Top-rated water heater pros.

Get matched with top water heater pros in Henryville, IN

There are 5 highly-rated local water heater pros.

TRUSTED BY HENRYVILLE, IN HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.8
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon22
    Verified water heater services reviews

Find Water heater pros in Henryville

Avatar for Tom Drexler Plumbing Air & Electric

Tom Drexler Plumbing Air & Electric

3718 Bardstown Rd
4.21(
468
)
Approved Pro

Tom Drexler Plumbing Air & Electric

3718 Bardstown Rd
4.21(
468
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
956 local quotes requested
43 years of experience

Tom Drexler Plumbing, Air & Electric was founded in 1982 by 4th generation Master Plumber, Tom Drexler. We are now one the area's largest home service provider. We offer plumbing, heating and cooling, indoor air quality, electrical, and other home services. Our highly qualified & expertly trained employees can help with any home repair services you may need.

"I typically do not leave reviews, but my experience with Tom Drexler Plumbing was so poor that I feel compelled to share it in hopes of preventing others from wasting their time and money. I initially contacted the company to address a leaking faucet in a spare bathroom. I was given a vague appointment window of 8 AM to 5 PM and informed that if I didn’t answer a call prior to their arrival, the technician would not show up. When the technician arrived, he spent time criticizing the company’s hiring practices rather than focusing on the repair. He determined that a full tub and shower replacement was needed, quoting over $1,000. The work could not be done the same day, requiring me to schedule another appointment. The technician arrived late and took the entire day to complete the job, spending a significant portion of time sitting on my staircase visibly exhausted. The installation was subpar—both the faucet and showerhead were protruding nearly two inches from the wall, and the showerhead was visibly crooked. The faucet and showerhead were protruding so far out they couldn't even be caulked. My wife documented the issues with photos. She sent them to me after the tech left. I immediately called Tom Drexler, informed them of the subpar work, and requested a different technician to correct the poor workmanship. A new technician arrived the following week and made the necessary adjustments. However, within four days of using the shower, a leak developed in the ceiling of the kitchen below, and our toilet began leaking from the base when flushed—suggesting possible plumbing pressure or blockage issues. I contacted the company again and scheduled yet another appointment. Despite being given the same 8 AM to 5 PM time frame, no one showed up, and I had to follow up myself to learn the technician wasn’t coming. Eventually, another technician did visit and claimed the ceiling leak was due to "residual water" and dismissed the toilet issue. When the ceiling stain continued to grow, I called again and requested a supervisor. The supervisor came a week later, concluded that the issue wasn’t related to their work, and left without offering any solutions. Altogether, I had to take four days off work to accommodate this series of visits. I now need to hire another plumber from a different company to resolve the ongoing leak. Based on my experience, I cannot in good conscience recommend Tom Drexler Plumbing. The quality of work, communication, and overall customer service were consistently poor throughout the entire process."

Matt B on September 2025

Tom Drexler Plumbing, Air & Electric was founded in 1982 by 4th generation Master Plumber, Tom Drexler. We are now one the area's largest home service provider. We offer plumbing, heating and cooling, indoor air quality, electrical, and other home services. Our highly qualified & expertly trained employees can help with any home repair services you may need.

"I typically do not leave reviews, but my experience with Tom Drexler Plumbing was so poor that I feel compelled to share it in hopes of preventing others from wasting their time and money. I initially contacted the company to address a leaking faucet in a spare bathroom. I was given a vague appointment window of 8 AM to 5 PM and informed that if I didn’t answer a call prior to their arrival, the technician would not show up. When the technician arrived, he spent time criticizing the company’s hiring practices rather than focusing on the repair. He determined that a full tub and shower replacement was needed, quoting over $1,000. The work could not be done the same day, requiring me to schedule another appointment. The technician arrived late and took the entire day to complete the job, spending a significant portion of time sitting on my staircase visibly exhausted. The installation was subpar—both the faucet and showerhead were protruding nearly two inches from the wall, and the showerhead was visibly crooked. The faucet and showerhead were protruding so far out they couldn't even be caulked. My wife documented the issues with photos. She sent them to me after the tech left. I immediately called Tom Drexler, informed them of the subpar work, and requested a different technician to correct the poor workmanship. A new technician arrived the following week and made the necessary adjustments. However, within four days of using the shower, a leak developed in the ceiling of the kitchen below, and our toilet began leaking from the base when flushed—suggesting possible plumbing pressure or blockage issues. I contacted the company again and scheduled yet another appointment. Despite being given the same 8 AM to 5 PM time frame, no one showed up, and I had to follow up myself to learn the technician wasn’t coming. Eventually, another technician did visit and claimed the ceiling leak was due to "residual water" and dismissed the toilet issue. When the ceiling stain continued to grow, I called again and requested a supervisor. The supervisor came a week later, concluded that the issue wasn’t related to their work, and left without offering any solutions. Altogether, I had to take four days off work to accommodate this series of visits. I now need to hire another plumber from a different company to resolve the ongoing leak. Based on my experience, I cannot in good conscience recommend Tom Drexler Plumbing. The quality of work, communication, and overall customer service were consistently poor throughout the entire process."

