Top-rated tub and shower conversion pros.

Get matched with top tub and shower conversion pros in Shelter Island, NY

There are 58 highly-rated local tub and shower conversion pros.

Need a pro for your tub and shower conversion project in Shelter Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon454
    Verified tub and shower conversion services reviews

Verified Reviews for Tub And Shower Conversion pros in Shelter Island, NY

Last update on October 11, 2025

Find Tub and shower conversion pros in Shelter Island

Avatar for Final Touch Restoration

Final Touch Restoration

856-2 Johnson Ave.
New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro

Final Touch Restoration

856-2 Johnson Ave.
New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro
30 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Final Touch Restoration Specializes in all phases of Remodeling and Restoration services. From Window, Door, Floor, Kitchens, and Bathroom installations to Water, Wind, Mold, Fire, and Smoke remediation to total home cleaning services. There is no project too small or too large for us to handle.

Final Touch Restoration Specializes in all phases of Remodeling and Restoration services. From Window, Door, Floor, Kitchens, and Bathroom installations to Water, Wind, Mold, Fire, and Smoke remediation to total home cleaning services. There is no project too small or too large for us to handle.

Avatar for Quest Home and Office Renovations

Quest Home and Office Renovations

2 Kay St.
5.00(
9
)
•Approved Pro

Quest Home and Office Renovations

2 Kay St.
5.00(
9
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
13 local quotes requested

Quest has been serving the Long Island Area in remodeling homes for over 30 years. We specialize in residential work and deal directly with the homeowners for a more personal and comfortable experience. We know the place you live is an important part of your life and take great care in making sure that the job is completed to your satisfaction. The owner of the company is present and working at every job providing full attention to your project. We make sure that you not only receive the best service possible, but we make sure we leave your home... SPOTLESS! Call us today to get a FREE quote!

"I think the quality was extremely satisfactory if there's anything that we found that we were not happy with, they are very responsive and will rectify everything to our satisfaction. Mike as the primary contractor they used other contractors for select basis of the construction like demolition, electrical, plumbing and sheetrock spackle, we're satisfied with all of them as well, they were very professional and accommodating. Mike used consumers kitchen and bath as the supplier of the kitchen cabinets and countertops for which we are also satisfied, The overall finished product has resulted a modern update of our kitchen in which we are extremely proud of and we would definitely recommend Quest Home and Office Renovation for a remodel of another consumers kitchen."

Joseoh T on April 2023

Quest has been serving the Long Island Area in remodeling homes for over 30 years. We specialize in residential work and deal directly with the homeowners for a more personal and comfortable experience. We know the place you live is an important part of your life and take great care in making sure that the job is completed to your satisfaction. The owner of the company is present and working at every job providing full attention to your project. We make sure that you not only receive the best service possible, but we make sure we leave your home... SPOTLESS! Call us today to get a FREE quote!

"I think the quality was extremely satisfactory if there's anything that we found that we were not happy with, they are very responsive and will rectify everything to our satisfaction. Mike as the primary contractor they used other contractors for select basis of the construction like demolition, electrical, plumbing and sheetrock spackle, we're satisfied with all of them as well, they were very professional and accommodating. Mike used consumers kitchen and bath as the supplier of the kitchen cabinets and countertops for which we are also satisfied, The overall finished product has resulted a modern update of our kitchen in which we are extremely proud of and we would definitely recommend Quest Home and Office Renovation for a remodel of another consumers kitchen."

Joseoh T on April 2023

MGT Construction Corp

Based Out Of
4.15(
13
)
•Approved Pro

MGT Construction Corp

Based Out Of
4.15(
13
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
78 local quotes requested

We specialize in all phases of remodeling for your home, business, bathrooms, kitchens, finishing basements, and more! We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out all the services we offer below and call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Steven was great, was very responsive, very knowledgeable, very honest, did what he said. I would hire him again! Completed the job on time. Did quality work and very good value for money. He did extra stuff for free as a courtesy."

Vincent R on September 2025

We specialize in all phases of remodeling for your home, business, bathrooms, kitchens, finishing basements, and more! We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out all the services we offer below and call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Steven was great, was very responsive, very knowledgeable, very honest, did what he said. I would hire him again! Completed the job on time. Did quality work and very good value for money. He did extra stuff for free as a courtesy."

Vincent R on September 2025

Avatar for Allied Construction Corp

Allied Construction Corp

26 Pagnotta Dr
4.45(
161
)
•Approved Pro

Allied Construction Corp

26 Pagnotta Dr
4.45(
161
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
34 local quotes requested
36 years of experience

**We are now specializing in Kitchen Remodeling**At this time we are unable to take on Bathroom Remodeling projects**Our first priority has always been the satisfaction of our customers, and we take great pride in both the quality of our work and the quality of the customer service we extend to each and every one of our clients, regardless of the size of their project. When trusting Allied Construction Corporation with your home remodeling project, you are trusting a crew of dedicated and talented home remodeling experts to take you through every single step of the process, and to keep you up to date on developments. We always treat your project – and your home – with the utmost level of care and respect. We strive to ensure that every last detail of your work order is performed with the same level of quality we would apply to our own home. Our work over the years has proven to yield exceptionally high return on investment, making your home not only the haven you envisioned but also more valuable. What is more, we provide extremely affordable home remodeling services, making it possible for you to see your vision come to life without breaking the bank. We also offer Angie's List members a 10% Discount on all Labor. We have been on the Discovery Channel. (References upon request). Additional Phone: 516-500-8170 Additional email: [email protected].

"RUN FAR AWAY FROM ALLIED AND TOM. Tom took my money and did not complete the renovations as per our contract. He lied about having a licensed electrician to do electrical work, it was just one of his workers who's not licensed. I paid for a dumpster and when it was delivered by tom it was already half full from another allied job and I was asked to pay the full amount of $950. Tom didn't listen to anything I said regarding the work I requested and he changed my design and did work that was cheaper for him. I was priced for one of my ceiling's to be ripped out and reinstalled with new sheetrock, Tom waited until I was away on business then he installed sheetrock on top of the bad sheetrock and told me he ripped out the old sheetrock and installed the new sheetrock, I found out when my EC cut holes to install lights and we found 2 layers of sheetrock preventing the lights from being able to be installed. Allied construction is a cheap, sneaky company who will steal your money and breach your contract. Do not hire these people Tom is a lair. Tom wore a gun in my house on his hip and told me "I use this to get paid by customer who don't want to pay". Tom left live 120v wires hanging out of the walls and ceiling, he removed a banister and didn't replace it for 3 weeks making my home very unsafe for me and my 9 year old son."

Adam C on May 2025

**We are now specializing in Kitchen Remodeling**At this time we are unable to take on Bathroom Remodeling projects**Our first priority has always been the satisfaction of our customers, and we take great pride in both the quality of our work and the quality of the customer service we extend to each and every one of our clients, regardless of the size of their project. When trusting Allied Construction Corporation with your home remodeling project, you are trusting a crew of dedicated and talented home remodeling experts to take you through every single step of the process, and to keep you up to date on developments. We always treat your project – and your home – with the utmost level of care and respect. We strive to ensure that every last detail of your work order is performed with the same level of quality we would apply to our own home. Our work over the years has proven to yield exceptionally high return on investment, making your home not only the haven you envisioned but also more valuable. What is more, we provide extremely affordable home remodeling services, making it possible for you to see your vision come to life without breaking the bank. We also offer Angie's List members a 10% Discount on all Labor. We have been on the Discovery Channel. (References upon request). Additional Phone: 516-500-8170 Additional email: [email protected].

"RUN FAR AWAY FROM ALLIED AND TOM. Tom took my money and did not complete the renovations as per our contract. He lied about having a licensed electrician to do electrical work, it was just one of his workers who's not licensed. I paid for a dumpster and when it was delivered by tom it was already half full from another allied job and I was asked to pay the full amount of $950. Tom didn't listen to anything I said regarding the work I requested and he changed my design and did work that was cheaper for him. I was priced for one of my ceiling's to be ripped out and reinstalled with new sheetrock, Tom waited until I was away on business then he installed sheetrock on top of the bad sheetrock and told me he ripped out the old sheetrock and installed the new sheetrock, I found out when my EC cut holes to install lights and we found 2 layers of sheetrock preventing the lights from being able to be installed. Allied construction is a cheap, sneaky company who will steal your money and breach your contract. Do not hire these people Tom is a lair. Tom wore a gun in my house on his hip and told me "I use this to get paid by customer who don't want to pay". Tom left live 120v wires hanging out of the walls and ceiling, he removed a banister and didn't replace it for 3 weeks making my home very unsafe for me and my 9 year old son."

