I had been getting quotes on my roof because it was getting on and about time to replace, but the quotes were coming back a little higher than I'd have liked. I have a circa 30-square roof, so I knew it wouldn't be cheap - but it was looking like I might put it off just one more year. Then Chuck got back to me with what I considered a ridiculously low price, and he came well-recommended by my mum's boyfriend (and his neighborhood) to boot. When the crew came by on the big day, I was impressed. They had two crews working, hoping to finish in one day instead of 2-3, and had everything stripped before my morning coffee. There were a couple sheets of decking that had to be replaced, but nothing crazy, and in the "problem areas" of my roof ice and water shield was installed, rather than regular felt paper. The foreman was courteous, all documentation and permitting was provided and posted properly, and Chuck was there personally for part of the job to oversee everything. After they were done, I did a walk around a few times over the next couple days to see if there were any things I didn't like. A lot of the issues I had were minor, and largely aesthetic. Most of them had to do with the zinc strips I had them install - on one section of the roof, the corners were all bent up at the end of each strip. The strips never seemed to be installed the same way, either - they would stop a couple feet from the end of the ridge on one end, then run all the way to the edge on the other, and on the other side stop where the ridge vent stopped. A professional repointed and flashed my chimney, which was a complex job with many angles, for two more days after the roofing was complete, and it came out excellent. They can't have made money on the extra charge for flashing my chimney (I think it was around $700 of the total price). That said, I called up Chuck, told him I had a list of little things, and he came right out to wrap things up. I gave him the check for our remaining balance at this time. A couple months later, on the back of my house I noticed a sort of "hump" in the shingles running in a straight line from the bottom all the way up to the ridge. It took us a while (4-6 weeks) to get hold of Chuck to have him take a look, but he did finally give me a call back and apologize for the delay. On looking at the problem, he informed my mother (I wasn't home at the time) that it had to be because of the decking, and that since they didn't install any decking there that he wasn't going to send a crew in to fix it. I called him back and left a voicemail to contest this judgment a bit, and was surprised to find one of his best craftsmen on my roof the next day. The gentleman stripped up the shingles to see what was going on, and found that my plywood decking wasn't staggered where the "hump" was - there was a vertical seam there running all the way to the ridge. This made sense to me, because my home had an addition put on it many years ago, and likely they didn't pull up the old decking at that time to stagger the seams. He applied ice and water shield to the problem area, reinstalled the shingles, and assured me it wouldn't leak over the winter, and if I was lucky the hump wouldn't reform after he set everything back in place. I was, however, disappointed to find that this defect had gone completely unnoticed when the roof was stripped bare. It also would have been a great opportunity on their part (I wish I had thought of this myself while they were still here), what with most of the shingles already removed in the problem area, to give me an estimate on fixing the issue then and there. That said, I still like this company, and will call them in the Spring to get a quote to fix the decking if my shingles hump up again - everyone else gets to have a flat roof, I want one too! SUMMARY: Company was very responsive initially, worked quickly, safely, and courteously. Responded to initial minor defects in a timely manner. Later, responsiveness was uncharacteristically poor. I was disappointed that a moderate to major defect in my decking went under the radar, but was pleased that a craftsman took the time to verify the issue, show me the problem, and explain it in detail. Pretty good folks, but if you have a "complicated" home (IE: built by a DIY homeowner, has had additions put on, etc.), take the time to request they really look for defects so nothing gets missed. You will not find a lower price, and I think this is a rare case in which you get more than you pay for.