Top-rated fencing pros.

Get matched with top fencing pros in Water Mill, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your fencing service project in Water Mill, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY WATER MILL, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.6
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon111
    Verified fencing services reviews

Find Fencing pros in Water Mill

Avatar for Performance Fence

Performance Fence

4.92(
59
)
•Approved Pro

Performance Fence

4.92(
59
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
16 years of experience

Call Jack today for a free estimate at 631-406-6139. Paying great attention to detail throughout the entire process from the initial meeting to the finished product, we give every job our full attention regardless of size. We deliver what we promise and aim to be easy to work with. What we promise is beautiful, long lasting fence installed with you in mind. Whatever your needs - you can depend on Performance Fence for quality workmanship at a competitive price with an emphasis on timely delivery and customer satisfaction.

"Jack was very responsive, he gave me estimate on the same day that I had contacted him. Excellent pricing, workmanship as well. Highly recommend!"

Robert V on October 2025

Call Jack today for a free estimate at 631-406-6139. Paying great attention to detail throughout the entire process from the initial meeting to the finished product, we give every job our full attention regardless of size. We deliver what we promise and aim to be easy to work with. What we promise is beautiful, long lasting fence installed with you in mind. Whatever your needs - you can depend on Performance Fence for quality workmanship at a competitive price with an emphasis on timely delivery and customer satisfaction.

"Jack was very responsive, he gave me estimate on the same day that I had contacted him. Excellent pricing, workmanship as well. Highly recommend!"

Robert V on October 2025

Avatar for Precision Fence Co

Precision Fence Co

4.87(
141
)
•Approved Pro

Precision Fence Co

4.87(
141
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
21 years of experience

Precision Fence Co is your trusted partner for all your fencing needs in the New York City (Tri-State Area). With our expertise and attention to detail, we deliver top-notch fencing solutions that enhance the security and beauty of your property. Contact us today for a seamless and professional fencing experience.

"I dealt with Mike from precision fence and he was great. The team was quick and neat. Looked like they were never here. The fence is thick and comparing it to other products I was completely satisfied. I would highly recommend Mike from precision and his guys Wilton and George."

Will D on September 2023

Precision Fence Co is your trusted partner for all your fencing needs in the New York City (Tri-State Area). With our expertise and attention to detail, we deliver top-notch fencing solutions that enhance the security and beauty of your property. Contact us today for a seamless and professional fencing experience.

"I dealt with Mike from precision fence and he was great. The team was quick and neat. Looked like they were never here. The fence is thick and comparing it to other products I was completely satisfied. I would highly recommend Mike from precision and his guys Wilton and George."

Will D on September 2023

Avatar for J&L Fencing and Railing, LLC

J&L Fencing and Railing, LLC

5.00(
18
)
•Approved Pro

J&L Fencing and Railing, LLC

5.00(
18
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
44 years of experience

J&L Fencing and Railing LLC is the leading fencing company on Long Island, offering the most affordable prices and quality products. Whether you want vinyl, cedar, wood, stockade or any other type of fence installed on your property, we have just the right solution for you.

"Jose was prompt (even early but would text and patiently wait in his car if we were not there or ready) and very up front, honest and knowledgeable. He worked with our needs and the crew came in and did great work on time and within the promised time frame. My neighbor even texted me to let me know the fence looked great and the crew did a great job. I would definitely recommend and use again for other jobs."

Jeannie L on February 2024

J&L Fencing and Railing LLC is the leading fencing company on Long Island, offering the most affordable prices and quality products. Whether you want vinyl, cedar, wood, stockade or any other type of fence installed on your property, we have just the right solution for you.

"Jose was prompt (even early but would text and patiently wait in his car if we were not there or ready) and very up front, honest and knowledgeable. He worked with our needs and the crew came in and did great work on time and within the promised time frame. My neighbor even texted me to let me know the fence looked great and the crew did a great job. I would definitely recommend and use again for other jobs."

Jeannie L on February 2024

Avatar for All Island Fence and Railings

All Island Fence and Railings

4.62(
203
)
•Approved Pro

All Island Fence and Railings

4.62(
203
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
34 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

All Island Fence & Railing is a full service fencing company. We have over 35 years of fencing experience, three locations throughout Long Island, and staff to help you along every step of your project. We Mark out utility (gas, electric and water) lines before each installation to protect our customer, customers property, employees, and communities. We are licensed, insured and bonded. Thank you for considering All Island Fence & Railing for your fencing needs!

"I highly recommend All Island Fence and Railings - They have done several jobs for us and we could not be happier with the quality of their work. All their staff from sales, design, office and installation are very professional, low pressure and extremely helpful. We will definitely use them in the future."

Edward M on November 2024

All Island Fence & Railing is a full service fencing company. We have over 35 years of fencing experience, three locations throughout Long Island, and staff to help you along every step of your project. We Mark out utility (gas, electric and water) lines before each installation to protect our customer, customers property, employees, and communities. We are licensed, insured and bonded. Thank you for considering All Island Fence & Railing for your fencing needs!

"I highly recommend All Island Fence and Railings - They have done several jobs for us and we could not be happier with the quality of their work. All their staff from sales, design, office and installation are very professional, low pressure and extremely helpful. We will definitely use them in the future."

Edward M on November 2024

Avatar for K Luna Fences & Decks

K Luna Fences & Decks

5.00(
4
)
•Approved Pro

K Luna Fences & Decks

5.00(
4
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
4 years of experience

k Luna Fences and Decks, 16 years of experience we specialize in installations of all types of aluminum fences, vinyl wood, stokade, post and rail, tennis court, handrail, pool fence enclosure, deer fence, chain link, repair etc. and remodeling of decks, mahogany, composite, azek, cedar, all kinds of wood, we have samples for you to choose the most beautiful one that matches the facade of your property, and so do we. We make sheds and chicken coop

"excellent came on time did job well as specified would hire again"

thomas p on March 2024

k Luna Fences and Decks, 16 years of experience we specialize in installations of all types of aluminum fences, vinyl wood, stokade, post and rail, tennis court, handrail, pool fence enclosure, deer fence, chain link, repair etc. and remodeling of decks, mahogany, composite, azek, cedar, all kinds of wood, we have samples for you to choose the most beautiful one that matches the facade of your property, and so do we. We make sheds and chicken coop

"excellent came on time did job well as specified would hire again"

thomas p on March 2024

Avatar for Decks by Decker Home Improvements

Decks by Decker Home Improvements

4.93(
168
)

Decks by Decker Home Improvements

4.93(
168
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers

Over 35 years construction experience from roofs to floors windows to doors...and everything in between! We believe our customer’s needs are of the utmost importance. As a result, a high percentage of our business is from repeat customers and referrals.

"Thank you Sean and team for a wonderful job on our deck replacement and repairs. You have exceeded our expectations and left us at ease during the process‼️ They do all types of home improvements if your looking for a reputable company. "

JoAnn G on October 2025

Over 35 years construction experience from roofs to floors windows to doors...and everything in between! We believe our customer’s needs are of the utmost importance. As a result, a high percentage of our business is from repeat customers and referrals.

"Thank you Sean and team for a wonderful job on our deck replacement and repairs. You have exceeded our expectations and left us at ease during the process‼️ They do all types of home improvements if your looking for a reputable company. "

JoAnn G on October 2025

Avatar for Bongiornos Contracting

Bongiornos Contracting

4.96(
123
)

Bongiornos Contracting

4.96(
123
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 99% of Angi customers
Recommended by 99% of HomeAdvisor customers

Three Generations of Masons Proudly Serving Nassau and Suffolk County for over 35 years. We are Family Owned and Operated, Full Service Landscape Mason Contractors. Licensed and Insured, Patios, Walks, Stoops, Walls, Steps and more....

"They did an outstanding job. They were very prompt and the price was great"

gary c on August 2022

Three Generations of Masons Proudly Serving Nassau and Suffolk County for over 35 years. We are Family Owned and Operated, Full Service Landscape Mason Contractors. Licensed and Insured, Patios, Walks, Stoops, Walls, Steps and more....

"They did an outstanding job. They were very prompt and the price was great"

gary c on August 2022

Avatar for Michael Basile Maintenance Inc

Michael Basile Maintenance Inc

4.90(
52
)

Michael Basile Maintenance Inc

4.90(
52
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers

M.B. Maintenance Co. is an owner/operated full service home construction, maintenance and repair company. We have been serving greater suffolk county since 1994. Through the years, we have created a solid reputation for honesty, hard work and reliability. Your home is our top priority! When you choose M.B. Maintenance Inc. to evaluate your home, we will provide you with a projected professional schedule to keep your home properly maintained. Have a comprehensive exterior inspection completed to identify any problems or repairs needed to protect and preserve your home. Our evaluation is always FREE! Call to schedule an appointment.All exterior maintenance roof repairs gutter cleaning and repairs power washing low pressure roof washing masonry install masonry repair fence repairs chimney repair Gutter Installs Gutter Guards Roof Repair Gutter screens Storm Damage & repairs

"He’s good, the repitching of the gutter looks great...definitely hire him again"

Fred L on January 2020

M.B. Maintenance Co. is an owner/operated full service home construction, maintenance and repair company. We have been serving greater suffolk county since 1994. Through the years, we have created a solid reputation for honesty, hard work and reliability. Your home is our top priority! When you choose M.B. Maintenance Inc. to evaluate your home, we will provide you with a projected professional schedule to keep your home properly maintained. Have a comprehensive exterior inspection completed to identify any problems or repairs needed to protect and preserve your home. Our evaluation is always FREE! Call to schedule an appointment.All exterior maintenance roof repairs gutter cleaning and repairs power washing low pressure roof washing masonry install masonry repair fence repairs chimney repair Gutter Installs Gutter Guards Roof Repair Gutter screens Storm Damage & repairs

"He’s good, the repitching of the gutter looks great...definitely hire him again"

Fred L on January 2020

Victorian Fence Inc

4.80(
123
)

Victorian Fence Inc

4.80(
123
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers

Victorian Fence Inc. specializes in all styles of vinyl, chain-link, aluminum, and wood including mahogany, as well as railings, pergolas, arbors, azek, and wrought iron. We offer customized designs and a professional installation.

"Hired them a month ago for the job, knowing I would need it reinstalled. Spoke to them 1 week ago and told them bottom rail was broken and would need a new one. They said no worries they will bring one extra incase the old one is unusable extra cost of 45$. I had no issue at with this. Job was set for May 4th at 2-3pm, spoke to the office that same morning to confirm and they said yes see you then. Nobody shows up at all and no phone call saying they are late or not coming at all. I call the office Today May 5th and ask what happened why didn't anyone come or even call, spoke to Jackie in office, she had no idea that the job wasn't done or that nobody showed up. Told me to hold on, came back and said they were very sorry and they guy will be here this afternoon, again i said ok and with the extra bottom rail, I was told YES. Crew shows up and the worker tells me they dont have any bottom rails for this job that they were never told they needed it. I call the office again, and the manager said that the install manager is on the way to the job to see what need to get done. 5 min later they call the workers and tell them to leave they will have to do the job next week some time. Not even a call to me at all, I call the office speak to Jackie and am told that they don't have the type of bottom rail I need so i will have to wait. Again no managers want to speak to me at all. This is a real crappy way to do business, DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY!! They don't care at all. Told Jackie I want my money back and that i will never use them again. Take heed before calling these crooks!"

Robert B on February 2019

Victorian Fence Inc. specializes in all styles of vinyl, chain-link, aluminum, and wood including mahogany, as well as railings, pergolas, arbors, azek, and wrought iron. We offer customized designs and a professional installation.

"Hired them a month ago for the job, knowing I would need it reinstalled. Spoke to them 1 week ago and told them bottom rail was broken and would need a new one. They said no worries they will bring one extra incase the old one is unusable extra cost of 45$. I had no issue at with this. Job was set for May 4th at 2-3pm, spoke to the office that same morning to confirm and they said yes see you then. Nobody shows up at all and no phone call saying they are late or not coming at all. I call the office Today May 5th and ask what happened why didn't anyone come or even call, spoke to Jackie in office, she had no idea that the job wasn't done or that nobody showed up. Told me to hold on, came back and said they were very sorry and they guy will be here this afternoon, again i said ok and with the extra bottom rail, I was told YES. Crew shows up and the worker tells me they dont have any bottom rails for this job that they were never told they needed it. I call the office again, and the manager said that the install manager is on the way to the job to see what need to get done. 5 min later they call the workers and tell them to leave they will have to do the job next week some time. Not even a call to me at all, I call the office speak to Jackie and am told that they don't have the type of bottom rail I need so i will have to wait. Again no managers want to speak to me at all. This is a real crappy way to do business, DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY!! They don't care at all. Told Jackie I want my money back and that i will never use them again. Take heed before calling these crooks!"

Robert B on February 2019

...
Showing 1-10 of 640
Fencing questions, answered by experts

Fences last anywhere from 10 to 50 years. Metal and glass fences have some of the longest lifespans, while wooden fences have one of the shortest lifespans, lasting around 15 years on average. Vinyl fences last somewhere in between, at around 20 to 30 years. You can extend the life of your fence by taking good care of it. Routine maintenance, like inspecting the fence, cleaning it, and repairing any sections that need it can go a long way.

The best height for your garden fence really depends on your visual preferences and what types of pests are common in your area. If you’re only dealing with small pests, your garden fence can be just about 3 feet tall. But if you live in a region with a lot of deer, you’ll need a deer-proof fence that’s at least 5 feet tall to keep deer from hopping over the fence and grubbing in your garden.

Costs depend on material quality, fence length and height, installation complexity, and customization choices, but they average $20-$40 per linear foot.

Ideally, your concrete should set slightly above ground at an angle sloping away from the fence post. This will add extra support and allow water to run away from the wood fence post. Keeping water out will help prevent wood rot. Additionally, you can add soil on top of the concrete for a seamless finish. 

If you come face-to-face with a wolf in your yard, chances are it will be afraid of you as a human. Make eye contact and get big—waving your arms to increase your size. Use noisemakers or air horns if you have them, or throw a few rocks around to discourage them from approaching you. If all else fails and the wolf does not retreat, back away slowly while maintaining eye contact and find safe ground, whether indoors or up a tree. 

The Water Mill, NY homeowners’ guide to fencing services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"