Top-rated fencing pros.

Get matched with top fencing pros in Shelter Island, NY

There are 15 highly-rated local fencing pros.

Need a pro for your fencing service project in Shelter Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.6
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon105
    Verified fencing services reviews

Verified Reviews for Fencing Service pros in Shelter Island, NY

*The Angi rating for Fencing Service companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Fencing Service needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Fencing Service companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Fencing Service needs.

Last update on October 24, 2025

Find Fencing pros in Shelter Island

Avatar for Performance Fence

Performance Fence

17 Beau Jol Ct
4.92(
59
)
•Approved Pro

Performance Fence

17 Beau Jol Ct
4.92(
59
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
152 local quotes requested

Call Jack today for a free estimate at 631-406-6139. Paying great attention to detail throughout the entire process from the initial meeting to the finished product, we give every job our full attention regardless of size. We deliver what we promise and aim to be easy to work with. What we promise is beautiful, long lasting fence installed with you in mind. Whatever your needs - you can depend on Performance Fence for quality workmanship at a competitive price with an emphasis on timely delivery and customer satisfaction.

"Jack was very responsive, he gave me estimate on the same day that I had contacted him. Excellent pricing, workmanship as well. Highly recommend!"

Robert V on October 2025

Call Jack today for a free estimate at 631-406-6139. Paying great attention to detail throughout the entire process from the initial meeting to the finished product, we give every job our full attention regardless of size. We deliver what we promise and aim to be easy to work with. What we promise is beautiful, long lasting fence installed with you in mind. Whatever your needs - you can depend on Performance Fence for quality workmanship at a competitive price with an emphasis on timely delivery and customer satisfaction.

"Jack was very responsive, he gave me estimate on the same day that I had contacted him. Excellent pricing, workmanship as well. Highly recommend!"

Robert V on October 2025

Avatar for Precision Fence Co

Precision Fence Co

3138 Rte112
4.57(
163
)
•Approved Pro

Precision Fence Co

3138 Rte112
4.57(
163
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
101 local quotes requested
21 years of experience

Precision Fence Co is your trusted partner for all your fencing needs in the New York City (Tri-State Area). With our expertise and attention to detail, we deliver top-notch fencing solutions that enhance the security and beauty of your property. Contact us today for a seamless and professional fencing experience.

"I dealt with Mike from precision fence and he was great. The team was quick and neat. Looked like they were never here. The fence is thick and comparing it to other products I was completely satisfied. I would highly recommend Mike from precision and his guys Wilton and George."

Will D on September 2023

Precision Fence Co is your trusted partner for all your fencing needs in the New York City (Tri-State Area). With our expertise and attention to detail, we deliver top-notch fencing solutions that enhance the security and beauty of your property. Contact us today for a seamless and professional fencing experience.

"I dealt with Mike from precision fence and he was great. The team was quick and neat. Looked like they were never here. The fence is thick and comparing it to other products I was completely satisfied. I would highly recommend Mike from precision and his guys Wilton and George."

Will D on September 2023

Avatar for All Island Fence and Railings

All Island Fence and Railings

1320 Motor Pkwy
4.34(
232
)
•Approved Pro

All Island Fence and Railings

1320 Motor Pkwy
4.34(
232
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
206 local quotes requested
34 years of experience

All Island Fence & Railing is a full service fencing company. We have over 35 years of fencing experience, three locations throughout Long Island, and staff to help you along every step of your project. We Mark out utility (gas, electric and water) lines before each installation to protect our customer, customers property, employees, and communities. We are licensed, insured and bonded. Thank you for considering All Island Fence & Railing for your fencing needs!

"I highly recommend All Island Fence and Railings - They have done several jobs for us and we could not be happier with the quality of their work. All their staff from sales, design, office and installation are very professional, low pressure and extremely helpful. We will definitely use them in the future."

Edward M on November 2024

All Island Fence & Railing is a full service fencing company. We have over 35 years of fencing experience, three locations throughout Long Island, and staff to help you along every step of your project. We Mark out utility (gas, electric and water) lines before each installation to protect our customer, customers property, employees, and communities. We are licensed, insured and bonded. Thank you for considering All Island Fence & Railing for your fencing needs!

"I highly recommend All Island Fence and Railings - They have done several jobs for us and we could not be happier with the quality of their work. All their staff from sales, design, office and installation are very professional, low pressure and extremely helpful. We will definitely use them in the future."

Edward M on November 2024

Avatar for Magistrale Fence & Railing Corp.

Magistrale Fence & Railing Corp.

38 SOUTHERN BLVD
New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro

Magistrale Fence & Railing Corp.

38 SOUTHERN BLVD
New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro
50 local quotes requested
7 years of experience

Magistrale Fence & Railing provides top quality Fencing products & solutions along with experienced, professional installation services to ensure that your new fencing looks great and provides you and your family with years of satisfaction. Magistrale Fence & Railing also provides the highest quality Custom Railings, Gates & Pergolas! Please consider contacting us for your next fencing project

Magistrale Fence & Railing provides top quality Fencing products & solutions along with experienced, professional installation services to ensure that your new fencing looks great and provides you and your family with years of satisfaction. Magistrale Fence & Railing also provides the highest quality Custom Railings, Gates & Pergolas! Please consider contacting us for your next fencing project

Avatar for Unlimited Outdoor Designs

Unlimited Outdoor Designs

435 Brook Ave Unit 21
4.24(
21
)
•Approved Pro

Unlimited Outdoor Designs

435 Brook Ave Unit 21
4.24(
21
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Terrific value
233 local quotes requested
12 years of experience

Unlimited Outdoor Designs, specializing in Indoor Kitchens and Baths and Basement remodels. Fencing, Decks, Railings, Concrete, and Masonry work. We are family-owned and take pride in treating our clients like family. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing.

