Get matched with top water heater pros in Lake Mills, WI
There are 5 highly-rated local water heater pros.
TRUSTED BY HOMEOWNERS
4.2 
16 Verified Reviews for Water Heater Service pros in Lake Mills, WI
*The Angi rating for Water Heater Service companies in Lake Mills, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Water Heater Service companies in Lake Mills, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.
Last update on May 23, 2025
Water heater pros in Lake Mills
Badger Water is family owned and operated. We have been in business for over 35 years. We are proud to provide service within 24 hours, if not immediately. Badger Water employees provide prompt, efficient and friendly service. Contact Badger Water today for a water analysis and the lowest prices for all your water needs.
"Fast! Very knowledgable."
Kevin H on November 2024
Badger Water is family owned and operated. We have been in business for over 35 years. We are proud to provide service within 24 hours, if not immediately. Badger Water employees provide prompt, efficient and friendly service. Contact Badger Water today for a water analysis and the lowest prices for all your water needs.
"Fast! Very knowledgable."
Kevin H on November 2024
Since 1984, Cardinal Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electric has provided the Sun Prairie, WI and the surrounding area with exceptional Heating, Air Conditioning, Electrical and Plumbing services. We offer professional technicians, same-day installations and 24-hour emergency service. We believe we are the right choice for any of your HVAC, Plumbing, or Electrical needs. Call today to schedule your next appointment!
"updated review Reconsider other options. Had a $27,700 furnace/heat pump installed 3 months ago (they were going to install one less zone then quoted until i showed them their quote and then they did not leave a start up sheet as requested) and first time turning on ac and heated air came out. Requested start up sheet again and it states cooling was tested which at least that section - apparently was a complete lie – RETROACTIVE FALSIFICATION OF DOCUMENTATION. Called for service for next time off 5 days later and was required to be on call with 20minutes notice for the entire day – “typical cardinal procedure” (Jasmine – “we give you 20 minutes notice so not to inconvenience you) till 230pm – which after much side stepping Andy finally admitted that customers to be oncall was not in the contract, after repeated request s for on call documentation and Andy’s intial reply that i would be “talked to” by a tech when they arrived. Jasmine said it was emergency repair for a system that should have been installed correctly but was not able to schedule after hours – then could but would charge. Requested at least a 2 hour window for tech to show up but was refused. Ian D. showed up and stated wires/switch were not installed correctly – surprise – never even tested (no wonder a start up sheet was not left at install) – and “never should of happened.” Asked why I had to be on call to compensate for mis-install – ‘I am not the scheduling department.’ Ask Ian to fill out a diagnostic repair sheet (22words) said he had to leave and had an important phone call and was not suppose to even be on service call that I was waiting for on call, for the entire day. Ian did return 15min later since his phone call was canceled. Asked for a quote to install my uv light (drill 4 holes and plug into outlet) $287. Maybe you don’t have a job and can be on call for free 24/7, spend more than 28k, and only expect half of the things to work, be blatantly lied to and only care of your beliefs in fair pricing and professionalism – then I could recommend cardinal – so far."
Ron B on May 2025
Since 1984, Cardinal Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electric has provided the Sun Prairie, WI and the surrounding area with exceptional Heating, Air Conditioning, Electrical and Plumbing services. We offer professional technicians, same-day installations and 24-hour emergency service. We believe we are the right choice for any of your HVAC, Plumbing, or Electrical needs. Call today to schedule your next appointment!
"updated review Reconsider other options. Had a $27,700 furnace/heat pump installed 3 months ago (they were going to install one less zone then quoted until i showed them their quote and then they did not leave a start up sheet as requested) and first time turning on ac and heated air came out. Requested start up sheet again and it states cooling was tested which at least that section - apparently was a complete lie – RETROACTIVE FALSIFICATION OF DOCUMENTATION. Called for service for next time off 5 days later and was required to be on call with 20minutes notice for the entire day – “typical cardinal procedure” (Jasmine – “we give you 20 minutes notice so not to inconvenience you) till 230pm – which after much side stepping Andy finally admitted that customers to be oncall was not in the contract, after repeated request s for on call documentation and Andy’s intial reply that i would be “talked to” by a tech when they arrived. Jasmine said it was emergency repair for a system that should have been installed correctly but was not able to schedule after hours – then could but would charge. Requested at least a 2 hour window for tech to show up but was refused. Ian D. showed up and stated wires/switch were not installed correctly – surprise – never even tested (no wonder a start up sheet was not left at install) – and “never should of happened.” Asked why I had to be on call to compensate for mis-install – ‘I am not the scheduling department.’ Ask Ian to fill out a diagnostic repair sheet (22words) said he had to leave and had an important phone call and was not suppose to even be on service call that I was waiting for on call, for the entire day. Ian did return 15min later since his phone call was canceled. Asked for a quote to install my uv light (drill 4 holes and plug into outlet) $287. Maybe you don’t have a job and can be on call for free 24/7, spend more than 28k, and only expect half of the things to work, be blatantly lied to and only care of your beliefs in fair pricing and professionalism – then I could recommend cardinal – so far."
Ron B on May 2025
We take pride in the quality of work and customer satisfaction that we give each and every customer. We are known to pay exquisite attention to detail while making customer satisfaction our top priority. 7 days a week. Call us today to learn more about how we can help you.
"Kurt was fantastic. Our entire building was suffering with no hot water on a cold winters day. I found Kurt recommended by the maker of our water heaters. I called a bit frantic, recieved a return call within minutes, got great advice, honest folks helped us get things back up and running when most would have let us wait and possibly charged us for something we could do ourselves. We are so glad to find a trustworthy service group, and wouldn't go anywhere else unless they refer us. You simply don't find this type of honest often, I'm proud of them and quite grateful."
Greg K on February 2025
We take pride in the quality of work and customer satisfaction that we give each and every customer. We are known to pay exquisite attention to detail while making customer satisfaction our top priority. 7 days a week. Call us today to learn more about how we can help you.
"Kurt was fantastic. Our entire building was suffering with no hot water on a cold winters day. I found Kurt recommended by the maker of our water heaters. I called a bit frantic, recieved a return call within minutes, got great advice, honest folks helped us get things back up and running when most would have let us wait and possibly charged us for something we could do ourselves. We are so glad to find a trustworthy service group, and wouldn't go anywhere else unless they refer us. You simply don't find this type of honest often, I'm proud of them and quite grateful."
Greg K on February 2025
Five Star Bath Solutions of is the top-of-the-line bathroom remodeling company. Weve earned this title by using advanced technology, custom products, and attention to customer service. Using innovative software, Five Star Bath Solutions professionals will deliver a detailed estimate for your bathroom renovation project at an affordable price. We believe in setting standards for how projects are estimated, installed, and completed and passing that value on to you.
"Everyone that we dealt with couldn?t have been nicer. We had a tub to shower conversion which was completed in one day. Matt, the installer, laid a tarp down from the door to our bathroom to protect the floors. He asked for our input when he was installing the shelves and grab bars. After he finished cleaning everything up he explained how to used the new shower head and what to use to clean the surface. The next day we texted him with a question and he immediately answered. We couldn?t be happier with the job done and the professionalism of the company."
Faith H on February 2025
Five Star Bath Solutions of is the top-of-the-line bathroom remodeling company. Weve earned this title by using advanced technology, custom products, and attention to customer service. Using innovative software, Five Star Bath Solutions professionals will deliver a detailed estimate for your bathroom renovation project at an affordable price. We believe in setting standards for how projects are estimated, installed, and completed and passing that value on to you.
"Everyone that we dealt with couldn?t have been nicer. We had a tub to shower conversion which was completed in one day. Matt, the installer, laid a tarp down from the door to our bathroom to protect the floors. He asked for our input when he was installing the shelves and grab bars. After he finished cleaning everything up he explained how to used the new shower head and what to use to clean the surface. The next day we texted him with a question and he immediately answered. We couldn?t be happier with the job done and the professionalism of the company."
Faith H on February 2025
We are a family owned home improvement company out of Sussex Wisconsin. We service Waukesha, Milwaukee, Washington, & parts of Ozaukee, Dodge, Racine, and Kenosha counties. We focus on the quality products we install & service, while maintaining a high level of customer service. We are proud to be recognized as a GAF Master Elite Contractor for roofing projects. We also provide fantastic siding & windows, as well as entry doors. We also specialize in bathroom and shower areas, converting tubs to showers or showers to tubs. Beautiful acrylic shower surrounds or tub liner inserts make any old bathroom wet space new again. We work efficiently with our resources to ensure your project is completed on time and on budget. We bring old-world, quality craftsmanship to every unique project we take on. We are licensed and insured & look forward to building strong, long-lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction. Call today for a Free Estimate 262-456-3530
"the contractor did a great job"
vicki s on January 2023
We are a family owned home improvement company out of Sussex Wisconsin. We service Waukesha, Milwaukee, Washington, & parts of Ozaukee, Dodge, Racine, and Kenosha counties. We focus on the quality products we install & service, while maintaining a high level of customer service. We are proud to be recognized as a GAF Master Elite Contractor for roofing projects. We also provide fantastic siding & windows, as well as entry doors. We also specialize in bathroom and shower areas, converting tubs to showers or showers to tubs. Beautiful acrylic shower surrounds or tub liner inserts make any old bathroom wet space new again. We work efficiently with our resources to ensure your project is completed on time and on budget. We bring old-world, quality craftsmanship to every unique project we take on. We are licensed and insured & look forward to building strong, long-lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction. Call today for a Free Estimate 262-456-3530
"the contractor did a great job"
vicki s on January 2023
We take pride in the quality of work and customer satisfaction that we give each and every customer. We are known to pay exquisite attention to detail while making customer satisfaction our top priority. 7 days a week. Call us today to learn more about how we can help you.
"Kurt is prompt, knowledgeable, and friendly. His pricing was competitive and he gave great advice after the install. Highly recommended!"
Ben L on September 2024
We take pride in the quality of work and customer satisfaction that we give each and every customer. We are known to pay exquisite attention to detail while making customer satisfaction our top priority. 7 days a week. Call us today to learn more about how we can help you.
"Kurt is prompt, knowledgeable, and friendly. His pricing was competitive and he gave great advice after the install. Highly recommended!"
Ben L on September 2024
Five Star Bath Solutions of is the top-of-the-line bathroom remodeling company. Weve earned this title by using advanced technology, custom products, and attention to customer service. Using innovative software, Five Star Bath Solutions professionals will deliver a detailed estimate for your bathroom renovation project at an affordable price. We believe in setting standards for how projects are estimated, installed, and completed and passing that value on to you.
"Everyone that we dealt with couldn?t have been nicer. We had a tub to shower conversion which was completed in one day. Matt, the installer, laid a tarp down from the door to our bathroom to protect the floors. He asked for our input when he was installing the shelves and grab bars. After he finished cleaning everything up he explained how to used the new shower head and what to use to clean the surface. The next day we texted him with a question and he immediately answered. We couldn?t be happier with the job done and the professionalism of the company. "
Faith H on February 2025
Five Star Bath Solutions of is the top-of-the-line bathroom remodeling company. Weve earned this title by using advanced technology, custom products, and attention to customer service. Using innovative software, Five Star Bath Solutions professionals will deliver a detailed estimate for your bathroom renovation project at an affordable price. We believe in setting standards for how projects are estimated, installed, and completed and passing that value on to you.
"Everyone that we dealt with couldn?t have been nicer. We had a tub to shower conversion which was completed in one day. Matt, the installer, laid a tarp down from the door to our bathroom to protect the floors. He asked for our input when he was installing the shelves and grab bars. After he finished cleaning everything up he explained how to used the new shower head and what to use to clean the surface. The next day we texted him with a question and he immediately answered. We couldn?t be happier with the job done and the professionalism of the company. "
Faith H on February 2025
Premier Home Pros specializes in full bathroom remodels and installs finely crafted bathtubs and showers in as little as one day. With maintenance-free solutions and a variety of stunning designs to match your style, getting your dream bathroom has never been easier and more affordable. All of our products our backed by a full lifetime and service warranty program to offer customers the last system they will ever need. Get a FREE design consultation and transform your bathroom into a space that's not only functional, beautiful.
"Price competitive. Easy to communicate with and professional from initial meeting and later discussion to add an item. Installation team arrived as promised and removed a vinyl shower, an over sized jacuzzi and completed installation and cleanup within eight hours. We're very pleased with our new shower. Would highly recommend. W. Porter"
Bill P on May 2025
Premier Home Pros specializes in full bathroom remodels and installs finely crafted bathtubs and showers in as little as one day. With maintenance-free solutions and a variety of stunning designs to match your style, getting your dream bathroom has never been easier and more affordable. All of our products our backed by a full lifetime and service warranty program to offer customers the last system they will ever need. Get a FREE design consultation and transform your bathroom into a space that's not only functional, beautiful.
"Price competitive. Easy to communicate with and professional from initial meeting and later discussion to add an item. Installation team arrived as promised and removed a vinyl shower, an over sized jacuzzi and completed installation and cleanup within eight hours. We're very pleased with our new shower. Would highly recommend. W. Porter"
Bill P on May 2025
At Basement Repair Specialists, we liked the idea of giving people a good deal so much that we trademarked it! That’s right, in October 2014 the US Patent and Trademark Office granted Basement Repair Specialists a trademark for our corporate motto “A Great Job at a Great Price®” From our first days in business, Basement Repair Specialists has been committed to offering excellent work at a reasonable price. Treating customers fairly is a part of our company culture, and you will be very happy you selected Basement Repair Specialists for your project. We offer the following services: Repair of failing, leaning, or collapsed basement walls Water control, sump pumps, and general drainage issues Helical piers, resistance piers and other solutions to settling foundations and footings Egress windows Dehumidifiers
"I could not believe what they did in only two days. It is so nice to not have water anymore. The salesman really knew and understood the project and what it would take to get it done."
Faith N on September 2024
At Basement Repair Specialists, we liked the idea of giving people a good deal so much that we trademarked it! That’s right, in October 2014 the US Patent and Trademark Office granted Basement Repair Specialists a trademark for our corporate motto “A Great Job at a Great Price®” From our first days in business, Basement Repair Specialists has been committed to offering excellent work at a reasonable price. Treating customers fairly is a part of our company culture, and you will be very happy you selected Basement Repair Specialists for your project. We offer the following services: Repair of failing, leaning, or collapsed basement walls Water control, sump pumps, and general drainage issues Helical piers, resistance piers and other solutions to settling foundations and footings Egress windows Dehumidifiers
"I could not believe what they did in only two days. It is so nice to not have water anymore. The salesman really knew and understood the project and what it would take to get it done."
Faith N on September 2024
We are a small family owned father son business that takes care of their customers like they are family. The services that we provide are well & pump and plumbing. We are fully transparent with our customers on what it will take to complete the job. The cost options will be presented to you before we start. So there will be no surprises when it comes time for billing.
"Scott installed two new sump pumps to replace our ones that were not working"
Mike S on April 2024
We are a small family owned father son business that takes care of their customers like they are family. The services that we provide are well & pump and plumbing. We are fully transparent with our customers on what it will take to complete the job. The cost options will be presented to you before we start. So there will be no surprises when it comes time for billing.
"Scott installed two new sump pumps to replace our ones that were not working"
Mike S on April 2024
Water heater services FAQs
The average cost to install a new water heater is around $1,300, but you can expect to pay between $875 and $1,750, depending on the kind of water heater, the size of the unit, and the professional chosen to complete the work. Tankless water heaters can push your price higher, as installation is more complicated, with prices as high as $3,500. The location and accessibility of your water heater will play a role in the project cost, as those sitting in tight spaces like a crawl space will drive up your labor costs.
Tankless water heaters are more expensive than those with a storage tank, but they come with some impressive benefits that most homeowners find worth the higher investment. Most importantly, they provide unlimited hot water, so you’ll never run out like you would with a storage tank. Tankless heaters are also more efficient, so comparing gallon-for-gallon, you’ll spend less on hot water with a tankless heater. Tankless water heaters are also smaller, require less maintenance, and tend to last longer than storage tank water heaters.
It usually takes a professional water heater installer between two and three hours to remove an existing water heater and install a new tank heater. However, it could take four to five hours if they have to work in a small utility closet or another tight area, like a crawl space. Tankless water heaters have a more complicated installation process, so they will take a bit longer. Additionally, a gas water heater requires a connection to a gas line, and that alone can add about an hour to the installation timeline compared to installing an electric water heater.
It is very difficult and dangerous to install your own water heater, so we strongly recommend against tackling this as a DIY project. Not only will you need to wire your water heater, but you’ll also need to connect plumbing to the intake and outlet. Sweating copper pipes and connecting wiring properly are skills most DIYers don’t have, and even if you do feel confident you can do it, working with water and electricity always leaves the potential for electrocution. Hiring a local water heater installer is well worth the investment.
In most municipalities, a license is not mandatory for water heater installation or replacement. However, we strongly recommend hiring a licensed plumber or water heater installer to handle the work. Licensed installers are far less likely to make a mistake during the installation, which means paying for the experience decreases your risk of a leak and other issues. You can use our state licensing tool to find out if a contractor you’re considering in your area holds a plumber’s license.
Get our Angi-powered app
