Top-rated fence painters.

Get matched with top fence painters in Bay Shore, NY

There are 12 highly-rated local fence painters.

Need a pro for your fence painting project in Bay Shore, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY BAY SHORE, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.5
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon353
    Verified fence painting services reviews

Find Fence painters in Bay Shore

Avatar for Precision Painting Plus of Long Island

Precision Painting Plus of Long Island

4.55(
710
)
Approved Pro

Precision Painting Plus of Long Island

4.55(
710
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
414 local quotes requested
18 years of experience

Looking for local professional painters? At Precision Painting Plus, we deliver premium painting services for both homes and businesses across Long Island. Our fully licensed and insured house painters and commercial painters provide interior painting services and exterior painting services tailored to your vision and needs. Whether you need a quick refresh or a complete transformation, our team can make your space look its very best. We offer free, no-obligation estimates so request a quote today and see if we’re right for your painting project!

"Great job! Efficient, kind, organized and adaptable. Would definitely use them again!"

Katelyn B on August 2025

Looking for local professional painters? At Precision Painting Plus, we deliver premium painting services for both homes and businesses across Long Island. Our fully licensed and insured house painters and commercial painters provide interior painting services and exterior painting services tailored to your vision and needs. Whether you need a quick refresh or a complete transformation, our team can make your space look its very best. We offer free, no-obligation estimates so request a quote today and see if we’re right for your painting project!

"Great job! Efficient, kind, organized and adaptable. Would definitely use them again!"

Katelyn B on August 2025


Avatar for Donard property services

Donard property services

New on AngiNew on Angi
Approved Pro

Donard property services

New on AngiNew on Angi
Approved Pro
Free onsite estimate
Emergency services offered

With over 10 years experience in the local area, Donard property services is your professional painting solution. Carrying out projects from small interiors, to cabinetry to full large exteriors. We have the knowledge and expertise to flawlessly complete your project

With over 10 years experience in the local area, Donard property services is your professional painting solution. Carrying out projects from small interiors, to cabinetry to full large exteriors. We have the knowledge and expertise to flawlessly complete your project


Avatar for Precision Fence Co

Precision Fence Co

4.87(
141
)
Approved Pro

Precision Fence Co

4.87(
141
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
90 local quotes requested

Precision Fence Co is your trusted partner for all your fencing needs in the New York City (Tri-State Area). With our expertise and attention to detail, we deliver top-notch fencing solutions that enhance the security and beauty of your property. Contact us today for a seamless and professional fencing experience.

"I dealt with Mike from precision fence and he was great. The team was quick and neat. Looked like they were never here. The fence is thick and comparing it to other products I was completely satisfied. I would highly recommend Mike from precision and his guys Wilton and George."

Will D on September 2023

Precision Fence Co is your trusted partner for all your fencing needs in the New York City (Tri-State Area). With our expertise and attention to detail, we deliver top-notch fencing solutions that enhance the security and beauty of your property. Contact us today for a seamless and professional fencing experience.

"I dealt with Mike from precision fence and he was great. The team was quick and neat. Looked like they were never here. The fence is thick and comparing it to other products I was completely satisfied. I would highly recommend Mike from precision and his guys Wilton and George."

Will D on September 2023


Avatar for METROPOLITAN PAINTING & CONTRACTING CO., INC

METROPOLITAN PAINTING & CONTRACTING CO., INC

5.00(
10
)
Approved Pro

METROPOLITAN PAINTING & CONTRACTING CO., INC

5.00(
10
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
24 local quotes requested

Metropolitan Painting and Contracting is a family-owned business serving the New York, Long Island and surrounding areas since 1995. Our experienced staff will deliver all aspects of your remodeling project. From breathing new life into an existing structure or completing a full scale remodeling project, our team of experienced professionals will make your vision a reality. We are fully licensed and insured so you can feel safe knowing that you'll have a professional contracting service fulfilling your needs.

"A great & clean paint job."

Jeff G on April 2024

Metropolitan Painting and Contracting is a family-owned business serving the New York, Long Island and surrounding areas since 1995. Our experienced staff will deliver all aspects of your remodeling project. From breathing new life into an existing structure or completing a full scale remodeling project, our team of experienced professionals will make your vision a reality. We are fully licensed and insured so you can feel safe knowing that you'll have a professional contracting service fulfilling your needs.

"A great & clean paint job."

Jeff G on April 2024


Avatar for DG Fence, Inc

DG Fence, Inc

5.00(
4
)
Approved Pro

DG Fence, Inc

5.00(
4
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
52 local quotes requested

DG Fence, Inc wyandanch ny 11798 (516) 860-9555 DG Fence, Inc is a fence contractor based in wyandanch, NY serving nassau,Suffolk and queens and customers in the surrounding areas. For more information please call us today or visit our website! Privacy Fence, Fence Panels, Plastic Fencing, Wood Fencing, Fence Building, Vinyl Fence Contractor, Vinyl Fence Company Lakeview NY;South Hempstead NY; North Merrick, NY; North Bellmore, NY; Wantagh, NY Fence, Fencing, Fence Contractor, Fencing Service, Fence Company http://dgfenceinc.com

"The crew was great, excellent workmanship"

Larry S on November 2024

DG Fence, Inc wyandanch ny 11798 (516) 860-9555 DG Fence, Inc is a fence contractor based in wyandanch, NY serving nassau,Suffolk and queens and customers in the surrounding areas. For more information please call us today or visit our website! Privacy Fence, Fence Panels, Plastic Fencing, Wood Fencing, Fence Building, Vinyl Fence Contractor, Vinyl Fence Company Lakeview NY;South Hempstead NY; North Merrick, NY; North Bellmore, NY; Wantagh, NY Fence, Fencing, Fence Contractor, Fencing Service, Fence Company http://dgfenceinc.com

"The crew was great, excellent workmanship"

Larry S on November 2024


Avatar for Just Right Carpentry & Painting

Just Right Carpentry & Painting

4.74(
190
)
Approved Pro

Just Right Carpentry & Painting

4.74(
190
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers
306 local quotes requested

Just Right Carpentry, Painting Inc., has served Suffolk County for decades with pride and integrity. Family owned and specializing in a range of carpentry and painting; we have the knowledge and expertise to recommend the work to truly fit your homes needs. Please call us for a free estimate. We do not use sub contractors. Charge by the job. No travel/trip charges apply.

"I just can’t say enough about Just Right carpentry and paint. Joe and his brother, Tom did an amazing job painting the inside and outside of our house. They were very fair with their prices. They showed up bright and early every day and worked a full day. I give them five stars all the way."

Arlene S on October 2025

Just Right Carpentry, Painting Inc., has served Suffolk County for decades with pride and integrity. Family owned and specializing in a range of carpentry and painting; we have the knowledge and expertise to recommend the work to truly fit your homes needs. Please call us for a free estimate. We do not use sub contractors. Charge by the job. No travel/trip charges apply.

"I just can’t say enough about Just Right carpentry and paint. Joe and his brother, Tom did an amazing job painting the inside and outside of our house. They were very fair with their prices. They showed up bright and early every day and worked a full day. I give them five stars all the way."

Arlene S on October 2025


Avatar for Performance Fence

Performance Fence

4.91(
58
)
Approved Pro

Performance Fence

4.91(
58
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
169 local quotes requested

Call Jack today for a free estimate at 631-406-6139. Paying great attention to detail throughout the entire process from the initial meeting to the finished product, we give every job our full attention regardless of size. We deliver what we promise and aim to be easy to work with. What we promise is beautiful, long lasting fence installed with you in mind. Whatever your needs - you can depend on Performance Fence for quality workmanship at a competitive price with an emphasis on timely delivery and customer satisfaction.

"Jack was very responsive, he gave me estimate on the same day that I had contacted him. Excellent pricing, workmanship as well. Highly recommend!"

Robert V on October 2025

Call Jack today for a free estimate at 631-406-6139. Paying great attention to detail throughout the entire process from the initial meeting to the finished product, we give every job our full attention regardless of size. We deliver what we promise and aim to be easy to work with. What we promise is beautiful, long lasting fence installed with you in mind. Whatever your needs - you can depend on Performance Fence for quality workmanship at a competitive price with an emphasis on timely delivery and customer satisfaction.

"Jack was very responsive, he gave me estimate on the same day that I had contacted him. Excellent pricing, workmanship as well. Highly recommend!"

Robert V on October 2025


Avatar for All Island Fence and Railings

All Island Fence and Railings

4.62(
203
)
Approved Pro

All Island Fence and Railings

4.62(
203
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
217 local quotes requested
34 years of experience

All Island Fence & Railing is a full service fencing company. We have over 35 years of fencing experience, three locations throughout Long Island, and staff to help you along every step of your project. We Mark out utility (gas, electric and water) lines before each installation to protect our customer, customers property, employees, and communities. We are licensed, insured and bonded. Thank you for considering All Island Fence & Railing for your fencing needs!

"I highly recommend All Island Fence and Railings - They have done several jobs for us and we could not be happier with the quality of their work. All their staff from sales, design, office and installation are very professional, low pressure and extremely helpful. We will definitely use them in the future."

Edward M on November 2024

All Island Fence & Railing is a full service fencing company. We have over 35 years of fencing experience, three locations throughout Long Island, and staff to help you along every step of your project. We Mark out utility (gas, electric and water) lines before each installation to protect our customer, customers property, employees, and communities. We are licensed, insured and bonded. Thank you for considering All Island Fence & Railing for your fencing needs!

"I highly recommend All Island Fence and Railings - They have done several jobs for us and we could not be happier with the quality of their work. All their staff from sales, design, office and installation are very professional, low pressure and extremely helpful. We will definitely use them in the future."

Edward M on November 2024


Avatar for J&L Fencing and Railing, LLC

J&L Fencing and Railing, LLC

5.00(
18
)
Approved Pro

J&L Fencing and Railing, LLC

5.00(
18
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
86 local quotes requested

J&L Fencing and Railing LLC is the leading fencing company on Long Island, offering the most affordable prices and quality products. Whether you want vinyl, cedar, wood, stockade or any other type of fence installed on your property, we have just the right solution for you.

"Jose was prompt (even early but would text and patiently wait in his car if we were not there or ready) and very up front, honest and knowledgeable. He worked with our needs and the crew came in and did great work on time and within the promised time frame. My neighbor even texted me to let me know the fence looked great and the crew did a great job. I would definitely recommend and use again for other jobs."

Jeannie L on February 2024

J&L Fencing and Railing LLC is the leading fencing company on Long Island, offering the most affordable prices and quality products. Whether you want vinyl, cedar, wood, stockade or any other type of fence installed on your property, we have just the right solution for you.

"Jose was prompt (even early but would text and patiently wait in his car if we were not there or ready) and very up front, honest and knowledgeable. He worked with our needs and the crew came in and did great work on time and within the promised time frame. My neighbor even texted me to let me know the fence looked great and the crew did a great job. I would definitely recommend and use again for other jobs."

Jeannie L on February 2024


Avatar for Frank's Painting

Frank's Painting

4.96(
340
)
Approved Pro

Frank's Painting

4.96(
340
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
46 local quotes requested

The team at Frank's Painting strives on excellence & repeat customer satisfaction. We have a crew of extremely respectful, trained, clean & neat painting employees. We treat your home or office like it was our own. We only use top premium paints from Benjamin Moore & Sherwin Williams on all our Residential projects. We come very highly recommended and have hundreds of customers that we can use as references. Call us for your small, large, or any size project you have in mind. Frank's Painting also offers FREE COLOR CONSULTATION services on any paint job over $3000. That includes (1) Free hour with my certified Interior Designer meeting you at your home, one on one, to help with choosing colors.

"Highly recommend Frank’s painting . They completed two large projects in my house . They were punctual , professional and neat . Each crew were amazing . I highly recommend !"

Robert M on October 2025

The team at Frank's Painting strives on excellence & repeat customer satisfaction. We have a crew of extremely respectful, trained, clean & neat painting employees. We treat your home or office like it was our own. We only use top premium paints from Benjamin Moore & Sherwin Williams on all our Residential projects. We come very highly recommended and have hundreds of customers that we can use as references. Call us for your small, large, or any size project you have in mind. Frank's Painting also offers FREE COLOR CONSULTATION services on any paint job over $3000. That includes (1) Free hour with my certified Interior Designer meeting you at your home, one on one, to help with choosing colors.

"Highly recommend Frank’s painting . They completed two large projects in my house . They were punctual , professional and neat . Each crew were amazing . I highly recommend !"

Robert M on October 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 213
Fence Painting questions, answered by experts

Staining a fence is less expensive than painting a fence due to the cost of materials and the longevity of the finish. Stain not only lasts longer than paint without chipping or peeling, but you also won’t have to put in the extra time and cost to prime the surface first. 

You should avoid staining your fence during hot weather or when it’s raining, because heat and moisture can make the stain dry unevenly. Instead, the best time to stain a fence is when the weather is dry and temperatures are between 50 and 90 degrees Fahrenheit. Typically, spring and fall are the best seasons for a fence-staining project.

Painting or staining protects fences from environmental damage, enhances durability, and improves curb appeal with a fresh, customized look.

If you don’t treat a cedar fence, it will turn from reddish brown to gray over time. You can keep the cedar from graying and retain its attractive, deep red color by sealing your cedar fence with a stain that keeps the wood’s oils in and serves as a barrier against the sun’s UV rays.

The general consensus is that two coats of stain are required and since the cedar is siding, a third coat of sealant is always a good idea. This helps protect the wood and stain, so you won’t need to resand and restain for at least a decade. Each stain after the first will darken the wood, so be aware of that when choosing a colored stain.

The Bay Shore, NY homeowners’ guide to fence painting services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"