Get matched with top garage pros in Fishers Island, NY
There are 15 highly-rated local garage pros.
TRUSTED BY FISHERS ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS
4.9 
10 Verified Reviews for Garage Service pros in Fishers Island, NY
*The Angi rating for Garage Service companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Garage Service needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Garage Service companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Garage Service needs.
Last update on July 18, 2025
Garage pros in Fishers Island
VP Quality Contracting is a family-owned and -operated, full-service construction company. Our professionalism and quality craftsmanship will accurately reflect your taste and lifestyle. Come visit our new showroom!
"Great experience working with Vinny"
Thomas Greenlawn G on February 2025
VP Quality Contracting is a family-owned and -operated, full-service construction company. Our professionalism and quality craftsmanship will accurately reflect your taste and lifestyle. Come visit our new showroom!
"Great experience working with Vinny"
Thomas Greenlawn G on February 2025
Mak Wood Work Inc specializes in custom cabinetry & custom closets, as well as general framing. As a locally owned and operated business, personal relationships are important to us. Our core values are providing high quality custom work and having great communication throughout the entire process. Let us help you plan your next project! Schedule a FREE Estimate - (631)879-1784
"Outstanding! Complex repair completed within just a few hours."
Kathryn B on January 2025
Mak Wood Work Inc specializes in custom cabinetry & custom closets, as well as general framing. As a locally owned and operated business, personal relationships are important to us. Our core values are providing high quality custom work and having great communication throughout the entire process. Let us help you plan your next project! Schedule a FREE Estimate - (631)879-1784
"Outstanding! Complex repair completed within just a few hours."
Kathryn B on January 2025
At Make it Right Contracting Corp we are a general contracting company we do all phase of home improvement from basement remodels, addition,bathroom remodels and kitchen remodels.No job is too big or small.
"HORRIBLE!! Reached out to them for 4 days straight through Angi - no reply. DO NOT RECOMMEND!!"
Michael F on April 2025
At Make it Right Contracting Corp we are a general contracting company we do all phase of home improvement from basement remodels, addition,bathroom remodels and kitchen remodels.No job is too big or small.
"HORRIBLE!! Reached out to them for 4 days straight through Angi - no reply. DO NOT RECOMMEND!!"
Michael F on April 2025
We are a building, remodeling, home improvement firm backed with 31 yrs experience. I, Arthur DeRosa, personally over see every project, big or small, from start to finish. I have an artists soul and every project that I am privileged to do is a reflection of that. With performance backed by experience and attention to detail, your project will be in good hands. The number of employees varies depending on work load. Sub-contractors are used when necessary. Proposals and estimates are free and include payment schedules with start and completion dates. Super Service Award winner for 2016! Call us today to schedule your appointment - (631) 774-1231
"Artie & Mike are simply the best. I used them to: 1) Build a LARGE extension to my house and redo my entire kitchen and dining room. The job was completed on time and on budget. Throughout the process Artie was transparent & professional. EVERY person who has stepped into my house has complimented at the detailed perfection. 3) Artie built us a custom walk in pantry 2) Built 2 large decks in the backyard as well as an outdoor shower. This project was completed on time, on budget while exceeding all expectations. If you are looking for a contractor and crew that is responsible, responsive, polite, creative and delivers the HIGHEST LEVEL of quality - Artie is the one."
Constantine M on March 2023
We are a building, remodeling, home improvement firm backed with 31 yrs experience. I, Arthur DeRosa, personally over see every project, big or small, from start to finish. I have an artists soul and every project that I am privileged to do is a reflection of that. With performance backed by experience and attention to detail, your project will be in good hands. The number of employees varies depending on work load. Sub-contractors are used when necessary. Proposals and estimates are free and include payment schedules with start and completion dates. Super Service Award winner for 2016! Call us today to schedule your appointment - (631) 774-1231
"Artie & Mike are simply the best. I used them to: 1) Build a LARGE extension to my house and redo my entire kitchen and dining room. The job was completed on time and on budget. Throughout the process Artie was transparent & professional. EVERY person who has stepped into my house has complimented at the detailed perfection. 3) Artie built us a custom walk in pantry 2) Built 2 large decks in the backyard as well as an outdoor shower. This project was completed on time, on budget while exceeding all expectations. If you are looking for a contractor and crew that is responsible, responsive, polite, creative and delivers the HIGHEST LEVEL of quality - Artie is the one."
Constantine M on March 2023
Coco’s Custom Building LLC specializes in setting and finishing Modular Homes, fabricating and installing structural steel, and all phases of residential and commercial construction. This includes extensions, dormers, basements, siding, exterior trim and roofing. We have 25 years of experience. We take pride in giving our customers a professional quality finish on all of our projects for a reasonable price. We work extremely hard to ensure that our customers hard earned money doesn’t go to waste.
"Excellent. On time and on budget"
Brian D on January 2025
Coco’s Custom Building LLC specializes in setting and finishing Modular Homes, fabricating and installing structural steel, and all phases of residential and commercial construction. This includes extensions, dormers, basements, siding, exterior trim and roofing. We have 25 years of experience. We take pride in giving our customers a professional quality finish on all of our projects for a reasonable price. We work extremely hard to ensure that our customers hard earned money doesn’t go to waste.
"Excellent. On time and on budget"
Brian D on January 2025
Ernest & Sons General Contractors and Landscaping Design We meet all of your residential needs. * Landscape * Hardscape * Shrubs * Mulching * Planting * Top Soil * Sod * Shrub Removal * Spring Clean Up * Driveways * Pavers * Patios * Steps * Curves * Retaining Walls * Seal Coating We have over ten years in business and landscape design. We provide experienced quality work at reasonable rates. Tell us what you have in mind and we will build it for you and your family. Call Us!
"HORRIBLE!! Reached out to them for 4 days straight through Angi - no reply. DO NOT RECOMMEND!!"
Michael F on April 2025
Ernest & Sons General Contractors and Landscaping Design We meet all of your residential needs. * Landscape * Hardscape * Shrubs * Mulching * Planting * Top Soil * Sod * Shrub Removal * Spring Clean Up * Driveways * Pavers * Patios * Steps * Curves * Retaining Walls * Seal Coating We have over ten years in business and landscape design. We provide experienced quality work at reasonable rates. Tell us what you have in mind and we will build it for you and your family. Call Us!
"HORRIBLE!! Reached out to them for 4 days straight through Angi - no reply. DO NOT RECOMMEND!!"
Michael F on April 2025
JL Remodeling has built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. We service both residential and commercial properties. We give you the peace of mind you need to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started! HOLIDAYS DISCOUNT APPLY
"Super honest and efficient, hard working and knowledgeable"
Alex c on December 2024
JL Remodeling has built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. We service both residential and commercial properties. We give you the peace of mind you need to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started! HOLIDAYS DISCOUNT APPLY
"Super honest and efficient, hard working and knowledgeable"
Alex c on December 2024
We are providers of construction services in the Ney York area. Our mission is to maintain the highest quality and professionalism from start to finish. We are confident in our results because all our jobs are custom for the needs of each home. We strive for the highest degree of quality products and workmanship. During the years in business, Mapogo Construction has satisfied many customers. It is our reputation of quality work, professionalism, and customer service our customers continue to rely on us for their needs. To understand the expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer professionally. We base our reputation on service, safety, and quality. Call us today and find out how we can meet all your construction needs!
"Jorge and his brother were wonderful, the front porch was replaces exactly as I wanted it! They were professional, polite and cleaned every thing up. I highly recommend them . Barbara"
Barbara S on March 2025
We are providers of construction services in the Ney York area. Our mission is to maintain the highest quality and professionalism from start to finish. We are confident in our results because all our jobs are custom for the needs of each home. We strive for the highest degree of quality products and workmanship. During the years in business, Mapogo Construction has satisfied many customers. It is our reputation of quality work, professionalism, and customer service our customers continue to rely on us for their needs. To understand the expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer professionally. We base our reputation on service, safety, and quality. Call us today and find out how we can meet all your construction needs!
"Jorge and his brother were wonderful, the front porch was replaces exactly as I wanted it! They were professional, polite and cleaned every thing up. I highly recommend them . Barbara"
Barbara S on March 2025
With two decades of expertise, our contracting and remodeling business specializes in revitalizing homes with a rich history. From renovations to antique house restoration, we bring a wealth of experience to every project. Trust us to seamlessly blend modern comfort with timeless charm, creating spaces that stand the test of time.
"This team is wonderful and can virtually do anything you need done. Beautiful finished carpentry. Very talented and reliable. We have worked with this team for 20 years over multiple properties.We do not hesitate to recommend enthusiastically. Wonderful design aesthetic. Excellent practical can-do approach. Very nice people. good prices. Terrific results and value for money."
Frank A on December 2023
With two decades of expertise, our contracting and remodeling business specializes in revitalizing homes with a rich history. From renovations to antique house restoration, we bring a wealth of experience to every project. Trust us to seamlessly blend modern comfort with timeless charm, creating spaces that stand the test of time.
"This team is wonderful and can virtually do anything you need done. Beautiful finished carpentry. Very talented and reliable. We have worked with this team for 20 years over multiple properties.We do not hesitate to recommend enthusiastically. Wonderful design aesthetic. Excellent practical can-do approach. Very nice people. good prices. Terrific results and value for money."
Frank A on December 2023
Dylan Ray Contracting is a trusted and reliable company providing excellent construction services to residential clients across Long Island. Whether you need home remodeling, kitchen and bathroom renovations or a home extension, you can rely on us. Our combined expertise in all phases of construction makes us confident to guarantee that you will receive nothing but exceptional craftsmanship when you choose us. No job is too big or too small for our dedicated company.
"Excellent work!!"
William B on November 2023
Dylan Ray Contracting is a trusted and reliable company providing excellent construction services to residential clients across Long Island. Whether you need home remodeling, kitchen and bathroom renovations or a home extension, you can rely on us. Our combined expertise in all phases of construction makes us confident to guarantee that you will receive nothing but exceptional craftsmanship when you choose us. No job is too big or too small for our dedicated company.
"Excellent work!!"
William B on November 2023
FAQs for garage service projects in Fishers Island, NY
Yes, you should be able to cover your detached garage on your homeowners insurance policy. Most policies will automatically cover it as a “separate structure,” but policies differ widely. It’s best to confirm with your insurance company whether or not it will cover the detached garage before starting this extensive project.
It’s typically less expensive to buy a garage-building kit than to build a garage from scratch if you’re supplying all the labor. However, unless you are an experienced builder, you will still need to hire pros to install the foundation, concrete floor, and add electrical and plumbing to your garage kit. In that case, it’s worth the investment to build a garage through a local garage builder who can coordinate the hiring of other necessary pros.
The cost to convert a carport into a garage averages about $22,000, ranging from about $15,000 and $55,000. Additional cost factors to consider include size, time of year, and how much of the carport you can reuse. Other cost factors include the kinds and amounts of materials used, such as:
Add insulation: $1 per square foot
Add drywall: $1–$3 per square foot
Add window: $450–$2,000 per window
Add outlets: $75–$500
Add garage door: $250–$11,200
Enclose framing: $5–$13 per square foot
Replace roofing: $1,000–$2,000
The cost to build a detached garage for two cars costs about $26,400 on average. Prices range from $19,200 to $33,600, depending on your location, the garage size, height, materials, and site prep required. Additional cost factors include any plumbing, electrical wiring, and insulation. If you need to build a concrete foundation for a new detached garage, you can expect to pay $1,000 to $8,600 for this essential addition.
The average cost to remodel a garage is around $18,000, ranging from $1,500 to $50,000, depending on size, materials, location, and other factors like plumbing and electrical. Garage remodels that include changing the roof and walls add significant expenses to the project. Plus, you can expect to pay about $1,400 for the building conversion permits. For a simple remodel, like painting interior walls and recoating the garage floor, it will cost about $2 to $5 per square foot.
Get our Angi-powered app
