Get matched with top water heater pros in Fishers Island, NY
There are 15 highly-rated local water heater pros.
TRUSTED BY HOMEOWNERS
4.7 
31 Verified Reviews for Water Heater Service pros in Fishers Island, NY
*The Angi rating for Water Heater Service companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Water Heater Service companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.
Last update on June 03, 2025
Water heater pros in Fishers Island
Full service plumbing company doing new construction and home service including 24/7 emergency service. No hot water at 1am? Call us. No heat at 3am? Call us. Clogged toilet on a Sunday? Call us. Frozen pipe in a blizzard? Call us. Flooded house? Call us. Slab leak? Call us. "A hot shower no matter the hour" we love to say! All of our work is warrantied for 1 year (with longer warranties available) which includes bot only the work but the parts and material as well. We wear booties and/or remove shoes in your home, always! Call us for all of your plumbing problems if you want somebody that you can trust and can ask hundreds of questions without an impatient technician losing his cool. Because we are there to HELP and we are at your service!
"Process was easy and professional was knowledgeable and very nice. Would definitely hire again."
Marie R on May 2025
Full service plumbing company doing new construction and home service including 24/7 emergency service. No hot water at 1am? Call us. No heat at 3am? Call us. Clogged toilet on a Sunday? Call us. Frozen pipe in a blizzard? Call us. Flooded house? Call us. Slab leak? Call us. "A hot shower no matter the hour" we love to say! All of our work is warrantied for 1 year (with longer warranties available) which includes bot only the work but the parts and material as well. We wear booties and/or remove shoes in your home, always! Call us for all of your plumbing problems if you want somebody that you can trust and can ask hundreds of questions without an impatient technician losing his cool. Because we are there to HELP and we are at your service!
"Process was easy and professional was knowledgeable and very nice. Would definitely hire again."
Marie R on May 2025
Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp. has been trusted and recommended since 1971, and recognized for our superb service. We are family owned and operated, with guaranteed great service. Our company specializes in all types of work, but especially: Plumbing, Gas Heating, Drain Cleaning, Oil to Gas Conversions, NYS RPZ Testing to name a few things. Call & schedule your appointment today! 631-666-9315
"Didn't show up on day scheduled, failed to call. Replaced ~$100 part in about a half hour. Charge was $595"
Bruce M on April 2025
Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp. has been trusted and recommended since 1971, and recognized for our superb service. We are family owned and operated, with guaranteed great service. Our company specializes in all types of work, but especially: Plumbing, Gas Heating, Drain Cleaning, Oil to Gas Conversions, NYS RPZ Testing to name a few things. Call & schedule your appointment today! 631-666-9315
"Didn't show up on day scheduled, failed to call. Replaced ~$100 part in about a half hour. Charge was $595"
Bruce M on April 2025
Work completed by Connecticut Basement Systems, Inc., is warranted for lifetime of your home. Satisfaction is guaranteed and we assure prompt reply to all inquiries. Free estimates and financing are available. We've wowed over 30,000 customers since 1987. We have an A plus Better Business Bureau rating. Check us out for unbiased reviews and customer testimonials.
"Overall, working with the company was a good experience."
Marcy W on October 2024
Work completed by Connecticut Basement Systems, Inc., is warranted for lifetime of your home. Satisfaction is guaranteed and we assure prompt reply to all inquiries. Free estimates and financing are available. We've wowed over 30,000 customers since 1987. We have an A plus Better Business Bureau rating. Check us out for unbiased reviews and customer testimonials.
"Overall, working with the company was a good experience."
Marcy W on October 2024
Here at 1-800-PLUMBER®, we know that you depend on your plumbing system to function properly, and when it doesn’t, it can be a real headache. If you are having problems with no hot water, a toilet not flushing properly, a water leak, or any of the many other plumbing problems that may arise, rest assured that we are here to meet your needs! Our licensed technicians are ready to solve any of your plumbing needs. Call us today to have one of our licensed technicians come to you. It’s easy, Our Name is Our Number!
"This company is the worst and no wonder they have a one star review on here. They failed to show up THREE SEPARATE TIMES! They promised each time that they would definitely come and then they never did. And I had to call and call and call to finally figure this out. Do not ever schedule them. I am left with an unusable kitchen drain on a holiday weekend after booking them two days ago"
Jacqueline A on January 2021
Here at 1-800-PLUMBER®, we know that you depend on your plumbing system to function properly, and when it doesn’t, it can be a real headache. If you are having problems with no hot water, a toilet not flushing properly, a water leak, or any of the many other plumbing problems that may arise, rest assured that we are here to meet your needs! Our licensed technicians are ready to solve any of your plumbing needs. Call us today to have one of our licensed technicians come to you. It’s easy, Our Name is Our Number!
"This company is the worst and no wonder they have a one star review on here. They failed to show up THREE SEPARATE TIMES! They promised each time that they would definitely come and then they never did. And I had to call and call and call to finally figure this out. Do not ever schedule them. I am left with an unusable kitchen drain on a holiday weekend after booking them two days ago"
Jacqueline A on January 2021
Welcome to South Shore Plumbing and Heating, Inc.! With over 25 years of experience, we work hard to bring each customer the best possible service and quality available. We look forward to working with you on your next project. South Shore Plumbing and Heating, Inc. We welcome your questions and thank you for your interest!
"Willing to work with schedule to make appointment Technician ran late but other then that he quickly and efficiently did the job"
Jennifer K on December 2024
Welcome to South Shore Plumbing and Heating, Inc.! With over 25 years of experience, we work hard to bring each customer the best possible service and quality available. We look forward to working with you on your next project. South Shore Plumbing and Heating, Inc. We welcome your questions and thank you for your interest!
"Willing to work with schedule to make appointment Technician ran late but other then that he quickly and efficiently did the job"
Jennifer K on December 2024
With over three decades of experience, First Choice Plumbing and Heating provides professional and quality service, to all the Selden community. Be sure to call us today to set up an appointment, and free estimate! Ask about our senior and military discounts. We look forward to earning your business.
"Great. He came on time, actually early, and fixed the problem. I would definitely call him again."
SAMINDRANATH M on September 2019
With over three decades of experience, First Choice Plumbing and Heating provides professional and quality service, to all the Selden community. Be sure to call us today to set up an appointment, and free estimate! Ask about our senior and military discounts. We look forward to earning your business.
"Great. He came on time, actually early, and fixed the problem. I would definitely call him again."
SAMINDRANATH M on September 2019
We've been in the Plumbing and Heating business for over 20 years. We employ certified and insured Master Plumbers who specialize in all stages of installs as well as all repair calls as well. It is important to our team to educate the customer and make sure they know all of their options, for this reason we often form a close bond with our clients, always making sure they feel empowered with the knowledge that our team can provide. Our property and home inspectors are the most thorough in the business. We inspect your property investments with a fine tooth comb, leaving you with a detailed report included with specific images of each stage of the inspection. Our property managers take care of aspects of property care, from large commercial to neighborhood residential, our teams cover it all! From the smallest job to the biggest, we always cover every base. When a customer contacts us they can expect to speak with a kind and courteous team member that will help with any and all questions they may have!
"The job performed by Jason and Shawn was excellent! They arrived as scheduled, were courteous and professional. Every aspect of SAFEHAVEN was a really rewarding experience. Loriann was extremely helpful with coordinating the work. If you are planning on having a CAC system installed, or replaced, SAFEHAVEN is the company to choose."
Kevin S on October 2022
We've been in the Plumbing and Heating business for over 20 years. We employ certified and insured Master Plumbers who specialize in all stages of installs as well as all repair calls as well. It is important to our team to educate the customer and make sure they know all of their options, for this reason we often form a close bond with our clients, always making sure they feel empowered with the knowledge that our team can provide. Our property and home inspectors are the most thorough in the business. We inspect your property investments with a fine tooth comb, leaving you with a detailed report included with specific images of each stage of the inspection. Our property managers take care of aspects of property care, from large commercial to neighborhood residential, our teams cover it all! From the smallest job to the biggest, we always cover every base. When a customer contacts us they can expect to speak with a kind and courteous team member that will help with any and all questions they may have!
"The job performed by Jason and Shawn was excellent! They arrived as scheduled, were courteous and professional. Every aspect of SAFEHAVEN was a really rewarding experience. Loriann was extremely helpful with coordinating the work. If you are planning on having a CAC system installed, or replaced, SAFEHAVEN is the company to choose."
Kevin S on October 2022
Quality Wholesale Plumbing Products since the 1950’s! South Amboy Plumbing Supply is an independent plumbing supply wholesaler with over 60 years of service supplying the needs of plumbing, heating, cooling and remodeling contractors in New Jersey and New York. When considering a purchase or product inquiry, South Amboy Plumbing Supply has a team that is product educated and customer service ready.
Quality Wholesale Plumbing Products since the 1950’s! South Amboy Plumbing Supply is an independent plumbing supply wholesaler with over 60 years of service supplying the needs of plumbing, heating, cooling and remodeling contractors in New Jersey and New York. When considering a purchase or product inquiry, South Amboy Plumbing Supply has a team that is product educated and customer service ready.
Pentagon Custom Building is a pet-friendly Company with a trustworthy people. When we start a project we finish and meet our client's expectation- provides 100% satisfaction guarantee. License and Insured company so clients are all covered. Sums up to 100% Reliable Roofing Service, Remodeling Service, Kitchen Remodeling, Bathroom Remodeling, Flooring, Framing, Plumbing, Electrical, Drywall, Carpentry West Grove NJ;
Pentagon Custom Building is a pet-friendly Company with a trustworthy people. When we start a project we finish and meet our client's expectation- provides 100% satisfaction guarantee. License and Insured company so clients are all covered. Sums up to 100% Reliable Roofing Service, Remodeling Service, Kitchen Remodeling, Bathroom Remodeling, Flooring, Framing, Plumbing, Electrical, Drywall, Carpentry West Grove NJ;
Brazing Mechanical is there for you when you need us the most. We offer complete HVAC services for residential, commercial, healthcare, and industrial locations. 24/7 Emergency services, service/maintenance contracts are currently offered at a discount of 75% for the first 6 months while openings are available.
Brazing Mechanical is there for you when you need us the most. We offer complete HVAC services for residential, commercial, healthcare, and industrial locations. 24/7 Emergency services, service/maintenance contracts are currently offered at a discount of 75% for the first 6 months while openings are available.
Water heater services FAQs
The average cost to install a new water heater is around $1,300, but you can expect to pay between $875 and $1,750, depending on the kind of water heater, the size of the unit, and the professional chosen to complete the work. Tankless water heaters can push your price higher, as installation is more complicated, with prices as high as $3,500. The location and accessibility of your water heater will play a role in the project cost, as those sitting in tight spaces like a crawl space will drive up your labor costs.
Tankless water heaters are more expensive than those with a storage tank, but they come with some impressive benefits that most homeowners find worth the higher investment. Most importantly, they provide unlimited hot water, so you’ll never run out like you would with a storage tank. Tankless heaters are also more efficient, so comparing gallon-for-gallon, you’ll spend less on hot water with a tankless heater. Tankless water heaters are also smaller, require less maintenance, and tend to last longer than storage tank water heaters.
It usually takes a professional water heater installer between two and three hours to remove an existing water heater and install a new tank heater. However, it could take four to five hours if they have to work in a small utility closet or another tight area, like a crawl space. Tankless water heaters have a more complicated installation process, so they will take a bit longer. Additionally, a gas water heater requires a connection to a gas line, and that alone can add about an hour to the installation timeline compared to installing an electric water heater.
It is very difficult and dangerous to install your own water heater, so we strongly recommend against tackling this as a DIY project. Not only will you need to wire your water heater, but you’ll also need to connect plumbing to the intake and outlet. Sweating copper pipes and connecting wiring properly are skills most DIYers don’t have, and even if you do feel confident you can do it, working with water and electricity always leaves the potential for electrocution. Hiring a local water heater installer is well worth the investment.
In most municipalities, a license is not mandatory for water heater installation or replacement. However, we strongly recommend hiring a licensed plumber or water heater installer to handle the work. Licensed installers are far less likely to make a mistake during the installation, which means paying for the experience decreases your risk of a leak and other issues. You can use our state licensing tool to find out if a contractor you’re considering in your area holds a plumber’s license.
Get our Angi-powered app
