4.5 
550 *The Angi rating for Roofing companies in Lancaster, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Roofing needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Roofing companies in Lancaster, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Roofing needs.
Last update on January 14, 2026
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 1978
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"Great job. Crew was friendly and worked very hard in crappy weather. They cleaned up afterwards. Very satisfied with roofing job."
+26
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2018
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"Buffalo Best Roof did a wonderful job in one day. Cleanup was great."
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2011
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"Roofologists answered my quote request right away and came over the next day to check out my dormer roof to give me an estimate. They did the resealed the roof the following week just in time for the next heat wave."
+1
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2019
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"Stellar roofing did a fantastic job with the roof. They did a full tear-off of the old roof and replaced it with a metal roof. It looks fantastic and have already received compliments on the new roof."
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2021
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"We received quotes from four different contractors. Most of the quotes were in the same price range. However, we chose MP Roofing and Siding because of Mikeâ s knowledge about siding products, his enthusiasm, and because he took the time to understand our ideas for the house. His work team was here at 8 AM every morning and worked fast and efficiently until the siding, window trim, porch ceilings, shutters and gutters were finished. They replaced the storm doors and Mike installed new light fixtures on the porches. There were a few places on the house (itâ s over 100 years old) that didnâ t require siding but looked bad, such as the kick plates under the door. They replaced those and a few other areas to give the house a completely made over, refinished look. Mike constantly checked in with us to make sure we were satisfied with the progress. He monitored the work every day. I would always get an immediate response if I texted him. Mike is friendly and enthusiastic, but at the same time very serious about making sure that our house looked spectacular! We are 100% pleased with the outcome and glad we chose MP Roofing and Siding."
+3
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2012
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"Very good and reliable company.They did a good job with my new roof."
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 1961
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"Had existing windows replaced. Whole process was easy and price reasonable. All work was done timely. All employees were professional and courteous. Customer service is excellent and kept me up-to-date during the whole process. They also responded promptly to phone calls and when I needed a torn screen replaced after installation."
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2012
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"These guys turned our garage into an apartment. We needed the extra living space for an aging relative. They were professional and knowledgeable. The project took awhile but it came out perfect. I would suggest their services to anyone!"
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved (Corporate)
In business since 1976
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"Workers showed up on time. Big job installing tiles to waterproof our 110 year old house. We are very happy with the results. It was an expensive project but well worth the money"
+15
Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2016
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
Bors Pros Roofing specializes in roofing, With a focus on quality craftsmanship and customer satisfaction, we deliver reliable solutions for all your exterior renovation needs
+1
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Thatched roofs add tons of old-world charm to your home and provide outstanding insulation. Learn about thatched roof costs and what affects your final price.
Patio or deck roof costs depend on your square footage and roofing material. Learn why this project can add considerable value to your home.
The average cost of roof repair for U.S. homeowners averages between $386 and $1,875. Learn what factors can affect roof repair costs.
If you happen to have a flat roof in need of some budget-friendly support, learning how to install roll roofing yourself may be an option. Get ready for a big job.
With so many different types of roofs, it’s important to know the pros and cons of your roof’s style. Learn about 14 common roof types and how they measure up.
Take these steps to help winterize your roof this season. These preventative maintenance tips could save you tons of time and money.
