Top-rated countertop repair pros.

Get matched with top countertop repair pros in Elma, NY

There are 4 highly-rated local countertop repair pros.

Need a pro for your countertop repair project in Elma, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY ELMA, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.3
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon217
    Verified countertop repair services reviews

Countertop Repair reviews from real Angi homeowners in Elma, NY

Last update on October 15, 2025

Find Countertop repair pros in Elma

Avatar for PR Carpentry

PR Carpentry

12 Humboldt Place
4.97(
29
)
•Approved Pro

PR Carpentry

12 Humboldt Place
4.97(
29
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
27 local quotes requested

We specialize in all phases of remodeling for your home and business, including but not limited to.. Home additions. Kitchen remodels. Construction and repair of decks and porches. Installation and/or renovation of stairs and railings. Installation and repair of interior and exterior doors. Faux/Mitered beam construction and installation. Construction and installation of floating shelves and mantles. Installation of Crown molding/wainscoting. Installation of windows and door casing. Hardwood or laminate flooring and baseboards installation. Personalization of above mentioned materials using paint or stain. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Paulo built me a custom closet cabinet. He listened and made sure to incorporate my wants into the project. He also installed hardwood floors, trim, and interior doors, along with painting them. We are looking forward to working with him on upcoming projects in our home."

Danielle H on July 2025

We specialize in all phases of remodeling for your home and business, including but not limited to.. Home additions. Kitchen remodels. Construction and repair of decks and porches. Installation and/or renovation of stairs and railings. Installation and repair of interior and exterior doors. Faux/Mitered beam construction and installation. Construction and installation of floating shelves and mantles. Installation of Crown molding/wainscoting. Installation of windows and door casing. Hardwood or laminate flooring and baseboards installation. Personalization of above mentioned materials using paint or stain. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Paulo built me a custom closet cabinet. He listened and made sure to incorporate my wants into the project. He also installed hardwood floors, trim, and interior doors, along with painting them. We are looking forward to working with him on upcoming projects in our home."

Danielle H on July 2025

Avatar for Hibbard Home Improvement

Hibbard Home Improvement

11 Foxcroft Lane
3.98(
46
)
•Approved Pro

Hibbard Home Improvement

11 Foxcroft Lane
3.98(
46
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
175 local quotes requested
34 years of experience

Hibbard Home Improvement has been in business for over 30 years. We have a full time crew and employ subcontractors periodically if needed. Our current rating with the BBB is A+

"Dale and his staff were wonderful to work with!"

Brittney S on September 2022

Hibbard Home Improvement has been in business for over 30 years. We have a full time crew and employ subcontractors periodically if needed. Our current rating with the BBB is A+

"Dale and his staff were wonderful to work with!"

Brittney S on September 2022

Bilt Rite

35 Pinegrove Ct
4.20(
5
)
•Approved Pro

Bilt Rite

35 Pinegrove Ct
4.20(
5
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
68 local quotes requested
71 years of experience

Business started in 1954. Free Estimates Business Phone 716-570-4777 Building a better WNY one job at a time

"DO NOT HIRE THIS COMPANY!!! You will be sorry. Mike was the worst person I could have hired to do my GC for my new build. In the beginning he was great. Really enjoyed meeting with him and talking about my project. He was your typical sales man, all talk and very lil if any actions. I would catch him multiple times lying to me and making up reasons why things were not getting done. He will over charge you way more than actual costs. He know the business and even better knows how to manipulate people into thinking he will over see the project. I hired him because I was assured he would be there everyday and make sure everything was done correctly. He never showed up and would never get back to you when there was a problem . Worst mistake I ever made contacting him. I would never recommend him to anyone. Your local paper boy would do a better job being your GC. I could write a book on the amount of problems I had with him."

Kevin E on February 2021

Business started in 1954. Free Estimates Business Phone 716-570-4777 Building a better WNY one job at a time

"DO NOT HIRE THIS COMPANY!!! You will be sorry. Mike was the worst person I could have hired to do my GC for my new build. In the beginning he was great. Really enjoyed meeting with him and talking about my project. He was your typical sales man, all talk and very lil if any actions. I would catch him multiple times lying to me and making up reasons why things were not getting done. He will over charge you way more than actual costs. He know the business and even better knows how to manipulate people into thinking he will over see the project. I hired him because I was assured he would be there everyday and make sure everything was done correctly. He never showed up and would never get back to you when there was a problem . Worst mistake I ever made contacting him. I would never recommend him to anyone. Your local paper boy would do a better job being your GC. I could write a book on the amount of problems I had with him."

Kevin E on February 2021

Avatar for Nickel City Repair

Nickel City Repair

5011 Broadway
4.56(
16
)
•Approved Pro

Nickel City Repair

5011 Broadway
4.56(
16
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
469 local quotes requested
4 years of experience

Nickel City Repair is Buffalos finest handy man service. With 15 year experience, I know what it takes to get the job done. There is no job to big or small, we do it all. From painting to fences and all interior work. We are offering free estimates and would love to look at any upcoming project you have in your home. Have a question? Call us or click for a free quote today!

"Very well. Rick showed up with the right tools and quickly finished the job with minimal fuss and mess. Would definitely hire again"

Benjamin J on July 2025

Nickel City Repair is Buffalos finest handy man service. With 15 year experience, I know what it takes to get the job done. There is no job to big or small, we do it all. From painting to fences and all interior work. We are offering free estimates and would love to look at any upcoming project you have in your home. Have a question? Call us or click for a free quote today!

"Very well. Rick showed up with the right tools and quickly finished the job with minimal fuss and mess. Would definitely hire again"

Benjamin J on July 2025

Avatar for Schultz Renovation And Construction, Inc.

Schultz Renovation And Construction, Inc.

49 Green Terrace
5.00(
2
)
•Approved Pro

Schultz Renovation And Construction, Inc.

49 Green Terrace
5.00(
2
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
5 years of experience

Welcome to Schultz Renovation and Construction Inc., proudly servicing Depew and the surrounding areas. Our goal is to complete your project to perfection. We look forward to building long lasting relationships with the customers that we serve. We look forward to serving you. Call us today! You will not be disappointed. 716-425-0797 or email at [email protected]

"Christian is very conscientious about what he is doing, does a good job and cleans up afterwards. Quite a bit of the work he did was when we were gone so I'd leave him a key. He is very trustworthy."

Jim W on March 2021

Welcome to Schultz Renovation and Construction Inc., proudly servicing Depew and the surrounding areas. Our goal is to complete your project to perfection. We look forward to building long lasting relationships with the customers that we serve. We look forward to serving you. Call us today! You will not be disappointed. 716-425-0797 or email at [email protected]

"Christian is very conscientious about what he is doing, does a good job and cleans up afterwards. Quite a bit of the work he did was when we were gone so I'd leave him a key. He is very trustworthy."

Jim W on March 2021

Avatar for Nickel City Property Maintenance

Nickel City Property Maintenance

41 Brandel Avenue
4.91(
58
)
•Approved Pro

Nickel City Property Maintenance

41 Brandel Avenue
4.91(
58
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
20 local quotes requested
5 years of experience

Nickel City Property Maintenance is a locally owned and operated out of Arcade N.Y! Our company values honesty and integrity in aspects of our business. Our services are customized to your individual needs, paying close attention to the details of each project that we are involved with. Please feel free to contact us today at (716)258-2100

"Outstanding! We’re very pleased with Nickel City- Nick did a fantastic job— very fair pricing, on time, quality workmanship— we’ll certainly call upon him for our next project. "

Roger S on September 2025

Nickel City Property Maintenance is a locally owned and operated out of Arcade N.Y! Our company values honesty and integrity in aspects of our business. Our services are customized to your individual needs, paying close attention to the details of each project that we are involved with. Please feel free to contact us today at (716)258-2100

"Outstanding! We’re very pleased with Nickel City- Nick did a fantastic job— very fair pricing, on time, quality workmanship— we’ll certainly call upon him for our next project. "

Roger S on September 2025

Sunrise Proscapes, LLC

24 Park Meadow Drive
5.00(
18
)
•Approved Pro

Sunrise Proscapes, LLC

24 Park Meadow Drive
5.00(
18
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
12 local quotes requested

Sunrise Proscapes, LLC, is a locally owned and operated company that values honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. Our dedicated team of professionals have over 12 years of hands on experience to provide innovative ideas and suggestions tailored to your projects. Our services are customized to your individual needs, paying close attention to the details of each project that we are involved with. Please feel free to contact us today! PLEASE CALL FOR AN APPOINTMENT, Thank you!!

"Sean & his son & crew did a great job with the landscaping in our backyard after we had a hot tub installed. He came up with suggestions on putting in pavers next to the hot tub and concrete pads in the back. He went above and beyond as we added things to the project and he came through with economical ways to complete the additions that we asked for. He even suggested using the extra pavers to make an area for the garbage can. They were professional, courteous and took care to clean up after themselves. I would recommend using him for your landscaping project. Thanks Sean!"

J Z on May 2021

Sunrise Proscapes, LLC, is a locally owned and operated company that values honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. Our dedicated team of professionals have over 12 years of hands on experience to provide innovative ideas and suggestions tailored to your projects. Our services are customized to your individual needs, paying close attention to the details of each project that we are involved with. Please feel free to contact us today! PLEASE CALL FOR AN APPOINTMENT, Thank you!!

"Sean & his son & crew did a great job with the landscaping in our backyard after we had a hot tub installed. He came up with suggestions on putting in pavers next to the hot tub and concrete pads in the back. He went above and beyond as we added things to the project and he came through with economical ways to complete the additions that we asked for. He even suggested using the extra pavers to make an area for the garbage can. They were professional, courteous and took care to clean up after themselves. I would recommend using him for your landscaping project. Thanks Sean!"

J Z on May 2021

Quality Craft Contracting

5200 Merlau Road
4.90(
5
)
•Approved Pro

Quality Craft Contracting

5200 Merlau Road
4.90(
5
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
11 local quotes requested

Here at Quality Craft Contracting, no job is too big. From custom renovations to your dream house built from the ground up, our team and our 70 years of combined experience execute with quality on time, every time. Call us for a free estimate today and check out our website! www.qualitycraftcontracting.com BBB Accredited

"We are in the beginning stages of a Master Bath, Walk in Closet & Laundry room addition. So far so good!"

Paula M on October 2017

Here at Quality Craft Contracting, no job is too big. From custom renovations to your dream house built from the ground up, our team and our 70 years of combined experience execute with quality on time, every time. Call us for a free estimate today and check out our website! www.qualitycraftcontracting.com BBB Accredited

"We are in the beginning stages of a Master Bath, Walk in Closet & Laundry room addition. So far so good!"

Paula M on October 2017

Avatar for Miracle Method of Western New York

Miracle Method of Western New York

645 Ling Rd
5.00(
1
)
•Approved Pro

Miracle Method of Western New York

645 Ling Rd
5.00(
1
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
15 local quotes requested

We are locally owned and operate. No job is too big or too small. Call us today for a free estimate! We are looking forward to going above and beyond on your project soon!

"They did a great job."

Shari C on January 2019

We are locally owned and operate. No job is too big or too small. Call us today for a free estimate! We are looking forward to going above and beyond on your project soon!

"They did a great job."

Shari C on January 2019

Avatar for Bath Planet of Buffalo

Bath Planet of Buffalo

4910 Camp Rd Ste 550
4.74(
96
)
•Approved Pro

Bath Planet of Buffalo

4910 Camp Rd Ste 550
4.74(
96
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
66 local quotes requested
2 years of experience

You deserve a bathroom that is more than just your everyday shower or tub. At Bath Planet, we put our expertise to work to create a spa-like retreat in the comfort of your own home, all without disrupting your daily routine! Our innovative process is engineered to transform your bathroom in as little as a day. Using only the most skilled craftsmen and custom-fabricated products, we'll revamp your outdated bathroom into your favorite room in the house! Bath Planet has also earned the prestigious Good Housekeeping Seal for installing top-quality products. Not only do we stand by our products, so do the experts who have been evaluating consumer products for one-hundred years. We have an outstanding team of consultants, designers, and installers, and we guarantee to handle your remodel with the utmost professionalism. Our expert installers will always respect your home, your time and your hard-earned money - we guarantee it!

"Fast and great work"

Yolanda M on January 2025

You deserve a bathroom that is more than just your everyday shower or tub. At Bath Planet, we put our expertise to work to create a spa-like retreat in the comfort of your own home, all without disrupting your daily routine! Our innovative process is engineered to transform your bathroom in as little as a day. Using only the most skilled craftsmen and custom-fabricated products, we'll revamp your outdated bathroom into your favorite room in the house! Bath Planet has also earned the prestigious Good Housekeeping Seal for installing top-quality products. Not only do we stand by our products, so do the experts who have been evaluating consumer products for one-hundred years. We have an outstanding team of consultants, designers, and installers, and we guarantee to handle your remodel with the utmost professionalism. Our expert installers will always respect your home, your time and your hard-earned money - we guarantee it!

"Fast and great work"

Yolanda M on January 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 208

FAQs for countertop repair projects in Elma, NY

The average cost to hire a handyman ranges from about $40 to $140 per hour. Average project cost ranges between $180 and $700, but the cost per hour and per project depends heavily on the type, size, and complexity of the project. The pro’s experience level and your location also factor into how much a handyman charges per hour or per project. You can also expect to pay higher rates or additional fees for emergency services, or around periods of high customer demand, like holidays. 

There are several countertop options available to fit your lifestyle and needs. 

  • Granite countertops are durable and come in a variety of colors.

  • Soapstone countertops are prone to scratches and best in smaller kitchens.

  • Marble countertops are less durable than granite but a good option for busy kitchens.

  • Slate countertops are stain-resistant, making them easy to clean.

  • Limestone countertops must be sealed often to prevent scratches.

  • Acrylic countertops cost less than granite while still providing durability.

  • Laminate countertops are the most affordable but chip and fade faster.

  • Wood countertops need monthly sealing to maintain.

The cost to install countertops is $3,105 on average. This project cost can range from $400 to $8,500, depending on the material, edging, and countertop size. 

Laminate countertops are generally the most cost-efficient, ranging from $8 to $27 per square foot. On the other hand, slate countertops are considered more luxurious and range from $30 to $90 per square foot. There are also countertop materials priced between those two, including stainless steel, granite, Corian, and wood.

There are several questions or things to know before hiring a handyman to do any work in your home.

  • What kind of work do they do?

  • Do they have proper licensing?

  • Do they charge for estimates?

  • Is the estimate for both labor and materials?

  • Do they provide references?

  • Do you provide a guarantee?

  • When can you start and finish the job?

  • Do you have any before and after photos of your work?

  • How long have you been doing this kind of work?

  • Do you clean up and dispose of waste when the job is finished?

Yes, you should hire a handyman who’s licensed, certified, and insured, if possible. States have different requirements for handyman licensing, registration, and certifications. If licensing is required in your area, you may pay more for a licensed handyman with experience than one who is not licensed or certified, but you’re likely to get a better end result for your project. Be sure to check our state licensing tool to review the local handymen guidelines.

The Elma, NY homeowners’ guide to countertop repair services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles