4.5 
108 *The Angi rating for Bathtub Replacement companies in New Madison, OH is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Bathtub Replacement needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Bathtub Replacement companies in New Madison, OH is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Bathtub Replacement needs.
Last update on September 20, 2026
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 1992
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"Very good. Bathtub looks like new."
+9
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved (Corporate)
In business since 2005
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"Very nice bathtub, deeper than most tubs, water stays warm because bathtub is insulated. Nice looking wall built to frame bathtub. I am very pleased with the salesman, Stryker, and the company definitely aims to please. They did a great job."
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved (Corporate)
In business since 2006
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"Taylor R and Ethan W did a fantastic job replacing our shower today. They were extremely professional! Besides being concerned that what they did would serve our purposes, they were so careful with the entire house. The area was very clean and instructions were very thorough. Thanks Taylor and Ethan!"
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2022
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"We had our shower area replaced and the install took 1 day. The team was very knowledgeable and helpful and the shower was customized to my liking!! Would highly recommend !!"
+26
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2001
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"We replaced our bathtub with a walk in shower, and are extremely happy with the work that was provided. In only took one person 6 hours to complete the job, and he was very professional and the quality of work was great. Would hire them again."
+20
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2011
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"Rob did a great job on our project. He remained flexible and helped walk us through the kind of surround we would need to convert our tub into a tub shower combo."
+349
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 1989
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"The new tub and walls are a dream. Soaker tub installed and this is the 2nd bathtub installed by this company. Will use them for other projects in the near future. Thank you for a fantastic job"
+23
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2025
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
Covenant Waterworks can take care of all of your residential, commercial, and industrial plumbing needs. We are focused on providing the highest quality work that shows our commitment to honesty, integrity, and love for God and His kingdom.\n
+3
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved (Corporate)
In business since 2014
Free estimates
Warranties offered
At Otterly Baths, we're a locally rooted, veteran-owned company built on trust. We know most homeowners have at least one renovation horror story, from disappearing contractors to crews who treat your home like just another job site. That's just not how we do things. From your first consultation to the final walkthrough, we show up on time, communicate clearly, and treat your home with the respect it deserves every step of the way. \n \nAs we've grown to serve more communities across three states, our focus hasn't changed. Every Otterly location is locally operated by people who live and work in the same neighborhoods we serve. That means you get the best of both worlds: the reliability and resources of a larger company, with the personal care and accountability of a local team. Because remodels don't have to be stressful. With the right team, they can even be fun.
Serving New Madison, OH and surrounding areas
Approved (Corporate)
In business since 1929
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"The sales agent never when presenting his product, never showed me different prices of walk in tubs, but just quoted me their highest prices. Then when I asked about different price in the tub, he showed me a pic of 1 and told me to take a picture of it, never talked about the qualities or anything concerning it."
+8
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
An updated bathtub can give a bathroom a whole new look. Find out how much it costs to replace a bathtub, including prices by type and labor costs.
We’ll cover the cost of replacing a shower or bathtub drain, whether you can tackle this repair yourself, and what other projects to consider along the way.
Do plumbers install bathtubs? Here’s a guide to what kind of professional you should hire to install your new tub.
From whirlpool tubs to bathtubs that are freestanding to gorgeous cast iron clawfoot tubs, consider a luxury tub the statement piece of your bathroom.
How long do bathtubs last? A bathtub’s lifespan depends on the materials, so choose wisely if you want the tub to stick with you for a decade or more.
Looking to refresh that old tub and breathe new life into your bathroom? Learn how to hire a bathtub installation pro for the best results.