Matt B on September 2025


Avatar for Dauenhauer Plumbing

Dauenhauer Plumbing

3416 Robards Ct
4.64(
621
)
Approved Pro

Dauenhauer Plumbing

3416 Robards Ct
4.64(
621
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers
163 local quotes requested

At Dauenhauer Plumbing, Heating, Air, and Electric, our skilled, licensed technicians will provide you with efficient, professional home services. Our friendly customer service staff will make every effort to get your problem taken care of fast, even on nights and weekends. From sump pumps and HVAC systems to drain cleanings and generators, our team takes pride in offering the area’s best customer experience. Additional DBA - Anytime Plumbing.

"Job completed"

Lee W on January 2025

At Dauenhauer Plumbing, Heating, Air, and Electric, our skilled, licensed technicians will provide you with efficient, professional home services. Our friendly customer service staff will make every effort to get your problem taken care of fast, even on nights and weekends. From sump pumps and HVAC systems to drain cleanings and generators, our team takes pride in offering the area’s best customer experience. Additional DBA - Anytime Plumbing.

"Job completed"

Lee W on January 2025


Avatar for Greenwell Plumbing Heating & Air

Greenwell Plumbing Heating & Air

1840 Scott Rd
4.50(
100
)
Approved Pro

Greenwell Plumbing Heating & Air

1840 Scott Rd
4.50(
100
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
246 local quotes requested
31 years of experience

We're your neighborhood plumbing, heating, and air company. We've been providing "Simply Dependable" services in Southern Indiana since 1972. We can take care of all your plumbing and HVAC needs, 24 hours a day, when you need us we will be there!!! We are proud of our service tech's and do monthly training and product awareness with our service team. Tech's are clean, drug-tested, and uniformed, we use shoe covers and floor runners when working on your home. We clean up after every job.

"They got the old sump pump removed and installed the new one. They even disposed of the old stuff which I greatly appreciated. They were wonderful and would call on Greenwell Plumbing again."

Sharon J on May 2025

We're your neighborhood plumbing, heating, and air company. We've been providing "Simply Dependable" services in Southern Indiana since 1972. We can take care of all your plumbing and HVAC needs, 24 hours a day, when you need us we will be there!!! We are proud of our service tech's and do monthly training and product awareness with our service team. Tech's are clean, drug-tested, and uniformed, we use shoe covers and floor runners when working on your home. We clean up after every job.

"They got the old sump pump removed and installed the new one. They even disposed of the old stuff which I greatly appreciated. They were wonderful and would call on Greenwell Plumbing again."

Sharon J on May 2025


Avatar for ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

Headquarters: 4580 Bridgeway Avenue
4.46(
320
)
Approved Pro

ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

Headquarters: 4580 Bridgeway Avenue
4.46(
320
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
1683 local quotes requested
36 years of experience

Since 1989, ImproveIt Home Remodeling, Inc., has specialized in helping homeowners improve the beauty, comfort and energy-efficiency of their homes. Our mission is simple: to provide each and every homeowner complete satisfaction through every step of the remodeling process. We don't just stand behind our work with lifetime product and labor warranties; we strive to deliver total satisfaction and complete peace-of-mind. During our 29 years, we are honored to have been named one of the top 50 remodelers by Remodeling Magazine, and to have won 21 Consumers Choice Awards. BBB accredited with an A+ Rating, we have helped over 50,000 customers. We serve communities across Central Ohio (Columbus, Dayton and Cincinnati) and Kentucky (Louisville and Lexington). Choose Improveit Home Remodeling to transform your bathroom or save on high utility bills with our Energy-star rated SolarTech replacement windows.

"I won't use them again. Took me too the cleaners price wise. The guy doing the work couldn't believe the price. "

William S on November 2025

Since 1989, ImproveIt Home Remodeling, Inc., has specialized in helping homeowners improve the beauty, comfort and energy-efficiency of their homes. Our mission is simple: to provide each and every homeowner complete satisfaction through every step of the remodeling process. We don't just stand behind our work with lifetime product and labor warranties; we strive to deliver total satisfaction and complete peace-of-mind. During our 29 years, we are honored to have been named one of the top 50 remodelers by Remodeling Magazine, and to have won 21 Consumers Choice Awards. BBB accredited with an A+ Rating, we have helped over 50,000 customers. We serve communities across Central Ohio (Columbus, Dayton and Cincinnati) and Kentucky (Louisville and Lexington). Choose Improveit Home Remodeling to transform your bathroom or save on high utility bills with our Energy-star rated SolarTech replacement windows.

"I won't use them again. Took me too the cleaners price wise. The guy doing the work couldn't believe the price. "

William S on November 2025


Milburn Mechanical Services, LLC

3209 W County Rd 850 S
5.00(
2
)
Approved Pro

Milburn Mechanical Services, LLC

3209 W County Rd 850 S
5.00(
2
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
14 local quotes requested
6 years of experience

At Milburn Mechanical Services LLC, we are your premier choice for all you HVAC needs. We have provided high quality work and friendly customer service for years. Choose the best not the rest. We will not let you down. Great work at a great price. A+ quality. Call today!

"Good quality work and very professional!"

Jeff W on November 2021

At Milburn Mechanical Services LLC, we are your premier choice for all you HVAC needs. We have provided high quality work and friendly customer service for years. Choose the best not the rest. We will not let you down. Great work at a great price. A+ quality. Call today!

"Good quality work and very professional!"

Jeff W on November 2021


Avatar for Infinity Design & Construction Group INC

Infinity Design & Construction Group INC

11605 Shelbyville Rd. Louisville Ky
No reviews yet

Infinity Design & Construction Group INC

11605 Shelbyville Rd. Louisville Ky
No reviews yet
12 years of experience

In Business Since 2013 Free Estimates with a Trip Charge for Any Service Completed We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job. How We Got Started We started in this industry in 2013. We describe our business as Well established

In Business Since 2013 Free Estimates with a Trip Charge for Any Service Completed We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job. How We Got Started We started in this industry in 2013. We describe our business as Well established


Avatar for Chads plumbing

Chads plumbing

Pirate Place
No reviews yet

Chads plumbing

Pirate Place
No reviews yet
5 years of experience

Licensed plumber and I Specialize in service plumbing including, faucet installs or fixes, shower installs or fixes, shower installs or repairs, water heater installs or repairs, toilet installs or repairs, and leaking water services

Licensed plumber and I Specialize in service plumbing including, faucet installs or fixes, shower installs or fixes, shower installs or repairs, water heater installs or repairs, toilet installs or repairs, and leaking water services


Avatar for 1-Tom-Plumber - Louisville

1-Tom-Plumber - Louisville

121 S. New Albany St.
5.00(
2
)

1-Tom-Plumber - Louisville

121 S. New Albany St.
5.00(
2
)
Customers say: Quick response
3 years of experience

We're the Plumber Louisville Trusts! The professionals at 1-Tom-Plumber Louisville understands that when you have an emergency plumbing or drain problem, you need help fast. It could be any time of day or night, even a holiday. That's why our team only includes experienced, certified, and customer focused plumbers, drain specialists, and excavators. We are trusted by Louisville area residents and businesses because we back our work and serve your plumbing needs, not ours.

"Excellent. First time to use the company and they did a great job from the 1st call till the end of the job."

Carrie L on October 2023

We're the Plumber Louisville Trusts! The professionals at 1-Tom-Plumber Louisville understands that when you have an emergency plumbing or drain problem, you need help fast. It could be any time of day or night, even a holiday. That's why our team only includes experienced, certified, and customer focused plumbers, drain specialists, and excavators. We are trusted by Louisville area residents and businesses because we back our work and serve your plumbing needs, not ours.

"Excellent. First time to use the company and they did a great job from the 1st call till the end of the job."

Carrie L on October 2023


Avatar for Plumbing Inspection & Repair Bedford KY

Plumbing Inspection & Repair Bedford KY

920 Wises Landing Rd
No reviews yet

Plumbing Inspection & Repair Bedford KY

920 Wises Landing Rd
No reviews yet
Free onsite estimate

Welcome To Plumbing Inspection & Repair Bedford KY. If you have any Issues about Plumbing OR you have any Issues about your Heating or Cooling System? Our Technicians fix all Problems. We take pride providing customer satisfaction and quality. We are a complete plumbing service company that has been around for more than a decade. Our growth has been massive over the years because our services and staff is can’t be compared to any other company. We have a trained team of professionals that specialize in all sorts of plumbing services and HVAC for both residential and commercial needs. Our services include: drain cleaning, sewer, garbage disposal replacement, clogged kitchen sink, faucet replacement, home stoppage, back flow tests, Heating And Cooling, Heating And Cooling Services, Air Conditioning Service, bathroom remodeling and much more! We Offer these services 24-hour plumbing & HVAC Service, line and leak detection, garbage disposer repair, water supply line replacement / repair, dishwashers and ice maker water lines, heating & cooling any issues. Emergency service is our specialty. Complete Residential & Commercial Plumbing & HVAC Services, Local Plumbing, Local Seattle Plumbing Company, Plumbing, Kitchen, Bathroom Plumbing, HVAC and other all type plumbing & HVAC services, plumbing repair, residential plumbing, commercial plumbing, bathroom plumbing solutions, trench less sewer line repair and replacement, pipe bursting, pipe relining, kitchen plumbing jobs, sink plumbing, toilet repair / replacement, water heaters, sump pumps, faucet replacement, video camera pipe inspections, back flow certification and repairs, Plumbers, Plumbing, Plumbing drain & sewer cleaning, Plumbing contractors commercial industrial, Fire water damage restoration, Water heater repair, Sewer cleaners & repairers All of our plumbers are licensed, professional and reliable. We provide estimates for every project and we offer guarantees on all of our work. Call us any time on 5027713702

Welcome To Plumbing Inspection & Repair Bedford KY. If you have any Issues about Plumbing OR you have any Issues about your Heating or Cooling System? Our Technicians fix all Problems. We take pride providing customer satisfaction and quality. We are a complete plumbing service company that has been around for more than a decade. Our growth has been massive over the years because our services and staff is can’t be compared to any other company. We have a trained team of professionals that specialize in all sorts of plumbing services and HVAC for both residential and commercial needs. Our services include: drain cleaning, sewer, garbage disposal replacement, clogged kitchen sink, faucet replacement, home stoppage, back flow tests, Heating And Cooling, Heating And Cooling Services, Air Conditioning Service, bathroom remodeling and much more! We Offer these services 24-hour plumbing & HVAC Service, line and leak detection, garbage disposer repair, water supply line replacement / repair, dishwashers and ice maker water lines, heating & cooling any issues. Emergency service is our specialty. Complete Residential & Commercial Plumbing & HVAC Services, Local Plumbing, Local Seattle Plumbing Company, Plumbing, Kitchen, Bathroom Plumbing, HVAC and other all type plumbing & HVAC services, plumbing repair, residential plumbing, commercial plumbing, bathroom plumbing solutions, trench less sewer line repair and replacement, pipe bursting, pipe relining, kitchen plumbing jobs, sink plumbing, toilet repair / replacement, water heaters, sump pumps, faucet replacement, video camera pipe inspections, back flow certification and repairs, Plumbers, Plumbing, Plumbing drain & sewer cleaning, Plumbing contractors commercial industrial, Fire water damage restoration, Water heater repair, Sewer cleaners & repairers All of our plumbers are licensed, professional and reliable. We provide estimates for every project and we offer guarantees on all of our work. Call us any time on 5027713702


Owens Construction & Remodeling

No reviews yet

Owens Construction & Remodeling

No reviews yet
15 years of experience

Owens Construction is a locally owned company based out of Louisville, KY. We will help you out with remodeling, renovating, additions, as well as new construction.Specializing in kitchen, bathrooms, basements and much more. We offer FREE ESTIMATES and would love the opportunity to provide you with a quote. We also offer referral recommendation of $100 to anybody that refers Owens Construction and we get the job.

Owens Construction is a locally owned company based out of Louisville, KY. We will help you out with remodeling, renovating, additions, as well as new construction.Specializing in kitchen, bathrooms, basements and much more. We offer FREE ESTIMATES and would love the opportunity to provide you with a quote. We also offer referral recommendation of $100 to anybody that refers Owens Construction and we get the job.

...
Showing 1-10 of 95
Water Heaters questions, answered by experts

Unless they are connected to the same system, boilers and water heaters will both need their own expansion tanks. The only case they wouldn’t have separate expansion tanks is if the boiler is pulling double duty and managing a heating system while also supplying hot water for a home. In which case, you may not need a hot water heater.

The cost to install a new water heater depends on the type and its size, but homeowners pay between $900 and $1,800 on average. By contrast, you’ll pay much less for certain repairs, like replacing a broken gas valve, which costs between $150 and $550 on average.

Professional installs conclude in mere hours, with complexity differences possibly prolonging efforts slightly. Site condition often dictates the exact duration.

Excessive pressure (above 80 psi) puts too much stress on plumbing pipes, joints, and fixtures. This can lead to leaks and burst pipes. Plus, it shortens the lifespan of appliances, can waste water, and can raise your utility bills. High water pressure might feel like a gift, but it’s actually a silent threat to plumbing.

Every type of water heater has its advantages and disadvantages. Understanding those can help you decide the best type for your situation and budget. 

Pros

  • Safer than gas or propane

  • Doesn’t require extensive venting systems

  • Lower upfront costs

  • Simpler to operate

  • No pilot light

  • Easier installation

  • More efficient heating than gas models

  • Available as point-of-use (POU) and whole-house units

Cons

  • Slower to heat water

  • Longer recovery time

  • Possibly higher operating costs

  • Doesn’t work during a power outage

  • Costs can increase without a 240-volt connection

The Henryville, IN homeowners’ guide to water heater services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.