Get matched with top plumbers in Shelter Island, NY
There are 40 highly-rated local plumbers.
Need a pro for your plumbing project in Shelter Island, NY?
Select your specific project to find the pro for you.
TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS
4.5 Average homeowner rating
858 Verified plumbing services reviews
Verified Reviews for Plumbing pros in Shelter Island, NY
*The Angi rating for Plumbing companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Plumbing needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Plumbing companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Plumbing needs.
Last update on September 27, 2025
Find Plumbers in Shelter Island
Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp.
54 Park Ave
Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp.
54 Park Ave
Customers say: True professional
187 local quotes requested
54 years of experience
Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp. has been trusted and recommended since 1971, and recognized for our superb service. We are family owned and operated, with guaranteed great service. Our company specializes in all types of work, but especially: Plumbing, Gas Heating, Drain Cleaning, Oil to Gas Conversions, NYS RPZ Testing to name a few things. Call & schedule your appointment today! 631-666-9315
"Didn't show up on day scheduled, failed to call. Replaced ~$100 part in about a half hour. Charge was $595"
Bruce M on April 2025
Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp. has been trusted and recommended since 1971, and recognized for our superb service. We are family owned and operated, with guaranteed great service. Our company specializes in all types of work, but especially: Plumbing, Gas Heating, Drain Cleaning, Oil to Gas Conversions, NYS RPZ Testing to name a few things. Call & schedule your appointment today! 631-666-9315
"Didn't show up on day scheduled, failed to call. Replaced ~$100 part in about a half hour. Charge was $595"
Bruce M on April 2025
Flush Busters
Flush Busters
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
52 local quotes requested
Full service plumbing company doing new construction and home service including 24/7 emergency service. No hot water at 1am? Call us. No heat at 3am? Call us. Clogged toilet on a Sunday? Call us. Frozen pipe in a blizzard? Call us. Flooded house? Call us. Slab leak? Call us. "A hot shower no matter the hour" we love to say! All of our work is warrantied for 1 year (with longer warranties available) which includes bot only the work but the parts and material as well. We wear booties and/or remove shoes in your home, always! Call us for all of your plumbing problems if you want somebody that you can trust and can ask hundreds of questions without an impatient technician losing his cool. Because we are there to HELP and we are at your service!
"Victor responds quickly and gets the job done for a fair price. I would definitely use him again!"
Jerold M on September 2025
Full service plumbing company doing new construction and home service including 24/7 emergency service. No hot water at 1am? Call us. No heat at 3am? Call us. Clogged toilet on a Sunday? Call us. Frozen pipe in a blizzard? Call us. Flooded house? Call us. Slab leak? Call us. "A hot shower no matter the hour" we love to say! All of our work is warrantied for 1 year (with longer warranties available) which includes bot only the work but the parts and material as well. We wear booties and/or remove shoes in your home, always! Call us for all of your plumbing problems if you want somebody that you can trust and can ask hundreds of questions without an impatient technician losing his cool. Because we are there to HELP and we are at your service!
"Victor responds quickly and gets the job done for a fair price. I would definitely use him again!"
Jerold M on September 2025
PRIORITY CESSPOOL SEWER & DRAIN, INC
PO Box 450
PRIORITY CESSPOOL SEWER & DRAIN, INC
PO Box 450
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers
127 local quotes requested
At Priority Cesspool we Install, service and maintaine cesspool & septic systems as well as providing sewer & drain cleaning services. Priority Cesspool is a full service cesspool, sewer & drain company. N.Y.S. Dec Lic # 1A-873 Member L.I.L.W.A. (L.I. Liquid Waste Ass.) Member B.B.B. Suffolk County License #44528-LW DBA of Clear River Environmental Service Corp
"Everything went well"
Jeanne D on August 2024
At Priority Cesspool we Install, service and maintaine cesspool & septic systems as well as providing sewer & drain cleaning services. Priority Cesspool is a full service cesspool, sewer & drain company. N.Y.S. Dec Lic # 1A-873 Member L.I.L.W.A. (L.I. Liquid Waste Ass.) Member B.B.B. Suffolk County License #44528-LW DBA of Clear River Environmental Service Corp
"Everything went well"
Jeanne D on August 2024
Proto Plumbing & Heating
188 Hubbard Ave
Proto Plumbing & Heating
188 Hubbard Ave
3 years of experience
Free onsite estimate
With years of experience, Proto Plumbing and Heating is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers' interests and make their concerns the basis of our business. Call us today!
"They did not complete the effective job that they said they going to do."
Chasiki B on October 2022
With years of experience, Proto Plumbing and Heating is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers' interests and make their concerns the basis of our business. Call us today!
"They did not complete the effective job that they said they going to do."
Chasiki B on October 2022
Handi-Bath Remodeling
16 Allen Point Rd
Handi-Bath Remodeling
16 Allen Point Rd
28 local quotes requested
25 years of experience
With over 20 years of experience in the industry, Handibath Remodeling is your industry expert on Long Island. We pride ourselves on our extreme professionalism and attention to detail. Give us a call today, we look forward to working with you!
"I hired Handi-Bath on the recommendation of the senior care agency that provided care to my 94 year old mother. In order to accommodate mom's move to the first floor of the house, we worked with Handi-Bath to make the entire first floor ADA compliant. Specifically, Joe and his team ripped out the small bathroom on the first floor and created a beautiful oasis of comfort for my mom with a walk-in shower with bench and grab bars; higher toilet seat with grab bars; installing an ADA-sink vanity to accommodate a potential wheelchair; widened doors to fit a potential wheelchair; created pocket doors and worked seamlessly and timely in order to complete the job in two weeks, which was out timeframe. Joe (Nickel), owner, was always available and worked with us on any requested last minute changes until we were 100% satisfied. I would definitely recommend Handi-Bath to anyone doing a renovation, and especially those who require an ADA compliant bathroom for an elderly or disabled loved one. "
Steven L on August 2025
With over 20 years of experience in the industry, Handibath Remodeling is your industry expert on Long Island. We pride ourselves on our extreme professionalism and attention to detail. Give us a call today, we look forward to working with you!
"I hired Handi-Bath on the recommendation of the senior care agency that provided care to my 94 year old mother. In order to accommodate mom's move to the first floor of the house, we worked with Handi-Bath to make the entire first floor ADA compliant. Specifically, Joe and his team ripped out the small bathroom on the first floor and created a beautiful oasis of comfort for my mom with a walk-in shower with bench and grab bars; higher toilet seat with grab bars; installing an ADA-sink vanity to accommodate a potential wheelchair; widened doors to fit a potential wheelchair; created pocket doors and worked seamlessly and timely in order to complete the job in two weeks, which was out timeframe. Joe (Nickel), owner, was always available and worked with us on any requested last minute changes until we were 100% satisfied. I would definitely recommend Handi-Bath to anyone doing a renovation, and especially those who require an ADA compliant bathroom for an elderly or disabled loved one. "
Steven L on August 2025
Mayjac Plumbing, Inc.
P.O Box 1258
Mayjac Plumbing, Inc.
P.O Box 1258
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
10 years of experience
At MayJac Plumbing Inc. we're dedicated to providing our clients with the very best service, installation, and repairs for all phases of their plumbing needs. We specialize in a variety of residential and commercial services and take pride in the attention to detail we put into each of the projects we're involved with. Our goal at MayJac is to maintain a relationship with every customer for life. MayJac Plumbing Inc. is fully licensed and insured. We have over 18 years of experience. Call us today at (631) 909-1829 to discuss your all plumbing needs!
"Joe was great."
Nicholas U on June 2024
At MayJac Plumbing Inc. we're dedicated to providing our clients with the very best service, installation, and repairs for all phases of their plumbing needs. We specialize in a variety of residential and commercial services and take pride in the attention to detail we put into each of the projects we're involved with. Our goal at MayJac is to maintain a relationship with every customer for life. MayJac Plumbing Inc. is fully licensed and insured. We have over 18 years of experience. Call us today at (631) 909-1829 to discuss your all plumbing needs!
"Joe was great."
Nicholas U on June 2024
Grant Heating & Cooling, Inc.
48 Route 114
Grant Heating & Cooling, Inc.
48 Route 114
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
35 local quotes requested
Family owned and operated since 1969, Grant Heating & Cooling is a knowledgeable and dependable resource for meeting all your comfort needs. Contact us for installation, maintenance or service
"I contracted with Grant Heating & Cooling Inc. to install HVAC system in my home in the spring of 2024. They were very professional and did a very good job. In the winter of 2025 I had a minor problem with one of the Mitsubishi heat pump system units. The company was quick to troubleshoot the situation. The technicians were courteous, knowledgeable about the system and thorough. It required several visits to diagnose the problem and fix it. The manager, Nick was very responsive to the situation which required bringing out an expert from Mitsubishi. All of this work was covered under my warranty. The problem was fixed and I could not speak highly enough about the company’s policies and customer service. I would highly recommend them for all facets of their work and standing behind their installations. I am very happy to be working with them for my continued maintenance. They are an excellent company. Sincerely, Susan Coursey"
Susan C on May 2025
Family owned and operated since 1969, Grant Heating & Cooling is a knowledgeable and dependable resource for meeting all your comfort needs. Contact us for installation, maintenance or service
"I contracted with Grant Heating & Cooling Inc. to install HVAC system in my home in the spring of 2024. They were very professional and did a very good job. In the winter of 2025 I had a minor problem with one of the Mitsubishi heat pump system units. The company was quick to troubleshoot the situation. The technicians were courteous, knowledgeable about the system and thorough. It required several visits to diagnose the problem and fix it. The manager, Nick was very responsive to the situation which required bringing out an expert from Mitsubishi. All of this work was covered under my warranty. The problem was fixed and I could not speak highly enough about the company’s policies and customer service. I would highly recommend them for all facets of their work and standing behind their installations. I am very happy to be working with them for my continued maintenance. They are an excellent company. Sincerely, Susan Coursey"
Susan C on May 2025
P.J. Fitzpatrick, LLC
21 Industrial Boulevard
P.J. Fitzpatrick, LLC
21 Industrial Boulevard
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers
140 local quotes requested
Why? Quite simply, because we strive for perfection. If you are hoping we will use cheaper materials, hurry through an installation, or overlook restrictions, P.J. Fitzpatrick, LLC, is not the company for you. We believe that when it comes to your home, the job should be done perfectly and last a lifetime. This might not make us the cheapest company in the area, but we stand behind our work and leave our customers extremely satisfied. So much that they refer friends, family and neighbors without hesitation. If something goes wrong with our installation, it's not your fault, it's ours. Our responsibility doesn't end once we pack up our tools and leave. If something breaks, malfunctions, or just plain doesn't make you happy, we'll fix it - for as long as you live in your home. Full lifetime warranties are included with many of our services. We also have 18 Repair Experts who do repairs all day, every day and love it! Experience the P.J. Fitzpatrick, LLC., difference today!
"Very professional and curteous"
Wilbur B on February 2023
Why? Quite simply, because we strive for perfection. If you are hoping we will use cheaper materials, hurry through an installation, or overlook restrictions, P.J. Fitzpatrick, LLC, is not the company for you. We believe that when it comes to your home, the job should be done perfectly and last a lifetime. This might not make us the cheapest company in the area, but we stand behind our work and leave our customers extremely satisfied. So much that they refer friends, family and neighbors without hesitation. If something goes wrong with our installation, it's not your fault, it's ours. Our responsibility doesn't end once we pack up our tools and leave. If something breaks, malfunctions, or just plain doesn't make you happy, we'll fix it - for as long as you live in your home. Full lifetime warranties are included with many of our services. We also have 18 Repair Experts who do repairs all day, every day and love it! Experience the P.J. Fitzpatrick, LLC., difference today!
"Very professional and curteous"
Wilbur B on February 2023
Master Remodelers
Covering Suffolk County
Master Remodelers
Covering Suffolk County
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
29 local quotes requested
We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service. Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule an estimate today!
"Master remodelers did a fantastic job without any complications. Joe and the team were very professional and efficient. My kitchen looks beautiful. Highly Recommend!"
Kathleen M on May 2025
We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service. Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule an estimate today!
"Master remodelers did a fantastic job without any complications. Joe and the team were very professional and efficient. My kitchen looks beautiful. Highly Recommend!"
Kathleen M on May 2025
Arthur DeRosa Building and Remodeling
10 Aldrich St
Arthur DeRosa Building and Remodeling
10 Aldrich St
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
225 local quotes requested
We are a building, remodeling, home improvement firm backed with 31 yrs experience. I, Arthur DeRosa, personally over see every project, big or small, from start to finish. I have an artists soul and every project that I am privileged to do is a reflection of that. With performance backed by experience and attention to detail, your project will be in good hands. The number of employees varies depending on work load. Sub-contractors are used when necessary. Proposals and estimates are free and include payment schedules with start and completion dates. Super Service Award winner for 2016! Call us today to schedule your appointment - (631) 774-1231
"Artie & Mike are simply the best. I used them to: 1) Build a LARGE extension to my house and redo my entire kitchen and dining room. The job was completed on time and on budget. Throughout the process Artie was transparent & professional. EVERY person who has stepped into my house has complimented at the detailed perfection. 3) Artie built us a custom walk in pantry 2) Built 2 large decks in the backyard as well as an outdoor shower. This project was completed on time, on budget while exceeding all expectations. If you are looking for a contractor and crew that is responsible, responsive, polite, creative and delivers the HIGHEST LEVEL of quality - Artie is the one."
Constantine M on March 2023
We are a building, remodeling, home improvement firm backed with 31 yrs experience. I, Arthur DeRosa, personally over see every project, big or small, from start to finish. I have an artists soul and every project that I am privileged to do is a reflection of that. With performance backed by experience and attention to detail, your project will be in good hands. The number of employees varies depending on work load. Sub-contractors are used when necessary. Proposals and estimates are free and include payment schedules with start and completion dates. Super Service Award winner for 2016! Call us today to schedule your appointment - (631) 774-1231
"Artie & Mike are simply the best. I used them to: 1) Build a LARGE extension to my house and redo my entire kitchen and dining room. The job was completed on time and on budget. Throughout the process Artie was transparent & professional. EVERY person who has stepped into my house has complimented at the detailed perfection. 3) Artie built us a custom walk in pantry 2) Built 2 large decks in the backyard as well as an outdoor shower. This project was completed on time, on budget while exceeding all expectations. If you are looking for a contractor and crew that is responsible, responsive, polite, creative and delivers the HIGHEST LEVEL of quality - Artie is the one."
Constantine M on March 2023
Plumbing questions, answered by experts
By submitting this question, I acknowledge and agree that Angi may publicly display my name, city, state, and question on the website for professionals and others to see.
The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to plumbing services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Making updates to your home? You may need to move your gas line to fuel new appliances or meet code regulations. We’ll cover the cost of moving a gas line, plus project tips.
A main water shut-off valve controls water flow for your entire home. Here we break down the cost to replace a main water shut-off valve.
This guide to toilet installation cost covers what you can expect to pay when adding a new toilet to an existing or new bathroom.
What is a shower cartridge? This small component is often overlooked, but it’s a key part of your shower plumbing. This guide will show you how it works.
Understanding the difference between plumber's putty and silicone will help you choose the right one for the job—read on to find out more.
Rerouting plumbing lines in a slab foundation can save your dream home from drowning. Take a look at when and why a plumber might reroute your pipes.
- Shelter Island Heights, NY Plumbers
- Greenport, NY Plumbers
- Southold, NY Plumbers
- Peconic, NY Plumbers
- Sag Harbor, NY Plumbers
- Bridgehampton, NY Plumbers
- Orient, NY Plumbers
- Cutchogue, NY Plumbers
- Wainscott, NY Plumbers
- East Hampton, NY Plumbers
- Southampton, NY Plumbers
- Water Mill, NY Plumbers
- Mattituck, NY Plumbers
- Amagansett, NY Plumbers
- Laurel, NY Plumbers
- Jamesport, NY Plumbers
- Aquebogue, NY Plumbers
- Hampton Bays, NY Plumbers
- Old Saybrook, CT Plumbers
- Westbrook, CT Plumbers
- Lyme, CT Plumbers
- Old Lyme, CT Plumbers
- Clinton, CT Plumbers
- Niantic, CT Plumbers
- Riverhead, NY Plumbers
- East Quogue, NY Plumbers
- Ivoryton, CT Plumbers
- Montauk, NY Plumbers
- Fishers Island, NY Plumbers
- Essex, CT Plumbers
- Outdoor Kitchens in Shelter Island
- Water Softeners in Shelter Island
- Pool Construction and Installation in Shelter Island
- Lawn Irrigation in Shelter Island
- Sewer Cleaning in Shelter Island
- Kitchen and Bathroom Remodel in Shelter Island
- Septic Tanks in Shelter Island
- Basement Remodel in Shelter Island
- Countertops and Backsplashes in Shelter Island
- Wells and Pumps in Shelter Island
- Pool and Spa Servicing in Shelter Island
- Home Warranties in Shelter Island
- Home Inspection in Shelter Island
- Fountains in Shelter Island
- Drain Pipe Installation in Shelter Island
- Mold Testing and Remediation in Shelter Island
- Heating and Air Conditioning in Shelter Island
- Unfinished Carpentry in Shelter Island
- Gas Leak Repair in Shelter Island
- Drain Cleaning in Shelter Island
- Appliance Repair in Shelter Island
- Modular and Mobile Home Remodel in Shelter Island
- Water and Smoke Damage Repair in Shelter Island
- Water Heaters in Shelter Island