Top-rated painters.

Get matched with top painters in Shelter Island, NY

There are 25 highly-rated local painters.

Need a pro for your painting project in Shelter Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon341
    Verified painting services reviews

Find Painters in Shelter Island

Avatar for Palencia's Painting and Window Cleaning Inc

Palencia's Painting and Window Cleaning Inc

5.00(
7
)
Approved Pro

Palencia's Painting and Window Cleaning Inc

5.00(
7
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
32 local quotes requested

We are a proud family owned company servicing the eastern of Long Island; North Fork and south fork since 2017. We specialize in both residential and commercial fine painting. We pride ourselves on providing top quality work and look forward to meeting your next painting and window cleaning needs.

"Eber Palencia and his crew were wonderful and so pleasant to work with. We absolutely recommend them and will hire them again for our next project. Each part of our complete bathroom renovation, from the estimate, demolition, tiling, installation of doors, painting, etc. to the professional clean up at the end of the job was done with honesty, professionalism and expertise, in a timely manner, resulting in our beautiful new bathroom and a stress free experience."

Madelyn R on February 2025

We are a proud family owned company servicing the eastern of Long Island; North Fork and south fork since 2017. We specialize in both residential and commercial fine painting. We pride ourselves on providing top quality work and look forward to meeting your next painting and window cleaning needs.

"Eber Palencia and his crew were wonderful and so pleasant to work with. We absolutely recommend them and will hire them again for our next project. Each part of our complete bathroom renovation, from the estimate, demolition, tiling, installation of doors, painting, etc. to the professional clean up at the end of the job was done with honesty, professionalism and expertise, in a timely manner, resulting in our beautiful new bathroom and a stress free experience."

Madelyn R on February 2025


Avatar for Just Right Carpentry & Painting

Just Right Carpentry & Painting

4.91(
183
)
Approved Pro

Just Right Carpentry & Painting

4.91(
183
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
306 local quotes requested

Just Right Carpentry, Painting Inc., has served Suffolk County for decades with pride and integrity. Family owned and specializing in a range of carpentry and painting; we have the knowledge and expertise to recommend the work to truly fit your homes needs. Please call us for a free estimate. We do not use sub contractors. Charge by the job. No travel/trip charges apply.

"Joe did a great repair job of my ceiling, was punctual, friendly, and even very quick. I will definitely be using their services again for some bigger projects. "

Josh S on November 2025

Just Right Carpentry, Painting Inc., has served Suffolk County for decades with pride and integrity. Family owned and specializing in a range of carpentry and painting; we have the knowledge and expertise to recommend the work to truly fit your homes needs. Please call us for a free estimate. We do not use sub contractors. Charge by the job. No travel/trip charges apply.

"Joe did a great repair job of my ceiling, was punctual, friendly, and even very quick. I will definitely be using their services again for some bigger projects. "

Josh S on November 2025


Avatar for UNIVERSE PAINTING LLC

UNIVERSE PAINTING LLC

5.00(
11
)
Approved Pro

UNIVERSE PAINTING LLC

5.00(
11
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
83 local quotes requested

WE DO ALL KIND OF PAINTING JOB, WE DO STAIN, CABINETS, WALLS, TRIM, HIG GLOSS CEILING AND ANY IDEA YOU WANT TO BRING TO LIFE. WHY CHOOSE US, WELL. WE HAVE BEEN WORKING FOR MORE THAN 10 YEARS DOING HIGH QUALITY WORK ALL OVER LONG ISLAND, AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO DO SO FOR EVEN LONGER. UNTIL OUR WONDERFUL CUSTOMERS ARE SATISFIED.

"Perfectly! Juan and his painters were extremely professional and neat. They did a beautiful job painting the exterior of our home. I highly recommend them!"

Vicki R on September 2025

WE DO ALL KIND OF PAINTING JOB, WE DO STAIN, CABINETS, WALLS, TRIM, HIG GLOSS CEILING AND ANY IDEA YOU WANT TO BRING TO LIFE. WHY CHOOSE US, WELL. WE HAVE BEEN WORKING FOR MORE THAN 10 YEARS DOING HIGH QUALITY WORK ALL OVER LONG ISLAND, AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO DO SO FOR EVEN LONGER. UNTIL OUR WONDERFUL CUSTOMERS ARE SATISFIED.

"Perfectly! Juan and his painters were extremely professional and neat. They did a beautiful job painting the exterior of our home. I highly recommend them!"

Vicki R on September 2025


OnCall Painting

New on AngiNew on Angi
Approved Pro

OnCall Painting

New on AngiNew on Angi
Approved Pro
79 local quotes requested

We guarantee your satisfaction and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule a free estimate today.

We guarantee your satisfaction and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule a free estimate today.


Avatar for MEGA PAINTING & DECORATING INC

MEGA PAINTING & DECORATING INC

4.87(
15
)
Approved Pro

MEGA PAINTING & DECORATING INC

4.87(
15
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
50 local quotes requested

Mega Painting & Decorating, Inc. is your premier choice for all your painting needs. Specializing in residential painting services, we bring years of industry experience to every project, whether large or small. Our commitment to customer satisfaction ensures that we get the job done right the first time, every time. We look forward to the opportunity to work with you. Contact us today to discuss your next project!

"Great! Phil is very professional and personable. The work was first rate and he had good suggestions to offer me. He was very fair with the pricing and helped me with associated projects as well. He completed projects in a timely manner and was very trustworthy. I highly recommend him and would definitely request him in the future!"

Fern D on October 2025

Mega Painting & Decorating, Inc. is your premier choice for all your painting needs. Specializing in residential painting services, we bring years of industry experience to every project, whether large or small. Our commitment to customer satisfaction ensures that we get the job done right the first time, every time. We look forward to the opportunity to work with you. Contact us today to discuss your next project!

"Great! Phil is very professional and personable. The work was first rate and he had good suggestions to offer me. He was very fair with the pricing and helped me with associated projects as well. He completed projects in a timely manner and was very trustworthy. I highly recommend him and would definitely request him in the future!"

Fern D on October 2025


Avatar for B&B painting by the pros

B&B painting by the pros

4.50(
169
)
Approved Pro

B&B painting by the pros

4.50(
169
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
57 local quotes requested
43 years of experience

B & B Painting by the Pro's Incorporated in Bay Shore, New York, is a painting contractor that has been providing outstanding services for more than 37 years. We employ workers that are clean, neat, and courteous and provide affordable and quality services. We have acquired many references thanks to our more than 37 years in the industry. Rest assured that we value your business, as clients deal directly with the boss.

"Four-person crew was excellent. All were very reliable, responsible and skilled technicians. They were quite responsive to my queries and requests. They also took considerable time cleaning rooms and restoring furniture to original placement. I would not hesitate to have them back in my home for additional work and will readily recommend to others. Supervisor provided good oversight of the job. He also responded to requests on a timely basis."

Carole N on April 2022

B & B Painting by the Pro's Incorporated in Bay Shore, New York, is a painting contractor that has been providing outstanding services for more than 37 years. We employ workers that are clean, neat, and courteous and provide affordable and quality services. We have acquired many references thanks to our more than 37 years in the industry. Rest assured that we value your business, as clients deal directly with the boss.

"Four-person crew was excellent. All were very reliable, responsible and skilled technicians. They were quite responsive to my queries and requests. They also took considerable time cleaning rooms and restoring furniture to original placement. I would not hesitate to have them back in my home for additional work and will readily recommend to others. Supervisor provided good oversight of the job. He also responded to requests on a timely basis."

Carole N on April 2022


Painter And Handyman Services INC

No reviews yet

Painter And Handyman Services INC

No reviews yet
Free onsite estimate

Hey,my name's Andrew. I'm from Ukraine. With extensive experience working in both the UK and Italy, I offer specialized painting and handyman services designed to meet all your home improvement needs. From carefully executed interior and exterior painting to a wide range of repair and maintenance tasks, my approach blends the precision and quality of European craftsmanship with a keen attention to detail. I take pride in delivering high-quality work that not only refreshes and enhances your space but also stands the test of time. Whether you need to touch up a single room, carry out small repairs, or give your entire property a new look, I'm here to provide a reliable, personal service you can depend on. King Regard.

Hey,my name's Andrew. I'm from Ukraine. With extensive experience working in both the UK and Italy, I offer specialized painting and handyman services designed to meet all your home improvement needs. From carefully executed interior and exterior painting to a wide range of repair and maintenance tasks, my approach blends the precision and quality of European craftsmanship with a keen attention to detail. I take pride in delivering high-quality work that not only refreshes and enhances your space but also stands the test of time. Whether you need to touch up a single room, carry out small repairs, or give your entire property a new look, I'm here to provide a reliable, personal service you can depend on. King Regard.



Avatar for Chuna

Chuna

No reviews yet

Chuna

No reviews yet
3 years of experience

Need work done no time to do it I’ll do it, one man operator at of bohemia someone you can trust in your home,I do painting deck painting,Power washing small jobs,Shrubs removal,Attic’s and basement and garage clean outs,Pictures hung,Tiolet installed and vanity door knobs installed window cleaning cutter cleaning anything give me a text with pictures you want done thanks

Need work done no time to do it I’ll do it, one man operator at of bohemia someone you can trust in your home,I do painting deck painting,Power washing small jobs,Shrubs removal,Attic’s and basement and garage clean outs,Pictures hung,Tiolet installed and vanity door knobs installed window cleaning cutter cleaning anything give me a text with pictures you want done thanks


Avatar for Tobar Construction Inc

Tobar Construction Inc

No reviews yet

Tobar Construction Inc

No reviews yet
1 years of experience

Tobars Construction is a newly established company specializing in general remodeling, kitchen and bathroom renovations, and interior painting. With years of experience in the industry, we’ve launched our own business to deliver high-quality construction and exceptional service. Our mission is to grow, satisfy, and bring your vision to life by creating refined, functional spaces. Whether it’s a full remodel or a fresh interior update, Tobars Construction is committed to excellence and customer satisfaction in every project.

Tobars Construction is a newly established company specializing in general remodeling, kitchen and bathroom renovations, and interior painting. With years of experience in the industry, we’ve launched our own business to deliver high-quality construction and exceptional service. Our mission is to grow, satisfy, and bring your vision to life by creating refined, functional spaces. Whether it’s a full remodel or a fresh interior update, Tobars Construction is committed to excellence and customer satisfaction in every project.

...
Showing 1-10 of 206
Painting questions, answered by experts

It’s best to remove wallpaper rather than paint over it. You should only paint over wallpaper if removing it would damage the wall, the surface is relatively smooth, or there are minimal problem areas—such as slight peeling and lifted seams—that you can fix easily. Painting over wallpaper can save time, but it can create more problems if the wallpaper is in poor condition and you don’t properly prep the area for painting. Depending on the state of the wallpaper, color, and textures could show through, and moisture from the paint could loosen the adhesive, causing unsightly bubbling.

An exterior paint job lasts an average of 5 to 10 years, although some might only last 2 or 3 years and others up to 20 years. How often you need to paint your home’s exterior depends on various factors. The type and quality of the paint, the application quality, the surface material, and local weather conditions all play a part in the paint’s longevity. 

Renting a sprayer is the easiest way to paint a barn, but for detailed areas, you’ll want to use a hand brush to get the job done. If you don’t wish to rent a sprayer, you can also use a roller to hand-paint your barn, but this will add time to your project.

Costs depend on room size, wall condition, and the required coats.

You may or may not be able to paint over your old exterior paint. If the existing paint is in good shape, then you can paint a new layer on top. But if your paint is flaky, you'll need to scrape off the old paint before adding any new layers. Also, it’s best to use primer first to help your paint stick properly.

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to painting services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.