Top-rated toilet pros.

Get matched with top toilet pros in Shelter Island, NY

There are 35 highly-rated local toilet pros.

Need a pro for your toilet service project in Shelter Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.6
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon1.3k+
    Verified toilet services reviews

Verified Reviews for Toilet Service pros in Shelter Island, NY

*The Angi rating for Toilet Service companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Toilet Service needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Toilet Service companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Toilet Service needs.

Last update on November 06, 2025

Find Toilet pros in Shelter Island

Avatar for Quest Home and Office Renovations

Quest Home and Office Renovations

2 Kay St.
5.00(
9
)
•Approved Pro

Quest Home and Office Renovations

2 Kay St.
5.00(
9
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
13 local quotes requested

Quest has been serving the Long Island Area in remodeling homes for over 30 years. We specialize in residential work and deal directly with the homeowners for a more personal and comfortable experience. We know the place you live is an important part of your life and take great care in making sure that the job is completed to your satisfaction. The owner of the company is present and working at every job providing full attention to your project. We make sure that you not only receive the best service possible, but we make sure we leave your home... SPOTLESS! Call us today to get a FREE quote!

"I think the quality was extremely satisfactory if there's anything that we found that we were not happy with, they are very responsive and will rectify everything to our satisfaction. Mike as the primary contractor they used other contractors for select basis of the construction like demolition, electrical, plumbing and sheetrock spackle, we're satisfied with all of them as well, they were very professional and accommodating. Mike used consumers kitchen and bath as the supplier of the kitchen cabinets and countertops for which we are also satisfied, The overall finished product has resulted a modern update of our kitchen in which we are extremely proud of and we would definitely recommend Quest Home and Office Renovation for a remodel of another consumers kitchen."

Joseoh T on April 2023

Quest has been serving the Long Island Area in remodeling homes for over 30 years. We specialize in residential work and deal directly with the homeowners for a more personal and comfortable experience. We know the place you live is an important part of your life and take great care in making sure that the job is completed to your satisfaction. The owner of the company is present and working at every job providing full attention to your project. We make sure that you not only receive the best service possible, but we make sure we leave your home... SPOTLESS! Call us today to get a FREE quote!

"I think the quality was extremely satisfactory if there's anything that we found that we were not happy with, they are very responsive and will rectify everything to our satisfaction. Mike as the primary contractor they used other contractors for select basis of the construction like demolition, electrical, plumbing and sheetrock spackle, we're satisfied with all of them as well, they were very professional and accommodating. Mike used consumers kitchen and bath as the supplier of the kitchen cabinets and countertops for which we are also satisfied, The overall finished product has resulted a modern update of our kitchen in which we are extremely proud of and we would definitely recommend Quest Home and Office Renovation for a remodel of another consumers kitchen."

Joseoh T on April 2023

Avatar for star22home

star22home

22 Plainfield Ave
4.64(
74
)
•Approved Pro

star22home

22 Plainfield Ave
4.64(
74
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
40 local quotes requested

Our mission is to service our customers in a prompt and professional manner. We do not consider a home improvement or remodeling project complete until the work is finished, the job site is clean, and the customer is completely satisfied. Licensed & Insured since 1997

"This is an overdue review. I hired Bernie and his team for a kitchen remodel in June 2021, after he did an excellent job with my three bathrooms in 2020. The kitchen remodel was also excellent. His works are efficient, hardworking and clean. My remodel took two weeks, as he had quoted and for the exact price he had quoted. I would hire him and his team again and I referred them to a coworker for her bathroom project. She was also very pleased with their work."

Maria C on January 2025

Our mission is to service our customers in a prompt and professional manner. We do not consider a home improvement or remodeling project complete until the work is finished, the job site is clean, and the customer is completely satisfied. Licensed & Insured since 1997

"This is an overdue review. I hired Bernie and his team for a kitchen remodel in June 2021, after he did an excellent job with my three bathrooms in 2020. The kitchen remodel was also excellent. His works are efficient, hardworking and clean. My remodel took two weeks, as he had quoted and for the exact price he had quoted. I would hire him and his team again and I referred them to a coworker for her bathroom project. She was also very pleased with their work."

Maria C on January 2025

Avatar for Unlimited Outdoor Designs

Unlimited Outdoor Designs

435 Brook Ave Unit 21
4.24(
21
)
•Approved Pro

Unlimited Outdoor Designs

435 Brook Ave Unit 21
4.24(
21
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Terrific value
214 local quotes requested
12 years of experience

Unlimited Outdoor Designs, specializing in Indoor Kitchens and Baths and Basement remodels. Fencing, Decks, Railings, Concrete, and Masonry work. We are family-owned and take pride in treating our clients like family. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing.

"Was professional and got it done in a timely fashion."

Michael N on May 2024

Unlimited Outdoor Designs, specializing in Indoor Kitchens and Baths and Basement remodels. Fencing, Decks, Railings, Concrete, and Masonry work. We are family-owned and take pride in treating our clients like family. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing.

"Was professional and got it done in a timely fashion."

Michael N on May 2024

Avatar for PRIORITY CESSPOOL SEWER & DRAIN, INC

PRIORITY CESSPOOL SEWER & DRAIN, INC

PO Box 450
4.82(
260
)
•Approved Pro

PRIORITY CESSPOOL SEWER & DRAIN, INC

PO Box 450
4.82(
260
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers
147 local quotes requested

At Priority Cesspool we Install, service and maintaine cesspool & septic systems as well as providing sewer & drain cleaning services. Priority Cesspool is a full service cesspool, sewer & drain company. N.Y.S. Dec Lic # 1A-873 Member L.I.L.W.A. (L.I. Liquid Waste Ass.) Member B.B.B. Suffolk County License #44528-LW DBA of Clear River Environmental Service Corp

"Everything went well"

Jeanne D on August 2024

At Priority Cesspool we Install, service and maintaine cesspool & septic systems as well as providing sewer & drain cleaning services. Priority Cesspool is a full service cesspool, sewer & drain company. N.Y.S. Dec Lic # 1A-873 Member L.I.L.W.A. (L.I. Liquid Waste Ass.) Member B.B.B. Suffolk County License #44528-LW DBA of Clear River Environmental Service Corp

"Everything went well"

Jeanne D on August 2024

Avatar for Ixhua Masonry & Landscaping, LLC

Ixhua Masonry & Landscaping, LLC

47 Ponquogue Ave.
New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro

Ixhua Masonry & Landscaping, LLC

47 Ponquogue Ave.
New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro
5 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Ixhua Masonry & Landscaping, LLC is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers interests and make their concerns the basis of our business.**Over 10 Years Experience**

Ixhua Masonry & Landscaping, LLC is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers interests and make their concerns the basis of our business.**Over 10 Years Experience**

Avatar for Proto Plumbing & Heating

Proto Plumbing & Heating

188 Hubbard Ave
3.88(
4
)
•Approved Pro

Proto Plumbing & Heating

188 Hubbard Ave
3.88(
4
)
•Approved Pro
3 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

With years of experience, Proto Plumbing and Heating is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers' interests and make their concerns the basis of our business. Call us today!

"They did not complete the effective job that they said they going to do."

Chasiki B on October 2022

With years of experience, Proto Plumbing and Heating is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers' interests and make their concerns the basis of our business. Call us today!

"They did not complete the effective job that they said they going to do."

Chasiki B on October 2022

Avatar for Allied Construction Corp.

Allied Construction Corp.

26 Pagnotta Drive
5.00(
17
)
•Approved Pro

Allied Construction Corp.

26 Pagnotta Drive
5.00(
17
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
15 years of experience

At Allied Construction Corp., we focus on quality kitchen remodel projects over quantity. We use our years of experience and expertise to complete your project with perfection. Customer service and honesty are the most important aspects of our business and your satisfaction is guaranteed. Please call us today for an estimate. We look forward to working with you.

"Got me good different kitchen planning and floor done right for me in time ..."

Keith R on September 2025

At Allied Construction Corp., we focus on quality kitchen remodel projects over quantity. We use our years of experience and expertise to complete your project with perfection. Customer service and honesty are the most important aspects of our business and your satisfaction is guaranteed. Please call us today for an estimate. We look forward to working with you.

"Got me good different kitchen planning and floor done right for me in time ..."

Keith R on September 2025

Avatar for 5 Stars Cabinetry, Inc.

5 Stars Cabinetry, Inc.

197 Hawthorne Street
5.00(
4
)
•Approved Pro

5 Stars Cabinetry, Inc.

197 Hawthorne Street
5.00(
4
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
11 years of experience

5 Stars Cabinetry, Inc. is a local construction company committed to excellence in every aspect of what we offer to the market place. We have over 17 years experience in this field! We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and individual accountability. Our distinction is the quality of service and the experience we deliver to our clients. Accurate knowledge of our trade fueled by passion combined with efficient systems is what makes us true professionals. Above all,5 Stars Cabinetry, Inc. understands and prioritizes your interest, as it's the foundation of our business.

"A job well done, punctual, they cleaned up."

Cesar G on October 2022

5 Stars Cabinetry, Inc. is a local construction company committed to excellence in every aspect of what we offer to the market place. We have over 17 years experience in this field! We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and individual accountability. Our distinction is the quality of service and the experience we deliver to our clients. Accurate knowledge of our trade fueled by passion combined with efficient systems is what makes us true professionals. Above all,5 Stars Cabinetry, Inc. understands and prioritizes your interest, as it's the foundation of our business.

"A job well done, punctual, they cleaned up."

Cesar G on October 2022

Avatar for Mayjac Plumbing, Inc.

Mayjac Plumbing, Inc.

