Top-rated home builders.

Get matched with top home builders in Fishers Island, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your home building project in Fishers Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY FISHERS ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.5
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon22
    Verified home building services reviews

Find Home builders in Fishers Island

Avatar for Arthur DeRosa Building and Remodeling

Arthur DeRosa Building and Remodeling

5.00(
12
)
Approved Pro

Arthur DeRosa Building and Remodeling

5.00(
12
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
39 years of experience

We are a building, remodeling, home improvement firm backed with 31 yrs experience. I, Arthur DeRosa, personally over see every project, big or small, from start to finish. I have an artists soul and every project that I am privileged to do is a reflection of that. With performance backed by experience and attention to detail, your project will be in good hands. The number of employees varies depending on work load. Sub-contractors are used when necessary. Proposals and estimates are free and include payment schedules with start and completion dates. Super Service Award winner for 2016! Call us today to schedule your appointment - (631) 774-1231

"Artie & Mike are simply the best. I used them to: 1) Build a LARGE extension to my house and redo my entire kitchen and dining room. The job was completed on time and on budget. Throughout the process Artie was transparent & professional. EVERY person who has stepped into my house has complimented at the detailed perfection. 3) Artie built us a custom walk in pantry 2) Built 2 large decks in the backyard as well as an outdoor shower. This project was completed on time, on budget while exceeding all expectations. If you are looking for a contractor and crew that is responsible, responsive, polite, creative and delivers the HIGHEST LEVEL of quality - Artie is the one."

Constantine M on March 2023

We are a building, remodeling, home improvement firm backed with 31 yrs experience. I, Arthur DeRosa, personally over see every project, big or small, from start to finish. I have an artists soul and every project that I am privileged to do is a reflection of that. With performance backed by experience and attention to detail, your project will be in good hands. The number of employees varies depending on work load. Sub-contractors are used when necessary. Proposals and estimates are free and include payment schedules with start and completion dates. Super Service Award winner for 2016! Call us today to schedule your appointment - (631) 774-1231

"Artie & Mike are simply the best. I used them to: 1) Build a LARGE extension to my house and redo my entire kitchen and dining room. The job was completed on time and on budget. Throughout the process Artie was transparent & professional. EVERY person who has stepped into my house has complimented at the detailed perfection. 3) Artie built us a custom walk in pantry 2) Built 2 large decks in the backyard as well as an outdoor shower. This project was completed on time, on budget while exceeding all expectations. If you are looking for a contractor and crew that is responsible, responsive, polite, creative and delivers the HIGHEST LEVEL of quality - Artie is the one."

Constantine M on March 2023


Avatar for Cocos Custom Building LLC

Cocos Custom Building LLC

4.75(
8
)
Approved Pro

Cocos Custom Building LLC

4.75(
8
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
2 years of experience

Coco’s Custom Building LLC specializes in setting and finishing Modular Homes, fabricating and installing structural steel, and all phases of residential and commercial construction. This includes extensions, dormers, basements, siding, exterior trim and roofing. We have 25 years of experience. We take pride in giving our customers a professional quality finish on all of our projects for a reasonable price. We work extremely hard to ensure that our customers hard earned money doesn’t go to waste.

"Excellent. On time and on budget"

Brian D on January 2025

Coco’s Custom Building LLC specializes in setting and finishing Modular Homes, fabricating and installing structural steel, and all phases of residential and commercial construction. This includes extensions, dormers, basements, siding, exterior trim and roofing. We have 25 years of experience. We take pride in giving our customers a professional quality finish on all of our projects for a reasonable price. We work extremely hard to ensure that our customers hard earned money doesn’t go to waste.

"Excellent. On time and on budget"

Brian D on January 2025


Avatar for Sentri Homes

Sentri Homes

New on AngiNew on Angi
Approved Pro

Sentri Homes

New on AngiNew on Angi
Approved Pro
2 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Sentri Homes is a full-service contractor delivering high-end home additions, whole-home remodels, new custom builds, luxury kitchens, structural framing, roof replacements, and every major renovation. We assign a dedicated project manager to every job, deliver meticulous craftsmanship with clear communication, and back our work with an industry-leading warranty to ensure complete peace of mind on your largest investments. Our in-house team of licensed builders and master craftsmen consistently earns 5-star reviews by turning big visions into stunning, high-value homes—when you need one trusted partner who truly does it all, we’re the proven choice.

