Top-rated roofers.

Get matched with top roofers in Elma, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

TRUSTED BY ELMA, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.4
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon582
    Verified roofing services reviews

Find Roofers in Elma

Avatar for Seibold Construction Inc. // Leak Master
Seibold Construction Inc. // Leak Master
4.8(
162
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1978

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"I signed up with Angie's List just to leave this review for Mike and his crew. If anyone is reading this its because you, like myself, want to make sure you find that right company to handle your project. Im a handy man myself and due to recent issues I could not complete my project myself. I needed to find a company that perform the way I would if I myself were to do the job. Lots of contractors out there hire the cheapest labor money can buy and in return the homeowner suffers. Had about 9 people come out to give estimates and if someone had no idea about roofing estimates, these guys were out for blood. All sales pitches and over pricing and couldn't start the job for weeks if not months later. Mike sat with me and went over all the details, was extremely fair with pricing, not over priced but spot-on to market value. Cleared his schedule and took my job the following week. He uses ones of the best material systems out there for roofing. His crew has been with him for many years if not decades, professional, well-mannered, friendly and last but least, clean. I did not have to pick up anything. They cleaned, swept and hauled away everything. Put everything back exactly how I had it, if they were not sure, they asked me. The wife did not have to worry about any of her plants or ornaments being damaged. They had the job done in 2 days and the dogs out playing in the yard middle of day 2. House looks amazing, proof is in the details. Everything done to spec and then some. Thank you. Hope this eases your concerns as you look through different contractors out there. This one is a rare find- give em a call you wont be disappointed."
Roofing Project
Roofing Project
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+26

Response time7 hrs
5 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by98%of homeowners
Avatar for Buffalo's Best Roofing Co LLC
Buffalo's Best Roofing Co LLC
4.5(
47
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2018

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"We hired Buffalo’s Best Roofing for a full shingle roof replacement, and the experience was excellent from start to finish. The crew was professional, on time, and worked efficiently. They explained the process clearly, answered all our questions, and delivered exactly what was promised. The workmanship is top-notch, the cleanup was thorough, and the new roof looks great. Fair pricing and honest service—highly recommend Buffalo’s Best Roofing."
Roof Replacement
Roof Replacement
Roof Replacement
Response time1 day
Response rate96%
46 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Stellar Roofing, Inc.
Stellar Roofing, Inc.
4.5(
198
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2019

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Stellar roofing did a fantastic job with the roof. They did a full tear-off of the old roof and replaced it with a metal roof. It looks fantastic and have already received compliments on the new roof."
New Roofs
New Roofs
New Roofs
New Roofs
Response time1 day
647 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by82%of homeowners
Avatar for Roof Armor
Roof Armor
5.0(
10
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2023

Free estimates

Customers say: True professional

"Excellent service from start to finish. I never realized how dirty my roof was. Roof looks brand new and adds curb appeal. Thanks again Roof Armor!"
18 years of algae cleaned off
Must be cleaned
How a gutter should look
Before
After

+5

Response time3 hrs
Response rate91%
14 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for MP Roofing and Siding, LLC
MP Roofing and Siding, LLC
4.9(
15
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2021

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"We received quotes from four different contractors. Most of the quotes were in the same price range. However, we chose MP Roofing and Siding because of Mikeâ s knowledge about siding products, his enthusiasm, and because he took the time to understand our ideas for the house. His work team was here at 8 AM every morning and worked fast and efficiently until the siding, window trim, porch ceilings, shutters and gutters were finished. They replaced the storm doors and Mike installed new light fixtures on the porches. There were a few places on the house (itâ s over 100 years old) that didnâ t require siding but looked bad, such as the kick plates under the door. They replaced those and a few other areas to give the house a completely made over, refinished look. Mike constantly checked in with us to make sure we were satisfied with the progress. He monitored the work every day. I would always get an immediate response if I texted him. Mike is friendly and enthusiastic, but at the same time very serious about making sure that our house looked spectacular! We are 100% pleased with the outcome and glad we chose MP Roofing and Siding."
Crofton Drive
Crofton
completed backside
Tear off
Tear off

+3

Response time3 days
14 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by83%of homeowners
Avatar for Buffalo's Best Roofing Company
Buffalo's Best Roofing Company
4.3(
116
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2012

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Buffalo's Best Roofing replaced my roof (full tearoff + cedar plank) in early 2020. It was roughly 5 1/2 months from signoff to actual roof replacement. Unfortunately, I did have a few problems during the roof replacement process and a portion of roofing that was missed completely, but at the end of the day, Roy made things right. My only suggestions are that the a thorough post-install inspection should be conducted with the homeowner in order to get a signoff on project completion and to make sure you fully tarp an open roof if there's rain/snow in the forecast. Despite everything, I would use them again."
Roof
Roof
Roof
Roof
Response time1 day
Response rate92%
191 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Monroe and More, LLC
Monroe and More, LLC
4.7(
47
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2016

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"They were very professional and courteous, on time, and job well done, was advised on a roof repair that I did not realize was needed so very thankful they informed me!!"
siding wash
ROOF WASH
GUTTER CLEANING
GUTTER SURFACES
Interior Painting

+4

Response time2 days
14 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by75%of homeowners
Avatar for N8S Exterior Solutions LLC
N8S Exterior Solutions LLC
5.0(
26
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2025

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"The Team from N8S Exterior Solutions LLC was quick and did an excellent job. You have to appreciate any team that is organized, friendly and as thorough as N8S. They kept in contact and up on their ETA and progress and made you as a consumer feel as they valued your business. I would definitely use them again for snow removal and other project on the property after reading about what else they offer. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend them."
Exterior house wash
Exterior house wash
Exterior house wash
Exterior house wash
Exterior house wash

+68

Response time1 day
Response rate97%
48 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for # 1 roofing & sealcoating
# 1 roofing & sealcoating
4.3(
9
)

Serving Elma, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2008

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I used Angie's List to find a Pro in my area to repair damaged shingles after a wind storm. Tony and Nick responded immediately and were able to make the repairs the same day. They were very professional and thorough. They not only made the repair to the roof, but resealed the chimney and nearby roof vents. They also cleaned the gutters at a fair price."
Remodeling - General Project
Roofing Project
Painting - Interior Project
Handymen Project
Remodeling - General Project

+14

Response time8 hrs
Response rate88%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
...
Showing 1-10 of 196
Roofing questions, answered by experts

You shouldn’t put a new roof underlayment over an old one for a few reasons. Old felt must be removed in order to assess the condition of your roof decking, such as rotting wood or other structural issues. Also, if your roofer doesn't install a fresh layer of felt as is required by shingle manufacturers, your warranty may be voided. Finally, old underlayment removal is often included in the cost of roof repair or replacement, so there's no real benefit to leaving it on before installing a new layer.

Roofers can install roof vents. Updating, upgrading, or simply replacing your roof's existing vents is common when installing a new roof. If you're looking to upgrade your ventilation system with a powered version, a local HVAC professional can also help with the task. If adding roof vents to your home is necessary while installing an addition or during other renovation work, your contractor will handle or hire out the venting work.

The best style of chimney cap for a brick chimney is one that fits tightly around the brick top of the chimney. The cap should have a screen to fully enclose it to keep animals out. The best materials include stainless steel, copper, or aluminum that fit tightly or are custom fabricated for a perfect fit on your chimney.

Yes, roof ridge caps are a necessary part of your roof system. Your roof ridge cap is at the peak of your roof, where two slopes of your roof meet. Roof ridge caps seal the seam and help protect your roof from water and debris, and because they’re pre-bent and thicker, they’re more suited to the job than regular roof shingles, which can break when bent.

In most cases, no, roofers won’t need to come inside. Some reasons roofers may need to come inside are to assess ventilation. inspect roof leaks, or check for any structural concerns.

The Elma, NY homeowners’ guide to roofing services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.