P.O Box 1258
4.92(
13
)
•Approved Pro

Mayjac Plumbing, Inc.

P.O Box 1258
4.92(
13
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
10 years of experience

At MayJac Plumbing Inc. we're dedicated to providing our clients with the very best service, installation, and repairs for all phases of their plumbing needs. We specialize in a variety of residential and commercial services and take pride in the attention to detail we put into each of the projects we're involved with. Our goal at MayJac is to maintain a relationship with every customer for life. MayJac Plumbing Inc. is fully licensed and insured. We have over 18 years of experience. Call us today at (631) 909-1829 to discuss your all plumbing needs!

"Joe was great."

Nicholas U on June 2024

At MayJac Plumbing Inc. we're dedicated to providing our clients with the very best service, installation, and repairs for all phases of their plumbing needs. We specialize in a variety of residential and commercial services and take pride in the attention to detail we put into each of the projects we're involved with. Our goal at MayJac is to maintain a relationship with every customer for life. MayJac Plumbing Inc. is fully licensed and insured. We have over 18 years of experience. Call us today at (631) 909-1829 to discuss your all plumbing needs!

"Joe was great."

Nicholas U on June 2024

Avatar for Grant Heating & Cooling, Inc.

Grant Heating & Cooling, Inc.

48 Route 114
4.83(
66
)
•Approved Pro

Grant Heating & Cooling, Inc.

48 Route 114
4.83(
66
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
38 local quotes requested

Family owned and operated since 1969, Grant Heating & Cooling is a knowledgeable and dependable resource for meeting all your comfort needs. Contact us for installation, maintenance or service

"I contracted with Grant Heating & Cooling Inc. to install HVAC system in my home in the spring of 2024. They were very professional and did a very good job. In the winter of 2025 I had a minor problem with one of the Mitsubishi heat pump system units. The company was quick to troubleshoot the situation. The technicians were courteous, knowledgeable about the system and thorough. It required several visits to diagnose the problem and fix it. The manager, Nick was very responsive to the situation which required bringing out an expert from Mitsubishi. All of this work was covered under my warranty. The problem was fixed and I could not speak highly enough about the company’s policies and customer service. I would highly recommend them for all facets of their work and standing behind their installations. I am very happy to be working with them for my continued maintenance. They are an excellent company. Sincerely, Susan Coursey"

Susan C on May 2025

Family owned and operated since 1969, Grant Heating & Cooling is a knowledgeable and dependable resource for meeting all your comfort needs. Contact us for installation, maintenance or service

"I contracted with Grant Heating & Cooling Inc. to install HVAC system in my home in the spring of 2024. They were very professional and did a very good job. In the winter of 2025 I had a minor problem with one of the Mitsubishi heat pump system units. The company was quick to troubleshoot the situation. The technicians were courteous, knowledgeable about the system and thorough. It required several visits to diagnose the problem and fix it. The manager, Nick was very responsive to the situation which required bringing out an expert from Mitsubishi. All of this work was covered under my warranty. The problem was fixed and I could not speak highly enough about the company’s policies and customer service. I would highly recommend them for all facets of their work and standing behind their installations. I am very happy to be working with them for my continued maintenance. They are an excellent company. Sincerely, Susan Coursey"

Susan C on May 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 223
Toilets questions, answered by experts

If you notice that your toilet is leaking puddles near the base, the leak is coming from your toilet bowl, and the water could be unsanitary. This is a situation that needs to be dealt with immediately—call a nearby plumbing repair pro right away. A contained leak from tank to bowl is not as urgent a situation, but it could be raising the cost of your water bill—have it looked at as soon as you can.

Snaking a toilet is similar to clearing sinks and bathtubs, but there are unique circumstances where you’d have to drain, disassemble, and remove the toilet to fix the clog. For stubborn clogs in the toilet trap, a toilet auger—designed with a shorter cable and a protective plastic encasing—can navigate the tight bends and clear the clog without risking damage to the porcelain. 

While a leak may seem small, even a gentle trickle of consistent moisture can lead to mold problems in your bathroom. Make sure you know how to check for mold if your toilet has been leaking for a while. Pooling water by your toilet also poses a risk for someone slipping on the slick floor of your bathroom. Finally, a leak of any size can lead to water waste that increases your water bill.

To test for toilet leaks, use water coloring in the water tank and see if the water slips into the bowl from the tank. This test will indicate if there’s a problem with the flapper or refill tube. You can also put water coloring in the bowl of the toilet to see if there is a leak there. If there is, you should see the colored water on the outside of the toilet bowl or on the floor. 

Yes, a toilet and shower can share a vent, which can simplify the plumbing installation and save space in your home. You’ll just need to make sure that the vent and associated plumbing are large enough to meet your local plumbing codes and handle the demands of both without compromising the efficacy of the vent. A qualified plumber can ensure that the vent is properly installed and adheres to local codes.

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to toilet services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"