Top-rated water heater pros.

Get matched with top water heater pros in Locust Valley, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

TRUSTED BY LOCUST VALLEY, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.8
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon36
    Verified water heater services reviews

Find Water heater pros in Locust Valley

Avatar for Heartland Village General Contracting and Handyman Services

Heartland Village General Contracting and Handyman Services

4.80(
184
)
Approved Pro

Heartland Village General Contracting and Handyman Services

4.80(
184
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers
1994 years of experience

WE ARE OPEN WITH SAFETY PRECAUTIONS ,,LICENSE AND INSURED NEW YORK,,NASSAU COUNTY,, NEW JERSEY AREAS, EPA LEAD CERTIFIED. We work with insurance claims With over 25 years of experience, Heartland Village Handyman Services is the top choice for Home Renovation and Repairs . We offer a full-range of Contracting Services including Remodeling,, Repairs, and virtually all phases of Home Improvement. We pride ourselves on customer satisfaction, and value our relationships. Proud recipient of the Angie's List Super Service Award Winner for 2016, 2017, and 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 We offer affordable rates Give us a call today to schedule your free consultation

"I highly recommend this company Heartland Village General Contracting Handyman Services of Staten Island, N.Y. Harvey the owner & his excellent team were professional, punctual & attentative to every detail in building my beautiful handicap TREX brown boards & Grey metal railings ramp to my front door. This fantastic company also closed in my screen house for the rain & possibly snow cold winter months with this beautiful design of Plexiglass. His team also completed odd jobs of installing two door bells, replaced damaged tiles in my kitchen & installed tinting sheets on four kitchen windows which I love. Thank you Harvey & your professional team of excellence. Sue M. - Staten Island 9/12/25"

sue m on September 2025

WE ARE OPEN WITH SAFETY PRECAUTIONS ,,LICENSE AND INSURED NEW YORK,,NASSAU COUNTY,, NEW JERSEY AREAS, EPA LEAD CERTIFIED. We work with insurance claims With over 25 years of experience, Heartland Village Handyman Services is the top choice for Home Renovation and Repairs . We offer a full-range of Contracting Services including Remodeling,, Repairs, and virtually all phases of Home Improvement. We pride ourselves on customer satisfaction, and value our relationships. Proud recipient of the Angie's List Super Service Award Winner for 2016, 2017, and 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 We offer affordable rates Give us a call today to schedule your free consultation

"I highly recommend this company Heartland Village General Contracting Handyman Services of Staten Island, N.Y. Harvey the owner & his excellent team were professional, punctual & attentative to every detail in building my beautiful handicap TREX brown boards & Grey metal railings ramp to my front door. This fantastic company also closed in my screen house for the rain & possibly snow cold winter months with this beautiful design of Plexiglass. His team also completed odd jobs of installing two door bells, replaced damaged tiles in my kitchen & installed tinting sheets on four kitchen windows which I love. Thank you Harvey & your professional team of excellence. Sue M. - Staten Island 9/12/25"

sue m on September 2025


Avatar for Tumminello Plumbing & Heating, Inc.

Tumminello Plumbing & Heating, Inc.

4.94(
116
)

Tumminello Plumbing & Heating, Inc.

4.94(
116
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Tumminello Plumbing & Heating, Inc. is a small owner business, ran by Michael Tumminello. Michael has been a Local Union 1 plumber for over 30 years with his Master's Plumbers License with The Town of Hempstead. He is also licensed by numerous other cities, towns, and villages throughout Nassau and Suffolk counties.

"I had a terrible leak in my bathrooms in a 60 year old home. Mike over at Tumminello's quoted me an all-in price. Mike immediately realized I needed the lead pipes leading up to my toilet replaced. I knew as soon as Mike described what he wanted to do that is what I waned. Mike gave me an alternative, but I went with the full replacement choice. The other plumbers I called could only give me an hourly rate. The two guys that came to my home, Matt and Ryan, were very friendly and respectful. The work was quoted and done quickly and at a very reasonable cost. I had 2 toilets installed and leak fixed. I had my lead bends replaced; both leaked; both definitely needed replacement. Mike was very flexible on whether I wanted to install my own toilets or if I wanted him to pick them up. I told him the toilet that I was looking at, and he told me he could get a quote on a similar toilet. He saved me from having to order the toilet, and waiting a week over at HD or Lowe's. He called me back in about 10 minutes, we agreed on a toilet. My elderly father then decided he wanted his toilet changed too. I called Mike, and someone else answered, I told them I wanted to add a toilet, but with a rounded shape. The next day, Matt and Ryan arrived with both toilets. They did a great job on the toilets and the leak. I'm doing more work to my plumbing, and will definitely be using Tumminello Plumbing and Heating again. Thanks to everyone over at Tumminello's Plumbing and Heating."

Alfred A on October 2021

Tumminello Plumbing & Heating, Inc. is a small owner business, ran by Michael Tumminello. Michael has been a Local Union 1 plumber for over 30 years with his Master's Plumbers License with The Town of Hempstead. He is also licensed by numerous other cities, towns, and villages throughout Nassau and Suffolk counties.

"I had a terrible leak in my bathrooms in a 60 year old home. Mike over at Tumminello's quoted me an all-in price. Mike immediately realized I needed the lead pipes leading up to my toilet replaced. I knew as soon as Mike described what he wanted to do that is what I waned. Mike gave me an alternative, but I went with the full replacement choice. The other plumbers I called could only give me an hourly rate. The two guys that came to my home, Matt and Ryan, were very friendly and respectful. The work was quoted and done quickly and at a very reasonable cost. I had 2 toilets installed and leak fixed. I had my lead bends replaced; both leaked; both definitely needed replacement. Mike was very flexible on whether I wanted to install my own toilets or if I wanted him to pick them up. I told him the toilet that I was looking at, and he told me he could get a quote on a similar toilet. He saved me from having to order the toilet, and waiting a week over at HD or Lowe's. He called me back in about 10 minutes, we agreed on a toilet. My elderly father then decided he wanted his toilet changed too. I called Mike, and someone else answered, I told them I wanted to add a toilet, but with a rounded shape. The next day, Matt and Ryan arrived with both toilets. They did a great job on the toilets and the leak. I'm doing more work to my plumbing, and will definitely be using Tumminello Plumbing and Heating again. Thanks to everyone over at Tumminello's Plumbing and Heating."

Alfred A on October 2021


Avatar for BILL WIENER'S HEATING & COOLING SERVICES, INC.

BILL WIENER'S HEATING & COOLING SERVICES, INC.

4.99(
117
)

BILL WIENER'S HEATING & COOLING SERVICES, INC.

4.99(
117
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

REPAIRS/SERVICE ONLY- NO INSTALLATIONS! Proud winner of the 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019 & 2020 Super Service Awards! Third Generation expert mechanic, highly skilled & professional- EXPERT REPAIRS for steam/gas/oil boilers, furnace and central air conditioning. I am available for water heater replacements. Unfortunately, we are no longer installing or replacing any old/broken heating or cooling equipment due to business model change. Bill is the owner/operator-will take your phone call, speak to you about the requested/required work and be on the job working. Repair Payment due upon completion. Call us today at (516) 771-5326

"After discovering my home heating system had failed, I contacted Mr. Bill Wiener's Heating & Cooling Services. Bill Wiener responded quickly and diagnosed our problem...the 42 y.o. boiler was leaking water and needed to be replaced. We hired Bill Wiener and are pleased that we did. Bill committed to removing and replacing our gas boiler. He did everything he promised in a professional, clean, and competent manner. He worked tirelessly to get our heat up and running in one day! I'm happy to recommend Bill Wiener to my family and friends, in fact, I already have, Thanks Bill...You're the best."

JOE R on February 2023

REPAIRS/SERVICE ONLY- NO INSTALLATIONS! Proud winner of the 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019 & 2020 Super Service Awards! Third Generation expert mechanic, highly skilled & professional- EXPERT REPAIRS for steam/gas/oil boilers, furnace and central air conditioning. I am available for water heater replacements. Unfortunately, we are no longer installing or replacing any old/broken heating or cooling equipment due to business model change. Bill is the owner/operator-will take your phone call, speak to you about the requested/required work and be on the job working. Repair Payment due upon completion. Call us today at (516) 771-5326

"After discovering my home heating system had failed, I contacted Mr. Bill Wiener's Heating & Cooling Services. Bill Wiener responded quickly and diagnosed our problem...the 42 y.o. boiler was leaking water and needed to be replaced. We hired Bill Wiener and are pleased that we did. Bill committed to removing and replacing our gas boiler. He did everything he promised in a professional, clean, and competent manner. He worked tirelessly to get our heat up and running in one day! I'm happy to recommend Bill Wiener to my family and friends, in fact, I already have, Thanks Bill...You're the best."

JOE R on February 2023


Avatar for AppliancePartsPros.com

AppliancePartsPros.com

4.73(
287
)

AppliancePartsPros.com

4.73(
287
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Since 1999, we've helped millions of do-it-yourselfers save money and fix their broken appliances quickly by providing quality appliance parts and free repair advice. We are only an online appliance parts retailer that offers a 365 day warranty and fast shipping. We also offer technical advice and diagnosis totally free 6 days a week. If you are interested in repairing your own appliance, please call us at 1-877-477-7278 or click live chat on our web site. We will help diagnose the problem and provide you with all the necessary information for the repair free of charge. It's better with the Pros!™ Avoid costly service calls - visit us at http://www.appliancepartspros.com

"Beware of shipping issues with this company. Ordered an ice maker installation kit on 10/10/25. Shipping was due no later than 10/20 according to company and FedEx tracking. FedEx tracking showed the package at their facility for 8 days without moving beginning on 10/15. Called FedEx 3 times. Each time they said they cannot find package and I have to contact shipper. Shipper has to make a claim, they will not mark it as lost. Called Appliance Parts Pros twice. Each time they say FedEx has to mark package lost before they will do anything. They also state they have to wait 14 days from them before doing anything because of their contract with FedEx. I don't care about their contract, I want what was ordered and paid for. Just going in circles with them and FedEX. If they shipped after 14 days it would be 22 days from that point, 32 days from the date of order if they shipped it that day. There was a deadline for installing this part before tenants arrive. They did not care, would not m"

Ron R on October 2025

Since 1999, we've helped millions of do-it-yourselfers save money and fix their broken appliances quickly by providing quality appliance parts and free repair advice. We are only an online appliance parts retailer that offers a 365 day warranty and fast shipping. We also offer technical advice and diagnosis totally free 6 days a week. If you are interested in repairing your own appliance, please call us at 1-877-477-7278 or click live chat on our web site. We will help diagnose the problem and provide you with all the necessary information for the repair free of charge. It's better with the Pros!™ Avoid costly service calls - visit us at http://www.appliancepartspros.com

"Beware of shipping issues with this company. Ordered an ice maker installation kit on 10/10/25. Shipping was due no later than 10/20 according to company and FedEx tracking. FedEx tracking showed the package at their facility for 8 days without moving beginning on 10/15. Called FedEx 3 times. Each time they said they cannot find package and I have to contact shipper. Shipper has to make a claim, they will not mark it as lost. Called Appliance Parts Pros twice. Each time they say FedEx has to mark package lost before they will do anything. They also state they have to wait 14 days from them before doing anything because of their contract with FedEx. I don't care about their contract, I want what was ordered and paid for. Just going in circles with them and FedEX. If they shipped after 14 days it would be 22 days from that point, 32 days from the date of order if they shipped it that day. There was a deadline for installing this part before tenants arrive. They did not care, would not m"

Ron R on October 2025


Avatar for Solar Living, Inc

Solar Living, Inc

5.00(
58
)

Solar Living, Inc

5.00(
58
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Providing Better than free solar(tm) electric solutions and Every degree is free(R) pool/water heating solutions. USA manufactured materials focused. 40+ years of continuous operations serving NJ and northeastern PA. Licensed and insured.

"Had my 13Kw system installed 2 years ago. I wanted to wait to see how everything was running before entering the review. The system is working great and no animals are getting in under the panels. Solar Living made sure the panels were well protected. The design is good and was able to add as many panels without compromising the look of the roof. In 2 years, one of the Enphase IQ 7 failed and Solar Living automatically contacted me to schedule a visit to replace the unit. It's great to have peace of mind where the system is being taken care of without me maintaining it."

HENRY K on October 2023

Providing Better than free solar(tm) electric solutions and Every degree is free(R) pool/water heating solutions. USA manufactured materials focused. 40+ years of continuous operations serving NJ and northeastern PA. Licensed and insured.

"Had my 13Kw system installed 2 years ago. I wanted to wait to see how everything was running before entering the review. The system is working great and no animals are getting in under the panels. Solar Living made sure the panels were well protected. The design is good and was able to add as many panels without compromising the look of the roof. In 2 years, one of the Enphase IQ 7 failed and Solar Living automatically contacted me to schedule a visit to replace the unit. It's great to have peace of mind where the system is being taken care of without me maintaining it."

HENRY K on October 2023


Avatar for Top Notch Climate Control LLC

Top Notch Climate Control LLC

4.85(
100
)

Top Notch Climate Control LLC

4.85(
100
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers

The owners of Top Notch Climate Control, LLC are with you from the very start of your job, through the planning and sale process, to the installation and any future service you may need. Whenever you call us you will talk with an owner, which means you will get “Top Notch Service”. We care about keeping you comfortable in your home, no matter the season. Top Notch Climate Control, LLC stands for the highest quality in the HVAC industry. We stand behind our work 100% and we are not happy until our clients are happy. Meet the owners of Top Notch Climate Control Stan Palaka and Dave Wade

"They are weak in trouble shooting and providing clear recommendations due to which we incurred significant costs. It’s sad to give your business to a company wherein you spend $2000 on a repair only to be told 72 hours later you need to replace the entire furnace. No appreciation for customer loyalty or that during COVID some refund should have been provided. Instead they did not take any ownership for it. Furnace was only 13 yrs old and they did the maintainence on it for 10 of those years. We lost our heating one say and they suggested the furnace required a new inducer and mother board for $2000. We went with that repair only to find out 72 hours later our heating stopped again abs this time it was found our heat exchanger was leaking water. Anyway nothing good comes out of taking undue advantage of people. The lesson here is try to find a company that has expertise in your brand of furnace. We later researched and found out our furnace was known to have heat exchanger issues. This company only has knowledge on the brand of furnace they install. Everything is else you as the customer do at risk as they will not take any accountability of their repairs don’t work. I have never come across a company like this one."

Vidhu D on December 2020

The owners of Top Notch Climate Control, LLC are with you from the very start of your job, through the planning and sale process, to the installation and any future service you may need. Whenever you call us you will talk with an owner, which means you will get “Top Notch Service”. We care about keeping you comfortable in your home, no matter the season. Top Notch Climate Control, LLC stands for the highest quality in the HVAC industry. We stand behind our work 100% and we are not happy until our clients are happy. Meet the owners of Top Notch Climate Control Stan Palaka and Dave Wade

"They are weak in trouble shooting and providing clear recommendations due to which we incurred significant costs. It’s sad to give your business to a company wherein you spend $2000 on a repair only to be told 72 hours later you need to replace the entire furnace. No appreciation for customer loyalty or that during COVID some refund should have been provided. Instead they did not take any ownership for it. Furnace was only 13 yrs old and they did the maintainence on it for 10 of those years. We lost our heating one say and they suggested the furnace required a new inducer and mother board for $2000. We went with that repair only to find out 72 hours later our heating stopped again abs this time it was found our heat exchanger was leaking water. Anyway nothing good comes out of taking undue advantage of people. The lesson here is try to find a company that has expertise in your brand of furnace. We later researched and found out our furnace was known to have heat exchanger issues. This company only has knowledge on the brand of furnace they install. Everything is else you as the customer do at risk as they will not take any accountability of their repairs don’t work. I have never come across a company like this one."

Vidhu D on December 2020


A-1 PLUMBING & HEATING

4.86(
165
)

A-1 PLUMBING & HEATING

4.86(
165
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers

I AM A 2ND GENERATION PLUMBER AND WE HAVE BEEN IN BUSINESS SINCE 1952 BETWEEN MY FATHER AND I IN WESTBURY. I LOOK FORWARD TO SERVING YOU. OWNER OPERATOR. TRAVEL CHARGES APPLY FOR FIRST 45 MINUTES. ASK ABOUT ANGIE'S LIST DISCOUNT.IF THERE IS NO RESPONSE TO E-MAIL [email protected] PLEASE CALL THE OFFICE. THANK YOU.

"Perfectly, everything is working better than it was before."

Peter K on July 2021

I AM A 2ND GENERATION PLUMBER AND WE HAVE BEEN IN BUSINESS SINCE 1952 BETWEEN MY FATHER AND I IN WESTBURY. I LOOK FORWARD TO SERVING YOU. OWNER OPERATOR. TRAVEL CHARGES APPLY FOR FIRST 45 MINUTES. ASK ABOUT ANGIE'S LIST DISCOUNT.IF THERE IS NO RESPONSE TO E-MAIL [email protected] PLEASE CALL THE OFFICE. THANK YOU.

"Perfectly, everything is working better than it was before."

Peter K on July 2021



Avatar for CILENTO PIPELINE PLUMBING & HEATING

CILENTO PIPELINE PLUMBING & HEATING

4.86(
57
)

CILENTO PIPELINE PLUMBING & HEATING

4.86(
57
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers

Cilento Pipeline Plumbing & Heating, has been dedicated to serving Nassau and western Suffolk counties of Long Island, NY for nearly a decade. Now, we're taking our heating expertise to the next level. We're proud to announce Radiant Pro, a division of Cilento Pipeline. Radiant Pro, specializing in the design and installation of radiant heating, is dedicated to providing the same quality workmanship you've come to expect from the technical staff of Cilento Pipeline. We are flexible enough to handle small residential jobs or larger commercial and industrial contracts. John Cilento, licensed plumber and founder of Cilento Pipeline and Radiant Pro, has been in the plumbing industry for over 15 years, earning an excellent reputation by providing professionalism and quality at competitive prices .

"Gene and Spencer did all the work in restructuring the system for our radiant heat. They were prompt, clean and courteous and explained in laymen terms what the issues were and how they were addressed. They went well above and beyond what the projected called for by "shocking" the hot water storage tank in order to purge sediment. This time consuming job was done with no additional charge. One replaced fitting developed a miniscule drip which was promptly addressed the next day, John Cilento, owner of the business personally came by to ensure the drip was stopped. Excellent work by very reliable people. A genuine throwback."

Michael M on November 2018

Cilento Pipeline Plumbing & Heating, has been dedicated to serving Nassau and western Suffolk counties of Long Island, NY for nearly a decade. Now, we're taking our heating expertise to the next level. We're proud to announce Radiant Pro, a division of Cilento Pipeline. Radiant Pro, specializing in the design and installation of radiant heating, is dedicated to providing the same quality workmanship you've come to expect from the technical staff of Cilento Pipeline. We are flexible enough to handle small residential jobs or larger commercial and industrial contracts. John Cilento, licensed plumber and founder of Cilento Pipeline and Radiant Pro, has been in the plumbing industry for over 15 years, earning an excellent reputation by providing professionalism and quality at competitive prices .

"Gene and Spencer did all the work in restructuring the system for our radiant heat. They were prompt, clean and courteous and explained in laymen terms what the issues were and how they were addressed. They went well above and beyond what the projected called for by "shocking" the hot water storage tank in order to purge sediment. This time consuming job was done with no additional charge. One replaced fitting developed a miniscule drip which was promptly addressed the next day, John Cilento, owner of the business personally came by to ensure the drip was stopped. Excellent work by very reliable people. A genuine throwback."

Michael M on November 2018


Avatar for Meenan

Meenan

4.62(
169
)

Meenan

4.62(
169
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Emergency services offered

For over 75 years, Meenan has been the name that your Long Island neighbors have trusted for all of their home comfort services (heating oil, natural gas, air conditioning, plumbing, and generators). From always being there when they need us 24/7 to pricing and payment plans that help them manage their energy costs throughout the year, your neighbors chose Meenan as the local company that provides total home comfort, total peace of mind and great savings on energy costs. Find out why by letting us do the same for you today!

"Getting a tune up appointment which they claim pays for the contract fee is impossible to get if they even keep it. In the 12 years I was with them maybe 4 tune ups happened as most of the time they are booked 6-12 months out. That’s how backup they are on this pre Covid Second I put my deliveries on hold and they sent me a cancellation fee. A few that was never disclosed in the email I agreed to (see attachment) after disputing it and saying they never disclosed it they sent me the bill again now with late fees. After 12 years and 10’s of thousands of dollars this is how they treat a long standing customer. Run but not to Petro as that’s the same company. Go to Slomins instead."

Michael K on October 2021

For over 75 years, Meenan has been the name that your Long Island neighbors have trusted for all of their home comfort services (heating oil, natural gas, air conditioning, plumbing, and generators). From always being there when they need us 24/7 to pricing and payment plans that help them manage their energy costs throughout the year, your neighbors chose Meenan as the local company that provides total home comfort, total peace of mind and great savings on energy costs. Find out why by letting us do the same for you today!

"Getting a tune up appointment which they claim pays for the contract fee is impossible to get if they even keep it. In the 12 years I was with them maybe 4 tune ups happened as most of the time they are booked 6-12 months out. That’s how backup they are on this pre Covid Second I put my deliveries on hold and they sent me a cancellation fee. A few that was never disclosed in the email I agreed to (see attachment) after disputing it and saying they never disclosed it they sent me the bill again now with late fees. After 12 years and 10’s of thousands of dollars this is how they treat a long standing customer. Run but not to Petro as that’s the same company. Go to Slomins instead."

Michael K on October 2021

...
Showing 1-10 of 1078
Water Heaters questions, answered by experts

Tankless water heaters are more expensive than those with a storage tank, but they come with some impressive benefits that most homeowners find worth the higher investment. Most importantly, they provide unlimited hot water, so you’ll never run out like you would with a storage tank. Tankless heaters are also more efficient, so comparing gallon-for-gallon, you’ll spend less on hot water with a tankless heater. Tankless water heaters are also smaller, require less maintenance, and tend to last longer than storage tank water heaters.

Replacing an older water heater that requires frequent repairs is almost always worth it. If your fixture is nearing the end of its life span—around 10 to 20 years, depending on the model—replacing a water heater might save you money in the long run. Replacing a water heater generally costs less than repairing a fully flooded basement, and some high-efficiency units pay for themselves thanks to energy savings. Plus, installing a new water heater and upgrading to tankless will boost your home value and make your hot water more readily available, improving comfort for your family.

Installing a water heater without a permit can result in high fines—as much as hundreds of dollars per day, in some areas. It can also void your homeowners' insurance and cause problems when selling your home because it violates local building codes and safety regulations.

A water heater is one of the heaviest hitters in your home, and it needs as much power as possible to help it run efficiently and effectively.

Your water heater should be on its own dedicated circuit breaker, with no other power sources running to it. This is required to meet the National Electric Code–and to ensure it runs as efficiently as possible.

Electric water heaters typically last 10 to 20 years, though proper maintenance can extend their lifespan. If your unit is over a decade old and showing signs of inefficiency—such as higher energy bills, frequent repairs, or leaks—replacement is a smart investment. Tankless models last over 20 years, which can make them a longer-lasting alternative to traditional tank water heaters.

The Locust Valley, NY homeowners’ guide to water heater services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.