Top-rated gutter repair and replacement pros.

Get matched with top gutter repair and replacement pros in Baileys Harbor, WI

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your gutter repair and replacement project in Baileys Harbor, WI?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

Verified Reviews for Gutter Repair And Replacement pros in Baileys Harbor, WI

*The Angi rating for Gutter Repair And Replacement companies in Baileys Harbor, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Gutter Repair And Replacement needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Gutter Repair And Replacement companies in Baileys Harbor, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Gutter Repair And Replacement needs.

Last update on December 06, 2025

Find Gutter repair and replacement pros in Baileys Harbor

Avatar for Armor Shield Metal Roofing

Armor Shield Metal Roofing

4.81(
177
)

Armor Shield Metal Roofing

4.81(
177
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers

Armor Shield Metal Roofing is proud to serve the Northeast and Northern Wisconsin communities with their roofing, insulation, gutter, siding, and window needs. We are a local, family-owned home improvement and roofing contractor located in Green Bay. We have over 27 years experience in the construction and home improvement industry. We continue to out-perform our competition in every category because our focus is on saving our customers money while improving the value of their homes by installing only the highest quality products. We have carefully chosen our product line because we understand energy costs are always a major concern with our harsh Wisconsin winters. We invite you to take a further look at what Armor Shield of Wisconsin can do for your home! Ask about Angie's list discount.

"They did a great job, looks great and cleaned up after like nothing happened."

Douglas J on August 2025

Armor Shield Metal Roofing is proud to serve the Northeast and Northern Wisconsin communities with their roofing, insulation, gutter, siding, and window needs. We are a local, family-owned home improvement and roofing contractor located in Green Bay. We have over 27 years experience in the construction and home improvement industry. We continue to out-perform our competition in every category because our focus is on saving our customers money while improving the value of their homes by installing only the highest quality products. We have carefully chosen our product line because we understand energy costs are always a major concern with our harsh Wisconsin winters. We invite you to take a further look at what Armor Shield of Wisconsin can do for your home! Ask about Angie's list discount.

"They did a great job, looks great and cleaned up after like nothing happened."

Douglas J on August 2025

Avatar for Property Image LLC

Property Image LLC

4.91(
34
)

Property Image LLC

4.91(
34
)
Customers say: Terrific value
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Property maintenance company working with commercial and residential customers. 8 - 12 Employees. Licensed and insured. Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Online work order system for all customers. Hourly rates. Per job pricing available too.

Property maintenance company working with commercial and residential customers. 8 - 12 Employees. Licensed and insured. Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Online work order system for all customers. Hourly rates. Per job pricing available too.

LeafGuard Gutters and Roofing by Keeney Home Services

4.68(
22
)

LeafGuard Gutters and Roofing by Keeney Home Services

4.68(
22
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers

Keeney Home Services is your homes expert from the attic up. We specialize in all work from your attic up including Gutter Shutter Gutters, Roofing and Insulation and air sealing. Your home is a very dynamic piece of equipment and you need to have an expert that understands how every aspect of your home works. Gutter Shutter Gutters offer the home owners the peace of mind of never going on a ladder to clean their gutters. Our roofing division gives the homeowner the best roof available to protect their biggest investment. Dr. Energy saver takes a diagnostic approach to making your home comfortable, healthier and more energy efficient .

"Really well."

Mathew L on October 2019

Keeney Home Services is your homes expert from the attic up. We specialize in all work from your attic up including Gutter Shutter Gutters, Roofing and Insulation and air sealing. Your home is a very dynamic piece of equipment and you need to have an expert that understands how every aspect of your home works. Gutter Shutter Gutters offer the home owners the peace of mind of never going on a ladder to clean their gutters. Our roofing division gives the homeowner the best roof available to protect their biggest investment. Dr. Energy saver takes a diagnostic approach to making your home comfortable, healthier and more energy efficient .

"Really well."

Mathew L on October 2019

SPS Roofing Systems

4.74(
47
)

SPS Roofing Systems

4.74(
47
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers

We provide commercial and residential roof services. Our goal is to deliver the highest quality materials and workmanship to our customers. We believe a satisfied customer is the backbone of a company. We will work with our customers to achieve the results they expect at a price they can afford.

"This company charged an elderly couple that lived in a different state $44,000 to replace a flat roof in Two Rivers. After inspecting the roof for a few minutes it was clear that none of the decking the customer paid for to have replaced was actually replaced. It was still spongy and rotten under the new membrane. Unfortunately they lived in a different state and were unable to see the finished product before they paid their invoice."

Duane D on September 2024

We provide commercial and residential roof services. Our goal is to deliver the highest quality materials and workmanship to our customers. We believe a satisfied customer is the backbone of a company. We will work with our customers to achieve the results they expect at a price they can afford.

"This company charged an elderly couple that lived in a different state $44,000 to replace a flat roof in Two Rivers. After inspecting the roof for a few minutes it was clear that none of the decking the customer paid for to have replaced was actually replaced. It was still spongy and rotten under the new membrane. Unfortunately they lived in a different state and were unable to see the finished product before they paid their invoice."

Duane D on September 2024

Castle Rock Restoration Inc

4.56(
16
)

Castle Rock Restoration Inc

4.56(
16
)
Customers say: Quality work
2010 years of experience

The Castle Rock staff is a dynamic group of professionals. They are a well-trained, cohesive team, each with many years of experience in their respective areas. Clients are impressed by the personal attention they receive by the staff at Castle Rock. Instead of the old "us against them" mentality, the staff treats each client as part of the team and stresses open communication Free Home Evaluation available. Additional phone - (855) 846-8424 & (847)-438-4442 Additional DBA - Castle Rock Construction 1 INC

"went very well. The regional manager, Dave, was very personable and knowledgeable. Work was done quickly, efficiently and well."

Nanci M on March 2018

The Castle Rock staff is a dynamic group of professionals. They are a well-trained, cohesive team, each with many years of experience in their respective areas. Clients are impressed by the personal attention they receive by the staff at Castle Rock. Instead of the old "us against them" mentality, the staff treats each client as part of the team and stresses open communication Free Home Evaluation available. Additional phone - (855) 846-8424 & (847)-438-4442 Additional DBA - Castle Rock Construction 1 INC

"went very well. The regional manager, Dave, was very personable and knowledgeable. Work was done quickly, efficiently and well."

Nanci M on March 2018

Hardy & Jensen Inc

4.78(
23
)

Hardy & Jensen Inc

4.78(
23
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers

Authorized installing retailer of Infinity Replacement Windows from Marvin. Additional phone number - (888) 870-4900. Additional email - [email protected] . Additional DBA - Leisure Living Center Inc.

Authorized installing retailer of Infinity Replacement Windows from Marvin. Additional phone number - (888) 870-4900. Additional email - [email protected] . Additional DBA - Leisure Living Center Inc.

Avatar for ARC Contracting of Wisconsin Inc

ARC Contracting of Wisconsin Inc

4.14(
51
)

ARC Contracting of Wisconsin Inc

4.14(
51
)
Customers say: Quality work
2006 years of experience

At ARC Contracting, we want to redefine the experience you have with your sales person, your contractor, and the support you get along the way. ARC Contracting specializes in residential and commercial full-service exterior contracting, including roofing, gutters, soffit, facia, windows, siding, insulation, and solar.

"Typically I don’t write reviews. However, the process of our project was very poorly managed by ARC despite the reassurance that we would have a project manager. We never saw a project manager through the whole process. We had to manage through many issues and rework, from the wrong color siding being put on, to water coming in my kitchen from the roof not being wrapped correctly and nails sticking out of the roof. From the edging not being finished and siding that covered our cable to siding that was cut in corners for some reason to poor calking and beyond. We had to manage and call or email the issues at every step of the way because no one was here managing the project. The final straw was when they were here to finally fix the issues they were nailing siding into a wall and broke the tile in our bathroom. I asked for ½ of the $5K that I had paid to have my shower tiled since the tile was discontinued and it would be roughly $8K to have it redone today. I thought I was being fair, but this is what I got back: “Again, I apologize. It is not an excuse, but with the transition of some key employees things weren't managed correctly. I would be upset if I was in your position. I would have a hard time recommending ARC also. I did talk with management and we will discount $1,000 for the shower with the understanding there won't be a negative review left online. I don't expect a 5 star review online since you didn't' have a 5 star experience. Does that sound fair?” This is not a company that stands behind their work or their word. I would not recommend them as in a previous email I was told: “I am having a hard time to justify a $2,500 discount to my management for a few tiles that may have broken from siding installation.” They MAY have broken? I’m lying? They also asked me to put in an “accent” color where it broke, where there is no other accent tiles and would look horrible. Thank you, but I loved my shower and now it looks horrible and will need to redo the entire shower. But you can’t buy a good review from me as the $1K is not worth it to me (and yes I was told that they have insurance, so they should have it covered). I have attached pictures that show only a portion of the crappy work that we had to have them redo. Shame on you ARC, I went with you despite you being more expensive than another company because of what you promised. Stand behind your word and your work. Very unhappy customer. Wanitta Charnon"

Wanitta C on April 2025

At ARC Contracting, we want to redefine the experience you have with your sales person, your contractor, and the support you get along the way. ARC Contracting specializes in residential and commercial full-service exterior contracting, including roofing, gutters, soffit, facia, windows, siding, insulation, and solar.

"Typically I don’t write reviews. However, the process of our project was very poorly managed by ARC despite the reassurance that we would have a project manager. We never saw a project manager through the whole process. We had to manage through many issues and rework, from the wrong color siding being put on, to water coming in my kitchen from the roof not being wrapped correctly and nails sticking out of the roof. From the edging not being finished and siding that covered our cable to siding that was cut in corners for some reason to poor calking and beyond. We had to manage and call or email the issues at every step of the way because no one was here managing the project. The final straw was when they were here to finally fix the issues they were nailing siding into a wall and broke the tile in our bathroom. I asked for ½ of the $5K that I had paid to have my shower tiled since the tile was discontinued and it would be roughly $8K to have it redone today. I thought I was being fair, but this is what I got back: “Again, I apologize. It is not an excuse, but with the transition of some key employees things weren't managed correctly. I would be upset if I was in your position. I would have a hard time recommending ARC also. I did talk with management and we will discount $1,000 for the shower with the understanding there won't be a negative review left online. I don't expect a 5 star review online since you didn't' have a 5 star experience. Does that sound fair?” This is not a company that stands behind their work or their word. I would not recommend them as in a previous email I was told: “I am having a hard time to justify a $2,500 discount to my management for a few tiles that may have broken from siding installation.” They MAY have broken? I’m lying? They also asked me to put in an “accent” color where it broke, where there is no other accent tiles and would look horrible. Thank you, but I loved my shower and now it looks horrible and will need to redo the entire shower. But you can’t buy a good review from me as the $1K is not worth it to me (and yes I was told that they have insurance, so they should have it covered). I have attached pictures that show only a portion of the crappy work that we had to have them redo. Shame on you ARC, I went with you despite you being more expensive than another company because of what you promised. Stand behind your word and your work. Very unhappy customer. Wanitta Charnon"

Wanitta C on April 2025

Avatar for Security-Luebke Roofing

Security-Luebke Roofing

4.46(
13
)

Security-Luebke Roofing

4.46(
13
)
Customers say: Super punctual
1957 years of experience

Everyone needs, and deserves, a reliable roof over their heads. Customers choose Security-Luebke because they want to get the best advice, products, warranties and installation techniques for long-lasting performance. Workers choose this company because they feel empowered to be part of the proud reputation of customer focus. They also feel the reliability of future employment growth. Since 1957, Security-Luebke Roofing has roofed homes and businesses across the Fox Valley. With over 120 employees, we provide personal, hands-on services from the first call to handing over the industry-leading warranty. The future of Security-Luebke Roofing is bright with steady growth, building on the foundation and principles of providing quality products installed with quality labor. Learn about our 60 year history of the best craftsmanship, safety, and environmental stewardship. Homeowners, businesses and organizations from Green Bay to Appleton to Manitowoc to Oshkosh can expect us to provide unmatched roofing excellence.

Everyone needs, and deserves, a reliable roof over their heads. Customers choose Security-Luebke because they want to get the best advice, products, warranties and installation techniques for long-lasting performance. Workers choose this company because they feel empowered to be part of the proud reputation of customer focus. They also feel the reliability of future employment growth. Since 1957, Security-Luebke Roofing has roofed homes and businesses across the Fox Valley. With over 120 employees, we provide personal, hands-on services from the first call to handing over the industry-leading warranty. The future of Security-Luebke Roofing is bright with steady growth, building on the foundation and principles of providing quality products installed with quality labor. Learn about our 60 year history of the best craftsmanship, safety, and environmental stewardship. Homeowners, businesses and organizations from Green Bay to Appleton to Manitowoc to Oshkosh can expect us to provide unmatched roofing excellence.

Buckshot General Contracting

4.05(
21
)

Buckshot General Contracting

4.05(
21
)
Customers say: Terrific value
1979 years of experience

Buckshot General Contracting, in Janesville, WI, is your premium roofing contractor. Locally owned and operated since 1979, we offer a variety of services including roofing, siding, gutters, storm damage (including hail damage and wind damage). You can count on us to be reliable, punctual, and professional. For all your roofing needs, contact Buckshot General Contracting, in Janesville, where we offer 24-hour emergency services!

"We could not have been happier. From start to finish the process was smooth and easy. I started out thinking I needed some roofing repair and by the time it was all said and done I had a lot more damage than I could see. Long story short, I have a new roof and new siding and my house is amazing. Buckshot answered the call and then some with friendly and experienced representatives. Top notch and couldn't be happier!!!"

Jason B on May 2022

Buckshot General Contracting, in Janesville, WI, is your premium roofing contractor. Locally owned and operated since 1979, we offer a variety of services including roofing, siding, gutters, storm damage (including hail damage and wind damage). You can count on us to be reliable, punctual, and professional. For all your roofing needs, contact Buckshot General Contracting, in Janesville, where we offer 24-hour emergency services!

"We could not have been happier. From start to finish the process was smooth and easy. I started out thinking I needed some roofing repair and by the time it was all said and done I had a lot more damage than I could see. Long story short, I have a new roof and new siding and my house is amazing. Buckshot answered the call and then some with friendly and experienced representatives. Top notch and couldn't be happier!!!"

Jason B on May 2022

...
Showing 1-10 of 51
Gutter Repair and Replacement questions, answered by experts

If you don't repair your home’s gutter leaks, water or the gutters themselves can damage your home’s siding, roofing, foundation, and landscaping. Untreated leaks encourage mildew, mold, and rot, depending on the type of siding material. The foundation, chimney, window frames, and drywall can also crack over time, leading to costly repairs. 

Gutters should not drip at the seams. This problem could indicate that water is collecting in the gutters instead of moving to the downspouts. You could have leaves or other debris blocking the flow of water at the seams. Try cleaning the gutters, adjusting the slope, and sealing any holes or cracks in the material to fix this problem.

A full gutter system, or even a full gutter replacement , costs homeowners an average of around $1,200 . This is a very rough number based on the average-sized home with a typical roof build, using vinyl gutters. This average also assumes the roof is in good condition, as you can’t hang new gutters on a rotting or sloping roof. Factors that increase cost are metal gutters, larger homes, and unique gutter styles.

Whether it’s better to repaint or replace gutters will depend on their overall state. One or two small damages can easily be fixed and covered up with a fresh coat of paint for minimal additional costs. On the other hand, you’ll likely pay less to install a new set-up rather than fixing one that’s heavily damaged.

Poor gutter drainage can cause sagging gutters, roof damage, mold, mildew, rot, basement flooding, and foundation cracks. With gutter replacement costs possible for just $500, getting the right system can save you thousands in repairs down the road.

The Baileys Harbor, WI homeowners’ guide to gutter repairs and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"