Top-rated garbage disposal repair pros.

Get matched with top garbage disposal repair pros in New Straitsville, OH

There are 3 highly-rated local garbage disposal repair pros.

Need a pro for your garbage and waste removal and hauling project in New Straitsville, OH?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY NEW STRAITSVILLE, OH HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.6
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon71
    Verified garbage disposal repair services reviews

Find Garbage disposal repair pros in New Straitsville

Avatar for Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Columbus

Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Columbus

405 N Brice Rd
4.46(
403
)
Approved Pro

Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Columbus

405 N Brice Rd
4.46(
403
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
473 local quotes requested
31 years of experience

At Mr. Rooter Plumbing every customer’s individual needs are important. Whether it’s a simple sink clog or a damaged sewer line, you can count on a Mr. Rooter plumber to take care of your plumbing needs day or night with never an overtime charge. Our professional service, quality products and honest, up-front pricing make Mr. Rooter the best value in plumbing services nationwide. Mr. Rooter is ready for all emergency plumbing issues, from clogged drains and sewage backups to frozen pipes and leaking water heaters. You can count on an expert diagnosis from Mr. Rooter with our camera inspection tools. Then we’ll fix it right the first time, whether it takes HydroScrub drain cleaning or trenchless pipe repair, with courteous smiles on our faces.

"Everything was done professionally. He wore booties in the house to reduce dirt, moved all my under counter things out of the way, and didn’t waste time. He was efficient and kind."

Michelle B on August 2025

At Mr. Rooter Plumbing every customer’s individual needs are important. Whether it’s a simple sink clog or a damaged sewer line, you can count on a Mr. Rooter plumber to take care of your plumbing needs day or night with never an overtime charge. Our professional service, quality products and honest, up-front pricing make Mr. Rooter the best value in plumbing services nationwide. Mr. Rooter is ready for all emergency plumbing issues, from clogged drains and sewage backups to frozen pipes and leaking water heaters. You can count on an expert diagnosis from Mr. Rooter with our camera inspection tools. Then we’ll fix it right the first time, whether it takes HydroScrub drain cleaning or trenchless pipe repair, with courteous smiles on our faces.

"Everything was done professionally. He wore booties in the house to reduce dirt, moved all my under counter things out of the way, and didn’t waste time. He was efficient and kind."

Michelle B on August 2025


Avatar for Drains & Excavation Services

Drains & Excavation Services

14941 Regal Rd
5.00(
6
)
Approved Pro

Drains & Excavation Services

14941 Regal Rd
5.00(
6
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
38 local quotes requested

With over 10 years of experience we can take care of all your excavation/outdoor plumbing needs! Call us today for a free quote!! We will guarantee customer satisfaction and worry free warranties.

"You will not find a nicer group of guys! They do great work for a great price! 10 out of 10 would recommend!"

Dylan C on July 2021

With over 10 years of experience we can take care of all your excavation/outdoor plumbing needs! Call us today for a free quote!! We will guarantee customer satisfaction and worry free warranties.

"You will not find a nicer group of guys! They do great work for a great price! 10 out of 10 would recommend!"

Dylan C on July 2021


Avatar for J&H Excavating, LLC

J&H Excavating, LLC

Located In:
4.80(
5
)
Approved Pro

J&H Excavating, LLC

Located In:
4.80(
5
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
39 local quotes requested

We specialize in excavating services. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"He was very trustworthy. He was there when he said that he would be. He did exactly what I asked him to do. He also gave his input and he was a really really good guy. He had a reasonable price as well."

Sheri N on April 2023

We specialize in excavating services. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"He was very trustworthy. He was there when he said that he would be. He did exactly what I asked him to do. He also gave his input and he was a really really good guy. He had a reasonable price as well."

Sheri N on April 2023


Avatar for Greene's Plumbing Services

Greene's Plumbing Services

1653 Township Rd 320 SE
5.00(
25
)
Approved Pro

Greene's Plumbing Services

1653 Township Rd 320 SE
5.00(
25
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
38 local quotes requested

Welcome to Greene’s Plumbing, proudly servicing Columbus and the surrounding areas. Our goal is to complete your project to perfection. Our focus is building long lasting relationships with the customers that we serve. We look forward to serving you. Call us today! You will not be disappointed.

