880-3373

"Joe was amazing. Was able to assist with our project next day and very available for questions prior (as I had many). Project was quick and done well. Will use him and premier water heaters again!"

Katie G on February 2025

Here at Premier Water Heaters, we specialize in water heater installations. We take a very unique "no markup" approach to our water heaters, which helps keep our installations very affordable (usually at least $300.00 less than our competition). We also offer a "You buy it, we install it" option, which can save our customers even more money. Locally owned and operated, we have serviced the Southeast Wisconsin area for over 25 years. We run daily routes in the Milwaukee / Waukesha / Racine / Kenosha area as well as the Madison / Janesville / Beloit area. Please check out our customer reviews... They literally tell our whole story! Customer satisfaction has always been our primary concern, so be sure to give us a call today! (262)880-3373

"Joe was amazing. Was able to assist with our project next day and very available for questions prior (as I had many). Project was quick and done well. Will use him and premier water heaters again!"

Katie G on February 2025


Avatar for VINCENT PLUMBING & HEATING

VINCENT PLUMBING & HEATING

W304S3925 Brookhill Rd
4.66(
32
)
Approved Pro

VINCENT PLUMBING & HEATING

W304S3925 Brookhill Rd
4.66(
32
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
78 local quotes requested

With over 30 years of experience spanning four generations, Vincent Plumbing is your trusted local expert for water heater installation, repair, and full-service plumbing. We are licensed, insured, and bonded, ensuring quality workmanship on every job. ✔ Water Heater Experts – Installation & repairs for all major brands ✔ Traditional & Tankless Systems – Energy-efficient solutions available ✔ Emergency Service & Same-Day Appointments – Get hot water fast ✔ Upfront Pricing – No hidden fees, no surprises ✔ 100% Satisfaction Guarantee – We stand behind our work ✨ Exclusive Angi Offer: Get $100 OFF a new water heater installation!

"Courteous, skilled, and quick.......but expensive! Less than one hours work plus a handful of parts...............$419.00 ?????"

Leo T on July 2024

With over 30 years of experience spanning four generations, Vincent Plumbing is your trusted local expert for water heater installation, repair, and full-service plumbing. We are licensed, insured, and bonded, ensuring quality workmanship on every job. ✔ Water Heater Experts – Installation & repairs for all major brands ✔ Traditional & Tankless Systems – Energy-efficient solutions available ✔ Emergency Service & Same-Day Appointments – Get hot water fast ✔ Upfront Pricing – No hidden fees, no surprises ✔ 100% Satisfaction Guarantee – We stand behind our work ✨ Exclusive Angi Offer: Get $100 OFF a new water heater installation!

"Courteous, skilled, and quick.......but expensive! Less than one hours work plus a handful of parts...............$419.00 ?????"

Leo T on July 2024


Avatar for Jensen Plumbing LLC

Jensen Plumbing LLC

4.68(
19
)
Approved Pro

Jensen Plumbing LLC

4.68(
19
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers
739 local quotes requested

Our team has quality experience in this industry, and we make sure our customers are happy before we leave. Call or click to schedule an estimate today!

"Very well. Only in need a copy of my receipt sent to [email protected]. The amount was $1436 and is needed immediately for State Farm insurance inspection tomorrow."

Gary G on September 2025

Our team has quality experience in this industry, and we make sure our customers are happy before we leave. Call or click to schedule an estimate today!

"Very well. Only in need a copy of my receipt sent to [email protected]. The amount was $1436 and is needed immediately for State Farm insurance inspection tomorrow."

Gary G on September 2025


Gans Plumbing

3712 Hickory Lane
5.00(
1
)
Approved Pro

Gans Plumbing

3712 Hickory Lane
5.00(
1
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
2 years of experience

We are committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers interests, and make their concerns the basis of our business.

"Called Eric, he called back within a couple of hours. Came over to my house that evening with a new hot water heater per my requested specs.. Got it installed in about 2 hours. He also rerouted my gas pipes to the new hot water heater to meet code. He also explained what he was doing and answered all my questions. I will call Gans Plumbing for any future plumbing needs."

Bruce H on November 2024

We are committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers interests, and make their concerns the basis of our business.

"Called Eric, he called back within a couple of hours. Came over to my house that evening with a new hot water heater per my requested specs.. Got it installed in about 2 hours. He also rerouted my gas pipes to the new hot water heater to meet code. He also explained what he was doing and answered all my questions. I will call Gans Plumbing for any future plumbing needs."

Bruce H on November 2024


Avatar for Specialized Home Handyman Services LLC

Specialized Home Handyman Services LLC

N166W21250 Glen Brooke Drive
5.00(
6
)
Approved Pro

Specialized Home Handyman Services LLC

N166W21250 Glen Brooke Drive
5.00(
6
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
6 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Custom Business Description Looking for reliable and expert home services in the Milwaukee metropolitan area? Look no further than Specialized Home Handyman Services LLC. With over 30 years of experience in the industry, our team of skilled professionals offers a wide range of services including Finnish carpentry, drywall installation and repairs, plaster repairs, kitchen and bathroom remodeling, custom cabinets and built-in units, and more. What sets us apart from our competitors is our commitment to quality and attention to detail. We take great pride in our work and strive to exceed our customers' expectations every time. Whether it's a small repair or a major renovation, we treat every project with the same level of care and dedication. We understand that home projects can be overwhelming and stressful, which is why we offer emergency services and quick response times to address any urgent needs. Our team is also licensed in the trade and offers competitive pricing,

"Very easy to work with. Was satisfied with the work done. He accommodated my schedule. I would hire him again."

Joan T on March 2021

Custom Business Description Looking for reliable and expert home services in the Milwaukee metropolitan area? Look no further than Specialized Home Handyman Services LLC. With over 30 years of experience in the industry, our team of skilled professionals offers a wide range of services including Finnish carpentry, drywall installation and repairs, plaster repairs, kitchen and bathroom remodeling, custom cabinets and built-in units, and more. What sets us apart from our competitors is our commitment to quality and attention to detail. We take great pride in our work and strive to exceed our customers' expectations every time. Whether it's a small repair or a major renovation, we treat every project with the same level of care and dedication. We understand that home projects can be overwhelming and stressful, which is why we offer emergency services and quick response times to address any urgent needs. Our team is also licensed in the trade and offers competitive pricing,

"Very easy to work with. Was satisfied with the work done. He accommodated my schedule. I would hire him again."

Joan T on March 2021


Avatar for Milwaukee Home Services

Milwaukee Home Services

P.O. Box 34
4.91(
28
)
Approved Pro

Milwaukee Home Services

P.O. Box 34
4.91(
28
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers
12 years of experience

Milwaukee Home Services is providing the best quality at the best prices around. Licensed and insured Master Plumber and Dwelling Contractor in Wisconsin. Call 414-248-3805 with general questions. We provide plumbing repair and installation services. Over 20 years experience in residential home repairs and commercial maintenance. We value honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. We can obtain permits for our customers if needed. We pride ourselves on the quality of our work as well as our commitment to outstanding results. We look forward to building lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction!

"John was AWESOME! He was very responsive, timely and knowledgeable. He explained my problem and the solution, so that I understood the what, where & why. I would hire him again and recommend him to my friends, family and business contacts definitely! 5-Stars Princess- Milwaukee, WI"

Princess B on June 2025

Milwaukee Home Services is providing the best quality at the best prices around. Licensed and insured Master Plumber and Dwelling Contractor in Wisconsin. Call 414-248-3805 with general questions. We provide plumbing repair and installation services. Over 20 years experience in residential home repairs and commercial maintenance. We value honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. We can obtain permits for our customers if needed. We pride ourselves on the quality of our work as well as our commitment to outstanding results. We look forward to building lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction!

"John was AWESOME! He was very responsive, timely and knowledgeable. He explained my problem and the solution, so that I understood the what, where & why. I would hire him again and recommend him to my friends, family and business contacts definitely! 5-Stars Princess- Milwaukee, WI"

Princess B on June 2025


Avatar for Vincent Plumbing & Heating

Vincent Plumbing & Heating

W304 S 3925 Brookhill Road
4.74(
354
)
Approved Pro

Vincent Plumbing & Heating

W304 S 3925 Brookhill Road
4.74(
354
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
21 local quotes requested

Need hot water fast? Vincent Plumbing has been the trusted name in plumbing for over 30 years, providing top-quality water heater installation, repair, and maintenance for homeowners like you. ✔ Licensed, Insured & Bonded – Quality You Can Trust ✔ Expert Installation & Repairs for All Water Heater Brands ✔ Traditional & Tankless Water Heater Specialists ✔ Same-Day & Emergency Service Available ✔ Upfront Pricing – No Hidden Fees, No Surprises

"Professional and reasonable. A"

Jessica J on April 2025

Need hot water fast? Vincent Plumbing has been the trusted name in plumbing for over 30 years, providing top-quality water heater installation, repair, and maintenance for homeowners like you. ✔ Licensed, Insured & Bonded – Quality You Can Trust ✔ Expert Installation & Repairs for All Water Heater Brands ✔ Traditional & Tankless Water Heater Specialists ✔ Same-Day & Emergency Service Available ✔ Upfront Pricing – No Hidden Fees, No Surprises

"Professional and reasonable. A"

Jessica J on April 2025


Avatar for Exterior Pros, LLC

Exterior Pros, LLC

W227 N6270 Sussex Road
4.53(
34
)
Approved Pro

Exterior Pros, LLC

W227 N6270 Sussex Road
4.53(
34
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers
13 years of experience

We are a family owned home improvement company out of Sussex Wisconsin. We service Waukesha, Milwaukee, Washington, & parts of Ozaukee, Dodge, Racine, and Kenosha counties. We focus on the quality products we install & service, while maintaining a high level of customer service. We are proud to be recognized as a GAF Master Elite Contractor for roofing projects. We also provide fantastic siding & windows, as well as entry doors. We also specialize in bathroom and shower areas, converting tubs to showers or showers to tubs. Beautiful acrylic shower surrounds or tub liner inserts make any old bathroom wet space new again. We work efficiently with our resources to ensure your project is completed on time and on budget. We bring old-world, quality craftsmanship to every unique project we take on. We are licensed and insured & look forward to building strong, long-lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction. Call today for a Free Estimate 262-456-3530

"the contractor did a great job"

Vicki S on January 2023

We are a family owned home improvement company out of Sussex Wisconsin. We service Waukesha, Milwaukee, Washington, & parts of Ozaukee, Dodge, Racine, and Kenosha counties. We focus on the quality products we install & service, while maintaining a high level of customer service. We are proud to be recognized as a GAF Master Elite Contractor for roofing projects. We also provide fantastic siding & windows, as well as entry doors. We also specialize in bathroom and shower areas, converting tubs to showers or showers to tubs. Beautiful acrylic shower surrounds or tub liner inserts make any old bathroom wet space new again. We work efficiently with our resources to ensure your project is completed on time and on budget. We bring old-world, quality craftsmanship to every unique project we take on. We are licensed and insured & look forward to building strong, long-lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction. Call today for a Free Estimate 262-456-3530

"the contractor did a great job"

Vicki S on January 2023

...
Showing 1-10 of 212
Water Heaters questions, answered by experts

Price variations arise from size, type (tankless or tank), efficiency grades, and installation complexity, including labor and materials.

Basements, specifically those without any air conditioning, are the best location for a hybrid water heater. These rooms are less likely to experience extreme temperature fluctuations, which can affect your hybrid water heater’s efficiency and performance. Basements often have more than enough space for their tanks and proper air circulation. Hybrid water heaters can also be a bit noisy, but putting them in your basement will keep the noise away from your main living areas.

Unless they are connected to the same system, boilers and water heaters will both need their own expansion tanks. The only case they wouldn’t have separate expansion tanks is if the boiler is pulling double duty and managing a heating system while also supplying hot water for a home. In which case, you may not need a hot water heater.

A water heater is one of the heaviest hitters in your home, and it needs as much power as possible to help it run efficiently and effectively.

Your water heater should be on its own dedicated circuit breaker, with no other power sources running to it. This is required to meet the National Electric Code–and to ensure it runs as efficiently as possible.

If you’re having problems with your hot water heater and it’s 10 to 15 years old—the typical life span of a gas hot water heater—you may want to consider replacing it rather than repairing it. Water heater replacement costs about $1,300 on average. If your water heater is younger than nine or 10 years, paying for repairs is most likely worth it. You can always have a plumber assess your fixture to see what it would cost to fix it and then decide if it’s more cost-effective in the long run to replace it.

By submitting this question, I acknowledge and agree that Angi may publicly display my name, city, state, and question on the website for professionals and others to see.

The New Berlin, WI homeowners’ guide to water heater services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.