If you’re wondering why there’s a basement toilet in the middle of the room, we’ve got answers
A Pittsburgh toilet is a standalone toilet installed in your basement without walls, originally designed to contain sewage backups from affecting your home's main living areas.
Expect to pay $50 to $200 for toilet removal or $225 to $550 for installation, with costs reaching $1,300 if your basement needs additional plumbing work.
You can convert your existing Pittsburgh potty into a finished bathroom by adding walls, flooring, and fixtures to create a convenient space for your basement.
Hiring a local toilet professional helps you remove outdated fixtures or transform your basement space into a functional bathroom with proper plumbing and installation.
There’s something strange about walking down the basement stairs to see a random toilet out in the open. But once you discover the history of the Pittsburgh toilet, you’ll have some context for this seemingly out-of-place feature. Whether you decide to keep this piece of Americana or ditch it, it’s up to you.
A Pittsburgh toilet (also known as a “Pittsburgh potty”) is a standalone toilet installed in a basement in the middle of the room, with no walls for privacy. Sometimes, the space also includes a shower, sink, or concrete tub. Although they’re called Pittsburgh toilets, they’re not exclusive to that city.
Homes built between the 1880s and before World War II may have these fixtures. During this period, sewage backups were common. The filthy flooding would affect the home’s lowest plumbing fixture. Installing a basement toilet prevented sewage from seeping into the home’s main living areas, and homeowners could simply scrub the bare cement flooring to clean up.
The Pittsburgh toilet is a relic of a bygone era of plumbing, but its name comes from Pittsburgh’s booming steel industry. According to Today, when the city became an industrial hub in the late 19th century, steel workers would get covered in dirt, dust, and grime during their shift. Rather than tracking a mess through their home after work, they’d enter through the basement, where they’d clean themselves up. Think of it as an old-fashioned mudroom—but with bathroom fixtures like a shower and the notorious Pittsburgh toilet.
The Pittsburgh toilet seems a little awkward to some when removed from its historical context, but there are some reasons you may want to keep it:
You have a messy job or hobby and want an easily accessible and easy-to-clean toilet where you won’t drag dirt through your home
You’re planning a remodel that puts your other bathrooms out of commission
You only have one bathroom and could use an extra toilet
To preserve the history of your home
If you keep the toilet, consider adding some sort of enclosure, like a bathroom stall. With the plumbing hookups already in place, you can consider adding a bathroom if you plan to finish your basement.
Despite the rich Pittsburgh potty history, there are a few reasons you might not want one in your home:
Some homebuyers think of them as an eyesore, but it depends on personal preferences
Without a stall or enclosure, they don’t have the privacy of a toilet in a regular bathroom
If you don’t use it, it will be another fixture you’ll need to maintain
They’re mostly obsolete since modern plumbing can handle fixtures on multiple levels
If you’re not confident about removing a toilet yourself or don’t fancy struggling up the basement stairs with this bulky item, hire someone to disconnect and dispose of your outdated Pittsburgh toilet for you. Toilet removal costs $50 to $200, depending on the job. If you’re ready to say bye to your Pittsburgh toilet, don’t hesitate to call a toilet pro near you to remove it.
One thing is for sure—an extra bathroom is convenient. Since the Pittsburgh potty in your home is already functional, all you need to do is install walls, flooring, and fixtures. This is a bonus when you consider that the bulk of the cost to install a toilet is the labor to put in the toilet and the drainpipe. You could DIY parts of the project, but call a plumber in your area for plumbing work.
Why not take advantage of what you already have, especially if you’re doing a whole basement remodel? There are many reasons to add a bathroom to your basement, like increasing your home’s value. If you want to kick back and relax in your new game room, home theater, or hobby room, having a nearby bathroom in the basement will make the space even more convenient.
The cost of installing a toilet is between $225 and $550 for most homeowners. To add an extra toilet to your basement, you’ll pay slightly more if you don’t already have plumbing hookups and need additional piping. In some cases, you may spend as much as $1,300.
Since Pittsburgh toilets are mostly backup toilets to use after work or a messy hobby, you can choose a bare-bones toilet model to save some cash.
A Pittsburgh toilet—now considered an obsolete, historical feature—won’t add much value to your home on its own. If you already have a Pittsburgh toilet, consider converting the space into a half bath or a water closet. A bathroom addition does add value to a home, especially in one that only has a single toilet.
If you add a midrange or upscale bathroom to your home, you can expect an ROI of about 55%. A bathroom addition is particularly valuable if you only have one full bathroom, as a second bathroom can make the home more livable for large households with children.
You can save an average of 40% to 65% by doing the labor for a basement bathroom remodel project yourself. However, whether you want to tackle this time-consuming and technical job depends on your experience level and the project's scope.
If the plumbing is already in place and in good working order, and the basement is finished, it could easily be a project within reach of a handy homeowner. A large, unfinished basement with dodgy plumbing is a bigger challenge and one best left to a local bathroom remodeling contractor. You might need building permits and specialized equipment, and a licensed local plumber and electrician should deal with complex plumbing and wiring work.
Positive experience. As previously stated, the replacement/repair could not be completed (no fault of the plumbing tech) b/c misinformation was rec?d by property management maintenance. Thanks to the plumbing tech for your efforts. Appreciate you!
The WaterworksIf you want to pay the most exorbitant prices possible for your job, this is the company for you. “By the job” pricing is a rip-off, at least how these people use it. Every job is plugged into a category and prices are set by category. You might have a job that takes half an hour or one that...
Benjamin Franklin PlumbingCole has been handling plumbing and general contracting for our four properties over the past three years, and he’s always done a great job. Most recently, he installed a sink and countertop in our retail store where none existed before, and it turned out exactly how we needed. He’s...
ANB Renovations LLCMatt is a consummate professional. The work turned out to be far more difficult than expected and rather than turn the job down, Matt rose to the occasion and completed a near impossible task. I can not recommend Greene's Plumbing Service more highly. On a scale of 1-5 I would give Matt a...
Greene's Plumbing ServiceInvolved an extensive bathroom remodel, including removing tub & installing walk in shower, new drywall, custome tile work to ceiling, plumbing, etc. Overall, job was done on time and on budget. Nick & his team were very professional and had high attention to detail. Quality was great. Highly...
Stamos Flooring and Remodeling LLCAwesome company. Had a jacuzzi tub taken out and replaced with huge walk in shower with partial glass enclosure. Onyx to the ceiling with a decorative border, moved plumbing and installed hand held shower, new ceiling, flooring, and paint. Replaced window with glass block. Everything was done...
Columbus Bath DesignThe initial quoted price from a walk-through seemed high, but we discussed that the quote represented worst case scenario (re-wiring to two floors) and we were excited about the opportunity to have the work done in a timely manner with closing for fire safety reasons, etc. When the job was...
Initially, I called the Service People to have a leaking garbage disposal replaced. I had purchased a special deal through Angie's List: $79 for $200-worth of plumbing services. <br /> When I went to schedule the work, the earliest date I could get through Angie's List was after the upcoming...
This company did a very good job on the brick wall and it looks just amazing. The staff was always professional and was practically OCD on how the bricks were stacked and how they were laid. Although it took longer than expected, I am willing to sacrifice time over perfection anyday. The...
My Handy Mate LLC Improvement & Remodeling<p>I am so glad we called Rotor-Rooter. I was hesitant to call them because we usually prefer to give business to local providers. But when we had sewage back up in our basement on a Saturday evening, I had a hard time getting a hold of someone, not to mention the high weekend/evening rate...
Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water CleanupFrom average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
When you flush the toilet, what’s going on in there? Depending on the type of toilet, the system works in different ways. Here’s how a toilet flushes.
Toilets are a mainstay of American bathrooms, but is it time for a bidet? Before you decide, here’s everything you need to know about bidets versus toilets.
Leaky toilet tank sounds driving you crazy? It might be your toilet flapper. Here’s how to choose the right size toilet flapper to save water and money.
Remodeling a bathroom? Toilet dimensions matter more than you think. This guide will tell you everything you need to know—from seat height to clearance.
If your toilet is leaking at the base, it can be a cause for concern. So grab some towels to stop the flow and explore these six common culprits for a leaky base.
Save big bucks by installing a new toilet with your DIY skills. Follow this guide to learn how to install a toilet or replace one with a brand-new model.