Sentri Homes is a full-service contractor delivering high-end home additions, whole-home remodels, new custom builds, luxury kitchens, structural framing, roof replacements, and every major renovation. We assign a dedicated project manager to every job, deliver meticulous craftsmanship with clear communication, and back our work with an industry-leading warranty to ensure complete peace of mind on your largest investments. Our in-house team of licensed builders and master craftsmen consistently earns 5-star reviews by turning big visions into stunning, high-value homes—when you need one trusted partner who truly does it all, we’re the proven choice.


Avatar for Crisvalih Home Remodeling Inc

Crisvalih Home Remodeling Inc

4.97(
144
)

Crisvalih Home Remodeling Inc

4.97(
144
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 99% of Angi customers
Recommended by 99% of HomeAdvisor customers

Leadership: At CRISVALIH HOME REMODELING. INC, you receive the kind of quality and service you expect from a leader. Our company is always evolving as the needs or our customers change and as new opportunities are created in the market. You can rest assured that Teamwork: We make it our responsibility to know you and your business. We work closely with you to ensure that the solutions we provide are tailored to meet your unique needs and challenges. We are committed to your success. Customer Relations: At CRISVALIH HOME REMODELING. INC our highest priority is satisfied customers. You are important to us and you can expect us to go the extra mile for your business. We are proud to serve you and work hard to earn your business.

"I had my master bathroom upgraded. Christian and his crew are top notch. From the drop cloths all the way up from the front door to the bathroom, to clean-off every day. It’s rare to not have to clean up every day after contractors leave for the day. Quality work across the board. I was very happy with the end result."

Vince s on November 2024

Leadership: At CRISVALIH HOME REMODELING. INC, you receive the kind of quality and service you expect from a leader. Our company is always evolving as the needs or our customers change and as new opportunities are created in the market. You can rest assured that Teamwork: We make it our responsibility to know you and your business. We work closely with you to ensure that the solutions we provide are tailored to meet your unique needs and challenges. We are committed to your success. Customer Relations: At CRISVALIH HOME REMODELING. INC our highest priority is satisfied customers. You are important to us and you can expect us to go the extra mile for your business. We are proud to serve you and work hard to earn your business.

"I had my master bathroom upgraded. Christian and his crew are top notch. From the drop cloths all the way up from the front door to the bathroom, to clean-off every day. It’s rare to not have to clean up every day after contractors leave for the day. Quality work across the board. I was very happy with the end result."

Vince s on November 2024


Avatar for Universal Roofing & Chimney of LI Inc

Universal Roofing & Chimney of LI Inc

4.96(
78
)

Universal Roofing & Chimney of LI Inc

4.96(
78
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Welcome To Universal Roofing and Chimney I am Art owner of the company; I have been in the roofing and Masonry industry for more than 20 years. I have seen many companies working in this field without caring for their customers. I opened my company, and I can proudly say that my staff and I genuinely care for our customers. I am always within the scope of my customer base and always ready to provide the estimate of the products and services they needed. Universal roofing & Chimney is a family owned business, and as I am a family oriented person, I truly love to work in this industry, to uphold the reputation of my family high. My father started Mason when he was 15 years old he was & is number one building the houses from ground up, but he use to like more Mason work which he teaches me how to built houses do mason concrete clay shingle and flat roof, i start working part time with my father when i was 12 years old he use to take me around and show me how to build houses. I been working full time now more than 10 years but my father is retired now and I would like to extend the heights to see him proud of our company. Some people in this industry have given the poor standing by their nefarious deeds and practices, but I want to say that not everyone is like that. I have been serving Long Island for over 5 years and as local expert, we pride ourselves in providing outstanding services to commercial and residential customer base, as well. Customers can simply call me at my cell number 917-744-7943 to get a free estimate on all our Roofing, Chimney, Gutter, and Masonry services, and I assure them to give 10% off the cheapest estimate than other company is providing. We are always happy to receive the call enquiries and our emergency services are available 24 hours 7 days a week in Suffolk. Call us now to get the best estimate on all our Roofing and Chimney services. Services: Chimney Cleaning as low as $24.95 gutter cleaning as low as 34.95 Chimney Inspections Chimney Service Blockage Removal Chimney Problems Chimney Liners Chimney Caps Chimney & Fireplace Maintenance Chimney Repair Animal Removal From Chimneys roof leaks repair & removed and replaced Siding repair removed & replaced

"Beyond thrilled with how the entire project went. Universal Roofing & Chimney gave me a good price on a whole new roof plus we did new gutters as well. The cost was well worth it knowing the warranty we have now and to know it was done right. The crew worked well and cleaned everything up when they were done."

Karen G on March 2024

Welcome To Universal Roofing and Chimney I am Art owner of the company; I have been in the roofing and Masonry industry for more than 20 years. I have seen many companies working in this field without caring for their customers. I opened my company, and I can proudly say that my staff and I genuinely care for our customers. I am always within the scope of my customer base and always ready to provide the estimate of the products and services they needed. Universal roofing & Chimney is a family owned business, and as I am a family oriented person, I truly love to work in this industry, to uphold the reputation of my family high. My father started Mason when he was 15 years old he was & is number one building the houses from ground up, but he use to like more Mason work which he teaches me how to built houses do mason concrete clay shingle and flat roof, i start working part time with my father when i was 12 years old he use to take me around and show me how to build houses. I been working full time now more than 10 years but my father is retired now and I would like to extend the heights to see him proud of our company. Some people in this industry have given the poor standing by their nefarious deeds and practices, but I want to say that not everyone is like that. I have been serving Long Island for over 5 years and as local expert, we pride ourselves in providing outstanding services to commercial and residential customer base, as well. Customers can simply call me at my cell number 917-744-7943 to get a free estimate on all our Roofing, Chimney, Gutter, and Masonry services, and I assure them to give 10% off the cheapest estimate than other company is providing. We are always happy to receive the call enquiries and our emergency services are available 24 hours 7 days a week in Suffolk. Call us now to get the best estimate on all our Roofing and Chimney services. Services: Chimney Cleaning as low as $24.95 gutter cleaning as low as 34.95 Chimney Inspections Chimney Service Blockage Removal Chimney Problems Chimney Liners Chimney Caps Chimney & Fireplace Maintenance Chimney Repair Animal Removal From Chimneys roof leaks repair & removed and replaced Siding repair removed & replaced

"Beyond thrilled with how the entire project went. Universal Roofing & Chimney gave me a good price on a whole new roof plus we did new gutters as well. The cost was well worth it knowing the warranty we have now and to know it was done right. The crew worked well and cleaned everything up when they were done."

Karen G on March 2024


Avatar for Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories, Inc

Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories, Inc

4.85(
347
)

Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories, Inc

4.85(
347
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers

ETR Laboratories in an analytic laboratory with a broad range of commercial, industrial and individual clients. We provide analytic services using a wide variety of scientific methods including GC/MS, IC/MS, GIR, NMR and SEM equipment. We can do particle analysis, organic and inorganic chemical analysis and micro analysis on biological and other materials. Private water analysis is our specialty. Award winning. Additional DBA - Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories Inc, ETR Labs, ETR Laboratories.

"as advertised"

Nancy C on July 2018

ETR Laboratories in an analytic laboratory with a broad range of commercial, industrial and individual clients. We provide analytic services using a wide variety of scientific methods including GC/MS, IC/MS, GIR, NMR and SEM equipment. We can do particle analysis, organic and inorganic chemical analysis and micro analysis on biological and other materials. Private water analysis is our specialty. Award winning. Additional DBA - Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories Inc, ETR Labs, ETR Laboratories.

"as advertised"

Nancy C on July 2018


Avatar for GENERAL BRICK DESIGNS

GENERAL BRICK DESIGNS

4.92(
174
)

GENERAL BRICK DESIGNS

4.92(
174
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers

Owner Eddie Costanzo is a unique combination of master stone mason and structural engineer. Licensed and insured and on every job. All of his employees have been with him for many years and are dedicated to keeping up the impeccable record with the Bureau of Consumer Affairs of not one complaint in all the years in business for over 25 years. Former Army Corp. of Engineers takes on the most challenging of building and structural problems as well as all stone and paver masonry that is done in a special way to have lasting beauty and no settling. Member of the BBB holding an A+ rating.

"From this site, I've learned that Eddie has passed away. Most sorry to hear. Unfortunately, he recently did some work (basement waterproofing which is failing). I see that Kastina z. and Jason L. have situations where they need to get in touch with someone. I would be willing to speak to either of you or others. Please let me know."

Peter M on April 2024

Owner Eddie Costanzo is a unique combination of master stone mason and structural engineer. Licensed and insured and on every job. All of his employees have been with him for many years and are dedicated to keeping up the impeccable record with the Bureau of Consumer Affairs of not one complaint in all the years in business for over 25 years. Former Army Corp. of Engineers takes on the most challenging of building and structural problems as well as all stone and paver masonry that is done in a special way to have lasting beauty and no settling. Member of the BBB holding an A+ rating.

"From this site, I've learned that Eddie has passed away. Most sorry to hear. Unfortunately, he recently did some work (basement waterproofing which is failing). I see that Kastina z. and Jason L. have situations where they need to get in touch with someone. I would be willing to speak to either of you or others. Please let me know."

Peter M on April 2024


Avatar for Piazza construction Co

Piazza construction Co

4.99(
104
)

Piazza construction Co

4.99(
104
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 99% of Angi customers
Recommended by 99% of HomeAdvisor customers

With over 20 years experience we know that home is where the heart is: and your project will be treated as such. Your home renovation will be handled with the same care, precision and quality as we would our own. Because renovating a home is a multifaceted task, we’ve built up a network of reputable contractors to aid us in our renovations and we hold them to the same standard of excellence. Give us a call for a free estimate today! For more pictures please visit us on Instagram @ Shawnpiazzaconstruction

"For the first time in a very long time, i can honestly say every dealing with Piazza construction was professional, honest, and very well done. When they said they would be here at 8, they were here at 7:55 and ready to go at 8. They worked hard, cleaned up well, were respectful, and went above and beyond to make the basement look amazing. the price was competitive and from start to finish, we kept remarking how for the first time, we are having a wonderful experience with our new one and only contractor!! We will definitely hire them again. When we asked for suggestions or advice, they were helpful, when we noticed something we might want to change, they were flexible, and most of all, they treated our house like their own."

Holly B on May 2020

With over 20 years experience we know that home is where the heart is: and your project will be treated as such. Your home renovation will be handled with the same care, precision and quality as we would our own. Because renovating a home is a multifaceted task, we’ve built up a network of reputable contractors to aid us in our renovations and we hold them to the same standard of excellence. Give us a call for a free estimate today! For more pictures please visit us on Instagram @ Shawnpiazzaconstruction

"For the first time in a very long time, i can honestly say every dealing with Piazza construction was professional, honest, and very well done. When they said they would be here at 8, they were here at 7:55 and ready to go at 8. They worked hard, cleaned up well, were respectful, and went above and beyond to make the basement look amazing. the price was competitive and from start to finish, we kept remarking how for the first time, we are having a wonderful experience with our new one and only contractor!! We will definitely hire them again. When we asked for suggestions or advice, they were helpful, when we noticed something we might want to change, they were flexible, and most of all, they treated our house like their own."

Holly B on May 2020


Avatar for Kevs Construction and Tile Works

Kevs Construction and Tile Works

4.97(
39
)

Kevs Construction and Tile Works

4.97(
39
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Pictures of previous projects and info on Angie's List profile page. Over 30 years experience in all phases of tile and construction and home remodeling. From small face lift jobs to ground up construction. Tile Re-grouts and sealing and all phases of kerdi drain systems and waterproofing membrane and schluter ditra uncoupling matting. *** Schluter systems certified Three times at their 3 day class seminars and hands on workshop!!!!!

"Kevin complete the job, was always on time and explained everything throughly. I’m a very satisfied with his work."

Nadine V on January 2025

Pictures of previous projects and info on Angie's List profile page. Over 30 years experience in all phases of tile and construction and home remodeling. From small face lift jobs to ground up construction. Tile Re-grouts and sealing and all phases of kerdi drain systems and waterproofing membrane and schluter ditra uncoupling matting. *** Schluter systems certified Three times at their 3 day class seminars and hands on workshop!!!!!

"Kevin complete the job, was always on time and explained everything throughly. I’m a very satisfied with his work."

Nadine V on January 2025


Avatar for ACA Electrical Contracting

ACA Electrical Contracting

4.95(
84
)

ACA Electrical Contracting

4.95(
84
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers

4-TIME ANGIE'S LIST SUPER SERVICE AWARD WINNER!! ACA Electric and Astrum Solar are teamed up to bring you huge savings on your electric bills for your home and work space ASK ABOUT OUR SOLAR installs and how we can make it work in your budget !!! ACA Electric is a privately owned business based in Babylon, NY serving the Nassau/ Suffolk area. All work is done in a clean professional manner, always on time, and offers the best pricing in the industry. ACA Electric will always leave your home or place of business clean and neat as the way we started the job. We offer clean and courteous service at all times. Although cost is determined by the job, we will meet your needs at all times. The biggest plus of ACA Electric is the fact that the owner, Alex, is always present on job sites making sure all work is done in a timely, professional manner and satisfying the customers needs. Video surveillance systems ● Recessed Lighting ● Troubleshooting ● Landscape Lighting ● TV and Appliance Installs ● New Homes Wired ● Service Upgrades ● Residential Lighting Maintenance ● Ceiling Fans/Attic Fans ● Pools and Hot Tubs

"ACA Electrical was recommended and they were excellent, after my original unreliable pool electrical company (Kel-Rob), I would never use Kel-Rob again."

J C on September 2021

4-TIME ANGIE'S LIST SUPER SERVICE AWARD WINNER!! ACA Electric and Astrum Solar are teamed up to bring you huge savings on your electric bills for your home and work space ASK ABOUT OUR SOLAR installs and how we can make it work in your budget !!! ACA Electric is a privately owned business based in Babylon, NY serving the Nassau/ Suffolk area. All work is done in a clean professional manner, always on time, and offers the best pricing in the industry. ACA Electric will always leave your home or place of business clean and neat as the way we started the job. We offer clean and courteous service at all times. Although cost is determined by the job, we will meet your needs at all times. The biggest plus of ACA Electric is the fact that the owner, Alex, is always present on job sites making sure all work is done in a timely, professional manner and satisfying the customers needs. Video surveillance systems ● Recessed Lighting ● Troubleshooting ● Landscape Lighting ● TV and Appliance Installs ● New Homes Wired ● Service Upgrades ● Residential Lighting Maintenance ● Ceiling Fans/Attic Fans ● Pools and Hot Tubs

"ACA Electrical was recommended and they were excellent, after my original unreliable pool electrical company (Kel-Rob), I would never use Kel-Rob again."

J C on September 2021

...
Showing 1-10 of 1434

FAQs for home building projects in Fishers Island, NY

One starting point to find a local home builder is to collect suggestions from friends and neighbors. However, it’s still wise to do some more research before you hire a builder. Read reviews to supplement any word-of-mouth recommendations. Check sources like Angi that have standards and criteria in place to screen the pros it lists can also help you find more reputable local home builders.

The pros and cons or advantages and disadvantages of building a new house include:

Pros:

  • It’s all new, so you should have several years before you need to pay for major repairs like a new roof. 

  • It’s under warranty, so many fixes within that warranty period should be covered.

  • You get to build the house to your specifications.

Cons:

  • You have to make a LOT of decisions.

  • You will almost certainly deal with building delays.

  • It can take a lot of work to stay within your budget.

  • Building can be more expensive than buying an existing house.

Typically, it’s more affordable to buy an existing home than it is to build a new one. New construction loan interest rates tend to be higher than interest rates for traditional mortgages. Additionally, the cost of materials is likely higher when building a new home than it was when an existing home was built (unless it’s a very new one). You’re also paying for all new appliances, finishes, permits, inspections, and connections for water, gas, and electricity. 

The average price per square foot to build a house is about $150 per square foot. Overall, the cost to build a house ranges anywhere from $100 to $500 per square foot, depending on where you build. The primary cost factors include location, size, and style of house you build.

Hiring a contractor to build your home is a big commitment. So be sure to ask as many questions up front as possible. Here are a few questions to ask a prospective home builder:

  • How many years of experience do you have?

  • Are you licensed, bonded, and insured?

  • Do you have worker’s compensation?

  • How long have you worked with your subcontractors?

  • How do you handle garbage and waste disposal?

  • Do you provide a guarantee or warranty on your work?

  • Do you give free estimates?

  • Do you offer design services?

  • How do you handle change orders?

  • Can you provide at least three references?

  • Can I see some of the work you’ve done?

The Fishers Island, NY homeowners’ guide to home building services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.