Top-rated water heater pros.

Get matched with top water heater pros in Benton, IL

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Verified Reviews for Water Heater Service pros in Benton, IL

*The Angi rating for Water Heater Service companies in Benton, IL is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Water Heater Service companies in Benton, IL is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.

Last update on November 22, 2025

Find Water heater pros in Benton

Avatar for AppliancePartsPros.com

AppliancePartsPros.com

4.73(
287
)

AppliancePartsPros.com

4.73(
287
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Since 1999, we've helped millions of do-it-yourselfers save money and fix their broken appliances quickly by providing quality appliance parts and free repair advice. We are only an online appliance parts retailer that offers a 365 day warranty and fast shipping. We also offer technical advice and diagnosis totally free 6 days a week. If you are interested in repairing your own appliance, please call us at 1-877-477-7278 or click live chat on our web site. We will help diagnose the problem and provide you with all the necessary information for the repair free of charge. It's better with the Pros!™ Avoid costly service calls - visit us at http://www.appliancepartspros.com

"Beware of shipping issues with this company. Ordered an ice maker installation kit on 10/10/25. Shipping was due no later than 10/20 according to company and FedEx tracking. FedEx tracking showed the package at their facility for 8 days without moving beginning on 10/15. Called FedEx 3 times. Each time they said they cannot find package and I have to contact shipper. Shipper has to make a claim, they will not mark it as lost. Called Appliance Parts Pros twice. Each time they say FedEx has to mark package lost before they will do anything. They also state they have to wait 14 days from them before doing anything because of their contract with FedEx. I don't care about their contract, I want what was ordered and paid for. Just going in circles with them and FedEX. If they shipped after 14 days it would be 22 days from that point, 32 days from the date of order if they shipped it that day. There was a deadline for installing this part before tenants arrive. They did not care, would not m"

Ron R on October 2025

Since 1999, we've helped millions of do-it-yourselfers save money and fix their broken appliances quickly by providing quality appliance parts and free repair advice. We are only an online appliance parts retailer that offers a 365 day warranty and fast shipping. We also offer technical advice and diagnosis totally free 6 days a week. If you are interested in repairing your own appliance, please call us at 1-877-477-7278 or click live chat on our web site. We will help diagnose the problem and provide you with all the necessary information for the repair free of charge. It's better with the Pros!™ Avoid costly service calls - visit us at http://www.appliancepartspros.com

"Beware of shipping issues with this company. Ordered an ice maker installation kit on 10/10/25. Shipping was due no later than 10/20 according to company and FedEx tracking. FedEx tracking showed the package at their facility for 8 days without moving beginning on 10/15. Called FedEx 3 times. Each time they said they cannot find package and I have to contact shipper. Shipper has to make a claim, they will not mark it as lost. Called Appliance Parts Pros twice. Each time they say FedEx has to mark package lost before they will do anything. They also state they have to wait 14 days from them before doing anything because of their contract with FedEx. I don't care about their contract, I want what was ordered and paid for. Just going in circles with them and FedEX. If they shipped after 14 days it would be 22 days from that point, 32 days from the date of order if they shipped it that day. There was a deadline for installing this part before tenants arrive. They did not care, would not m"

Ron R on October 2025

Avatar for Hays Plumbing Co Inc

Hays Plumbing Co Inc

4.87(
67
)

Hays Plumbing Co Inc

4.87(
67
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers

Hays Plumbing Co., Inc. has been a family owned and operated company for two generations. We provide a variety of plumbing related services to Springfield and surrounding communities in Central Illinois. Here at Hays Plumbing Co. we specialize in those challenging and tricky plumbing tasks. Some of our specific services include, but are not limited to: -residential plumbing repairs -remodeling and new construction -installation -water heaters -disposers -sump pumps Stop wasting time talking to machines and being just another service call customer. Work with us and get the personalized service with attention to detail you deserve. So next time you are looking for a quality company that will be honest about their recommendations on what will work best for your situation, call Linda Mattson and her crew, to see why they will be around for generations to come.

Hays Plumbing Co., Inc. has been a family owned and operated company for two generations. We provide a variety of plumbing related services to Springfield and surrounding communities in Central Illinois. Here at Hays Plumbing Co. we specialize in those challenging and tricky plumbing tasks. Some of our specific services include, but are not limited to: -residential plumbing repairs -remodeling and new construction -installation -water heaters -disposers -sump pumps Stop wasting time talking to machines and being just another service call customer. Work with us and get the personalized service with attention to detail you deserve. So next time you are looking for a quality company that will be honest about their recommendations on what will work best for your situation, call Linda Mattson and her crew, to see why they will be around for generations to come.

Heartland Plumbing & Sewer Inc

5.00(
14
)

Heartland Plumbing & Sewer Inc

5.00(
14
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Heartland Plumbing & Sewer, Inc. is a family owned, full-service, modern plumbing company based on simple old fashioned values. Here at Heartland, we strive each and every day to ensure and deliver complete customer satisfaction with honest, professional, courteous service, with the highest level of quality workmanship. Serving residential and commercial customers throughout Illinois, Heartland Plumbing is licensed, bonded and insured for our customer’s protection and peace of mind. We offer quality plumbing services at the most reasonable rates. We also provide same day service! We understand that you have many options when it comes to plumbing contractors. Here at Heartland Plumbing, we excel in helping you solve your plumbing problems and strive to be your plumbing contractor of choice. Heartland Plumbing takes immense pride in the way we take care of our customers, and it is our goal that your choice will be us!

Heartland Plumbing & Sewer, Inc. is a family owned, full-service, modern plumbing company based on simple old fashioned values. Here at Heartland, we strive each and every day to ensure and deliver complete customer satisfaction with honest, professional, courteous service, with the highest level of quality workmanship. Serving residential and commercial customers throughout Illinois, Heartland Plumbing is licensed, bonded and insured for our customer’s protection and peace of mind. We offer quality plumbing services at the most reasonable rates. We also provide same day service! We understand that you have many options when it comes to plumbing contractors. Here at Heartland Plumbing, we excel in helping you solve your plumbing problems and strive to be your plumbing contractor of choice. Heartland Plumbing takes immense pride in the way we take care of our customers, and it is our goal that your choice will be us!

TURNEY Heating/Cooling, Plumbing and Electrical

4.92(
12
)

TURNEY Heating/Cooling, Plumbing and Electrical

4.92(
12
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

TURNEY has been locally owned and operated for 25 years and take pride in doing good quality work at a reasonable price. From new construction to replacement of your existing system we can help. We service all makes and models of equipment. We take pride in being able to handle all of your Heating/Cooling, Plumbing and Electrical needs with just one phone call or email.

TURNEY has been locally owned and operated for 25 years and take pride in doing good quality work at a reasonable price. From new construction to replacement of your existing system we can help. We service all makes and models of equipment. We take pride in being able to handle all of your Heating/Cooling, Plumbing and Electrical needs with just one phone call or email.

Avatar for McDonagh & Sons Plumbing & Sewer Inc

McDonagh & Sons Plumbing & Sewer Inc

4.86(
51
)

McDonagh & Sons Plumbing & Sewer Inc

4.86(
51
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers

Mcdonagh & sons plumbing & sewer takes great pride with 15 years of experience! We are honest, reliable, genuine and trustworthy! We are constantly referred by our customers because of our great service and dedication to meet their needs! We offer free estimates! "anything plumbing, anything sewer, any time". Ertain areas are to subject a service fee *prices may vary. Discounts can not be combined, unless noted. Award winning. Additional dba - mcdonagh & sons plumbing and sewer.

Mcdonagh & sons plumbing & sewer takes great pride with 15 years of experience! We are honest, reliable, genuine and trustworthy! We are constantly referred by our customers because of our great service and dedication to meet their needs! We offer free estimates! "anything plumbing, anything sewer, any time". Ertain areas are to subject a service fee *prices may vary. Discounts can not be combined, unless noted. Award winning. Additional dba - mcdonagh & sons plumbing and sewer.

JACOBS AIR CONDITIONING AND HEATING INC

4.25(
12
)

JACOBS AIR CONDITIONING AND HEATING INC

4.25(
12
)
Customers say: Quick response
2000 years of experience

ADDITIONAL EMAILS: [email protected].

"If I could give negative stars I would. The owner is a horrible, horrible person. I never imagined someone working in the customer service field would act with such incredible rudeness. During the initial phone call, he (Mr. Jacobs) stated he needed an e-mail to send a billing invoice and I assumed I would have X amount of days to pay, as per usual with other heating/plumbing/service companies. After the visit, he asked for the money while still in my home. Obviously I was shocked and tried to explain the misunderstanding. His reaction was to roll his eyes, shake his head, and insult me by assuming I was making up the story to not pay for his visit. I received his invoice with a zero dollar amount owed, basically writing me off as a liar, manipulator, and someone he already jumped to the conclusion had never intended to pay in the first place. Now as an old-fashioned farmer at heart, telling someone their word is no good when you've just met them is pretty much the ultimate insult. This was on a Thursday. Called him on the following Monday to pay the original amount, despite it being zeroed out, and tried yet again to explain the misunderstanding. He argued with me on taking up more than 5 minutes of his time to explain something he didn't want to hear and stated he didn't want me as his customer. This, from a man who was on a phone call with someone willing to give him money for an invoice he had zeroed out. He emailed me a link with the new invoice and promptly hung up on me. I'm in complete shock at how someone who has his own business in a small, rural area where word spreads very fast, could get away with treating decent, honest people so horribly and still stay in business. Paid my invoice and learned my lesson."

Rhonda C on February 2024

ADDITIONAL EMAILS: [email protected].

"If I could give negative stars I would. The owner is a horrible, horrible person. I never imagined someone working in the customer service field would act with such incredible rudeness. During the initial phone call, he (Mr. Jacobs) stated he needed an e-mail to send a billing invoice and I assumed I would have X amount of days to pay, as per usual with other heating/plumbing/service companies. After the visit, he asked for the money while still in my home. Obviously I was shocked and tried to explain the misunderstanding. His reaction was to roll his eyes, shake his head, and insult me by assuming I was making up the story to not pay for his visit. I received his invoice with a zero dollar amount owed, basically writing me off as a liar, manipulator, and someone he already jumped to the conclusion had never intended to pay in the first place. Now as an old-fashioned farmer at heart, telling someone their word is no good when you've just met them is pretty much the ultimate insult. This was on a Thursday. Called him on the following Monday to pay the original amount, despite it being zeroed out, and tried yet again to explain the misunderstanding. He argued with me on taking up more than 5 minutes of his time to explain something he didn't want to hear and stated he didn't want me as his customer. This, from a man who was on a phone call with someone willing to give him money for an invoice he had zeroed out. He emailed me a link with the new invoice and promptly hung up on me. I'm in complete shock at how someone who has his own business in a small, rural area where word spreads very fast, could get away with treating decent, honest people so horribly and still stay in business. Paid my invoice and learned my lesson."

Rhonda C on February 2024

Avatar for High Tech Home Warranties

High Tech Home Warranties

4.37(
35
)

High Tech Home Warranties

4.37(
35
)
Customers say: Terrific value
2008 years of experience

We are a one stop shop for all your home warranty needs. Our upbeat and friendly support team is always at your fingertips to respond to questions about your warranty 365 days a year! Emergency claims will be addressed within 24 hours from time claim is submitted and non-emergency claims will be addressed within 48 hours Monday - Friday 8:30 am - 6:00 pm. During nights and weekends non-emergency claims will not receive a call back until the next business day. Our service call deductibles range from $65 - $75.

"I had a bad computer board in my oven. they said they would not cover it because they found a roach. This is Florida we have some roaches. i do not have a bug problem. It has nothing to do with a bad computer board. This company looks for a way to deny claims. i had one other claim and they tried to deny it as well. Save yourself some agravation and stay away. They must post their own positive reviews. They took my $65.00 fee and did nothing"

marc g on August 2018

We are a one stop shop for all your home warranty needs. Our upbeat and friendly support team is always at your fingertips to respond to questions about your warranty 365 days a year! Emergency claims will be addressed within 24 hours from time claim is submitted and non-emergency claims will be addressed within 48 hours Monday - Friday 8:30 am - 6:00 pm. During nights and weekends non-emergency claims will not receive a call back until the next business day. Our service call deductibles range from $65 - $75.

"I had a bad computer board in my oven. they said they would not cover it because they found a roach. This is Florida we have some roaches. i do not have a bug problem. It has nothing to do with a bad computer board. This company looks for a way to deny claims. i had one other claim and they tried to deny it as well. Save yourself some agravation and stay away. They must post their own positive reviews. They took my $65.00 fee and did nothing"

marc g on August 2018

THE HANDYMAN SERVICE

4.44(
16
)

THE HANDYMAN SERVICE

4.44(
16
)
Customers say: Quick response
1998 years of experience

The Handyman Service has been doing business in the Morris, IL. area for 9 years. The business moved here from Tulsa Ok. and has been building a customer base since. With over 35 years experience in roofing and remodeling, including kitchen and bathroom remodels. We enjoy what we do and what we do gets results for you.

"late every time, worse work I've ever seen, refuses to take credit for it. renamed his company to THI with # 815-333-7183. Gotta spend hours fixing his bad work now. This is definitely a new guy that took over an old company name from 2017."

Tyler G on October 2024

The Handyman Service has been doing business in the Morris, IL. area for 9 years. The business moved here from Tulsa Ok. and has been building a customer base since. With over 35 years experience in roofing and remodeling, including kitchen and bathroom remodels. We enjoy what we do and what we do gets results for you.

"late every time, worse work I've ever seen, refuses to take credit for it. renamed his company to THI with # 815-333-7183. Gotta spend hours fixing his bad work now. This is definitely a new guy that took over an old company name from 2017."

Tyler G on October 2024

Showing 1-10 of 32
Water Heaters questions, answered by experts

Standard electric water heaters (about 40 gallons) typically need a 30-amp circuit breaker. But if you have a newer model, a tankless water heater, or one that’s more energy efficient, you’ll likely need a higher amperage to power it. 

Having the right size circuit breaker for your water heater is an important part of making sure it heats water efficiently and runs safely. A licensed electrician can help you navigate your options, and determine what you need for your new water heater. 

Signs your electric water heater is failing include inconsistent water temperature, reduced hot water supply, longer heating times, or discolored water (rusty or cloudy). Unusual noises like popping or rumbling suggest sediment buildup, while leaks or corrosion around the tank signal structural damage. If your unit is over 10 to 15 years old and experiencing frequent issues, it may be time to replace it.

The chemicals in a water softener can wear down the anode rod in the heater and shorten its life span. However, for most people, the benefits of the softener outweigh this potential drawback.

Have a plumber inspect the anode rod annually for damage, as replacing the anode rod is far less expensive than replacing the entire water heater.

Converting a gas water heater to an electric one can cost between $870 and $4,100, depending on the installation scope, plumbing and electrical needs, and the water heater model. However, it’s always better to contact a local pro for a more accurate quote. Also, since natural gas is cheaper than electricity in most regions, you should prepare yourself for a higher monthly cost after the initial conversion.

Every city and state will have its own set of installation codes and laws. Some won’t require you to obtain a permit before replacing your water heater, though we recommend you do, regardless of the local codes. On the other hand, some cities and states might require secondary permits for plumbing and electrical work related to the installation. Check with a local water heater installation company and local building codes to confirm which permits are required and what the specific laws are.

The Benton, IL homeowners’ guide to water heater services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles