
Get matched with top handymen in Shelter Island, NY
There are 23 highly-rated local handymen.
Need a pro for your handyman service project in Shelter Island, NY?
TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS
4.4
Average homeowner rating337
Verified handyman services reviews
Verified Reviews for Handyman Service pros in Shelter Island, NY
*The Angi rating for Handyman Service companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Handyman Service needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Handyman Service companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Handyman Service needs.
Last update on October 29, 2025
Find Handymen in Shelter Island

All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration
All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration
The Professional Team of All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration is capable of handling, as well as carrying everything necessary to provide immediate on-site furniture disassembling, assembling and all repairs, on wood, leather, vinyl, fabric, upholstery, restorations of antiques, metal, stone, and mechanisms. Methods and products are chosen to make their repairs permanent, invisible and to return furniture to its original or even better condition. On-site or in-shop services offered to all: Manufactures, Stores, Vendors, Warehouses, Designers, Hotels, Restaurants, Construction, Moving, Insurance Companies as well as Individual Customers. We have been at the forefront of the Antique and Modern Repair & Restoration.
"Dmytro is a pro!! He worked very hard to get my recliner back in shape!! Great job Dmytro! Thanks again."
Nancy B on September 2025
The Professional Team of All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration is capable of handling, as well as carrying everything necessary to provide immediate on-site furniture disassembling, assembling and all repairs, on wood, leather, vinyl, fabric, upholstery, restorations of antiques, metal, stone, and mechanisms. Methods and products are chosen to make their repairs permanent, invisible and to return furniture to its original or even better condition. On-site or in-shop services offered to all: Manufactures, Stores, Vendors, Warehouses, Designers, Hotels, Restaurants, Construction, Moving, Insurance Companies as well as Individual Customers. We have been at the forefront of the Antique and Modern Repair & Restoration.
"Dmytro is a pro!! He worked very hard to get my recliner back in shape!! Great job Dmytro! Thanks again."
Nancy B on September 2025
OnCall Handyman
OnCall Handyman
Welcome to OnCall Handyman, we look forward to discussing all of your handyman needs, please give us a call!
Welcome to OnCall Handyman, we look forward to discussing all of your handyman needs, please give us a call!

Neversweat Property Management
Neversweat Property Management
Neversweat Property Management specializes in the care and maintenance of properties in the picturesque East End of Long Island. Our dedicated team offers a comprehensive range of services, including property management, seasonal house care, and handyman repairs. With a passion for excellence and a commitment to property owners, we ensure that each property thrives, allowing our clients to enjoy peace of mind and the full experience of East End living. At Neversweat, we take care of your property as if it were our own, making your investment our responsibility.
"Everything went great, went over and above to make sure that we were pleased with the job."
Carlos F on November 2023
Neversweat Property Management specializes in the care and maintenance of properties in the picturesque East End of Long Island. Our dedicated team offers a comprehensive range of services, including property management, seasonal house care, and handyman repairs. With a passion for excellence and a commitment to property owners, we ensure that each property thrives, allowing our clients to enjoy peace of mind and the full experience of East End living. At Neversweat, we take care of your property as if it were our own, making your investment our responsibility.
"Everything went great, went over and above to make sure that we were pleased with the job."
Carlos F on November 2023

Magic Improvement, LLC
Magic Improvement, LLC
We are extremely passionate about the work that we do. You can depend on us to provide a high quality service at a fair and honest price. We understand that the future of our business depends upon our reputation and that is why customer service is by far our highest priority. If you are looking for a professional you can trust, please call today to schedule a no-obligation estimate!
"We had a few jobs including grouting of shower, reinforcing kitchen cabinets and making a wall opening in our laundry room. Angel and his workers are truly professional, friendly and hard working. They were perfectionists."
John F on October 2025
We are extremely passionate about the work that we do. You can depend on us to provide a high quality service at a fair and honest price. We understand that the future of our business depends upon our reputation and that is why customer service is by far our highest priority. If you are looking for a professional you can trust, please call today to schedule a no-obligation estimate!
"We had a few jobs including grouting of shower, reinforcing kitchen cabinets and making a wall opening in our laundry room. Angel and his workers are truly professional, friendly and hard working. They were perfectionists."
John F on October 2025

Peconic Bay Home Services LLC
Peconic Bay Home Services LLC
We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality and customer service that we provide to meet the consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship, and complete customer satisfaction, from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety and quality, regardless of how large, or small the job. Call us today!
"PBHS renovated my bathroom and kitchen. Adam was extremely professional and knowledgeable. I’ve been recommending PBHS to friends and family since. Fair pricing."
Hunter L on October 2025
We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality and customer service that we provide to meet the consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship, and complete customer satisfaction, from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety and quality, regardless of how large, or small the job. Call us today!
"PBHS renovated my bathroom and kitchen. Adam was extremely professional and knowledgeable. I’ve been recommending PBHS to friends and family since. Fair pricing."
Hunter L on October 2025
Painter And Handyman Services INC
Painter And Handyman Services INC
Hey,my name's Andrew. I'm from Ukraine. With extensive experience working in both the UK and Italy, I offer specialized painting and handyman services designed to meet all your home improvement needs. From carefully executed interior and exterior painting to a wide range of repair and maintenance tasks, my approach blends the precision and quality of European craftsmanship with a keen attention to detail. I take pride in delivering high-quality work that not only refreshes and enhances your space but also stands the test of time. Whether you need to touch up a single room, carry out small repairs, or give your entire property a new look, I'm here to provide a reliable, personal service you can depend on. King Regard.
Hey,my name's Andrew. I'm from Ukraine. With extensive experience working in both the UK and Italy, I offer specialized painting and handyman services designed to meet all your home improvement needs. From carefully executed interior and exterior painting to a wide range of repair and maintenance tasks, my approach blends the precision and quality of European craftsmanship with a keen attention to detail. I take pride in delivering high-quality work that not only refreshes and enhances your space but also stands the test of time. Whether you need to touch up a single room, carry out small repairs, or give your entire property a new look, I'm here to provide a reliable, personal service you can depend on. King Regard.

Chuna
Chuna
Need work done no time to do it I’ll do it, one man operator at of bohemia someone you can trust in your home,I do painting deck painting,Power washing small jobs,Shrubs removal,Attic’s and basement and garage clean outs,Pictures hung,Tiolet installed and vanity door knobs installed window cleaning cutter cleaning anything give me a text with pictures you want done thanks
Need work done no time to do it I’ll do it, one man operator at of bohemia someone you can trust in your home,I do painting deck painting,Power washing small jobs,Shrubs removal,Attic’s and basement and garage clean outs,Pictures hung,Tiolet installed and vanity door knobs installed window cleaning cutter cleaning anything give me a text with pictures you want done thanks

OG DIAMOND CONTRACTING
OG DIAMOND CONTRACTING
Renovation, Painting Interior & Exterior, Deck, Vinyl & Hardwood Flooring, Powerwash, Bathroom Remodeling, Carpentry Finish, Wallpaper, Window Cleaning.
Renovation, Painting Interior & Exterior, Deck, Vinyl & Hardwood Flooring, Powerwash, Bathroom Remodeling, Carpentry Finish, Wallpaper, Window Cleaning.

Pesantez Construcción corp
Pesantez Construcción corp
We specialize in carpentry and all home improvement. We also do property Maintenance and management.
We specialize in carpentry and all home improvement. We also do property Maintenance and management.
The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to handyman services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

Looking to add a personal touch or some patriotic flair to your property? Learn about flagpole installation costs and how to budget appropriately.

Mobile home skirting replacement costs come down to the material you choose and the size of your home. Use this guide to budget for your skirting project.

Find out how much it costs to build a chicken coop—whether you've got a few hens in your backyard or a big, self-sustaining flock—with our expert guide.
•Discover the cost to build a dog house. Learn about materials, labor, and ways to save on your custom or prefab dog house project.

If you're wondering who to hire to remove a basketball hoop, it's important to know that handypersons and professionals alike can haul it away.

Have a home repair problem? A highly rated handyman service shares 4 easy DIY tricks you can try yourself before spending money on a handyman service.
- Shelter Island Heights, NY Handymen
- Greenport, NY Handymen
- Southold, NY Handymen
- Peconic, NY Handymen
- Sag Harbor, NY Handymen
- Bridgehampton, NY Handymen
- Orient, NY Handymen
- Cutchogue, NY Handymen
- Wainscott, NY Handymen
- East Hampton, NY Handymen
- Southampton, NY Handymen
- Water Mill, NY Handymen
- Mattituck, NY Handymen
- Amagansett, NY Handymen
- Laurel, NY Handymen
- Jamesport, NY Handymen
- Aquebogue, NY Handymen
- Hampton Bays, NY Handymen
- Old Saybrook, CT Handymen
- Westbrook, CT Handymen
- Lyme, CT Handymen
- Old Lyme, CT Handymen
- Clinton, CT Handymen
- Niantic, CT Handymen
- Riverhead, NY Handymen
- East Quogue, NY Handymen
- Ivoryton, CT Handymen
- Montauk, NY Handymen
- Fishers Island, NY Handymen
- Essex, CT Handymen
- Piano Moving in Shelter Island
- Awnings in Shelter Island
- Screen Repair in Shelter Island
- Lawn Tool Repair in Shelter Island
- Home and Garage Organization in Shelter Island
- Real Estate Agents in Shelter Island
- Childproofing in Shelter Island
- Electrical in Shelter Island
- Dryer Vent Cleaning in Shelter Island
- Playground Equipment in Shelter Island
- Basketball Goals in Shelter Island
- Gutter Cleaning in Shelter Island
- Ceiling Fans in Shelter Island
- 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
- 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
- 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"




