Top-rated home builders work.

Get matched with top home builders in Reynoldsburg, OH

There are 32 highly-rated local home builders.

Matching on Angi

Share some details about your home project.
Within moments, match with highly-rated local Pros.
Compare quotes and choose the best Pro for the job.

Recent Home Builder Reviews in Reynoldsburg

  • Finished Basements Plus Inc.
    5.0
    Todd got back to us right away! Priced around a couple of options and he was by far the most affordable AND it came with everything included we weren’t finding at other companies as everything became add on fees (permits, mirrors, etc). Todd kept in touch weekly and let me know when/who would be coming and all of the contractors were on time. Quality is great and they were able to replicate my new build materials from the first floor for a seamless transition in style. I would highly recommend , we love our new basement
    Dyana B.
  • Berger Building Services
    5.0
    Jeff and his team were wonderful to work with. They are all very nice and professional and easy to work with. They did an amazing job with our home addition and renovation with attention to detail and consistency until the project was completed. They did such a good job you can’t even tell our home has been added onto! I would highly recommend Berger Building and would gladly work with them again
    Kara R.
  • Finished Basements Plus Inc.
    5.0
    They did a great job! The finished product looks amazing. I am mostly impressed with the crew (many are employees), the detailed craftsmanship and even their conscientious clean up. The owner, Todd, coordinated the project and had things moving so quickly. As with any remodeling projects, schedules are up in the air- Todd had our project finished in just a few weeks and with fairly good coordination of his crew
    Ailun C.
  • Finished Basements Plus Inc.
    5.0
    We hired Todd and his team to finish about 1000 sq ft of our basement. We are very happy with how the project turned out, they were very good about working with us to design the layout and finishes the way that we wanted them and had no problem making adjustments to the plan along the way. They made sure that we were closely involved during the process and were quick to fix any issues that arose making sure we were satisfied. The project took a little bit longer than planned but we were fine with that in the context of a pandemic. The project came out exactly how we envisioned and the price was fair. Todd was great to work with and had no problem coming out after the project was finished to help with a couple items after the fact
    Matthew B.
  • DAVE'S CUSTOM PAINTING
    5.0
    The service was top notch. Dave was very responsive and great to work with. Very personable and easy to deal with leading up to the actual service date. Price was fair, paint price was fair and service was excellent.
    Tony B.
  • Finished Basements Plus Inc.
    5.0
    The job was done as discussed. They were very professional and well priced because I got several quotes. A big thank you to Todd for overseeing the project. Would definitely recommend them to my family and friends!
    Grace U.
  • Finished Basements Plus Inc.
    5.0
    We started this project just before the state mandated a stay at home order due to COVID-19 so I knew it was going to be a lengthy process. The communication was good throughout the project. If I had to reach out to them I usually received a call back within 24 hours. I would say there was less than five times I expected someone to work on my basement for the day and no one showed up. It was understandable with the current state of the times. If something was not done to our standard we would collaborate with the project manager to come up with a solution we could all accept. Given the opportunity to pick a company to finish my basement, I would choose them again
    Tim J.
  • American Heritage Homes Corp
    1.0
    I was thrilled to begin building my first new house. Now after waiting on Bill Crum to finish it I have nothing but regrets. Greg, the main contractor was never on site when I stopped in. I only saw him when something was wrong and I requested we meet. One example is the dryer vent was not hooked up and the drywall was put up over it. I told Greg but he didn't believe me. He had me look through all my photos because he didn't want to take down a couple pieces of drywall. I insisted. I was correct. My tub was installed with a crack. Water poured through the ceiling to my bathroom below. Bill Crum went against manufacturer and industry standards that called for a complete replacement by only wanting to patch the tub even after being told I would only be able to use it as a shower due to iminate failure of the patch. He said I was making a mountain out of a mole hill. I paid to replace the tub with a steel tub and tile to avoid more issues with their inferior products. I told Bill I expect reimbursement for half the labor. He offered an insulting $350.00. My gutters have an inverted fall. Four people have looked at them just to waste my time taking off work. Bill himself came a few weeks ago. I refused to take off work again and meet him. My work order inquiries and emails to Bill are still going unanswered and nothing is being done to fix the gutters. I filed a complaint with the BIA only to have Bill tell me they would side with him. I guess we will see. Back door does not latch. Carpet company has never shown up and painting not finished. Ive put in numerous work orders and sent many emails. I posted a review on their Facebook page and it mysteriously disappeared along with another negative review from someone else. Do yourself a favor and go with another builder
    Kim S.
  • Diyanni Custom Homes
    1.0
    Everything was fine until we signed the contract. Communication is horrible, emails and phone calls remain unanswered. The owner, Ray, said it isn’t his responsibility to talk to customers, that is what he hires people for. I kept the text in case anyone needs to see it. I have built with Dominion, MI, and Ryan…they were 100 percent better at a much lower price. Diyanni doesn’t care about honesty or integrity as long as they have your money
    Christi B.
  • Finished Basements Plus Inc.
    5.0
    The project went great even with COVID going on. All of Todd and Brian’s workers wore masks, were very respectful, and did great work. Very happy with the project.
    Joe R.

Last update on March 22, 2022

See all 32 highly rated companies in Reynoldsburg
Join Angi now

Related cost guides

How Much Does a Building Permit Cost?

How Much Does It Cost to Build a Brick House?

How Much Does It Cost to Demolish a House?

How Much Does It Cost to Raise My House?

How Much Are Construction Management Fees?

Into the Woods on How Much a Log Cabin Costs

Explore our Solution Center for helpful home builder articles

Find home builders in

home builders in Reynoldsburg

Companies below are listed in alphabetical order.

To view top rated service providers along with reviews & ratings, join Angi now!

Rate Angi’s House builders in Reynoldsburg

Featured Rating:
4.4

House builders in Reynoldsburg are rated 4.4 out of 5 based on 5,308 reviews of the 39 featured Reynoldsburg pros

The Angi rating for House builders in Reynoldsburg is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their House builders needs. Angi’s review system takes into account ratings on price, quality, timeliness, responsiveness and feedback for Angi Certified Pros.