Top-rated plaster repair specialists.

Get matched with top plaster repair specialists in Fishers Island, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your plaster repair project in Fishers Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY FISHERS ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.6
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon100
    Verified plaster repairs reviews

Verified Reviews for Plaster Repair pros in Fishers Island, NY

*The Angi rating for Plaster Repair companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Plaster Repair needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Plaster Repair companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Plaster Repair needs.

Last update on December 04, 2025

Find Plaster repair specialists in Fishers Island

P.A.C. Drywall

5.00(
4
)
•Approved Pro

P.A.C. Drywall

5.00(
4
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
42 local quotes requested

At P.A.C. Drywall, we specialize in top-quality drywall installation, repair, and finishing services for residential and commercial projects. With precision craftsmanship and exceptional customer service, we bring your spaces to life!

"I recently had PAC Drywall repair my kitchen and dining room ceilings, and the entire experience was absolutely flawless. Pat, Tom, and Aaron completed the work in just one and a half days with incredible attention to detail. They were punctual, professional, and clearly take pride in their craft. The quality of the repair was outstanding—smooth, seamless, and as good as new. On top of that, their pricing was very reasonable, and they were honest and straightforward from start to finish. I truly appreciate the excellent work and the care they put into the job. I highly recommend PAC Drywall to anyone looking for top-notch service. Five Stars!!!"

John D on August 2025

At P.A.C. Drywall, we specialize in top-quality drywall installation, repair, and finishing services for residential and commercial projects. With precision craftsmanship and exceptional customer service, we bring your spaces to life!

"I recently had PAC Drywall repair my kitchen and dining room ceilings, and the entire experience was absolutely flawless. Pat, Tom, and Aaron completed the work in just one and a half days with incredible attention to detail. They were punctual, professional, and clearly take pride in their craft. The quality of the repair was outstanding—smooth, seamless, and as good as new. On top of that, their pricing was very reasonable, and they were honest and straightforward from start to finish. I truly appreciate the excellent work and the care they put into the job. I highly recommend PAC Drywall to anyone looking for top-notch service. Five Stars!!!"

John D on August 2025

Grady's Painting Plastering/Construction

4.56(
54
)
•Approved Pro

Grady's Painting Plastering/Construction

4.56(
54
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
56 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

WE SPECIALIZE IN THE HISTORICAL REPAIR AND RESTORATIONS FOR INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR. WE WORK THE WHOLE STATE OF NEW JERSEY, MARYLAND, WASHINGTON DC, CONNECTICUT, VIRGINA AND MASSACHUSETTS. WE ARE LICENSED AND INSURED IN ALL STATES. WE ARE WILLING TO TRAVEL, ANY JOB SMALL OR LARGE. CONSULTATION AND TRANSPORTATION FEES WILL APPLY. WE DO WINDOW REPAIR. PLASTER REPAIRS. AND ALL MASONRY REPAIRS

"We had cracks in the dyed mortar of the bricks above our garage. Grady took the time to match the color, even with the color having aged 10 years, and you would not even be able to tell that there was new mortar. If your project is anything like ours, you will not be disappointed."

Bradley S on August 2024

WE SPECIALIZE IN THE HISTORICAL REPAIR AND RESTORATIONS FOR INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR. WE WORK THE WHOLE STATE OF NEW JERSEY, MARYLAND, WASHINGTON DC, CONNECTICUT, VIRGINA AND MASSACHUSETTS. WE ARE LICENSED AND INSURED IN ALL STATES. WE ARE WILLING TO TRAVEL, ANY JOB SMALL OR LARGE. CONSULTATION AND TRANSPORTATION FEES WILL APPLY. WE DO WINDOW REPAIR. PLASTER REPAIRS. AND ALL MASONRY REPAIRS

"We had cracks in the dyed mortar of the bricks above our garage. Grady took the time to match the color, even with the color having aged 10 years, and you would not even be able to tell that there was new mortar. If your project is anything like ours, you will not be disappointed."

Bradley S on August 2024

Avatar for A&D Remodel LLC

A&D Remodel LLC

5.00(
30
)
•Approved Pro

A&D Remodel LLC

5.00(
30
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
41 local quotes requested

5 Years Of Experience. Servicing Eastern Connecticut. Our Mission Is To Be A Provider That Brings Back Personal Touches & Quality Work! We Build Lifelong Relationships With Our Clients. We Feel Invested With Our Clients & Strive For Customer Satisfaction!

"Excellent very prompt and competent work was completed very fast. Tear down three rooms of old plaster put up new sheet rock mud sand paint three rooms. The best I’ve seen. Always on time. Work was done. Impressed me so much. very very reasonable price. Don’t think twice about Hiring them. Great job."

Maryann K on December 2025

5 Years Of Experience. Servicing Eastern Connecticut. Our Mission Is To Be A Provider That Brings Back Personal Touches & Quality Work! We Build Lifelong Relationships With Our Clients. We Feel Invested With Our Clients & Strive For Customer Satisfaction!

"Excellent very prompt and competent work was completed very fast. Tear down three rooms of old plaster put up new sheet rock mud sand paint three rooms. The best I’ve seen. Always on time. Work was done. Impressed me so much. very very reasonable price. Don’t think twice about Hiring them. Great job."

Maryann K on December 2025

TF Plasters

New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro

TF Plasters

New on AngiNew on Angi
•Approved Pro
10 local quotes requested
8 years of experience

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

Avatar for PatchitUP of Suffolk County

PatchitUP of Suffolk County

5.00(
9
)
•Approved Pro

PatchitUP of Suffolk County

5.00(
9
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
128 local quotes requested

PatchitUP is a business that specializes in taking on the job that many contractors or handyman do not want to do. We'll repair any small or large drywall damage in your home or business. For over a decade, Patch It Up has been specializing in drywall and ceiling repair jobs for homeowners throughout Long Island. From the beginning, we have focused on the small drywall, and plaster repair and installation projects that most larger repair and construction companies simply won’t take on. Because of this focus, we have been able to develop and perfect our process of professional drywall repair to ensure quality, seamless results every time.

"PatchitUP did a great job at removing old kitchen tile backsplash and installing replacement sheetrock. They were very professional and courteous."

Brian D on April 2025

PatchitUP is a business that specializes in taking on the job that many contractors or handyman do not want to do. We'll repair any small or large drywall damage in your home or business. For over a decade, Patch It Up has been specializing in drywall and ceiling repair jobs for homeowners throughout Long Island. From the beginning, we have focused on the small drywall, and plaster repair and installation projects that most larger repair and construction companies simply won’t take on. Because of this focus, we have been able to develop and perfect our process of professional drywall repair to ensure quality, seamless results every time.

"PatchitUP did a great job at removing old kitchen tile backsplash and installing replacement sheetrock. They were very professional and courteous."

Brian D on April 2025

Avatar for The Perfect Interior

The Perfect Interior

5.00(
1
)

The Perfect Interior

5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Perfect Interior LC specializes in interior renovations of all scales, focusing on energy efficiency to comply with NYC’s Local Law 97. With over 10 years of experience in industrial energy efficiency, we enhance comfort without increasing costs. Our expert team designs, manages, and ensures measurable success in every project, guiding clients through energy-saving steps that scale effectively. Partnering with industry allies, we bring innovative solutions to NYC, creating beautiful, efficient spaces that align with your vision. Contact us today to start your transformation!

"Professionalism and good service."

Marcela G on November 2024

Perfect Interior LC specializes in interior renovations of all scales, focusing on energy efficiency to comply with NYC’s Local Law 97. With over 10 years of experience in industrial energy efficiency, we enhance comfort without increasing costs. Our expert team designs, manages, and ensures measurable success in every project, guiding clients through energy-saving steps that scale effectively. Partnering with industry allies, we bring innovative solutions to NYC, creating beautiful, efficient spaces that align with your vision. Contact us today to start your transformation!

"Professionalism and good service."

Marcela G on November 2024

Avatar for Meoded Paint and Plaster

Meoded Paint and Plaster

No reviews yet

Meoded Paint and Plaster

No reviews yet

Meoded Paint & Plaster is proud to serve the state of New York for all their paint, plaster, and decorative finishing needs. Our goal is to encourage customers to express their personal taste and style through the use of unique products like Venetian Plaster, Metallic Paint, Glitter Paint, and more.

Meoded Paint & Plaster is proud to serve the state of New York for all their paint, plaster, and decorative finishing needs. Our goal is to encourage customers to express their personal taste and style through the use of unique products like Venetian Plaster, Metallic Paint, Glitter Paint, and more.

M Hernandez Home Improvement Inc

4.75(
12
)

M Hernandez Home Improvement Inc

4.75(
12
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Home improvement and remodeling Serving home owners and real state investors with a full range of construction and renovation related services since 1982. Commercial and residential - licensed and insured.

"It went well."

Glenn R on December 2021

Home improvement and remodeling Serving home owners and real state investors with a full range of construction and renovation related services since 1982. Commercial and residential - licensed and insured.

"It went well."

Glenn R on December 2021

...
Showing 1-10 of 205
Plaster Repair questions, answered by experts

Plaster can be a difficult DIY to master, especially if you plan to plaster an entire room, rather than patch a small area. Before you begin a plaster DIY project, you need to know which tools and type of plaster to use. It's also important to know how to prepare the surface and apply the plaster for a smooth finish. If that all sounds like a lot of work, you may prefer hiring a local plaster repair contractor to do the job.

The tool you use to sand plaster will depend on the size of the project. If you’re just working on a small section of your wall to get rid of an uneven spot on the surface, hand-sanding might work. However, for larger projects, a drywall sander can make a huge difference when it comes to both time and elbow grease—and an orbital sander can help for detailed areas such as around ceiling fans.

Drywall can be better than plaster if you’re installing a new wall and want to keep costs low. It’s much cheaper than installing plaster and provides a smooth, uniform surface. Many homeowners simply paint over the drywall or add a texture like sand or orange peel. It’s also much easier to DIY than plaster, and if you need to change your layout, it’s much easier to remove.

Wondering who to call for ceiling repair? While you can hire a handyperson to fix minor cracks, you’ll want to hire a drywall professional for larger issues. Depending on the cause of the crack, you may need to hire other contractors, such as a foundation contractor, mold remediation company, roofer, or plumber near you.

If the holes in the plaster are small, you can fill them with layers of patching plaster until they’re filled. After it dries, you can sand the plaster and paint over it. If the hole is much larger, consider using bonding plaster first and then a layer of patching plaster, completing the process with sanding and a layer of paint.

The Fishers Island, NY homeowners’ guide to plaster repairs

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles