Top-rated water heater pros.

Get matched with top water heater pros in Lancaster, WI

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

TRUSTED BY LANCASTER, WI HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.2
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon10
    Verified water heater services reviews

Verified Reviews for Water Heater Service pros in Lancaster, WI

*The Angi rating for Water Heater Service companies in Lancaster, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Water Heater Service companies in Lancaster, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.

Last update on November 23, 2025

Find Water heater pros in Lancaster

Avatar for AppliancePartsPros.com

AppliancePartsPros.com

4.73(
287
)

AppliancePartsPros.com

4.73(
287
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Since 1999, we've helped millions of do-it-yourselfers save money and fix their broken appliances quickly by providing quality appliance parts and free repair advice. We are only an online appliance parts retailer that offers a 365 day warranty and fast shipping. We also offer technical advice and diagnosis totally free 6 days a week. If you are interested in repairing your own appliance, please call us at 1-877-477-7278 or click live chat on our web site. We will help diagnose the problem and provide you with all the necessary information for the repair free of charge. It's better with the Pros!™ Avoid costly service calls - visit us at http://www.appliancepartspros.com

"Beware of shipping issues with this company. Ordered an ice maker installation kit on 10/10/25. Shipping was due no later than 10/20 according to company and FedEx tracking. FedEx tracking showed the package at their facility for 8 days without moving beginning on 10/15. Called FedEx 3 times. Each time they said they cannot find package and I have to contact shipper. Shipper has to make a claim, they will not mark it as lost. Called Appliance Parts Pros twice. Each time they say FedEx has to mark package lost before they will do anything. They also state they have to wait 14 days from them before doing anything because of their contract with FedEx. I don't care about their contract, I want what was ordered and paid for. Just going in circles with them and FedEX. If they shipped after 14 days it would be 22 days from that point, 32 days from the date of order if they shipped it that day. There was a deadline for installing this part before tenants arrive. They did not care, would not m"

Ron R on October 2025

Since 1999, we've helped millions of do-it-yourselfers save money and fix their broken appliances quickly by providing quality appliance parts and free repair advice. We are only an online appliance parts retailer that offers a 365 day warranty and fast shipping. We also offer technical advice and diagnosis totally free 6 days a week. If you are interested in repairing your own appliance, please call us at 1-877-477-7278 or click live chat on our web site. We will help diagnose the problem and provide you with all the necessary information for the repair free of charge. It's better with the Pros!™ Avoid costly service calls - visit us at http://www.appliancepartspros.com

"Beware of shipping issues with this company. Ordered an ice maker installation kit on 10/10/25. Shipping was due no later than 10/20 according to company and FedEx tracking. FedEx tracking showed the package at their facility for 8 days without moving beginning on 10/15. Called FedEx 3 times. Each time they said they cannot find package and I have to contact shipper. Shipper has to make a claim, they will not mark it as lost. Called Appliance Parts Pros twice. Each time they say FedEx has to mark package lost before they will do anything. They also state they have to wait 14 days from them before doing anything because of their contract with FedEx. I don't care about their contract, I want what was ordered and paid for. Just going in circles with them and FedEX. If they shipped after 14 days it would be 22 days from that point, 32 days from the date of order if they shipped it that day. There was a deadline for installing this part before tenants arrive. They did not care, would not m"

Ron R on October 2025

All Seasons Heating & Cooling

4.84(
25
)

All Seasons Heating & Cooling

4.84(
25
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers

Additional emails - [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected].

"They do excellent work."

pam w on November 2020

Additional emails - [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected].

"They do excellent work."

pam w on November 2020

Avatar for Service One

Service One

4.57(
132
)

Service One

4.57(
132
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Locally owned and operated for 25 years ServiceOne is your One Simple Solution... With over 90 employees ready to HELP, we are your friends, family and neighbors. Our Residential and Commercial Service Departments employ highly trained technicians, who are licensed, bonded and insured. We guarantee your 100% satisfaction.

"They fixed the furnace instead of us having to go buy a new one. Which saved us about $4,000.00. Our experience was really good. They took the time to explain everything to my husband and gave us a really good price and saved us money."

Cindy S on July 2020

Locally owned and operated for 25 years ServiceOne is your One Simple Solution... With over 90 employees ready to HELP, we are your friends, family and neighbors. Our Residential and Commercial Service Departments employ highly trained technicians, who are licensed, bonded and insured. We guarantee your 100% satisfaction.

"They fixed the furnace instead of us having to go buy a new one. Which saved us about $4,000.00. Our experience was really good. They took the time to explain everything to my husband and gave us a really good price and saved us money."

Cindy S on July 2020

Henson Robinson Co

4.58(
19
)

Henson Robinson Co

4.58(
19
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

With over 150 years of experience, Henson Robinson Company is Central Illinois' most established commercial/residential contractor. With expert design, professional installation, unsurpassed craftsmanship and proven long-term support; Henson Robinson Company has indeed withstood the test of time. When you want a greater return on your investment in roofing, residential and commercial heating and cooling, commercial plumbing and mechanical projects.....you can depend on us. Additional email - [email protected]. Additional address - PO Box 13137, Springfield, IL 62791.

