Top-rated custom home builders.

Best custom home builders near Arcadia, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your custom home building project in Arcadia, IN?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY ARCADIA, IN HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon104
    Verified custom home building reviews

Top-Rated Custom home builders in Arcadia - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Maynor Construction, LLC
Maynor Construction, LLC
4.3(
38
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Arcadia, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1995

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I rarely, if ever give 5 star reviews. But, I DO recommend Maynor Construction (MC)! But, 5 = perfection, and nothing is perfect : ) I hired MC for cement siding and sunroom addition project, beginning in June of 22, ending Sep, 22. I will review the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly. But, this doesn't cover everything, because Home Advisor only allows so many characters. Finally, this was my first (major) home improvement project and likely the largest investment I will ever make in my home. The Good - Maynor (owner) is a very knowledgeable and a skilled builder, with many years of experience. I appreciated that he was actually on site many days, not only supervising, but also working along side his team. - The administrative staff was magnificent. Responsive, knowledgeable, friendly, and available. Having the right people in the front office can make or break a business. Hire the right people to manage the office and it will pay dividends toward the success of your company...in my humble opinion. - I had fiber cement siding installed on my home, and a sunroom that replaced an old, broken-down outdoor breezeway. This was no easy project and teams of highly-skilled workers were at my home daily, typically from before 8am until nearly sundown - and even partially on Saturdays. We were blessed with very little rain through the 3 months, which accelerated the work. Maynor's team worked very hard, moved efficiently, and maintained a great level of skill throughout the process. The Bad - For the most part, none of my utilities were affected all that much. Utility boxes were moved away at the beginning, were moved back at the end, and worked just fine. I also had a lot of electrical added and moved throughout the project, but alterations and small inconveniences were to be expected. However, there was a problem when it came to Maynor's (unintended) disruption of my ATT Fiber. While there was no cutting of that fiber, the siding was installed over the fiber and it shut down my internet. Maynor's workers claimed innocence, but it was clearly something for which they were likely responsible. The fiber cable box was moved back into place, and when I got home the internet wasn't working any longer. This required ATT to come out and reinstall the fiber cable and box that came into my house from the outside. - Kitchen flooring fix. I have a very small special strip of (tiled) kitchen flooring that had to be removed during the remodel because I wanted a small portion of a wall removed. Years ago, this strip was created with very cool, colored, (intentionally) broken glass tiles. But, sadly those tiles are no longer available. Happily, I found some of the original kitchen tile that Maynor could break-up into pieces and install into the strip. I approved a change order for Maynor to fill-in that strip of flooring, which required some pretty major cutting of the floor and sub floor. However, they cut the floor crooked and at an unpleasing angle. And, while it is not terrible, it is very noticeable to me and I wish Maynor had done a better to cut the area straighter. I can live with it, but someday I will need to replace the entire kitchen floor to maintain the professional look. The Ugly - While I live in a populated area, with restaurants, a gas station, hotels, etc... workers, laboring in extremely hot summer conditions, even with lots of shade, require lots of hydration. Those fluids need to go somewhere! Unfortunately, there were at least two instances (likely more), I personally witnessed workers finding their own ways to relieve themselves - not inside my home, nor at the gas station just next door. I complained to Maynor and they promptly brought in, at their expense, a Porta Potty, which would remain for the duration of the project. But, I had to ask them to include and only after I discovered what was happening on my property. Ove..."
Sunroom 2
Sunroom 1
Screened In Porch 1
Screened In Porch 2
Sunroom & Screened Porch

+41

Response time2 days
12 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by96%of homeowners
BBG Construction, LLC
5.0(
2
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Arcadia, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2004

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"BBG Construction did a fabulous job remolding my kitchen. It was a total gut and start over project. Ben the contractor is very good at getting back to you when, called, texted, etc. The job was finished in a timely manner and the contractors who worked on the project were all very competent, trustworthy and friendly. Ben was very easy to work with and kept you updated what the next phase would be. I would hire him again for more remolding projects"
Kitchen Renovation
Kitchen Remodel
Bathroom Renovation
Bathroom Remodel
Response time30 mins
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Wesley Design & Contracting
4.4(
90
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Arcadia, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 2012

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"According to my tenant and her feedback everything was done professionally and they showed up as scheduled. It took a little longer to get the project done and I almost canceled. When I first contacted Mr Wesley I emphasized that I needed to have the work done before Thanksgiving and he did do this. Mr Wesley takes pride in whatever he does and wanted to do a lot more work than the $300 deal I had purchased. I only wanted to use my $300 deal. He did a lot of other estimates on his own and presented me with a higher estimate a little over $3,000. We disagreed on the bathtub lever (use to turn the shower on) that I and the tenant wanted repaired. The job he wanted to do was much more like remodeling the bathtub surround area and fixtures. He did not want to the job unles he could do it his way. This resulted in him not doing this repair and me having someone else come out to do it. I respect his feelings for wanting to do a quality job. I believe Mr Wesley is more of a high quality contractor and not necessary a person for doing small everyday repairs for rentals. I do have some other work that I am considering to ask Mr Wesley to give me a bid for.
"
sheds
Drainage job
remodel
Recommended by82%of homeowners
Avatar for Greg Kearns Builder/Designer
Greg Kearns Builder/Designer
4.5(
158
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Arcadia, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1980

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"The quality of the work was well done.  Greg and Adam are very responsive.  Adam does excellent work, and very fast once he had all the cabinets, etc.  The thing folks need to know is that it takes a very long time to get cabinets custom ordered and to get granite selected and cut.  Make sure you build this in.  Overall I think this project took too long to complete (over two months), but the overall final product was really great.
"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+5

Recommended by89%of homeowners
Avatar for Silverwood Builders
Silverwood Builders
4.6(
33
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Arcadia, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1983

Free estimates

"He was great. Punctual and candid with helpful knowledge on the costs of numerous home-remodeling ideas we have had. Also incredibly helpful insights on how we could better implement some of our ideas. Overall just a great, helpful meeting. Would absolutely consider hiring for a project."
Additional Photos
Carmel
Zionsville
Carmel
Butler-Tarkington

+51

Recommended by96%of homeowners
SMALLING CONSTRUCTION
4.2(
25
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Arcadia, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1996

Emergency services offered

"HOWEVER, he found a company in OH that could create a textured brick and then found a company in northern IN who came and hand stained every brick to match our existing brick.  If you didn't know our home had damage, you wouldn't be able to tell.  They did a beautiful job.  The reno took longer than I thought it would, but they had to find the brick and I know that was a chore. Plus to get on the schedule of the brick painters. Great workers and great job.  .  
"
Recommended by78%of homeowners
Avatar for BMD Electric
BMD Electric
5.0(
11
)
Find a Custom Home Builder

Serving Arcadia, IN and surrounding areas

Free estimates

"Service was excellent. Brandon is very knowledgeable and had some great recommendations on how to implement the work I wanted done. The quality of his work is obvious and it's clear he prioritizes customer satisfaction."
Decks and Porches Project
Remodeling - General Project
Decks and Porches Project
Remodeling - General Project
Decks and Porches Project

+43

Recommended by100%of homeowners
...
Showing 1-10 of 78
Custom Home Builders FAQs, answered by experts

The term “cottage” is subjective, so there’s no rigid definition, but it generally refers to a small home with simple and purposeful architecture that embraces nature and focuses on charm over everything else. Cottages are typically 1 or 1 1/2-stories tall, usually with gabled roofs, and are built out of natural materials that help make the structure a part of the surrounding nature rather than something that stands out from it. A big part of what makes a cottage a cottage is the decor, which includes natural materials from the nearby area.

Modular homes can go up or down in value depending on a few factors. In areas where real estate is appreciating, the value of modular homes is likely to increase, and vice versa. Additionally, the value of modular homes depends partially on the area. In cities where every other home is stick-built, modular homes might be considered a functional obsolescence, in which case they could be less desirable and go down in value. In either case, though, modular homes can still be a good investment, especially since they provide housing at a lower upfront cost.

Whether it’s more affordable to gut a house than build a new one depends on the markets where you'd be buying and selling. However, it’s usually less expensive to renovate a home than to build new construction. 

Most homeowners pay between $100,000 and $200,000 for demolition and remodeling costs, whereas the average cost to build a new home is between $139,000 and $531,300.

Yes, modular homes offer a wide range of customization options for layout, finishes, and features.

Remodeling a house is often less expensive than building a new house. You can expect to pay an average of $100 per square foot when you are remodeling. The cost to build a house averages about $150 per square foot. When remodeling, though, some rooms cost more than $100 per square foot and some cost less. Use a home renovation cost estimator to accurately estimate your remodeling costs.

The Arcadia, IN homeowners’ guide to custom home building

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.