Top-rated plaster repair specialists.

Get matched with top plaster repair specialists in Upper Arlington, OH

There are 9 highly-rated local plaster repair specialists.

Need a pro for your plaster repair project in Upper Arlington, OH?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY UPPER ARLINGTON, OH HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon137
    Verified plaster repairs reviews

Find Plaster repair specialists in Upper Arlington

Mark Monnette Masonry

3087 Grange Hill Pl
4.93(
428
)

Mark Monnette Masonry

3087 Grange Hill Pl
4.93(
428
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers

Mark Monnette Masonry is your trusted choice for all your masonry needs in Columbus and surrounding areas. With over 1 employee dedicated to providing top-notch service, we charge by the job with no hidden travel charges. No job is too small. Contact us today for expert assistance with your masonry project.

"Mark repaired my brick front steps & walk, as well as my brick patio. He also put down polymeric sand. He did a great job for a very reasonable price."

Don P on June 2024

Mark Monnette Masonry is your trusted choice for all your masonry needs in Columbus and surrounding areas. With over 1 employee dedicated to providing top-notch service, we charge by the job with no hidden travel charges. No job is too small. Contact us today for expert assistance with your masonry project.

"Mark repaired my brick front steps & walk, as well as my brick patio. He also put down polymeric sand. He did a great job for a very reasonable price."

Don P on June 2024


Stauffers Painting Systems LLC

1170 Penny St
4.76(
320
)

Stauffers Painting Systems LLC

1170 Penny St
4.76(
320
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers

Owner-operated company serving Columbus and Dayton surrounding areas. We are a full-service provider of interior and exterior painting. We have built our stellar reputation by providing quality painting services, expert customer service and reliability to our customers.

"Stauffer's did a great job on my 2-story Tudor style home with synthetic stucco and cedar trim. I wanted the project done within a month of getting the quote, and they were able to accommodate. There were several parts to the project that they handled: power wash, repair holes in both wood and stucco made by carpenter bees and woodpeckers, replace trim boards that were damaged from incorrect flashing placement, prep and painting of all exterior surfaces including garage doors, entry doors, gutters/downspouts, and chimney flashing. Jorge and his crew worked diligently and with pride in the results. They power washed the entire exterior including all the brick and a large chimney, even removing stains from a rusted chimney cap. Multiple holes were patched and now can't tell where they were. Jerry (the owner) kept in close touch, making sure I understood when they would be doing what, and the options when it came to replacing the rotted wood and repairing damaged stucco. The carpentry expert he brought in for that part of the job did flawless work. During the final inspection, Jerry walked around the house with me and the crew quickly took care of a few things that were missed. One of them had roofing expertise and he fixed how one of the gutters was incorrectly positioned. I would definitely recommend Stauffer's Painting, Jerry is a straight shooter and very nice to work with, and his company does a quality job at a fair price."

Tom T on April 2021

Owner-operated company serving Columbus and Dayton surrounding areas. We are a full-service provider of interior and exterior painting. We have built our stellar reputation by providing quality painting services, expert customer service and reliability to our customers.

"Stauffer's did a great job on my 2-story Tudor style home with synthetic stucco and cedar trim. I wanted the project done within a month of getting the quote, and they were able to accommodate. There were several parts to the project that they handled: power wash, repair holes in both wood and stucco made by carpenter bees and woodpeckers, replace trim boards that were damaged from incorrect flashing placement, prep and painting of all exterior surfaces including garage doors, entry doors, gutters/downspouts, and chimney flashing. Jorge and his crew worked diligently and with pride in the results. They power washed the entire exterior including all the brick and a large chimney, even removing stains from a rusted chimney cap. Multiple holes were patched and now can't tell where they were. Jerry (the owner) kept in close touch, making sure I understood when they would be doing what, and the options when it came to replacing the rotted wood and repairing damaged stucco. The carpentry expert he brought in for that part of the job did flawless work. During the final inspection, Jerry walked around the house with me and the crew quickly took care of a few things that were missed. One of them had roofing expertise and he fixed how one of the gutters was incorrectly positioned. I would definitely recommend Stauffer's Painting, Jerry is a straight shooter and very nice to work with, and his company does a quality job at a fair price."

Tom T on April 2021


The Waterworks

550 Schrock Rd
4.66(
2,430
)

The Waterworks

550 Schrock Rd
4.66(
2,430
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Better care. Better value. Better results. Our well-trained and certified technicians are available to fix all of your plumbing and drain issues, as well as heating and cooling services. We are the drain cleaning and clearing experts. We replace, repair and install everything from toilets and faucets to sump pumps and water heaters, downspouts and main sewer, water and gas lines. We are also your go-to for repair, replace and install for heating and cooling and we offer annual tune-ups. We offer guarantees on our work so that you know the work was completed right the first time! We belong to the Central Ohio Better Business Bureau and are a Consumer Choice winner 21 years running. In addition, we are a NextDoor Neighborhood Favorite and CBUS TOP PICK! Additional emails: [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

"Exactly what I expected - I have used them several times in the past years. They are professional and know the plumbing business inside and out. I am never disappointed."

KATHY K on February 2025

Better care. Better value. Better results. Our well-trained and certified technicians are available to fix all of your plumbing and drain issues, as well as heating and cooling services. We are the drain cleaning and clearing experts. We replace, repair and install everything from toilets and faucets to sump pumps and water heaters, downspouts and main sewer, water and gas lines. We are also your go-to for repair, replace and install for heating and cooling and we offer annual tune-ups. We offer guarantees on our work so that you know the work was completed right the first time! We belong to the Central Ohio Better Business Bureau and are a Consumer Choice winner 21 years running. In addition, we are a NextDoor Neighborhood Favorite and CBUS TOP PICK! Additional emails: [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

"Exactly what I expected - I have used them several times in the past years. They are professional and know the plumbing business inside and out. I am never disappointed."

KATHY K on February 2025


The Durable Slate Co

3933 Groves Rd
4.83(
200
)

The Durable Slate Co

3933 Groves Rd
4.83(
200
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Additional DBA- The Durable Group. Additional emails - [email protected], [email protected]. Additional contact name - Chris Kline. Additional phone numbers - (800) 666-7445, (877) 340-9181.

"we've used durable slate for 15 years for routine maintenance on a slate roof, major repair of copper work after hail damage and on two occasions redoing work mishandled by contractors during remodeling. we've never been disappointed in their work or professionalism."

LINDA L on March 2019

Additional DBA- The Durable Group. Additional emails - [email protected], [email protected]. Additional contact name - Chris Kline. Additional phone numbers - (800) 666-7445, (877) 340-9181.

"we've used durable slate for 15 years for routine maintenance on a slate roof, major repair of copper work after hail damage and on two occasions redoing work mishandled by contractors during remodeling. we've never been disappointed in their work or professionalism."

LINDA L on March 2019


George F Neff & Co. Plaster & Stucco, LLC

491 N Powell Ave
4.91(
245
)

George F Neff & Co. Plaster & Stucco, LLC

491 N Powell Ave
4.91(
245
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

George F Neff and Company, established in 1917, has a proven record of excellence in plaster (new/repair), stucco(new/repair), and decorative product services in the central Ohio area. Family owned and operated, the experienced professionals at George F. Neff and Company will help you realize the resolution to your needs or the fulfillment of your vision.

"They called to schedule the appointment several days ahead, called when they arrived and came a few minutes early. They covered everything and did a professional job."

Suzanne R on August 2020

George F Neff and Company, established in 1917, has a proven record of excellence in plaster (new/repair), stucco(new/repair), and decorative product services in the central Ohio area. Family owned and operated, the experienced professionals at George F. Neff and Company will help you realize the resolution to your needs or the fulfillment of your vision.

"They called to schedule the appointment several days ahead, called when they arrived and came a few minutes early. They covered everything and did a professional job."

Suzanne R on August 2020

...
Showing 141-145 of 145
Plaster Repair questions, answered by experts

If your home was built before the 1940s and was not remodeled in the past 50 or so years, you probably have plaster walls. Aside from assuming, there are some practical ways to tell if you have plaster walls, including the following: If you knock on the wall and it feels solid, not hollow, if you can’t insert a thumbtack easily, if there are cracks that look like spiderwebs, or if your home has curved, arched, or swirled walls, doorways, or window openings.

If you have an unfinished basement or attic, you could examine the backs of any finished walls to check, too.

Plaster is a beautiful finish but is labor-intensive to install and remove. It’s vulnerable to cracking and more sensitive to moisture variance than drywall. Installing plaster on a new wall is an expensive process that can take days to weeks, depending on the scope. Removing a plaster wall can also be quite expensive and time-consuming.

You can apply plaster over plaster, but before you do, check the stability of the existing plaster. If it’s been there for a while, it may require a base coat of PVA emulsion. This will make the existing plaster less porous and ensure the new and old plaster adhere properly.

You can drywall over plaster, but there are some things to consider. First, installing drywall over plaster will increase the wall’s thickness. This could create challenges for window and door frames that no longer fit the wall’s thickness. You may also have to adjust power outlets so they are accessible. When done right, drywall can create a smooth, flat appearance, but it’s best when handled by professionals.

Professionals diagnose underlying causes, such as structural shifts or moisture problems, and apply appropriate solutions like reinforcement, patching, or sealing. These measures restore wall integrity and prevent recurrence, ensuring long-term stability.

By submitting this question, I acknowledge and agree that Angi may publicly display my name, city, state, and question on the website for professionals and others to see.

The Upper Arlington, OH homeowners’ guide to plaster repairs

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.