
Get matched with top home builders in Reynolds, IN
Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros
Need a pro for your home building project in Reynolds, IN?
Verified Reviews for Home Building pros in Reynolds, IN
*The Angi rating for Home Building companies in Reynolds, IN is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Home Building needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Home Building companies in Reynolds, IN is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Home Building needs.
Last update on December 15, 2025
Find Home builders in Reynolds

The Refiner's Collective
The Refiner's Collective
At The Refiner’s Collective, we take pride in being a central Indiana, third-generation construction company with a rich heritage and a commitment to excellence. We are a collective of people, skills, and strengths who are passionate about revitalizing old spaces and building new ones. Whether you need a room remodel, a complete home renovation, or are building a new home, our team has the expertise to take your vision to reality. At the core of our philosophy is an unwavering commitment to honesty and reliability. We understand that building or renovating a space is a significant investment. That’s why we always strive to deliver exceptional workmanship, use high-quality materials, and maintain open, transparent communication. We know every project will have it’s challenges, and no home is perfect. What matters most is that those challenges are handled with transparency, care, and high-level problem solving.
"The Refiner's Collective did an awesome job listening and doing exactly what I asked for. The owner was empathetic and engaged with my family's needs. The crew that came was courteous and friendly and the communication throughout the project was strong. Highly recommend this vendor!"
Mike S on October 2025
At The Refiner’s Collective, we take pride in being a central Indiana, third-generation construction company with a rich heritage and a commitment to excellence. We are a collective of people, skills, and strengths who are passionate about revitalizing old spaces and building new ones. Whether you need a room remodel, a complete home renovation, or are building a new home, our team has the expertise to take your vision to reality. At the core of our philosophy is an unwavering commitment to honesty and reliability. We understand that building or renovating a space is a significant investment. That’s why we always strive to deliver exceptional workmanship, use high-quality materials, and maintain open, transparent communication. We know every project will have it’s challenges, and no home is perfect. What matters most is that those challenges are handled with transparency, care, and high-level problem solving.
"The Refiner's Collective did an awesome job listening and doing exactly what I asked for. The owner was empathetic and engaged with my family's needs. The crew that came was courteous and friendly and the communication throughout the project was strong. Highly recommend this vendor!"
Mike S on October 2025

Sentri Homes
Sentri Homes
Sentri Homes is a full-service contractor delivering high-end home additions, whole-home remodels, new custom builds, luxury kitchens, structural framing, roof replacements, and every major renovation. We assign a dedicated project manager to every job, deliver meticulous craftsmanship with clear communication, and back our work with an industry-leading warranty to ensure complete peace of mind on your largest investments. Our in-house team of licensed builders and master craftsmen consistently earns 5-star reviews by turning big visions into stunning, high-value homes—when you need one trusted partner who truly does it all, we’re the proven choice.
Sentri Homes is a full-service contractor delivering high-end home additions, whole-home remodels, new custom builds, luxury kitchens, structural framing, roof replacements, and every major renovation. We assign a dedicated project manager to every job, deliver meticulous craftsmanship with clear communication, and back our work with an industry-leading warranty to ensure complete peace of mind on your largest investments. Our in-house team of licensed builders and master craftsmen consistently earns 5-star reviews by turning big visions into stunning, high-value homes—when you need one trusted partner who truly does it all, we’re the proven choice.

Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories, Inc
Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories, Inc
ETR Laboratories in an analytic laboratory with a broad range of commercial, industrial and individual clients. We provide analytic services using a wide variety of scientific methods including GC/MS, IC/MS, GIR, NMR and SEM equipment. We can do particle analysis, organic and inorganic chemical analysis and micro analysis on biological and other materials. Private water analysis is our specialty. Award winning. Additional DBA - Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories Inc, ETR Labs, ETR Laboratories.
"as advertised"
Nancy C on July 2018
ETR Laboratories in an analytic laboratory with a broad range of commercial, industrial and individual clients. We provide analytic services using a wide variety of scientific methods including GC/MS, IC/MS, GIR, NMR and SEM equipment. We can do particle analysis, organic and inorganic chemical analysis and micro analysis on biological and other materials. Private water analysis is our specialty. Award winning. Additional DBA - Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories Inc, ETR Labs, ETR Laboratories.
"as advertised"
Nancy C on July 2018
F C Electric
F C Electric
Additional phone - (765) 418-7242 Award winning.
"It’s so nice when you find an electrician you can really trust. FC Electric has been out to my house multiple times, three of which were to research and fix problems with its very strange wiring. Everyone who has been out has been polite, courteous, and knowledgeable - they’ve always gotten the work done right the first time, and quickly too. They are the only electricians I call."
Heather S on February 2021
Additional phone - (765) 418-7242 Award winning.
"It’s so nice when you find an electrician you can really trust. FC Electric has been out to my house multiple times, three of which were to research and fix problems with its very strange wiring. Everyone who has been out has been polite, courteous, and knowledgeable - they’ve always gotten the work done right the first time, and quickly too. They are the only electricians I call."
Heather S on February 2021

Bender Construction Co
Bender Construction Co
Founded in 1997 by Kevin L. Bender, a Purdue Construction Management graduate, Bender Construction Company, Inc. is based in Lafayette and specializes in residential remodeling, renovations and new construction. We have a reputation for exceptional craftsmanship and perform the vast majority of work in-house by our skilled carpenters and when needed only utilize a small selective group of subcontractors that we have worked with for years. We have a full time Environmental, Health & Safety professional on staff and can provide safety consulting for both the construction and general industries in addition to residential thermal image energy assessments. We are very proud and grateful for the long-lasting relationships we have developed with our clients and consider it the utmost compliment to be given repeat business, which along with customer referrals, have always been the major source of our business. We are not a production builder and our clients receive personal service throughout the project from Kevin himself. We have a detail oriented management and field staff and provide the highest level of communication throughout all phases of the project - planning, execution and follow-up and we stand by our work. We utilize a team approach that encourages the participation of the contractor, owner and architect (when applicable). This synergistic approach results in better communication and creates a smoother design, building or remodeling process.
"We were highly satisfied with their work, they were careful and did the job very timely, they have a good communication. We are highly satisfied with the work. We give the highest rating, they always arrive on the dot, their responses to issues was great, they're very courteous."
Gary F on December 2018
Founded in 1997 by Kevin L. Bender, a Purdue Construction Management graduate, Bender Construction Company, Inc. is based in Lafayette and specializes in residential remodeling, renovations and new construction. We have a reputation for exceptional craftsmanship and perform the vast majority of work in-house by our skilled carpenters and when needed only utilize a small selective group of subcontractors that we have worked with for years. We have a full time Environmental, Health & Safety professional on staff and can provide safety consulting for both the construction and general industries in addition to residential thermal image energy assessments. We are very proud and grateful for the long-lasting relationships we have developed with our clients and consider it the utmost compliment to be given repeat business, which along with customer referrals, have always been the major source of our business. We are not a production builder and our clients receive personal service throughout the project from Kevin himself. We have a detail oriented management and field staff and provide the highest level of communication throughout all phases of the project - planning, execution and follow-up and we stand by our work. We utilize a team approach that encourages the participation of the contractor, owner and architect (when applicable). This synergistic approach results in better communication and creates a smoother design, building or remodeling process.
"We were highly satisfied with their work, they were careful and did the job very timely, they have a good communication. We are highly satisfied with the work. We give the highest rating, they always arrive on the dot, their responses to issues was great, they're very courteous."
Gary F on December 2018
Toombs Construction
Toombs Construction
Toombs Construction can assist you with your home improvement needs.
Toombs Construction can assist you with your home improvement needs.
Claton & Claton Builders By Design
Claton & Claton Builders By Design
When you're looking to take on a home improvement project, using the services of a Lafayette, IN, general contractor can help ensure that the project goes as smoothly as possible. At Claton & Claton Builders By Design, we use our more than 45 years of combined experience to work closely with you so that your project turns out exactly how you want it to. Additional Address: 6151 Browntown Rd, Sawyer, MI 49125. Family owned and operated. Occasionally uses subs. Cost is determined by the job or by the hour. No travel charges. Ask for licensing information. Additional phone: (765) 479-0091.
When you're looking to take on a home improvement project, using the services of a Lafayette, IN, general contractor can help ensure that the project goes as smoothly as possible. At Claton & Claton Builders By Design, we use our more than 45 years of combined experience to work closely with you so that your project turns out exactly how you want it to. Additional Address: 6151 Browntown Rd, Sawyer, MI 49125. Family owned and operated. Occasionally uses subs. Cost is determined by the job or by the hour. No travel charges. Ask for licensing information. Additional phone: (765) 479-0091.

Hallmark Homes Inc
Hallmark Homes Inc
Additional phones - (765) 644-6566, (812) 526-2336, (765) 864-9400, (765) 482-9984, (765) 742-8480.
"We built our home in 2004, until you have to start replacing things on your home is when you find out the quality of work. 5 years in our A/C outdoor unit stopped working, when we got it fixed found out that what was installed was a refurbished unit not the new unit that was on our plans that we paid for. I did contact Hallmark homes at the time and only got that it was out of warranty and that we should have check when it was getting built. Who checks inside of an outdoor A/C unit. Next thing that happened was that the pipes froze in one of our bathrooms, when we took out the surround tub behind the tub were the duct work for the furnace was, actual trash was left inside the walls of our house. And we found no insulation between wall and the attic part of the garage, no wonder the pipes froze. This year we unfortunately got hit by a tornado with wind and hail damage to the outside of our house, yesterday they started pulling off the original siding and found there is no house wrap on our house! Not only that the OSB board have 1" to 2" gaps in them, you can see the inner drywall from between the gaps, meaning there is no insulation in the wall!! It now makes since over the past 19 years why our home has had so many drafts. We are now going to have to pay out of our pockets for the water damage caused by not having house wrap under the siding and fixing all the OSB board that are gapped. Unless you have time to be at you home while it is being built 24/7 do not contract with Hallmark Homes."
Chris F on May 2023
Additional phones - (765) 644-6566, (812) 526-2336, (765) 864-9400, (765) 482-9984, (765) 742-8480.
"We built our home in 2004, until you have to start replacing things on your home is when you find out the quality of work. 5 years in our A/C outdoor unit stopped working, when we got it fixed found out that what was installed was a refurbished unit not the new unit that was on our plans that we paid for. I did contact Hallmark homes at the time and only got that it was out of warranty and that we should have check when it was getting built. Who checks inside of an outdoor A/C unit. Next thing that happened was that the pipes froze in one of our bathrooms, when we took out the surround tub behind the tub were the duct work for the furnace was, actual trash was left inside the walls of our house. And we found no insulation between wall and the attic part of the garage, no wonder the pipes froze. This year we unfortunately got hit by a tornado with wind and hail damage to the outside of our house, yesterday they started pulling off the original siding and found there is no house wrap on our house! Not only that the OSB board have 1" to 2" gaps in them, you can see the inner drywall from between the gaps, meaning there is no insulation in the wall!! It now makes since over the past 19 years why our home has had so many drafts. We are now going to have to pay out of our pockets for the water damage caused by not having house wrap under the siding and fixing all the OSB board that are gapped. Unless you have time to be at you home while it is being built 24/7 do not contract with Hallmark Homes."
Chris F on May 2023

Hays & Sons
Hays & Sons
Family owned. Office locations in Indianapolis, Lafayette, Crown Point, Ft. Wayne, Muncie and Cincinnati, OH. Additional DBAs - Hays & Sons Construction Inc.
"Working with Hays and Sons was not a good experience. We had water damage and they made repairs without checking with our insurance company so we ended up paying out of pocket. They did a terrible job painting our ceiling and their solution was to paint one stripe at the top of each wall. Now we have to paint all the walls on the first floor ourselves. They initially charged us for over $2,000 of services they did not provide. I think they hope customers don't look carefully at the bills, especially if the insurance company is paying."
Laurie W on June 2023
Family owned. Office locations in Indianapolis, Lafayette, Crown Point, Ft. Wayne, Muncie and Cincinnati, OH. Additional DBAs - Hays & Sons Construction Inc.
"Working with Hays and Sons was not a good experience. We had water damage and they made repairs without checking with our insurance company so we ended up paying out of pocket. They did a terrible job painting our ceiling and their solution was to paint one stripe at the top of each wall. Now we have to paint all the walls on the first floor ourselves. They initially charged us for over $2,000 of services they did not provide. I think they hope customers don't look carefully at the bills, especially if the insurance company is paying."
Laurie W on June 2023
SCHUMANN CUSTOM BUILDING AND LANDSCAPING
SCHUMANN CUSTOM BUILDING AND LANDSCAPING
Schumann Custom Building and Landscaping has provided the Lafayette/West Lafayette area with remodeling and landscape services for 30 years. We have full service crews for any of your remodel or landscape needs, from design through installation.
Schumann Custom Building and Landscaping has provided the Lafayette/West Lafayette area with remodeling and landscape services for 30 years. We have full service crews for any of your remodel or landscape needs, from design through installation.
FAQs for home building projects in Reynolds, IN
One starting point to find a local home builder is to collect suggestions from friends and neighbors. However, it’s still wise to do some more research before you hire a builder. Read reviews to supplement any word-of-mouth recommendations. Check sources like Angi that have standards and criteria in place to screen the pros it lists can also help you find more reputable local home builders.
The pros and cons or advantages and disadvantages of building a new house include:
Pros:
It’s all new, so you should have several years before you need to pay for major repairs like a new roof.
It’s under warranty, so many fixes within that warranty period should be covered.
You get to build the house to your specifications.
Cons:
You have to make a LOT of decisions.
You will almost certainly deal with building delays.
It can take a lot of work to stay within your budget.
Building can be more expensive than buying an existing house.
Typically, it’s more affordable to buy an existing home than it is to build a new one. New construction loan interest rates tend to be higher than interest rates for traditional mortgages. Additionally, the cost of materials is likely higher when building a new home than it was when an existing home was built (unless it’s a very new one). You’re also paying for all new appliances, finishes, permits, inspections, and connections for water, gas, and electricity.
The average price per square foot to build a house is about $150 per square foot. Overall, the cost to build a house ranges anywhere from $100 to $500 per square foot, depending on where you build. The primary cost factors include location, size, and style of house you build.
Hiring a contractor to build your home is a big commitment. So be sure to ask as many questions up front as possible. Here are a few questions to ask a prospective home builder:
How many years of experience do you have?
Are you licensed, bonded, and insured?
Do you have worker’s compensation?
How long have you worked with your subcontractors?
How do you handle garbage and waste disposal?
Do you provide a guarantee or warranty on your work?
Do you give free estimates?
Do you offer design services?
How do you handle change orders?
Can you provide at least three references?
Can I see some of the work you’ve done?
The Reynolds, IN homeowners’ guide to home building services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

Building a home and looking to go as green as possible? Learn about the cost to build a green home and how energy-efficient features will affect the total.
•Get transparent shed repair cost info so you can learn average prices, cost factors, and ways to save on shed repairs for your home.
•Use our home demolition cost calculator to estimate your project’s price and learn what factors impact the total cost before you start your demolition.

Building your dream home starts with hiring a builder. Here is how to find a builder who understands your needs and preferences for your brand-new home.

Building a wheelchair ramp for your home or residential business can offer vital accessibility. Learn how to build a wheelchair ramp with this DIY guide.

Looking to compare a mobile home vs. a tiny home? Here, we share the significant differences, including the best lifestyles for each home type.
- Monticello, IN Home builders
- Monon, IN Home builders
- Wolcott, IN Home builders
- Brookston, IN Home builders
- Remington, IN Home builders
- Delphi, IN Home builders
- Battle Ground, IN Home builders
- Francesville, IN Home builders
- Rensselaer, IN Home builders
- Royal Center, IN Home builders
- Otterbein, IN Home builders
- Goodland, IN Home builders
- West Lafayette, IN Home builders
- Camden, IN Home builders
- Medaryville, IN Home builders
- Star City, IN Home builders
- Flora, IN Home builders
- Lafayette, IN Home builders
- Fowler, IN Home builders
- Logansport, IN Home builders
- Oxford, IN Home builders
- Winamac, IN Home builders
- Brook, IN Home builders
- Rossville, IN Home builders
- Mulberry, IN Home builders
- Boswell, IN Home builders
- Kewanna, IN Home builders
- Highland, IN Home builders
- Kentland, IN Home builders
- Burlington, IN Home builders






