Top-rated garage pros.

Get matched with top garage pros in Shelter Island, NY

There are 14 highly-rated local garage pros.

Need a pro for your garage service project in Shelter Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.9
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon11
    Verified garage services reviews

Find Garage pros in Shelter Island

Avatar for Allied Construction Corp

Allied Construction Corp

26 Pagnotta Dr
4.45(
161
)
Approved Pro

Allied Construction Corp

26 Pagnotta Dr
4.45(
161
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
36 local quotes requested
36 years of experience

**We are now specializing in Kitchen Remodeling**At this time we are unable to take on Bathroom Remodeling projects**Our first priority has always been the satisfaction of our customers, and we take great pride in both the quality of our work and the quality of the customer service we extend to each and every one of our clients, regardless of the size of their project. When trusting Allied Construction Corporation with your home remodeling project, you are trusting a crew of dedicated and talented home remodeling experts to take you through every single step of the process, and to keep you up to date on developments. We always treat your project – and your home – with the utmost level of care and respect. We strive to ensure that every last detail of your work order is performed with the same level of quality we would apply to our own home. Our work over the years has proven to yield exceptionally high return on investment, making your home not only the haven you envisioned but also more valuable. What is more, we provide extremely affordable home remodeling services, making it possible for you to see your vision come to life without breaking the bank. We also offer Angie's List members a 10% Discount on all Labor. We have been on the Discovery Channel. (References upon request). Additional Phone: 516-500-8170 Additional email: [email protected].

"RUN FAR AWAY FROM ALLIED AND TOM. Tom took my money and did not complete the renovations as per our contract. He lied about having a licensed electrician to do electrical work, it was just one of his workers who's not licensed. I paid for a dumpster and when it was delivered by tom it was already half full from another allied job and I was asked to pay the full amount of $950. Tom didn't listen to anything I said regarding the work I requested and he changed my design and did work that was cheaper for him. I was priced for one of my ceiling's to be ripped out and reinstalled with new sheetrock, Tom waited until I was away on business then he installed sheetrock on top of the bad sheetrock and told me he ripped out the old sheetrock and installed the new sheetrock, I found out when my EC cut holes to install lights and we found 2 layers of sheetrock preventing the lights from being able to be installed. Allied construction is a cheap, sneaky company who will steal your money and breach your contract. Do not hire these people Tom is a lair. Tom wore a gun in my house on his hip and told me "I use this to get paid by customer who don't want to pay". Tom left live 120v wires hanging out of the walls and ceiling, he removed a banister and didn't replace it for 3 weeks making my home very unsafe for me and my 9 year old son."

Adam C on May 2025

**We are now specializing in Kitchen Remodeling**At this time we are unable to take on Bathroom Remodeling projects**Our first priority has always been the satisfaction of our customers, and we take great pride in both the quality of our work and the quality of the customer service we extend to each and every one of our clients, regardless of the size of their project. When trusting Allied Construction Corporation with your home remodeling project, you are trusting a crew of dedicated and talented home remodeling experts to take you through every single step of the process, and to keep you up to date on developments. We always treat your project – and your home – with the utmost level of care and respect. We strive to ensure that every last detail of your work order is performed with the same level of quality we would apply to our own home. Our work over the years has proven to yield exceptionally high return on investment, making your home not only the haven you envisioned but also more valuable. What is more, we provide extremely affordable home remodeling services, making it possible for you to see your vision come to life without breaking the bank. We also offer Angie's List members a 10% Discount on all Labor. We have been on the Discovery Channel. (References upon request). Additional Phone: 516-500-8170 Additional email: [email protected].

"RUN FAR AWAY FROM ALLIED AND TOM. Tom took my money and did not complete the renovations as per our contract. He lied about having a licensed electrician to do electrical work, it was just one of his workers who's not licensed. I paid for a dumpster and when it was delivered by tom it was already half full from another allied job and I was asked to pay the full amount of $950. Tom didn't listen to anything I said regarding the work I requested and he changed my design and did work that was cheaper for him. I was priced for one of my ceiling's to be ripped out and reinstalled with new sheetrock, Tom waited until I was away on business then he installed sheetrock on top of the bad sheetrock and told me he ripped out the old sheetrock and installed the new sheetrock, I found out when my EC cut holes to install lights and we found 2 layers of sheetrock preventing the lights from being able to be installed. Allied construction is a cheap, sneaky company who will steal your money and breach your contract. Do not hire these people Tom is a lair. Tom wore a gun in my house on his hip and told me "I use this to get paid by customer who don't want to pay". Tom left live 120v wires hanging out of the walls and ceiling, he removed a banister and didn't replace it for 3 weeks making my home very unsafe for me and my 9 year old son."

Adam C on May 2025


Avatar for Cocos Custom Building LLC

Cocos Custom Building LLC

66 Radburn Drive
4.75(
8
)
Approved Pro

Cocos Custom Building LLC

66 Radburn Drive
4.75(
8
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
426 local quotes requested

Coco’s Custom Building LLC specializes in setting and finishing Modular Homes, fabricating and installing structural steel, and all phases of residential and commercial construction. This includes extensions, dormers, basements, siding, exterior trim and roofing. We have 25 years of experience. We take pride in giving our customers a professional quality finish on all of our projects for a reasonable price. We work extremely hard to ensure that our customers hard earned money doesn’t go to waste.

"Excellent. On time and on budget"

Brian D on January 2025

Coco’s Custom Building LLC specializes in setting and finishing Modular Homes, fabricating and installing structural steel, and all phases of residential and commercial construction. This includes extensions, dormers, basements, siding, exterior trim and roofing. We have 25 years of experience. We take pride in giving our customers a professional quality finish on all of our projects for a reasonable price. We work extremely hard to ensure that our customers hard earned money doesn’t go to waste.

"Excellent. On time and on budget"

Brian D on January 2025


JL Remodeling

124 Queens Lane
5.00(
1
)

JL Remodeling

124 Queens Lane
5.00(
1
)
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

JL Remodeling has built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. We service both residential and commercial properties. We give you the peace of mind you need to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started! HOLIDAYS DISCOUNT APPLY

"Super honest and efficient, hard working and knowledgeable"

Alex C on December 2024

JL Remodeling has built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. We service both residential and commercial properties. We give you the peace of mind you need to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started! HOLIDAYS DISCOUNT APPLY

"Super honest and efficient, hard working and knowledgeable"

Alex C on December 2024


Paradise Handyman Services

5.00(
4
)

Paradise Handyman Services

5.00(
4
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We are there for your home remodeling and repair needs. We also specialize in building storage compartments and shelving, garage remodeling, and junk removal.

"Yes, execllent job done"

Robin S on February 2025

We are there for your home remodeling and repair needs. We also specialize in building storage compartments and shelving, garage remodeling, and junk removal.

"Yes, execllent job done"

Robin S on February 2025


AMCM Services

33 Whalers Dr
5.00(
2
)

AMCM Services

33 Whalers Dr
5.00(
2
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

With two decades of expertise, our contracting and remodeling business specializes in revitalizing homes with a rich history. From renovations to antique house restoration, we bring a wealth of experience to every project. Trust us to seamlessly blend modern comfort with timeless charm, creating spaces that stand the test of time.

"This team is wonderful and can virtually do anything you need done. Beautiful finished carpentry. Very talented and reliable. We have worked with this team for 20 years over multiple properties.We do not hesitate to recommend enthusiastically. Wonderful design aesthetic. Excellent practical can-do approach. Very nice people. good prices. Terrific results and value for money."

Frank A on December 2023

With two decades of expertise, our contracting and remodeling business specializes in revitalizing homes with a rich history. From renovations to antique house restoration, we bring a wealth of experience to every project. Trust us to seamlessly blend modern comfort with timeless charm, creating spaces that stand the test of time.

"This team is wonderful and can virtually do anything you need done. Beautiful finished carpentry. Very talented and reliable. We have worked with this team for 20 years over multiple properties.We do not hesitate to recommend enthusiastically. Wonderful design aesthetic. Excellent practical can-do approach. Very nice people. good prices. Terrific results and value for money."

Frank A on December 2023


Dylan Ray Contracting, LLC

Based In
5.00(
5
)

Dylan Ray Contracting, LLC

Based In
5.00(
5
)
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Dylan Ray Contracting is a trusted and reliable company providing excellent construction services to residential clients across Long Island. Whether you need home remodeling, kitchen and bathroom renovations or a home extension, you can rely on us. Our combined expertise in all phases of construction makes us confident to guarantee that you will receive nothing but exceptional craftsmanship when you choose us. No job is too big or too small for our dedicated company.

"Excellent work!!"

William B on November 2023

Dylan Ray Contracting is a trusted and reliable company providing excellent construction services to residential clients across Long Island. Whether you need home remodeling, kitchen and bathroom renovations or a home extension, you can rely on us. Our combined expertise in all phases of construction makes us confident to guarantee that you will receive nothing but exceptional craftsmanship when you choose us. No job is too big or too small for our dedicated company.

"Excellent work!!"

William B on November 2023


LAJ Contracting Corp

100 Jefferson Ave
5.00(
1
)

LAJ Contracting Corp

100 Jefferson Ave
5.00(
1
)
Free onsite estimate

"LAJ Contracting NY Corp. is a 100% insured company. We have more than 20 years of experience in the construction industry. We specialize in in a various of different services like remodeling, carpentry, flooring, bathroom, kitchen, windows, drywall, painting, plumbing and much more."

"LAJ Contracting NY Corp. is a 100% insured company. We have more than 20 years of experience in the construction industry. We specialize in in a various of different services like remodeling, carpentry, flooring, bathroom, kitchen, windows, drywall, painting, plumbing and much more."


Four J Construction

No reviews yet

Four J Construction

No reviews yet
2 years of experience

Welcome to Four J Construction, where we bring your vision to life with exceptional craftsmanship and unparalleled expertise. We specialize in a wide range of construction services, including full home renovation, kitchen renovation, bathroom renovation, basement finishing, patio and deck installations, as well as roof repair and installation. At Four J Construction, we understand that your home is your sanctuary, and we are dedicated to transforming it into the perfect space that reflects your unique style and meets your functional needs. Our team of highly skilled professionals is committed to delivering top-quality workmanship, ensuring that every project is completed to the highest standards of excellence. What sets us apart from our competitors is our unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction. We prioritize open communication, actively listening to your ideas, and collaborating closely with you throughout the entire construction process. Our goal is not only to meet your expectations but to exceed them, providing you with a seamless and enjoyable experience from start to finish. With years of experience in the industry, we have established a solid reputation for delivering exceptional results. As a family-owned and operated business, we take immense pride in our work, treating every project as if it were our own home. Our dedicated team of professionals combines their expertise, attention to detail, and creative solutions to bring your vision to fruition. At Four J Construction, we understand that industry-specific jargon can be overwhelming and confusing for potential customers. That's why we strive to communicate in clear and concise terms, making sure that you fully understand the process, timeline, and costs involved. We are here to guide you every step of the way, making your construction journey as seamless and stress-free as possible. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and let us turn your dreams into reality.

Welcome to Four J Construction, where we bring your vision to life with exceptional craftsmanship and unparalleled expertise. We specialize in a wide range of construction services, including full home renovation, kitchen renovation, bathroom renovation, basement finishing, patio and deck installations, as well as roof repair and installation. At Four J Construction, we understand that your home is your sanctuary, and we are dedicated to transforming it into the perfect space that reflects your unique style and meets your functional needs. Our team of highly skilled professionals is committed to delivering top-quality workmanship, ensuring that every project is completed to the highest standards of excellence. What sets us apart from our competitors is our unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction. We prioritize open communication, actively listening to your ideas, and collaborating closely with you throughout the entire construction process. Our goal is not only to meet your expectations but to exceed them, providing you with a seamless and enjoyable experience from start to finish. With years of experience in the industry, we have established a solid reputation for delivering exceptional results. As a family-owned and operated business, we take immense pride in our work, treating every project as if it were our own home. Our dedicated team of professionals combines their expertise, attention to detail, and creative solutions to bring your vision to fruition. At Four J Construction, we understand that industry-specific jargon can be overwhelming and confusing for potential customers. That's why we strive to communicate in clear and concise terms, making sure that you fully understand the process, timeline, and costs involved. We are here to guide you every step of the way, making your construction journey as seamless and stress-free as possible. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and let us turn your dreams into reality.


PROBROS

5.00(
1
)

PROBROS

5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

PROBROS Custom Aesthetics, for all your home remodeling needs. We do it all from building complete custom homes, interior remodeling that includes but is not limited to; Kitchen remodels, Bathroom remodels, Flooring, Roofing, Deck installation, and much more. Here at PROBROS we value each of our jobs as a unique and creative way for our homeowners to express themselves, all for an affordable price while maintaining a high quality finished product. With a dedicated team with over 20 years of experience, we have been around a long time and like to stay ahead of the competition, giving the best prices available and giving a reliable trusted service. There is no home renovation service that is too big or too small for us.

"The team did a great job on our deck in our backyard"

Fred C on March 2023

PROBROS Custom Aesthetics, for all your home remodeling needs. We do it all from building complete custom homes, interior remodeling that includes but is not limited to; Kitchen remodels, Bathroom remodels, Flooring, Roofing, Deck installation, and much more. Here at PROBROS we value each of our jobs as a unique and creative way for our homeowners to express themselves, all for an affordable price while maintaining a high quality finished product. With a dedicated team with over 20 years of experience, we have been around a long time and like to stay ahead of the competition, giving the best prices available and giving a reliable trusted service. There is no home renovation service that is too big or too small for us.

"The team did a great job on our deck in our backyard"

Fred C on March 2023


Cruz Brothers Construction

163 W. Montauk Hwy
5.00(
6
)

Cruz Brothers Construction

163 W. Montauk Hwy
5.00(
6
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Cruz Brothers Construction is a family-owned and operated business that has been servicing the east end of Long Island for over 15 years. We specialize in New Construction, Renovations, Additions, Finished Basements, Kitchen and Bathroom Renovations, Decks, Patios. Our Mission is to build long lasting relationships with all our clients. Please look at our website to see some of our work or follow us on Instagram to see some of our latest projects. https://www.instagram.com/cruzbrothersconstruction/

"The Cruz Brothers were true professionals and craftsmen. Against a terrible backdrop with absurd inflation and supply chain bottlenecks, they were able to deliver a total backyard renovation in the targeted 3.5 months (some of which was unusable time to do winter). They did a fantastic job and all along the way were helpful in accommodating changes we jointly determined would be positive enhancements. They were always very responsive and keen to not sound like they were trying to steer us to add to the project – often being candid about how expensive certain things were becoming versus what they were used to (again, because of a broken post-Covid world when it comes to supply and commodity costs). In the many months since, they have checked in periodically to make sure everything is OK. We are very very happy with how everything worked out."

Eduardo R on November 2022

Cruz Brothers Construction is a family-owned and operated business that has been servicing the east end of Long Island for over 15 years. We specialize in New Construction, Renovations, Additions, Finished Basements, Kitchen and Bathroom Renovations, Decks, Patios. Our Mission is to build long lasting relationships with all our clients. Please look at our website to see some of our work or follow us on Instagram to see some of our latest projects. https://www.instagram.com/cruzbrothersconstruction/

"The Cruz Brothers were true professionals and craftsmen. Against a terrible backdrop with absurd inflation and supply chain bottlenecks, they were able to deliver a total backyard renovation in the targeted 3.5 months (some of which was unusable time to do winter). They did a fantastic job and all along the way were helpful in accommodating changes we jointly determined would be positive enhancements. They were always very responsive and keen to not sound like they were trying to steer us to add to the project – often being candid about how expensive certain things were becoming versus what they were used to (again, because of a broken post-Covid world when it comes to supply and commodity costs). In the many months since, they have checked in periodically to make sure everything is OK. We are very very happy with how everything worked out."

Eduardo R on November 2022

...
Showing 1-10 of 201
Garages questions, answered by experts

When searching for the best pro to complete this project for you, here are a few steps you can take:

  • Get multiple quotes

  • Ask about their qualifications

  • Ask to see and verify their license and insurance

  • Get recommendations from your family and friends

  • Read reviews

Besides vetting your future pro, you also want to watch out for these red flags:

  • Rushing you to sign the contract

  • The installer does not listen to your wants and needs

  • Excessively high or low quotes

  • No written, detailed estimate

While the ideal temperature for your garage is partially based on your preferences for a comfortable garage space, you'll still want to maintain a temperature between 40 degrees and 68 degrees Fahrenheit to protect your belongings and vehicles. If you are unable to maintain temperatures that fall within this range, then you may want to consider installing a heater in your garage to prevent temperatures from dropping below 40 degrees.

The main con of a heated garage is that if cold air comes into your garage and hits warm tools, it could lead to rust. You may also have to deal with the slush and run-off from any snow or ice that comes into the garage from vehicles, leading to more maintenance and upkeep.

Annually, to check for wear, lubricate parts, and ensure safe operation.

In some cases, a detached garage can be considered extra living space, but you will need to gain permission and comply with your local building code. Depending on where you live, you may need permits for a variety of installations, including electrical work, plumbing, and structural work. Many homeowners make the mistake of converting a garage into a living space without acquiring permits, which can result in hefty fines and even the removal of your hard work. Furthermore, a detached garage doesn’t add to the livable square footage of your home when it’s time to sell.

By submitting this question, I acknowledge and agree that Angi may publicly display my name, city, state, and question on the website for professionals and others to see.

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to garage services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.