Top-rated hardwood flooring pros.

Get matched with top hardwood flooring pros in Shelter Island, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your hardwood flooring service project in Shelter Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.5
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon73
    Verified hardwood flooring services reviews

Find Hardwood flooring pros in Shelter Island

Avatar for Talex home improvement, inc.

Talex home improvement, inc.

5.00(
57
)

Talex home improvement, inc.

5.00(
57
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We offer all phases of home improvements including: painting, carpentry, kitchens, bathrooms, basements, roofing, siding, decks and full additions just to name a few. We listen to the needs of each individual client and our goal is to make sure we deliver. We treat your home as if it were our own. We make an extra effort to cover any belongings and keep dust to a minimum. We shop vac each job after completion and make sure the client is happy with the end product. We also offer handyman services . No job to big or to small. We do it all. Many satisfied repeat clients. Super service award winner 2016, 2017,2019,2020,2021 and 2022.

"I am extremely happy with the way the deck looks now. Not only was the work completed in a timely manner, but the quality of the workmanship and the attention to detail was amazing. Also, the care taken to remove the pieces of the old deck were really appreciated. In addition, it was a pleasure to work with Chuck from Talex."

Pam S on September 2023

We offer all phases of home improvements including: painting, carpentry, kitchens, bathrooms, basements, roofing, siding, decks and full additions just to name a few. We listen to the needs of each individual client and our goal is to make sure we deliver. We treat your home as if it were our own. We make an extra effort to cover any belongings and keep dust to a minimum. We shop vac each job after completion and make sure the client is happy with the end product. We also offer handyman services . No job to big or to small. We do it all. Many satisfied repeat clients. Super service award winner 2016, 2017,2019,2020,2021 and 2022.

"I am extremely happy with the way the deck looks now. Not only was the work completed in a timely manner, but the quality of the workmanship and the attention to detail was amazing. Also, the care taken to remove the pieces of the old deck were really appreciated. In addition, it was a pleasure to work with Chuck from Talex."

Pam S on September 2023


G.J. Custom Renovations, LLC

4.91(
45
)

G.J. Custom Renovations, LLC

4.91(
45
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Carpenter by trade, with more than 10 years of experience in home renovation projects. Experience includes, but not limited to: Kitchen renovations, Bathroom renovations, & Custom woodwork, including custom kitchen cabinets, Minor repairs, Deck building and repairs, Door and window installations. Attention to detail and excellence in all my work.

"A convict, out on parole, was sent as a member of the team to work unsupervised in our home. We were never informed of this until an incident requiring police involvement occurred."

Suan M on November 2025

Carpenter by trade, with more than 10 years of experience in home renovation projects. Experience includes, but not limited to: Kitchen renovations, Bathroom renovations, & Custom woodwork, including custom kitchen cabinets, Minor repairs, Deck building and repairs, Door and window installations. Attention to detail and excellence in all my work.

"A convict, out on parole, was sent as a member of the team to work unsupervised in our home. We were never informed of this until an incident requiring police involvement occurred."

Suan M on November 2025


Avatar for Class Carpet & Interiors

Class Carpet & Interiors

4.89(
83
)

Class Carpet & Interiors

4.89(
83
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Super Service Award Winner 4 Years in a Row! 1 Year Interest Free Financing. Family owned since 1989, Class Carpet & Interiors is the one-stop shop for all your remodeling & restoration needs. We carry every brand & service! We're well known for our personalized service, top-notch installation team and products & services to satisfy every preference and budget. Specializing in: -ALL Types of Flooring -ALL Types of Window Treatments -ALL Types of Upholstery Services -Wood Floor Refinishing -Area Rugs -Carpet, Rug, & Upholstery Cleaning -Interior Painting -Kitchen & Bath

"It went really well"

Danica V on June 2018

Super Service Award Winner 4 Years in a Row! 1 Year Interest Free Financing. Family owned since 1989, Class Carpet & Interiors is the one-stop shop for all your remodeling & restoration needs. We carry every brand & service! We're well known for our personalized service, top-notch installation team and products & services to satisfy every preference and budget. Specializing in: -ALL Types of Flooring -ALL Types of Window Treatments -ALL Types of Upholstery Services -Wood Floor Refinishing -Area Rugs -Carpet, Rug, & Upholstery Cleaning -Interior Painting -Kitchen & Bath

"It went really well"

Danica V on June 2018


Avatar for Dan Bozzo Spackling & Taping

Dan Bozzo Spackling & Taping

5.00(
56
)

Dan Bozzo Spackling & Taping

5.00(
56
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

631-839-3948. New construction and renovation work. We sheetrock jobs when needed, spackle new construction jobs, renovations and repairs and skim coat old walls to make them look new. Call Dan directly to schedule an appointment 631-839-3948.

"I completely recommend Dan Bozzo Spackling to do the job! I used their service for the first time, and I was completely thrilled with the work they did!!! Dan and his team are dedicated and professional and not interested in doing something simply so they can charge you for it. Instead, they work carefully with you, and together you decide on the best approach for your job. Dan’s team has been instrumental in helping to get my sheetrock and spackling job done right. Before Dan, I had another company start the job, but it was incorrectly done and so bad, that I needed to remove the sheetrock and have it replaced. This is where Dan’s team came in. They removed the bad sheetrock and installed new sheetrock correctly and spackled the area and several other areas in my house. The job looked so good, the spackle is smooth and seamless, and the ceiling looks great!!! Also, the team was so neat and cleaned up after finishing the job. Dan is very amiable and easy to work with. He is quick to respond, very professional and honest. He is responsible and timely in attending to every situation. This is how a business like this should be run. Dan Bozzo Spackling is easily the best Spackling and Sheetrock company in town, and it would be a mistake not to hire them as soon as possible. I will recommend them to anyone who needs this service. In summary, I would highly recommend them and would gladly continue to work with them again."

Angela R on February 2024

631-839-3948. New construction and renovation work. We sheetrock jobs when needed, spackle new construction jobs, renovations and repairs and skim coat old walls to make them look new. Call Dan directly to schedule an appointment 631-839-3948.

"I completely recommend Dan Bozzo Spackling to do the job! I used their service for the first time, and I was completely thrilled with the work they did!!! Dan and his team are dedicated and professional and not interested in doing something simply so they can charge you for it. Instead, they work carefully with you, and together you decide on the best approach for your job. Dan’s team has been instrumental in helping to get my sheetrock and spackling job done right. Before Dan, I had another company start the job, but it was incorrectly done and so bad, that I needed to remove the sheetrock and have it replaced. This is where Dan’s team came in. They removed the bad sheetrock and installed new sheetrock correctly and spackled the area and several other areas in my house. The job looked so good, the spackle is smooth and seamless, and the ceiling looks great!!! Also, the team was so neat and cleaned up after finishing the job. Dan is very amiable and easy to work with. He is quick to respond, very professional and honest. He is responsible and timely in attending to every situation. This is how a business like this should be run. Dan Bozzo Spackling is easily the best Spackling and Sheetrock company in town, and it would be a mistake not to hire them as soon as possible. I will recommend them to anyone who needs this service. In summary, I would highly recommend them and would gladly continue to work with them again."

Angela R on February 2024


Avatar for Artisan Interior Contracting LLC

Artisan Interior Contracting LLC

5.00(
27
)

Artisan Interior Contracting LLC

5.00(
27
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Artisan Contracting LLC is a full service, owner operated, residential contracting company.. We plan and remodel residential bathrooms and kitchens, install tile floors, walls, back-splashes, etc. We move walls and install load-bearing headers to create larger spaces. All manner of Sheetrock, sparkle and interior painting services are available, as well as all aspects of millwork such as doors, windows, trims and moldings. We have a great deal of experience with all types of solid, laminate and engineered flooring installation. We can provide and refer numerous local sub-contractors to help complete your project, such as floor re-finishing, electrical, plumbing experts. Licensed and insured in Suffolk County for 15 years. The owner is present at all times during planning and remodel. Initial consultation and estimate is always free, call anytime to speak with owner, my name is Ian Williams.

"Ian and his team did an amazing job tackling a huge project in my home. They completed a full kitchen remodel that included gutting to the studs and floorboards. No detail was left untended to. His crew was neat, polite, and ultra professional. The kitchen remodel expanded to the rest of the house where they updated exterior windows, removed load bearing wall to create an open floor plan, and removed/replaced the flooring throughout the first floor of my home. My house looks like a showroom!"

Dana S on February 2020

Artisan Contracting LLC is a full service, owner operated, residential contracting company.. We plan and remodel residential bathrooms and kitchens, install tile floors, walls, back-splashes, etc. We move walls and install load-bearing headers to create larger spaces. All manner of Sheetrock, sparkle and interior painting services are available, as well as all aspects of millwork such as doors, windows, trims and moldings. We have a great deal of experience with all types of solid, laminate and engineered flooring installation. We can provide and refer numerous local sub-contractors to help complete your project, such as floor re-finishing, electrical, plumbing experts. Licensed and insured in Suffolk County for 15 years. The owner is present at all times during planning and remodel. Initial consultation and estimate is always free, call anytime to speak with owner, my name is Ian Williams.

"Ian and his team did an amazing job tackling a huge project in my home. They completed a full kitchen remodel that included gutting to the studs and floorboards. No detail was left untended to. His crew was neat, polite, and ultra professional. The kitchen remodel expanded to the rest of the house where they updated exterior windows, removed load bearing wall to create an open floor plan, and removed/replaced the flooring throughout the first floor of my home. My house looks like a showroom!"

Dana S on February 2020


Avatar for Bay Carpet

Bay Carpet

4.86(
104
)

Bay Carpet

4.86(
104
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers

Bay Carpet & Flooring has been in business for 28 years and has a free shop-at-home service covering the entire metro area. We offer day, evening, and weekend appointments - to have samples brought to your home and have your floors measured, at no charge. Check our website (baycarpet.com) for special discounts. Additional service areas: Midtown, Nassau, Rockland, Staten, Suffolk, Union, Upper Manhattan & Westchester Counties.

"They did a wonderful job and they are listed as the top for carpet company. I recommend them highly, they cleaned up everything after the installation. We are very happy with the work that they did."

Jesse W on April 2022

Bay Carpet & Flooring has been in business for 28 years and has a free shop-at-home service covering the entire metro area. We offer day, evening, and weekend appointments - to have samples brought to your home and have your floors measured, at no charge. Check our website (baycarpet.com) for special discounts. Additional service areas: Midtown, Nassau, Rockland, Staten, Suffolk, Union, Upper Manhattan & Westchester Counties.

"They did a wonderful job and they are listed as the top for carpet company. I recommend them highly, they cleaned up everything after the installation. We are very happy with the work that they did."

Jesse W on April 2022


Avatar for Hi Tech Contracting & Restoration Corp

Hi Tech Contracting & Restoration Corp

4.97(
30
)

Hi Tech Contracting & Restoration Corp

4.97(
30
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers

Hi Tech Contracting & Restorations Corp Is a New York City based construction company with many years of experience in the construction industry. We are capable of undertaking both commercial and residential projects. We have the ability to handle new construction as well as additions, remodels, build out and minor renovations. Our team will work with you step by step to ensure your facility meets the scope and goals needed. At the onset of your construction project our team will meet with you to discuss your intended goals and purposes for the project. Once all aspects have been agreed and understood, our design specialist will give you several options and variations of your project design. In doing so we hope to offer aesthetic value as well as cost effectiveness. We are a certified general contractor, being so we are able to draw from a large and extensive set of resources and network. Whether your project is big or small we can outline a tailored course of work that will meet your construction and facility needs. One of the many services we offer is design consultation. We understand that a construction project often retains a multitude of factors and variables. To lessen the complexity & ease the transition into your new facility or project, our team will explain in detail all variables and options at your disposal. Our Services includes: Roofing, Water Proofing, Brick Work, Side Walk, Drive Way, Concrete, Interior & Exterior Painting We have a simple mantra “on time and under-budget” .

"I had them to redo my whole roof 1.5 year ago and I found a piece of shingle fell off recently. I contacted the owner and they stood behind their work and promise. He quickly scheduled a follow-up and sent his team to fix it in a short period of time. In these days you can easily find any contractors do the work and work away with your money. However once the job is done, you will never see them again when there are any issues. This will not happen to Hi Tech Contracting as they are professional, responsible and trustworthy. Highly recommended!"

William T on April 2024

Hi Tech Contracting & Restorations Corp Is a New York City based construction company with many years of experience in the construction industry. We are capable of undertaking both commercial and residential projects. We have the ability to handle new construction as well as additions, remodels, build out and minor renovations. Our team will work with you step by step to ensure your facility meets the scope and goals needed. At the onset of your construction project our team will meet with you to discuss your intended goals and purposes for the project. Once all aspects have been agreed and understood, our design specialist will give you several options and variations of your project design. In doing so we hope to offer aesthetic value as well as cost effectiveness. We are a certified general contractor, being so we are able to draw from a large and extensive set of resources and network. Whether your project is big or small we can outline a tailored course of work that will meet your construction and facility needs. One of the many services we offer is design consultation. We understand that a construction project often retains a multitude of factors and variables. To lessen the complexity & ease the transition into your new facility or project, our team will explain in detail all variables and options at your disposal. Our Services includes: Roofing, Water Proofing, Brick Work, Side Walk, Drive Way, Concrete, Interior & Exterior Painting We have a simple mantra “on time and under-budget” .

"I had them to redo my whole roof 1.5 year ago and I found a piece of shingle fell off recently. I contacted the owner and they stood behind their work and promise. He quickly scheduled a follow-up and sent his team to fix it in a short period of time. In these days you can easily find any contractors do the work and work away with your money. However once the job is done, you will never see them again when there are any issues. This will not happen to Hi Tech Contracting as they are professional, responsible and trustworthy. Highly recommended!"

William T on April 2024



Avatar for R & D Floor Sanding & Refinishing

R & D Floor Sanding & Refinishing

5.00(
30
)

R & D Floor Sanding & Refinishing

5.00(
30
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Family owned and operated since 1985, we take great pride in the reputation we have built over the past 35 years. We are dedicated in providing our customers with the highest quality products and services at competitive prices, producing floors that we both can be proud of.

"Excellent. Exactly what we wished for. Price was very competitive, work was competent and clean."

WARD D on May 2018

Family owned and operated since 1985, we take great pride in the reputation we have built over the past 35 years. We are dedicated in providing our customers with the highest quality products and services at competitive prices, producing floors that we both can be proud of.

"Excellent. Exactly what we wished for. Price was very competitive, work was competent and clean."

WARD D on May 2018


Avatar for Don's Hardwood Flooring

Don's Hardwood Flooring

4.93(
81
)

Don's Hardwood Flooring

4.93(
81
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

First off I would just like to thank all of my great Angie’s List customers over the many years that have honored me with 70-some ‘A’ reviews and all of the consecutive Super Service awards. Our philosophy is to educate the customer to insure that their decisions are made from a thoroughly informed place. We promote extremely durable, ecologically responsible finishes that have a 15 year manufacturer’s warranty. **Estimates outside of our regular service area may incur a trip charge but will be credited toward the project -call for details.

"Excellent. Crew was efficient and job was done quickly but thoroughly."

Paul P on November 2019

First off I would just like to thank all of my great Angie’s List customers over the many years that have honored me with 70-some ‘A’ reviews and all of the consecutive Super Service awards. Our philosophy is to educate the customer to insure that their decisions are made from a thoroughly informed place. We promote extremely durable, ecologically responsible finishes that have a 15 year manufacturer’s warranty. **Estimates outside of our regular service area may incur a trip charge but will be credited toward the project -call for details.

"Excellent. Crew was efficient and job was done quickly but thoroughly."

Paul P on November 2019

...
Showing 1-10 of 1036

FAQs for hardwood flooring service projects in Shelter Island, NY

The cost to refinish hardwood floors is $1,900 on average, ranging from $600 to $4,500, depending on the area size, the floor’s condition, the type of wood, the type of coating, and the refinishing method. Traditional refinishing includes sanding the floors, which can be very dusty and costs about $3 to $8 per square foot. Dustless refinishing uses a vacuum to collect dust during the sanding process, reducing the amount of dust produced, and costs about $5 to $8 per square foot

The cost to install hardwood flooring is about $4,800 on average, ranging from about $1,000 to $12,000. Nationally, the average cost to install hardwood floors ranges from $6 to $12 per square foot for labor and materials. High-end woods and large spaces may cost $13 to $25 per square foot

Additional cost factors include:

  • Square footage of the area

  • Type of wood

  • Preparation requirements

  • Type of finish

  • Location

  • Floor style and pattern

  • Plank thickness

  • Wood grade, color, and grain

It’s time to refinish your hardwood floors when they show signs of age that diminish their overall appearance and function. A few surefire signals that you should consider refinishing your hardwood floors include:

  • Gouges, scrapes, deep scratches, and dents over a significant area

  • Discoloration from stains or sun exposure

  • Water damage causing rotting, warping, or bowing

  • Weak, spongy, or soft spots in the floor indicating damaged subflooring

  • Dull and worn appearance across most of the floor

Despite the costly upfront expense, hardwood floors can add value and appeal to your home, making them one of the highest ROI home improvements. In terms of functionality, hardwood floors are very durable and can last several decades when properly maintained, making them well worth the investment. In some cases, installing hardwood floors can even alleviate allergies in household members, as it’s easier to keep this floor type free of dust mites, pet dander, pollen, and other pesky allergens.

Several kinds of wood can be used for wood flooring, not all being hardwood, ranging in price per square foot. You should choose the best type of wood for your flooring based on desired color, cost, durability, feel, and texture.

Check out the cost of common wood types per square foot:

  • Maple: $7–$11

  • Pine: $5–$10

  • Bamboo: $5–$11

  • White ash: $9–$13 

  • Hickory: $6–$13 

  • Red oak: $8–$13 

  • White oak: $8–$15 

  • Brazilian walnut: $11–$20 

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to hardwood flooring services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.