Top-rated asphalt driveway pros.

Get matched with top asphalt driveway pros in Shelter Island, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your asphalt driveway service project in Shelter Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.3
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon104
    Verified asphalt driveway services reviews

Find Asphalt driveway pros in Shelter Island

Avatar for Premium Paving

Premium Paving

5.00(
6
)
Approved Pro

Premium Paving

5.00(
6
)
Approved Pro
195 local quotes requested
14 years of experience

Premium Paving is a well-established paving company serving Suffolk County, Long Island since 2007. We specialize in asphalt installation, concrete installation, masonry and more. Our estimates are always free without obligation. Reach out today to see if we're right for your project! Please note that we do not provide sealing services.

Premium Paving is a well-established paving company serving Suffolk County, Long Island since 2007. We specialize in asphalt installation, concrete installation, masonry and more. Our estimates are always free without obligation. Reach out today to see if we're right for your project! Please note that we do not provide sealing services.


Avatar for Unlimited Outdoor Designs

Unlimited Outdoor Designs

4.24(
21
)
Approved Pro

Unlimited Outdoor Designs

4.24(
21
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Terrific value
209 local quotes requested
12 years of experience

Unlimited Outdoor Designs, specializing in Indoor Kitchens and Baths and Basement remodels. Fencing, Decks, Railings, Concrete, and Masonry work. We are family-owned and take pride in treating our clients like family. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing.

"We had three companies call us back. Company 1 met with us to discuss our wishes and drew a rough sketch of the proposed work. They said they would work up a more detailed drawing and e-mail it to us for review. A few days later the sales rep sent a text asking if we had a chance to look at his proposal. I said we never received the drawing and perhaps it was sent to the wrong e-mail address. I confirmed my e-mail address and was told that he would correct and resend. I never heard back from them. Company 2 met with us to discuss our wishes. We ended the meeting with the expectation that they would send me a formal proposal. I never heard from them at all so they were even less responsive than Company 1. Fortunately Universal Unlimited called us also. Universal Unlimited (Hector Marmol the owner) wasn't the first to respond to our project request but his was the most responsive. We set up a meeting. Hector Marmol (the owner) listened to our wants and used his PC to create a rendering of the proposed deck based on our talking points. We also inquired about PVC fencing for a future date. Hector gave us a very attractive price for a bundled package of decking and fencing. We accepted although I was a little hesitant because most of his reviews were for fencing. I'm glad we made the decision since the final results were exceptional. Props to Jose Salguero who did most of the work."

John N on May 2019

Unlimited Outdoor Designs, specializing in Indoor Kitchens and Baths and Basement remodels. Fencing, Decks, Railings, Concrete, and Masonry work. We are family-owned and take pride in treating our clients like family. We've built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, a great attention to detail, and competitive pricing.

"We had three companies call us back. Company 1 met with us to discuss our wishes and drew a rough sketch of the proposed work. They said they would work up a more detailed drawing and e-mail it to us for review. A few days later the sales rep sent a text asking if we had a chance to look at his proposal. I said we never received the drawing and perhaps it was sent to the wrong e-mail address. I confirmed my e-mail address and was told that he would correct and resend. I never heard back from them. Company 2 met with us to discuss our wishes. We ended the meeting with the expectation that they would send me a formal proposal. I never heard from them at all so they were even less responsive than Company 1. Fortunately Universal Unlimited called us also. Universal Unlimited (Hector Marmol the owner) wasn't the first to respond to our project request but his was the most responsive. We set up a meeting. Hector Marmol (the owner) listened to our wants and used his PC to create a rendering of the proposed deck based on our talking points. We also inquired about PVC fencing for a future date. Hector gave us a very attractive price for a bundled package of decking and fencing. We accepted although I was a little hesitant because most of his reviews were for fencing. I'm glad we made the decision since the final results were exceptional. Props to Jose Salguero who did most of the work."

John N on May 2019


Avatar for Randazzo Masonary

Randazzo Masonary

4.81(
53
)
Approved Pro

Randazzo Masonary

4.81(
53
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
49 local quotes requested

PLEASE GO TO MY WEBSITE TO SEE THE QUALITY JOBS I HAVE DONE. Randazzo Masonary Est since 1989 Specializing in custom, clean, quality cement, flat work, interlocking pavers, pools areas, driveways, and much more! Creating unique designs to fit your home. Reliable, dependable & beautiful. POOL AREA SPECIALISTS Expert installations with Nicolock or Unlock Pavers. Creating unique designs that will fit your home and your budget. Reliable, Dependable, and Beautiful!

"It is my pleasure and honor to highly recommend the services of Stephen Randazzo Masonary. Stephen and his son, John, exhibited the epitome of dedication, professionalism and ability to deliver excellent results. Stephen and his team completed paving our backyard area within the time frame discussed. Stephen's extensive experience and exceptional knowledge as well as attention to detail were fundamental in our projects successful completion and we are thrilled with the final outcome. Since the day I contacted Stephen to the day of our projects completion I was nothing but impressed with their strong work ethic, expertise and integrity."

JoAnne S on March 2025

PLEASE GO TO MY WEBSITE TO SEE THE QUALITY JOBS I HAVE DONE. Randazzo Masonary Est since 1989 Specializing in custom, clean, quality cement, flat work, interlocking pavers, pools areas, driveways, and much more! Creating unique designs to fit your home. Reliable, dependable & beautiful. POOL AREA SPECIALISTS Expert installations with Nicolock or Unlock Pavers. Creating unique designs that will fit your home and your budget. Reliable, Dependable, and Beautiful!

"It is my pleasure and honor to highly recommend the services of Stephen Randazzo Masonary. Stephen and his son, John, exhibited the epitome of dedication, professionalism and ability to deliver excellent results. Stephen and his team completed paving our backyard area within the time frame discussed. Stephen's extensive experience and exceptional knowledge as well as attention to detail were fundamental in our projects successful completion and we are thrilled with the final outcome. Since the day I contacted Stephen to the day of our projects completion I was nothing but impressed with their strong work ethic, expertise and integrity."

JoAnne S on March 2025



Triple s industries LLC

No reviews yet

Triple s industries LLC

No reviews yet

Triple s industries LLC is a licensed n insured business does residential and commercial properties we do anything from asphalt n paver driveways to hard scraping patios retaining walls excavation land clearing demo drainage and so much more contact us today 631-708-9448

Triple s industries LLC is a licensed n insured business does residential and commercial properties we do anything from asphalt n paver driveways to hard scraping patios retaining walls excavation land clearing demo drainage and so much more contact us today 631-708-9448


Avatar for Cardinal Concrete & Paving

Cardinal Concrete & Paving

No reviews yet

Cardinal Concrete & Paving

No reviews yet
3 years of experience

Cardinal Concrete & Paving Inc. is a concrete and asphalt contractor specializing in poured concrete, asphalt and masonry. We offer stamped concrete, pavers, patios, stairs, retaining walls, foundations and foundation extensions, and much more. Call us for your free estimate satisfaction guaranteed.

Cardinal Concrete & Paving Inc. is a concrete and asphalt contractor specializing in poured concrete, asphalt and masonry. We offer stamped concrete, pavers, patios, stairs, retaining walls, foundations and foundation extensions, and much more. Call us for your free estimate satisfaction guaranteed.



Silva's Construction/Landscapes

No reviews yet

Silva's Construction/Landscapes

No reviews yet
Emergency services offered

At Salvador Construction/Landscape we value our customers and are passionate about helping you enhance your outdoor or indoor living space. Our team of tradesman has over 20 years of combined experience, and we are proud to say that our work ethic is second-to-none! We do everything from start to finish, and we get it done right the first time. Weather your project involves renovations, electrical, plumbing, or landscaping Salvador Construction/Landscape can help you make your dreams into reality!

At Salvador Construction/Landscape we value our customers and are passionate about helping you enhance your outdoor or indoor living space. Our team of tradesman has over 20 years of combined experience, and we are proud to say that our work ethic is second-to-none! We do everything from start to finish, and we get it done right the first time. Weather your project involves renovations, electrical, plumbing, or landscaping Salvador Construction/Landscape can help you make your dreams into reality!



Avatar for Armorproof Paving & Masonry LI

Armorproof Paving & Masonry LI

4.00(
3
)

Armorproof Paving & Masonry LI

4.00(
3
)
23 years of experience

We look forward to discussing your next New York paving and Masonry project. We are an owner operated, highly skilled team of professionals and we strive for 100%satisfaction from each and every client. http://www.armorproofpavingandmasonryli.com/

"THE WORK THE EMPLOYEES DID WAS VERY NICE. THE BOSS HOWEVER WAS VERY PUSHY. TYPICAL SALESMAN A SIMPLE JOB TURNED INTO 29,000 THEM UPPED TO 55,000. I HAD 2 OTHER COMPANIES LOOK AT THE JOB AND CANT BELIEVE THEY CHARGED 55,000. THEN ON TOP OF THAT WANTED TO REDO MY DRIVEWAY AND WAS DOING ME A FAVOR OF ONLY CHARGING 100,000. ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS. WHEN THEY WERE FINISHED THE CLEANUP WAS TERRIBLE THEY PUT TOPSOIL ALL OVER THE SURROUNDING AREA THAT WAS FULL OF STONES, ETC. LANDSCAPERS HAD TO RIP OUT AND REDO. THE OWNER ALSO HAD SOME PROBLEM WITH THE VILLAGE REGARDING INSURANCES, PERMIT, AND WORKERS COMP. DIDNT LIKE TO FOLLOW THE VILLAGES RULES. "

John D on July 2025

We look forward to discussing your next New York paving and Masonry project. We are an owner operated, highly skilled team of professionals and we strive for 100%satisfaction from each and every client. http://www.armorproofpavingandmasonryli.com/

"THE WORK THE EMPLOYEES DID WAS VERY NICE. THE BOSS HOWEVER WAS VERY PUSHY. TYPICAL SALESMAN A SIMPLE JOB TURNED INTO 29,000 THEM UPPED TO 55,000. I HAD 2 OTHER COMPANIES LOOK AT THE JOB AND CANT BELIEVE THEY CHARGED 55,000. THEN ON TOP OF THAT WANTED TO REDO MY DRIVEWAY AND WAS DOING ME A FAVOR OF ONLY CHARGING 100,000. ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS. WHEN THEY WERE FINISHED THE CLEANUP WAS TERRIBLE THEY PUT TOPSOIL ALL OVER THE SURROUNDING AREA THAT WAS FULL OF STONES, ETC. LANDSCAPERS HAD TO RIP OUT AND REDO. THE OWNER ALSO HAD SOME PROBLEM WITH THE VILLAGE REGARDING INSURANCES, PERMIT, AND WORKERS COMP. DIDNT LIKE TO FOLLOW THE VILLAGES RULES. "

John D on July 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 201
Asphalt Driveways questions, answered by experts

Like all driveway materials, asphalt can crack in the wrong conditions and with age. Many things can cause asphalt to crack, including shifting soil or settling under the foundation. Other common causes are driving oversized vehicles on the asphalt, tree roots, and using rock salt during the snowy season. Proper installation and sealing the driveway every 10 years can help prevent cracks.

Even with regular maintenance, most driveways don’t last much longer than 30 years. Alligator cracking is a clear warning sign that your driveway’s foundation is failing, and cracks that are deep and wide can let water in, causing more damage. Standing water is another red flag. If your driveway doesn’t drain properly, it’s going to degrade slowly. Finally, if you’re seeing dips or uneven patches, that’s a sign the base layer or soil is shifting. If these issues pop up, it’s time to replace your driveway.

If your driveway is cracked, you can repave it with a process called asphalt overlay. Overlay is more cost-effective than a full replacement but is better suited for minor cracks and issues. If you have major cracks or other problems like water pooling, asphalt overlay isn’t your best bet. Plus, paving over a cracked driveway only extends the lifetime by about 10 years, whereas replacing it would start the clock over completely to give you up to 30 years.

Installing a heated driveway is often worth the cost because it will significantly boost a home's value, especially in areas that often suffer from heavy snow and freezing temperatures. Even if you only install the basic components and never activate the heating system yourself, giving the future buyer an option to finish the system can still increase your home’s value.

By grading and compacting the base soil, ensuring proper drainage and stability.

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to asphalt driveway services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.