With over 150 years of experience, Henson Robinson Company is Central Illinois' most established commercial/residential contractor. With expert design, professional installation, unsurpassed craftsmanship and proven long-term support; Henson Robinson Company has indeed withstood the test of time. When you want a greater return on your investment in roofing, residential and commercial heating and cooling, commercial plumbing and mechanical projects.....you can depend on us. Additional email - [email protected]. Additional address - PO Box 13137, Springfield, IL 62791.

Avatar for High Tech Home Warranties

High Tech Home Warranties

4.37(
35
)

High Tech Home Warranties

4.37(
35
)
Customers say: Terrific value
2008 years of experience

We are a one stop shop for all your home warranty needs. Our upbeat and friendly support team is always at your fingertips to respond to questions about your warranty 365 days a year! Emergency claims will be addressed within 24 hours from time claim is submitted and non-emergency claims will be addressed within 48 hours Monday - Friday 8:30 am - 6:00 pm. During nights and weekends non-emergency claims will not receive a call back until the next business day. Our service call deductibles range from $65 - $75.

"I had a bad computer board in my oven. they said they would not cover it because they found a roach. This is Florida we have some roaches. i do not have a bug problem. It has nothing to do with a bad computer board. This company looks for a way to deny claims. i had one other claim and they tried to deny it as well. Save yourself some agravation and stay away. They must post their own positive reviews. They took my $65.00 fee and did nothing"

marc g on August 2018

We are a one stop shop for all your home warranty needs. Our upbeat and friendly support team is always at your fingertips to respond to questions about your warranty 365 days a year! Emergency claims will be addressed within 24 hours from time claim is submitted and non-emergency claims will be addressed within 48 hours Monday - Friday 8:30 am - 6:00 pm. During nights and weekends non-emergency claims will not receive a call back until the next business day. Our service call deductibles range from $65 - $75.

"I had a bad computer board in my oven. they said they would not cover it because they found a roach. This is Florida we have some roaches. i do not have a bug problem. It has nothing to do with a bad computer board. This company looks for a way to deny claims. i had one other claim and they tried to deny it as well. Save yourself some agravation and stay away. They must post their own positive reviews. They took my $65.00 fee and did nothing"

marc g on August 2018

Avatar for Service Guard - A Division of Black Hills Energy

Service Guard - A Division of Black Hills Energy

5.00(
6
)

Service Guard - A Division of Black Hills Energy

5.00(
6
)
Customers say: Terrific value
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We're Service Guard, and we fix appliances! We're a division of natural gas and electric utility Black Hills Energy, and we operate in Colorado, Iowa, Kansas and Nebraska. We've been providing peace of mind protection against the unexpected cost and hassle of appliance repair for over 35 years. You owe it to yourself to learn more about Service Guard.

We're Service Guard, and we fix appliances! We're a division of natural gas and electric utility Black Hills Energy, and we operate in Colorado, Iowa, Kansas and Nebraska. We've been providing peace of mind protection against the unexpected cost and hassle of appliance repair for over 35 years. You owe it to yourself to learn more about Service Guard.

Avatar for Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Dubuque

Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Dubuque

4.29(
14
)

Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Dubuque

4.29(
14
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Emergency services offered

At Mr. Rooter® Plumbing every customer’s individual needs are important. Whether it’s a simple sink clog or a damaged sewer line, you can count on a Mr. Rooter plumber to take care of your plumbing needs – day or night – with never an overtime charge. Our professional service, quality products and honest, up-front pricing make Mr. Rooter the best value in plumbing services nationwide. Mr. Rooter is ready for all emergency plumbing issues, from clogged drains and sewage backups to frozen pipes and leaking water heaters. You can count on an expert diagnosis from Mr. Rooter with our camera inspection tools. Then we’ll fix it right the first time, whether it takes HydroScrub® drain cleaning or trenchless pipe repair, with courteous smiles on our faces. There's a reason they call us Mr.® Call your local Mr. Rooter today.

"Mr Rooter showed up and spent 3 hours augering on our kitchen sink drain that was draining very slow. The tech gave up and started instructing me to find where the drain line ran in the basement and start cutting inspection holes in the drywall ceiling and walls to cut into pipe in the basement. Left with sinks in kitchen both full and drain was then completely plugged. Charged me $320 to make my problem worse. I called Kruser Septic the next day. They showed up and used a small jet and within 45 minutes the drain was running free and junk was completely blown out of the pipe. Total bill was $180 with 2 service techs on site."

Nick B on December 2022

At Mr. Rooter® Plumbing every customer’s individual needs are important. Whether it’s a simple sink clog or a damaged sewer line, you can count on a Mr. Rooter plumber to take care of your plumbing needs – day or night – with never an overtime charge. Our professional service, quality products and honest, up-front pricing make Mr. Rooter the best value in plumbing services nationwide. Mr. Rooter is ready for all emergency plumbing issues, from clogged drains and sewage backups to frozen pipes and leaking water heaters. You can count on an expert diagnosis from Mr. Rooter with our camera inspection tools. Then we’ll fix it right the first time, whether it takes HydroScrub® drain cleaning or trenchless pipe repair, with courteous smiles on our faces. There's a reason they call us Mr.® Call your local Mr. Rooter today.

"Mr Rooter showed up and spent 3 hours augering on our kitchen sink drain that was draining very slow. The tech gave up and started instructing me to find where the drain line ran in the basement and start cutting inspection holes in the drywall ceiling and walls to cut into pipe in the basement. Left with sinks in kitchen both full and drain was then completely plugged. Charged me $320 to make my problem worse. I called Kruser Septic the next day. They showed up and used a small jet and within 45 minutes the drain was running free and junk was completely blown out of the pipe. Total bill was $180 with 2 service techs on site."

Nick B on December 2022

Patterson Comfort & Safety

4.33(
12
)

Patterson Comfort & Safety

4.33(
12
)
Customers say: Super punctual
1970 years of experience

Additional contact names - Steve Davis, or Robb Beltran. Call 563-556-4587 to save money on your utility bill now. Patterson Comfort & Safety is Dubuque, Iowa's leading provider of residential and commercial quality heating, air conditioning, radon mitigation and testing, service and repair. We also offer the convenience and peace of mind knowing you can stop one place to see a complete selection of fireplaces, inserts, stoves, surrounds, brick and stone products, and accessories. Ask about our free indoor air quality evaluation to help you improve the air quality in your home or business.

Additional contact names - Steve Davis, or Robb Beltran. Call 563-556-4587 to save money on your utility bill now. Patterson Comfort & Safety is Dubuque, Iowa's leading provider of residential and commercial quality heating, air conditioning, radon mitigation and testing, service and repair. We also offer the convenience and peace of mind knowing you can stop one place to see a complete selection of fireplaces, inserts, stoves, surrounds, brick and stone products, and accessories. Ask about our free indoor air quality evaluation to help you improve the air quality in your home or business.

Avatar for Warmzone

Warmzone

4.00(
3
)

Warmzone

4.00(
3
)
Customers say: Quick response
2003 years of experience

WARMZONE is a national company designs and sells radiant snow removal systems for heated driveways and walkways, radiant floor heating and roof deicing. We have a trained staff of professionals that will learn about your project requirements and perscribe the best solution possible to heat your driveway or home. We have a network of subcontractors across the United States. Our consultations and designs are free and we have one of the largest selection of proven products to choose from. Call or email us to receive a free quote.

"They were absolutely wonderful. Will sure recommend them"

jorge d on April 2018

WARMZONE is a national company designs and sells radiant snow removal systems for heated driveways and walkways, radiant floor heating and roof deicing. We have a trained staff of professionals that will learn about your project requirements and perscribe the best solution possible to heat your driveway or home. We have a network of subcontractors across the United States. Our consultations and designs are free and we have one of the largest selection of proven products to choose from. Call or email us to receive a free quote.

"They were absolutely wonderful. Will sure recommend them"

jorge d on April 2018

Showing 1-10 of 24
Water Heaters questions, answered by experts

The average lifespan of a water heater is eight to 12 years. If your water heater is approaching its first decade of life and is giving you problems, talk to a plumber about your replacement options.

Keep in mind that certain parts of a water heater, such as the anode rod, may need replacement long before the heater itself. An anode rod often has a lifespan of three to five years.

If you’re having problems with your hot water heater and it’s 10 to 15 years old—the typical life span of a gas hot water heater—you may want to consider replacing it rather than repairing it. Water heater replacement costs about $1,300 on average. If your water heater is younger than nine or 10 years, paying for repairs is most likely worth it. You can always have a plumber assess your fixture to see what it would cost to fix it and then decide if it’s more cost-effective in the long run to replace it.

The average cost to replace a water heater is $1,325. How much your replacement heater costs depends on the type, size, and complexity of installation. Gas and electric heaters may cost a similar amount out of pocket, but one type may cost more to operate than the other, depending on the cost of utilities in your area.

The chemicals in a water softener can wear down the anode rod in the heater and shorten its life span. However, for most people, the benefits of the softener outweigh this potential drawback.

Have a plumber inspect the anode rod annually for damage, as replacing the anode rod is far less expensive than replacing the entire water heater.

If your gas water heater is over 20 years old, it should be replaced. Gas water heaters can last up to 12 years and while they can exceed this expectancy if well-maintained, a heater that's 20 years old would require replacement. The heater is unlikely to run as efficiently as a new model and could be more expensive to do so.

The Lancaster, WI homeowners’ guide to water heater services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"