Adam C on May 2025

Avatar for Hampton Bay Construction - Babylon Bay Construction

Hampton Bay Construction - Babylon Bay Construction

280 Central Ave
4.94(
98
)
•Approved Pro

Hampton Bay Construction - Babylon Bay Construction

280 Central Ave
4.94(
98
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers
70 local quotes requested

Owner owned & operated. Full service remodeling company specializing in medium to large projects. Serving Suffolk county and the Hamptons. High end building and remodeling firm. Expect excellent quality and customer service. Permit and Variance Specialists.

"We went over everything that was going to be done step by step both A.J. and Sam explained and guided us in the process. All came in at budget and in a timely manner. They were clean and reliable. I Will use them for my next project! ps. All of their recommendations for plumbing, electrical and painting were fantastic."

VINCENT S on March 2025

Owner owned & operated. Full service remodeling company specializing in medium to large projects. Serving Suffolk county and the Hamptons. High end building and remodeling firm. Expect excellent quality and customer service. Permit and Variance Specialists.

"We went over everything that was going to be done step by step both A.J. and Sam explained and guided us in the process. All came in at budget and in a timely manner. They were clean and reliable. I Will use them for my next project! ps. All of their recommendations for plumbing, electrical and painting were fantastic."

VINCENT S on March 2025

Avatar for Hampton Contracting

Hampton Contracting

128 Underwood Drive
5.00(
5
)
•Approved Pro

Hampton Contracting

128 Underwood Drive
5.00(
5
)
•Approved Pro
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
15 local quotes requested

We are a quality contracting company serving the Hamptons for over 20 years! From small scale projects such as deck construction, siding, and window installation to complete home renovations. You name it we'll get it done.

"Excellent - very professional & neat ! A pleasure to work with ."

Viviane P on January 2025

We are a quality contracting company serving the Hamptons for over 20 years! From small scale projects such as deck construction, siding, and window installation to complete home renovations. You name it we'll get it done.

"Excellent - very professional & neat ! A pleasure to work with ."

Viviane P on January 2025

OnCall Kitchen & Bath

64 Woodbine Drive
New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro

OnCall Kitchen & Bath

64 Woodbine Drive
New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro
38 local quotes requested

We guarantee your satisfaction and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule a free estimate today.

We guarantee your satisfaction and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule a free estimate today.

Avatar for star22home

star22home

22 Plainfield Ave
4.64(
74
)
•Approved Pro

star22home

22 Plainfield Ave
4.64(
74
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
41 local quotes requested

Our mission is to service our customers in a prompt and professional manner. We do not consider a home improvement or remodeling project complete until the work is finished, the job site is clean, and the customer is completely satisfied. Licensed & Insured since 1997

"This is an overdue review. I hired Bernie and his team for a kitchen remodel in June 2021, after he did an excellent job with my three bathrooms in 2020. The kitchen remodel was also excellent. His works are efficient, hardworking and clean. My remodel took two weeks, as he had quoted and for the exact price he had quoted. I would hire him and his team again and I referred them to a coworker for her bathroom project. She was also very pleased with their work."

Maria C on January 2025

Our mission is to service our customers in a prompt and professional manner. We do not consider a home improvement or remodeling project complete until the work is finished, the job site is clean, and the customer is completely satisfied. Licensed & Insured since 1997

"This is an overdue review. I hired Bernie and his team for a kitchen remodel in June 2021, after he did an excellent job with my three bathrooms in 2020. The kitchen remodel was also excellent. His works are efficient, hardworking and clean. My remodel took two weeks, as he had quoted and for the exact price he had quoted. I would hire him and his team again and I referred them to a coworker for her bathroom project. She was also very pleased with their work."

Maria C on January 2025

Avatar for Unlimited Outdoor Designs

Unlimited Outdoor Designs

435 Brook Ave Unit 21
4.24(
21
)
•Approved Pro

Unlimited Outdoor Designs

435 Brook Ave Unit 21
4.24(
21
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Terrific value
245 local quotes requested
12 years of experience

Unlimited Outdoor Designs, specializing in Indoor Kitchens and Baths and Basement remodels. Fencing, Decks, Railings, Concrete, and Masonry work. We are family-owned and take pride in treating our clients like family. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing.

"Was professional and got it done in a timely fashion."

Michael N on May 2024

Unlimited Outdoor Designs, specializing in Indoor Kitchens and Baths and Basement remodels. Fencing, Decks, Railings, Concrete, and Masonry work. We are family-owned and take pride in treating our clients like family. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing.

"Was professional and got it done in a timely fashion."

Michael N on May 2024

Avatar for Just Right Carpentry & Painting

Just Right Carpentry & Painting

10 Byron Pl
4.74(
190
)
•Approved Pro

Just Right Carpentry & Painting

10 Byron Pl
4.74(
190
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers
311 local quotes requested

Just Right Carpentry, Painting Inc., has served Suffolk County for decades with pride and integrity. Family owned and specializing in a range of carpentry and painting; we have the knowledge and expertise to recommend the work to truly fit your homes needs. Please call us for a free estimate. We do not use sub contractors. Charge by the job. No travel/trip charges apply.

"I just can’t say enough about Just Right carpentry and paint. Joe and his brother, Tom did an amazing job painting the inside and outside of our house. They were very fair with their prices. They showed up bright and early every day and worked a full day. I give them five stars all the way."

Arlene S on October 2025

Just Right Carpentry, Painting Inc., has served Suffolk County for decades with pride and integrity. Family owned and specializing in a range of carpentry and painting; we have the knowledge and expertise to recommend the work to truly fit your homes needs. Please call us for a free estimate. We do not use sub contractors. Charge by the job. No travel/trip charges apply.

"I just can’t say enough about Just Right carpentry and paint. Joe and his brother, Tom did an amazing job painting the inside and outside of our house. They were very fair with their prices. They showed up bright and early every day and worked a full day. I give them five stars all the way."

Arlene S on October 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 209

FAQs for tub and shower conversion projects in Shelter Island, NY

The cost of home remodeling is $50,000 for the average homeowner. However, this cost can range anywhere from $3,000 for a small project to $170,000 for a whole home remodel. Factors like project size, location, and room type all affect your overall cost. For example, bedroom remodeling costs are one of the least expensive projects, costing about $1,500 to $5,500 per bedroom. However, a kitchen remodel has a significant cost range, totaling anywhere from $14,500 to over $70,000.

Generally, general contractors charge between $50 and $150 hourly, though not every contractor charges by the hour. If charging based on the project, you can expect a markup of 10% to 20% of the construction cost. You can expect to pay between $300 and $500 daily if charged by the day.

Yes, most states require home remodeling contractors to be licensed, and for good reason. Hiring an unlicensed home remodeling contractor could lead to poor quality work, costly future expenses, and potential code violations. 

As you browse our pro listings, take note of the “Angi Approved” badge. Angi Approved businesses meet our standards for certification which include:

  • The owner, principal, or relevant manager passed a criminal background check

  • Required to have applicable state and local licenses

  • Maintain an average star rating of 3.0 or better on our network, if they have at least one review

  • Paying to advertise their services

  • Meeting any other eligibility criteria required by Angi

Keep in mind licensing is different from certifications. A license is a legal requirement to operate a business, while certifications are voluntary.

While city and state laws vary on general contractor licensing requirements, hiring an unlicensed general contractor could lead to poor quality work, costly future expenses, and potential code violations. Be sure to check our state licensing tool to review the local general contractor guidelines for your area.

As you browse our pro listings, take note of the “Angi Approved” badge. Angi Approved businesses meet our standards for certification which include:

  • The owner, principal, or relevant manager passed a criminal background check

  • Required to have applicable state and local licenses

  • Maintain an average star rating of 3.0 or better on our network, if they have at least one review

  • Paying to advertise their services

  • Meeting any other eligibility criteria required by Angi

Keep in mind licensing is different from certifications. A license is a legal requirement to operate a business, while certifications are voluntary.

The best time of year to remodel your home is late winter and early spring when fewer homeowners are thinking about projects and pros are more available. Also consider the type of remodel you want and plan ahead as much as possible. For example, the summer is a great time of year to update your fireplace, but winter is a better option for fixing foundations and building room additions.

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to tub and shower conversion services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles