4.4 
23 *The Angi rating for Gutter Repair And Replacement companies in Arena, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Gutter Repair And Replacement needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Gutter Repair And Replacement companies in Arena, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Gutter Repair And Replacement needs.
Last update on September 25, 2026
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
Approved (Corporate)
In business since 2005
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"Fast response to request for quote. Thorough explanation of repair needed & cost of the job. Prompt & efficient repair of gutters & replacement of gutter guards."
+79
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 1997
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"I submitted service request through Angi's List months ago with no response. Then, suddenly, there was a flurry of activity as my request was released to eligible gutter repair firms. Robbie from P&J Eagle Sheet Metal (DBA A-1 Seamless Rain Gutters) called and arranged an appointment to submit a quote. He arrived exactly on schedule a couple of days later. The quote was acceptable. A crew arrived and performed the needed repair/replacement of a gutter and downspout in a timely and efficient manner. We're pleased with the quality of the work and would recommend this company. A bonus was that they did not try to sell a complete gutter system like some of the other interested companies. They quoted the work that we wanted done."
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 1994
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"They came to my house the day I called them and gave me an estimate. They had the repairs made by 5pm that very day! Reasonable price, and the service was great. Thus far, the repairs are holding up very well (this was done several months ago)."
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 1993
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
LeafGuard is a market-leading, unique, customized gutter protection system for your home. It carries water away from your property faster, protecting it from water damage associated with clogged, or faulty gutters. The system is 20% thicker than regular gutters and provides added strength against the elements. \n \nLeafGuard is the only gutter brand to offer a Lifetime, No-Clog Warranty. What does this mean? Simple--your gutters are guaranteed not to clog for as long as they're installed on your home. If they do, we'll clean them out for free!
+1
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2016
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"Prairie Exteriors does a great job. Shows up when promised, does quality work and are reasonably priced. Update: (August 26) - We’ve been impressed with Prairie Exteriors for years, but their work after our April 2026 hail damage reminded us why we trust them so much. This wasn’t a small job — 4,300 square feet of roofing with complicated angles, six skylights, interior patching and painting after the skylights were replaced, gutter‑guard and downspout work, and replacement of several LP trim boards. Prairie handled every part of it with confidence, clarity, and professionalism from the very beginning. They used all the proper materials, installation processes and even provided a transferable lifetime warranty, which gives us confidence not only in the work but in the long‑term value of our home. What stood out most with this project was the people. Every Prairie employee was respectful, friendly, and clearly proud to be part of the team. You can feel the family atmosphere the mom"
+72
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
Approved (Corporate)
In business since 2002
Free estimates
Warranties offered
"I replaced all my windows, gutters and downspouts. The crew showed on time each day and job took less than 3 days. The area inside and out was cleaned up each day. I was very satisfied with the work that was done. I will use Ridge Top again and recommend them to anyone who needs work done on their home."
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
Approved (Corporate)
In business since 2020
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"Many roofs replace in this area..and leaf guard had the fastest crew that I saw...cleaned up well...great job...."
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2015
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
With several years experience, we work hard to bring each customer the best possible service and quality available. We look forward to working with you on your next project. We welcome your questions and thank you for your interest.
+2
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
In business since 1988
"It went very well. We had some issues with our roof leaking and couldn't find the source or correct the problem. It is an older roof with a few layers of shingles, but we can't afford to replace it quite yet. The owner and one of his employees stopped by and did a thorough inspection of the roof for us and found the main problem. They suggested a quick and dirty fix to immediately remedy the problem until we could afford to replace the roofing. Overall, helpful advice and a great job finding the issue.
"
+100
Serving Arena, WI and surrounding areas
In business since 2015
Free estimates
"Dave arrived on time as promised. He cleaned the gutters as well as removing all the debris. He was friendly, worked hard and I would recommend him to anyone. Excellent job!"
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Gutter repair costs may not be as high as you think—but it depends on the type of damage you're addressing. Learn why you need to hire a gutter pro for this work.
Find out average roof shingle repair costs, factors affecting pricing, such as material and labor, and how to save on your next roof repair project.
Vinyl gutters are solid, low-cost alternatives to expensive metals like steel and copper. Learn what makes up the total project cost for installing them—and where you can save.
Learn how to hire a qualified gutter repair pro. Find tips on credentials, questions to ask, and what to expect for your gutter repair project.
Gutters have a huge responsibility to protect your home from water damage. These simple DIY gutter repair tips will keep rainwater flowing and your home happy.
Are your gutters sagging or leaking? Learn about gutter repair costs, warning signs of water damage, and how to hire the right local pro to fix your system.
