The rest of the story played out exactly the same as all other reviews....Tom and Corey are very talented, professional, detail oriented, hard working nice guys who take pride in what they do. Our bathtub tiles look like new and the floor that resembled a poorly maintained public restroom...

Get matched with top bathtub replacement pros in Bay Shore, NY
There are 4 highly-rated local bathtub replacement pros.
Need a pro for your bathtub replacement project in Bay Shore, NY?
TRUSTED BY BAY SHORE, NY HOMEOWNERS
4.5
Average homeowner rating1.9k+
Verified bathtub replacements reviews
Verified Reviews for Bathtub Replacement pros in Bay Shore, NY
Last update on October 12, 2025
- Maryjane S.
- Paul M.
Our existing bathtub developed a crack, and was leaking onto the bathroom floor and into the basement. I found this company on Angie's List, and was impressed with the consistent reviews. I requested an estimate, and from that point on everything was outstanding. Mr. Argano contacted me...
- Anand H.
I had called Water Dr to get a quote for replacing a water softener injector pump that had developed a slow leak several months ago. The service guy was quick to respond and came over the same day. But, instead of providing a quote, he patched the motor with duct tape and a dirty towel...
- Jan N.
The plumber from CJ's came out soon after I called and did a temporary fix on the bathtub as he had to order the part. He came back when the new faucet arrived and everything went well. He was personable and I would recommend him.
Find Bathtub replacement pros in Bay Shore

The Honest Cesspool Company
The Honest Cesspool Company
Please consider us for any of your cesspool or drain issues. Make sure to save our number our coupon never expires! Check us out on Instagram for specials, discounts and additional ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ reviews @thehonestcesspoolco
"The experience with Joe and Troy was great they came multiple times until the issues I was having with my septic was resolved. 10/10 would recommend."
Nick B on October 2025
Please consider us for any of your cesspool or drain issues. Make sure to save our number our coupon never expires! Check us out on Instagram for specials, discounts and additional ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ reviews @thehonestcesspoolco
"The experience with Joe and Troy was great they came multiple times until the issues I was having with my septic was resolved. 10/10 would recommend."
Nick B on October 2025

Islandwide Contracting
Islandwide Contracting
At Islandwide Contracting LLC, we have been proudly serving Suffolk County and surrounding areas since 2019, bringing over 30 years of combined experience to every project. Our comprehensive range of residential and commercial construction services includes interior and exterior work, such as medical offices, restaurants, urgent care facilities, dormers, and extensions. We specialize in bathroom and kitchen renovations, as well as basement transformations. Contact us today for a free estimate at 631-779-9277, and let us help you build the dream you envision. **At Islandwide Contracting, we deeply appreciate the dedication and sacrifices of our military personnel, first responders, and senior citizens. As a token of our gratitude, we are proud to offer special discounts tailored specifically for these esteemed groups. Please inquire about these exclusive offers when you contact us, and let us assist you in bringing your vision to life.**
"Excellent. Workers were neat respectful and I was very happy with the results I will be using the company again for any work needed in my home."
Cathy V on June 2025
At Islandwide Contracting LLC, we have been proudly serving Suffolk County and surrounding areas since 2019, bringing over 30 years of combined experience to every project. Our comprehensive range of residential and commercial construction services includes interior and exterior work, such as medical offices, restaurants, urgent care facilities, dormers, and extensions. We specialize in bathroom and kitchen renovations, as well as basement transformations. Contact us today for a free estimate at 631-779-9277, and let us help you build the dream you envision. **At Islandwide Contracting, we deeply appreciate the dedication and sacrifices of our military personnel, first responders, and senior citizens. As a token of our gratitude, we are proud to offer special discounts tailored specifically for these esteemed groups. Please inquire about these exclusive offers when you contact us, and let us assist you in bringing your vision to life.**
"Excellent. Workers were neat respectful and I was very happy with the results I will be using the company again for any work needed in my home."
Cathy V on June 2025
Top Gun Kitchen & Cabinets
Top Gun Kitchen & Cabinets
Full service Kitchen Remodeling company. Specializing in cabinet painting and kitchen face lifts with over 25 years experience. Free consultations. ZERO pressure sales. Let us save you thousands. Call today.
"I would highly recommend Top Gun!! My bath remodel was done on time. They cleaned up before ending each day!! Communication was excellent!!"
Rose F on September 2025
Full service Kitchen Remodeling company. Specializing in cabinet painting and kitchen face lifts with over 25 years experience. Free consultations. ZERO pressure sales. Let us save you thousands. Call today.
"I would highly recommend Top Gun!! My bath remodel was done on time. They cleaned up before ending each day!! Communication was excellent!!"
Rose F on September 2025

Classic Remodeling Group Inc
Classic Remodeling Group Inc
Full service remodeling, roofing and siding contractors serving Long Island. Whether you are in need of new roof installation, roof restoration, or roof repairs; new siding installation, siding repairs; new windows & doors installation; kitchen remodeling; bathroom remodeling; we are the Long Island home remodeling contractors to call, due to our professionalism and affordability.
"Guys did great job! Would hire again."
Beth K on October 2025
Full service remodeling, roofing and siding contractors serving Long Island. Whether you are in need of new roof installation, roof restoration, or roof repairs; new siding installation, siding repairs; new windows & doors installation; kitchen remodeling; bathroom remodeling; we are the Long Island home remodeling contractors to call, due to our professionalism and affordability.
"Guys did great job! Would hire again."
Beth K on October 2025

JBL HOME IMPROVEMENTS INC
JBL HOME IMPROVEMENTS INC
JBL Home Improvements, Inc, located in St. James, is a family owned and operated remodeling business specializing in residential projects. Owner & Contractor David Kaplan, General Manager Jill Kaplan, along with their team of talented professionals, are dedicated to providing outstanding workmanship and customer service to homeowners who live in their community.
"Extremely pleased with the recommended supplies and workmanship."
Noreen C on September 2025
JBL Home Improvements, Inc, located in St. James, is a family owned and operated remodeling business specializing in residential projects. Owner & Contractor David Kaplan, General Manager Jill Kaplan, along with their team of talented professionals, are dedicated to providing outstanding workmanship and customer service to homeowners who live in their community.
"Extremely pleased with the recommended supplies and workmanship."
Noreen C on September 2025

Final Touch Restoration
Final Touch Restoration
Final Touch Restoration Specializes in all phases of Remodeling and Restoration services. From Window, Door, Floor, Kitchens, and Bathroom installations to Water, Wind, Mold, Fire, and Smoke remediation to total home cleaning services. There is no project too small or too large for us to handle.
Final Touch Restoration Specializes in all phases of Remodeling and Restoration services. From Window, Door, Floor, Kitchens, and Bathroom installations to Water, Wind, Mold, Fire, and Smoke remediation to total home cleaning services. There is no project too small or too large for us to handle.

QC Construction
QC Construction
We specialize in interior finish work such as: kitchen and bath remodels, basements, crown molding, trim work, built-ins, and more! We take a personalized approach to each project. We work closely with our clients to understand their vision, preferences, and budgetary requirements. We strive to exceed expectations by delivering exceptional service, great quality work, and professionalism on every job. Read more below on all the services we offer and contact us with any questions or to schedule a free estimate today!
"Install went according to plan. The contractor was clean, organized, and on time. I would definitely use him again for any of my contracting needs."
Liam K on October 2024
We specialize in interior finish work such as: kitchen and bath remodels, basements, crown molding, trim work, built-ins, and more! We take a personalized approach to each project. We work closely with our clients to understand their vision, preferences, and budgetary requirements. We strive to exceed expectations by delivering exceptional service, great quality work, and professionalism on every job. Read more below on all the services we offer and contact us with any questions or to schedule a free estimate today!
"Install went according to plan. The contractor was clean, organized, and on time. I would definitely use him again for any of my contracting needs."
Liam K on October 2024

OZ General Contracting Co Inc
OZ General Contracting Co Inc
OZ General Contracting Co Inc. has an over 30 year extensive portfolio of incredible kitchen and bathroom renovations in Nassau and Suffolk County Long Island, NY. We are innovative, efficient, reliable, and we always exceed our client’s expectations.
"I hired Oz General Contracting Co Inc in 2013 to remodel my kitchen. The company also remodeled my half bath in 2021 and in 2025 remodeled our main bathroom and linen closet. Every project turned out great! Everyone involved with my projects was courteous, talented, and professional. Ozi Ovadia is a master at maximizing space. I highly recommend this company."
Frank D on April 2025
OZ General Contracting Co Inc. has an over 30 year extensive portfolio of incredible kitchen and bathroom renovations in Nassau and Suffolk County Long Island, NY. We are innovative, efficient, reliable, and we always exceed our client’s expectations.
"I hired Oz General Contracting Co Inc in 2013 to remodel my kitchen. The company also remodeled my half bath in 2021 and in 2025 remodeled our main bathroom and linen closet. Every project turned out great! Everyone involved with my projects was courteous, talented, and professional. Ozi Ovadia is a master at maximizing space. I highly recommend this company."
Frank D on April 2025

SCI Construction Group
SCI Construction Group
Family owned business with over 20 years of experience handling all your Remodeling Needs for residential and commercial- Kitchen and Bathrooms, Room Additions, Basements, etc.
Family owned business with over 20 years of experience handling all your Remodeling Needs for residential and commercial- Kitchen and Bathrooms, Room Additions, Basements, etc.

Hampton Bay Construction - Babylon Bay Construction
Hampton Bay Construction - Babylon Bay Construction
Owner owned & operated. Full service remodeling company specializing in medium to large projects. Serving Suffolk county and the Hamptons. High end building and remodeling firm. Expect excellent quality and customer service. Permit and Variance Specialists.
"We went over everything that was going to be done step by step both A.J. and Sam explained and guided us in the process. All came in at budget and in a timely manner. They were clean and reliable. I Will use them for my next project! ps. All of their recommendations for plumbing, electrical and painting were fantastic."
VINCENT S on March 2025
Owner owned & operated. Full service remodeling company specializing in medium to large projects. Serving Suffolk county and the Hamptons. High end building and remodeling firm. Expect excellent quality and customer service. Permit and Variance Specialists.
"We went over everything that was going to be done step by step both A.J. and Sam explained and guided us in the process. All came in at budget and in a timely manner. They were clean and reliable. I Will use them for my next project! ps. All of their recommendations for plumbing, electrical and painting were fantastic."
VINCENT S on March 2025
The Bay Shore, NY homeowners’ guide to bathtub replacements
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Bathtub refinishing costs are relatively inexpensive and can make your bathroom look like new. Our guide gives you the information to learn more about this process.
Accessory dwelling units can be a smart investment, but your ADU cost will depend on the size, type, and materials you choose. Here’s how it breaks down.
Get a breakdown of home remodeling costs by project, from a minor bathroom update to a full kitchen remodel. Learn what factors affect the cost of a home remodel.
The short answer is yes, you can paint a fiberglass tub. But you need the right preparation and paint to transform your bathtub successfully.
Torn between choosing a shower curtain or a glass door? We break down cost, cleanliness, appearance, and comfort to help you pick for your bathroom.
Get inspired for your bathroom makeover with these bathroom remodel ideas, including decor styles and materials to elevate your space.
- East Islip, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Great River, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Islip, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Brightwaters, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- West Islip, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Oakdale, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Islip Terrace, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- West Sayville, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- West Babylon, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- North Babylon, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Babylon, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Sayville, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Lindenhurst, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Bohemia, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Brentwood, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Bayport, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Copiague, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Deer Park, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Central Islip, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Blue Point, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Amityville, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Wyandanch, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Islandia, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Hauppauge, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Ronkonkoma, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Holbrook, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Long Island, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Lake Ronkonkoma, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Massapequa Park, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- Smithtown, NY Bathtub replacement pros
- 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
- 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
- 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"