Get matched with top roofers in Bucyrus, OH

SRS Construction

4.38(

64 local quotes requested

32 years of experience

We guarantee your satisfaction. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service. Check out our services offered and call or click to schedule an estimate today!

"BUYERS BEWARE!! I am posting our horrible experience and the results here, so others are forewarned and do not experience the same. My husband and I hired SRS Construction (Blue Cardinal Construction), Don Caudill Jr, owner, and project manager, to renovate our first and forever home. He presented a contract for the scope of the project, guaranteeing completion before summer’s end. The renovation process began June 1st and as of today is still NOWHERE near completion. During the process we were left for 21 days with NO sanitation, potable water, HVAC, and limited electricity. Several requests were made on estimated time of completion for the essentials of working utilities since we have three young children, my elderly father living with us and multiple animals. SRS Construction owner Don Caudill’s hired subcontractors to complete the HVAC, electrical, and plumbing. After the work was “complete” we noticed several red flags. We hired licensed independent companies to come evaluate the work done by SRS Construction’s Don Caudill. Based on their findings all electrical, HVAC and plumbing are not up to Ohio code and unsafe. SRS Construction left our home with the following: structural damage to the roof, ceiling and basement stairway, multiple electrical fire hazards in the attic and basement, 10+ unworking outlets, improper duct work and several other areas of unfinished work. We paid $54,000 to SRS Construction’s owner Don Caudill for contractual work, and it is incomplete. The company has not replied to my request or the Better Business Bureau’s request to fix the damaged structural ceiling, stairwell, electrical and HVAC."

Rachel S on September 2023

"BUYERS BEWARE!! I am posting our horrible experience and the results here, so others are forewarned and do not experience the same. My husband and I hired SRS Construction (Blue Cardinal Construction), Don Caudill Jr, owner, and project manager, to renovate our first and forever home. He presented a contract for the scope of the project, guaranteeing completion before summer’s end. The renovation process began June 1st and as of today is still NOWHERE near completion. During the process we were left for 21 days with NO sanitation, potable water, HVAC, and limited electricity. Several requests were made on estimated time of completion for the essentials of working utilities since we have three young children, my elderly father living with us and multiple animals. SRS Construction owner Don Caudill’s hired subcontractors to complete the HVAC, electrical, and plumbing. After the work was “complete” we noticed several red flags. We hired licensed independent companies to come evaluate the work done by SRS Construction’s Don Caudill. Based on their findings all electrical, HVAC and plumbing are not up to Ohio code and unsafe. SRS Construction left our home with the following: structural damage to the roof, ceiling and basement stairway, multiple electrical fire hazards in the attic and basement, 10+ unworking outlets, improper duct work and several other areas of unfinished work. We paid $54,000 to SRS Construction’s owner Don Caudill for contractual work, and it is incomplete. The company has not replied to my request or the Better Business Bureau’s request to fix the damaged structural ceiling, stairwell, electrical and HVAC."

Rachel S on September 2023

Home Genius Exteriors

Home Genius Exteriors

Customers say: Quality work

150 local quotes requested

21 years of experience

Elevate your home with Home Genius Exteriors, setting the standard in Columbus by offering full-service solutions for roofing, siding, windows, doors, gutters and insulation. We support our veterans and communities by supporting local and national charitable organizations through our Home Genius Cares initiative. With an Owens Corning® Platinum Preferred designation, we also offer flexible payment options, industry leading warranties and a wide range of premium products tailored for your home. It’s time for a different experience, entrust your next home project to a genius and schedule your free inspection today!

"Our roof installation happened after a 4 inch snow and in very cold weather. Our crew worked non-stop to get the snow off the roof, remove the old shingles and get the new ones on. They finished just before it got too dark to work. They're coming back in the daylight to finish the clean up. They did a great job in harsh conditions! Thanks, guys!"

Anita D on December 2025

"Our roof installation happened after a 4 inch snow and in very cold weather. Our crew worked non-stop to get the snow off the roof, remove the old shingles and get the new ones on. They finished just before it got too dark to work. They're coming back in the daylight to finish the clean up. They did a great job in harsh conditions! Thanks, guys!"

Anita D on December 2025

AMERICAN HOMESTEAD EXTERIORS LLC

AMERICAN HOMESTEAD EXTERIORS LLC

Recommended by 100% of Angi customers

3 years of experience

American Homestead Exteriors, LLC is dedicated to providing our customers with the best quality and craftsmanship. We are here to build relationships with our customers and communities and to provide our employees with a great place to work. American Homestead Exteriors, LLC is a leader in providing our customers with the highest quality products and craftsmanship in an honest, efficient, and professional way. Our pledge is to create successful relationships with our customers, employees and community by building trust, treating every project with the utmost integrity and exceeding expectations. We look forward to working with you!

"great people, pleasure to work with. highly recommend."

Al H on August 2023

"great people, pleasure to work with. highly recommend."

Al H on August 2023

The Roof Guys LLC

The Roof Guys LLC

Customers say: Quality work

8 years of experience

Free onsite estimate

Our company invites you to experience prompt service and superior attention to detail. Our customer satisfaction is our top priority. We will earn your trust for a lifetime. We believe in making all clients repeat clients. You can be assured you're in good hands with our company working on your home improvement project. If you are looking for a contractor that follows business practices such as promptly returning phone calls, arriving on time for appointments and following through on promises then call our reputable company today We will be the one and only contractor you'll ever need. Call us today you'll be pleased you did. Thank you! proroofguys.com FB: facebook.com/trustedroofing

"They were punctual, they did exactly what we requested, cant complain at all. Good communication!"

Kevin T on February 2023

"They were punctual, they did exactly what we requested, cant complain at all. Good communication!"

Kevin T on February 2023

Home Genius Exteriors

Home Genius Exteriors

20 years of experience

Free onsite estimate

Elevate your home with Home Genius Exteriors, setting the standard in Cleveland by offering full-service solutions for roofing, siding, windows, doors, gutters and insulation. We support our veterans and communities by supporting local and national charitable organizations through our Home Genius Cares initiative. With an Owens Corning® Platinum Preferred designation, we also offer flexible payment options, industry leading warranties and a wide range of premium products tailored for your home. It?s time for a different experience, entrust your next home project to a genius and schedule your free inspection today!

"They got the job done quick and the work looks impeccable. The sales and planning portions of the work went off without a hitch. Sadly, the project manager got into a car accident on the phone with me and the installation crew cut the fiber optic internet cable to my house and then tried to hide it by tucking it into the siding. While I’m ultimately happy with the result, I’d be cautious next time I need major work done."

Patrick R on December 2024

"They got the job done quick and the work looks impeccable. The sales and planning portions of the work went off without a hitch. Sadly, the project manager got into a car accident on the phone with me and the installation crew cut the fiber optic internet cable to my house and then tried to hide it by tucking it into the siding. While I’m ultimately happy with the result, I’d be cautious next time I need major work done."

Patrick R on December 2024

Panda Roof, LLC

Panda Roof, LLC

Customers say: True professional

Recommended by 93% of Angi customers

379 local quotes requested

Panda Roof is known for its beautiful colorful warm metal roofs. When choosing a contractor consider the upside of one that can provide full service on all their products they install like we do. Panda Roof also installs asphalt roofs and helps homeowners with solar systems that provides long lasting green energy. Contact us today. 330-54two-4200

"The team at Panda did a quick and thorough job at our house. We appreciate how professional the support team was as well as the engineer. "

Jamie K on December 2025

"The team at Panda did a quick and thorough job at our house. We appreciate how professional the support team was as well as the engineer. "

Jamie K on December 2025

Shetler Roofing

Shetler Roofing

Recommended by 100% of Angi customers

10 years of experience

With 7 years of experience, we work hard to bring each customer the best possible service and quality available. We look forward to working with you on your next project. We welcome your questions and thank you for your interest.

"The job was well done and done quickly. Very pleased!!"

BARBARA W on October 2023

"The job was well done and done quickly. Very pleased!!"

BARBARA W on October 2023

Bontrager Roofing, LLC

Bontrager Roofing, LLC

Recommended by 100% of Angi customers

10 years of experience

Bontrager Roofing, LLC, prides itself on being the number one home improvement company in the area. We service both residential and commercial properties. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. Allow us to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today, and let's get started!

"He does great work! A pleasure to have around and he is trustworthy, honest and dependable!"

Eli P on January 2017

"He does great work! A pleasure to have around and he is trustworthy, honest and dependable!"

Eli P on January 2017

Home Genius Exteriors

Home Genius Exteriors

Customers say: Quality work

1035 local quotes requested

21 years of experience

"5 stars is Good! Thank you"

Chauncey J on October 2025

"5 stars is Good! Thank you"

Chauncey J on October 2025

Rose Roofing & Repair, LLC

4.71(

Rose Roofing & Repair, LLC

4.71(