"The service was outstanding. Matt was very professional at all times and took the time to explain in detail all the services being completed. He also completed some extra work on a water softer tank that I asked about after his arrival. I compared prices with other companies and Greene's was cheaper, but the work and time put into this service call was way above my expectations. I highly recommend this company and if Matt is your tech, feel free to ask any questions he will not make you feel like a dummy:-)"

Albert M on September 2025

Welcome to Greene’s Plumbing, proudly servicing Columbus and the surrounding areas. Our goal is to complete your project to perfection. Our focus is building long lasting relationships with the customers that we serve. We look forward to serving you. Call us today! You will not be disappointed.

"The service was outstanding. Matt was very professional at all times and took the time to explain in detail all the services being completed. He also completed some extra work on a water softer tank that I asked about after his arrival. I compared prices with other companies and Greene's was cheaper, but the work and time put into this service call was way above my expectations. I highly recommend this company and if Matt is your tech, feel free to ask any questions he will not make you feel like a dummy:-)"

Albert M on September 2025


Avatar for John Peters Plumbing & Heating

John Peters Plumbing & Heating

29064 Enterprise Iles Rd
4.58(
19
)
Approved Pro

John Peters Plumbing & Heating

29064 Enterprise Iles Rd
4.58(
19
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
14 local quotes requested
47 years of experience

Homeowners and businesses in Logan, Ohio, and throughout Greater Fairfield County rely on the trusted service of John Peters Plumbing and Heating. Family-owned since 1978, John Peters Plumbing and Heating provides same-day response, uniformed personnel, and 24-hour emergency service for all residential customers and commercial businesses. Our employees are fully insured, and we use cell phone dispatched trucks to get to your needs as quickly as possible. We proudly serve customers throughout Logan, Ohio, and all of Greater Fairfield County.

"The service was great, it was excellent, he's always on time and efficient. It was John who actually comes to do do the work himself."

TERRY P on June 2021

Homeowners and businesses in Logan, Ohio, and throughout Greater Fairfield County rely on the trusted service of John Peters Plumbing and Heating. Family-owned since 1978, John Peters Plumbing and Heating provides same-day response, uniformed personnel, and 24-hour emergency service for all residential customers and commercial businesses. Our employees are fully insured, and we use cell phone dispatched trucks to get to your needs as quickly as possible. We proudly serve customers throughout Logan, Ohio, and all of Greater Fairfield County.

"The service was great, it was excellent, he's always on time and efficient. It was John who actually comes to do do the work himself."

TERRY P on June 2021


Avatar for Neli Virtual Appliance Repair

Neli Virtual Appliance Repair

143 Charlotte Ave
4.29(
575
)
Approved Pro

Neli Virtual Appliance Repair

143 Charlotte Ave
4.29(
575
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
33429 local quotes requested
9 years of experience

NEW! Appliance Consultation – Just $35 Get expert advice before you spend on repairs or replacements. A Neli technician will evaluate your issue and help you decide if your appliance can be fixed—or if it’s time for a new one. Virtual Appliance Diagnosis and Repair - Just $45 Service Description: Diagnose or repair your appliance virtually—no need for anyone to enter your home. Neli’s certified technicians guide you step-by-step via secure video chat. How It Works: Book online at nelihome.com or call 833-876-0900 Connect with a tech through our video platform Diagnose or fix the issue in real time Get expert advice and confidence in your next steps What’s Included: Real-time video guidance from a certified technician Diagnosis of the issue OR full repair (when possible) Step-by-step guidance using your smartphone or tablet Safe, contact-free service - no one in your home Flexible scheduling—appointments available daily Perfect For: Appliance fixes HVAC troubleshooting DIY-savvy homeowners Saving time and money on service calls

"Great! Punctual easy to work with cleaned up area when done"

Kay J on September 2025

NEW! Appliance Consultation – Just $35 Get expert advice before you spend on repairs or replacements. A Neli technician will evaluate your issue and help you decide if your appliance can be fixed—or if it’s time for a new one. Virtual Appliance Diagnosis and Repair - Just $45 Service Description: Diagnose or repair your appliance virtually—no need for anyone to enter your home. Neli’s certified technicians guide you step-by-step via secure video chat. How It Works: Book online at nelihome.com or call 833-876-0900 Connect with a tech through our video platform Diagnose or fix the issue in real time Get expert advice and confidence in your next steps What’s Included: Real-time video guidance from a certified technician Diagnosis of the issue OR full repair (when possible) Step-by-step guidance using your smartphone or tablet Safe, contact-free service - no one in your home Flexible scheduling—appointments available daily Perfect For: Appliance fixes HVAC troubleshooting DIY-savvy homeowners Saving time and money on service calls

"Great! Punctual easy to work with cleaned up area when done"

Kay J on September 2025


West Shore Home Columbus

4744 Bridgeway Avenue
New on AngiNew on Angi
Approved Pro

West Shore Home Columbus

4744 Bridgeway Avenue
New on AngiNew on Angi
Approved Pro
279 local quotes requested
19 years of experience

To accomplish our mission, we have implemented a simple approach that will restore the beauty of your home while significantly reducing your energy bills - and we get it done in just one day! From start to finish, the West Shore Window & Door, Inc., experience is engineered to bring happiness to every home. The health and safety of our customers and employees is a top priority. Our team is following all CDC guidelines so we can provide you with the fast and convenient home improvements. We are also offering free virtual design consultations! Schedule your free consultation today.

To accomplish our mission, we have implemented a simple approach that will restore the beauty of your home while significantly reducing your energy bills - and we get it done in just one day! From start to finish, the West Shore Window & Door, Inc., experience is engineered to bring happiness to every home. The health and safety of our customers and employees is a top priority. Our team is following all CDC guidelines so we can provide you with the fast and convenient home improvements. We are also offering free virtual design consultations! Schedule your free consultation today.


Avatar for Xcellent Renovations

Xcellent Renovations

1879 Seasprite Dr.
4.87(
58
)
Approved Pro

Xcellent Renovations

1879 Seasprite Dr.
4.87(
58
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
20 local quotes requested
11 years of experience

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, pricing and quality work. We strongly believe in giving our absolute best in all of our projects no matter how big or small. Therefore, we are very informative when it comes to helping our customers. We are experts in our trade with over a decade of experience. Our customers come first so we pay strong attention to each project needs. Service with a smile. Give us a call! We look forward to earning your business!

"Xavier completed the installation and fully tested the system with me there to observe to confirm operation of my existing sump pump and the new battery back up pump. While there he troubleshot a check valve problem that was discovered during testing and installed new check valves with no up charge from his quoted price."

David D on August 2025

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, pricing and quality work. We strongly believe in giving our absolute best in all of our projects no matter how big or small. Therefore, we are very informative when it comes to helping our customers. We are experts in our trade with over a decade of experience. Our customers come first so we pay strong attention to each project needs. Service with a smile. Give us a call! We look forward to earning your business!

"Xavier completed the installation and fully tested the system with me there to observe to confirm operation of my existing sump pump and the new battery back up pump. While there he troubleshot a check valve problem that was discovered during testing and installed new check valves with no up charge from his quoted price."

David D on August 2025


Avatar for The Basement Doctor

The Basement Doctor

4400 Easton Commons, Suite 250
5.00(
5
)
Approved Pro

The Basement Doctor

4400 Easton Commons, Suite 250
5.00(
5
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
56 local quotes requested
38 years of experience

PROUDLY SERVING THE COLUMBUS AREA SINCE 1987 The Basement Doctor has delivered quality services, exceptional results, and the most competitive prices to homeowners in Ohio. With more than three decades of experience, you can trust our waterproofing team of experts to handle your next home repair project as quickly and efficiently as possible. We understand your home is one of your biggest investments. When you need to make improvements or repairs, you don’t want to deal with a company that cuts corners. Luckily, we have three decades of satisfied customers. Additionally, we have certified installers who deliver dependable basement waterproofing, foundation repair, and crawl space encapsulation services. Lastly, we use the best products, which last longer and provide permanent solutions to your home problems. Our goal has always been to provide Ohio homeowners with a drier, cleaner, healthier, safer, and more energy-efficient place to live.

"They did a great job. Thank you Basement Dr"

Tina D on April 2025

PROUDLY SERVING THE COLUMBUS AREA SINCE 1987 The Basement Doctor has delivered quality services, exceptional results, and the most competitive prices to homeowners in Ohio. With more than three decades of experience, you can trust our waterproofing team of experts to handle your next home repair project as quickly and efficiently as possible. We understand your home is one of your biggest investments. When you need to make improvements or repairs, you don’t want to deal with a company that cuts corners. Luckily, we have three decades of satisfied customers. Additionally, we have certified installers who deliver dependable basement waterproofing, foundation repair, and crawl space encapsulation services. Lastly, we use the best products, which last longer and provide permanent solutions to your home problems. Our goal has always been to provide Ohio homeowners with a drier, cleaner, healthier, safer, and more energy-efficient place to live.

"They did a great job. Thank you Basement Dr"

Tina D on April 2025


Avatar for ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

Headquarters: 4580 Bridgeway Avenue
4.47(
319
)
Approved Pro

ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

Headquarters: 4580 Bridgeway Avenue
4.47(
319
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
1617 local quotes requested
36 years of experience

Since 1989, ImproveIt Home Remodeling, Inc., has specialized in helping homeowners improve the beauty, comfort and energy-efficiency of their homes. Our mission is simple: to provide each and every homeowner complete satisfaction through every step of the remodeling process. We don't just stand behind our work with lifetime product and labor warranties; we strive to deliver total satisfaction and complete peace-of-mind. During our 29 years, we are honored to have been named one of the top 50 remodelers by Remodeling Magazine, and to have won 21 Consumers Choice Awards. BBB accredited with an A+ Rating, we have helped over 50,000 customers. We serve communities across Central Ohio (Columbus, Dayton and Cincinnati) and Kentucky (Louisville and Lexington). Choose Improveit Home Remodeling to transform your bathroom or save on high utility bills with our Energy-star rated SolarTech replacement windows.

"They claimed that they were finished and left nails sticking out of the wall. When I tried to call the supervisor I found out that the number was not connected. This is good customer service? I now realize that I paid to much for the sloppy work."

Sherri M on August 2025

Since 1989, ImproveIt Home Remodeling, Inc., has specialized in helping homeowners improve the beauty, comfort and energy-efficiency of their homes. Our mission is simple: to provide each and every homeowner complete satisfaction through every step of the remodeling process. We don't just stand behind our work with lifetime product and labor warranties; we strive to deliver total satisfaction and complete peace-of-mind. During our 29 years, we are honored to have been named one of the top 50 remodelers by Remodeling Magazine, and to have won 21 Consumers Choice Awards. BBB accredited with an A+ Rating, we have helped over 50,000 customers. We serve communities across Central Ohio (Columbus, Dayton and Cincinnati) and Kentucky (Louisville and Lexington). Choose Improveit Home Remodeling to transform your bathroom or save on high utility bills with our Energy-star rated SolarTech replacement windows.

"They claimed that they were finished and left nails sticking out of the wall. When I tried to call the supervisor I found out that the number was not connected. This is good customer service? I now realize that I paid to much for the sloppy work."

Sherri M on August 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 125
Garbage Disposal Repair questions, answered by experts

Once you have your garbage disposal disconnected, you can remove the mounting bracket by unscrewing the bolts that are holding the bracket. You can back them out just enough to pop off the snap ring, which prevents the bottom portion of the bracket from disconnecting from the top when you unscrew the bolts. Use a regular screwdriver to pop off the snap ring, and the rest of the components should fall off by themselves.

Garbage disposals are durable appliances that usually last at least eight years as long as you clean and maintain them. It’s relatively rare for a garbage disposal to break on its own, as most malfunctions happen due to user errors, like overstuffing the grinding compartment or damaging the blades by trying to dispose of metal or bone. Eventually, cracks or leaks could develop in the unit, which requires a full replacement. 

Replacing a garbage disposal costs anywhere from $150 to $950, but the average cost is somewhere around $550. There are two types of garbage disposal units, and continuous feed disposals tend to cost more than batch feed disposals. Going for an aluminum garbage disposal is also significantly cheaper than choosing a stainless steel garbage disposal. You'll also need to factor in the horsepower of the motor, labor, and the removal and disposal of your old unit.

There are many maintenance and repair issues that lead to a malfunctioning garbage disposal. Regular clogs place wear and tear on the motors, leading to an eventual shutdown. Electrical issues at the breaker, wall outlet, or disposal itself can fry the unit. The most common cause is simply a worn-down motor. These motors can only handle so much use before powering down for good. 

Whether you choose to repair your garbage disposal will depend on the problem. For minor issues like a bad seal, you can fix the unit for less than $10. If the motor unit is broken, which can easily cost $150, you may want to consider replacing the entire disposal if it’s getting on in years. 

By submitting this question, I acknowledge and agree that Angi may publicly display my name, city, state, and question on the website for professionals and others to see.

The New Straitsville, OH homeowners’ guide to garbage disposal repair services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.