"Was professional and got it done in a timely fashion."

Michael N on May 2024

Unlimited Outdoor Designs, specializing in Indoor Kitchens and Baths and Basement remodels. Fencing, Decks, Railings, Concrete, and Masonry work. We are family-owned and take pride in treating our clients like family. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing.

"Was professional and got it done in a timely fashion."

Michael N on May 2024

Avatar for Oscar’s complete landscaping

Oscar’s complete landscaping

Located In:
5.00(
8
)

Oscar’s complete landscaping

Located In:
5.00(
8
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We specialize in all phases of landscaping, hardscaping, lawn maintenance, fertilization, masonry, pool services, housecleaning and more. We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service. As an added bonus, your first week of lawn maintenance is free! Call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Eric, Oscar and crew were an absolute pleasure to work with. They are true craftsman and did a fantastic Job on my driveway. They completed the job very quickly, cleaning up at the end of each day. I give Dream Pro Care my highest recommendation!"

Ron L on October 2024

We specialize in all phases of landscaping, hardscaping, lawn maintenance, fertilization, masonry, pool services, housecleaning and more. We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service. As an added bonus, your first week of lawn maintenance is free! Call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Eric, Oscar and crew were an absolute pleasure to work with. They are true craftsman and did a fantastic Job on my driveway. They completed the job very quickly, cleaning up at the end of each day. I give Dream Pro Care my highest recommendation!"

Ron L on October 2024

Dfence Group

No reviews yet

Dfence Group

No reviews yet
6 years of experience

DFence was founded by industry veterans to deliver the highest quality of products and craftsmanship. We install and repair Fences, gates, railings and decks. We serve NYC, Nassau & Suffolk county. Fully licensed, bonded and insured.

DFence was founded by industry veterans to deliver the highest quality of products and craftsmanship. We install and repair Fences, gates, railings and decks. We serve NYC, Nassau & Suffolk county. Fully licensed, bonded and insured.

Prima Homes LLC

235P Aerial Way
No reviews yet

Prima Homes LLC

235P Aerial Way
No reviews yet
30 years of experience

We are home improvement company, we specialize doing our work in lowest cost without compromising quality. We dont pile up jobs and give personal touch to one job at a time. We are a services based company since 27 years

We are home improvement company, we specialize doing our work in lowest cost without compromising quality. We dont pile up jobs and give personal touch to one job at a time. We are a services based company since 27 years

EAST END FENCE & DECKING CORP.

5.00(
1
)

EAST END FENCE & DECKING CORP.

5.00(
1
)
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

For ten years, we have been working with materials of all types to build you the perfect fence for your needs. From short vinyl picket fences, to towering steel privacy fences, to the bucolic split rail wood fences, you will be 100% satisfied.

"The reason they were selected is because they provided first-class service to the customers. They returned phone calls promptly; those are the things that I look for. And they were very detail-oriented in terms of the work that they would do for me. They got the job done as they stated it would be completed, and they were cheaper than all of the other contractors. I am 100 percent satisfied with the work that they’ve done. And here’s the bonus: My neighbors were so impressed with their work that they hired them. He did two properties on time, very efficiently, and to our satisfaction. I would recommend them to anyone. He was able to get two jobs because he was so honest, hardworking, and very diligent."

Ron M on June 2024

For ten years, we have been working with materials of all types to build you the perfect fence for your needs. From short vinyl picket fences, to towering steel privacy fences, to the bucolic split rail wood fences, you will be 100% satisfied.

"The reason they were selected is because they provided first-class service to the customers. They returned phone calls promptly; those are the things that I look for. And they were very detail-oriented in terms of the work that they would do for me. They got the job done as they stated it would be completed, and they were cheaper than all of the other contractors. I am 100 percent satisfied with the work that they’ve done. And here’s the bonus: My neighbors were so impressed with their work that they hired them. He did two properties on time, very efficiently, and to our satisfaction. I would recommend them to anyone. He was able to get two jobs because he was so honest, hardworking, and very diligent."

Ron M on June 2024

...
Showing 1-10 of 203
Fencing questions, answered by experts

Paint your fence, install customized fence slats, or attach a bamboo screen for a more appealing yard aesthetic. Paint can give your yard a unique and fun look, and adding fence slats gives you a classic fence appearance. Bamboo screens are probably the most unique option that can add a fun vibe to your space.

You can use a few different tactics to prevent your deck gate from sagging. Aside from using strong, rot-resistant woods, introducing a diagonal element—such as a tension rod or solid piece of wood to act as a brace—across the gate will offer better support. You can also use rigid joists to prevent the gate from sagging.

How long a fence lasts, including a split rail fence, will depend on the material from which it’s made. The average lifespan of a wood fence is about 15 to 20 years. However, split rail fences made out of premium materials, like composite, vinyl, steel, or aluminum, can last for 25 to 30 years or more, especially if you take good care of the material and carry out necessary maintenance.

Some types of snow fences may work for keeping Fido in your yard. The openings can be small enough to prevent a dog from escaping. However, you want to make sure the openings aren’t susceptible for them to get stuck. While some types may contain the pup, the fence will require regular inspection and maintenance. It’s best to discuss which type of snow fence is ideal for your needs with a pro.

Wood fences provide privacy, security, and aesthetic appeal for commercial properties.

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to fencing services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles