Top-rated bathtub replacement pros.

Get matched with top bathtub replacement pros in Colgate, WI

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your bathtub replacement project in Colgate, WI?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY COLGATE, WI HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.6
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon1.1k+
    Verified bathtub replacements reviews

Find Bathtub replacement pros in Colgate

Avatar for Premier Water Heaters LLC

Premier Water Heaters LLC

4.98(
911
)
Approved Pro

Premier Water Heaters LLC

4.98(
911
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers
13 years of experience

Here at Premier Water Heaters, we specialize in water heater installations. We take a very unique "no markup" approach to our water heaters, which helps keep our installations very affordable (usually at least $300.00 less than our competition). We also offer a "You buy it, we install it" option, which can save our customers even more money. Locally owned and operated, we have serviced the Southeast Wisconsin area for over 25 years. We run daily routes in the Milwaukee / Waukesha / Racine / Kenosha area as well as the Madison / Janesville / Beloit area. Please check out our customer reviews... They literally tell our whole story! Customer satisfaction has always been our primary concern, so be sure to give us a call today! (262)880-3373

"great job and price"

Dennis F on November 2025

Here at Premier Water Heaters, we specialize in water heater installations. We take a very unique "no markup" approach to our water heaters, which helps keep our installations very affordable (usually at least $300.00 less than our competition). We also offer a "You buy it, we install it" option, which can save our customers even more money. Locally owned and operated, we have serviced the Southeast Wisconsin area for over 25 years. We run daily routes in the Milwaukee / Waukesha / Racine / Kenosha area as well as the Madison / Janesville / Beloit area. Please check out our customer reviews... They literally tell our whole story! Customer satisfaction has always been our primary concern, so be sure to give us a call today! (262)880-3373

"great job and price"

Dennis F on November 2025


Avatar for Mad City Windows & Baths

Mad City Windows & Baths

4.83(
2,970
)
Approved Pro

Mad City Windows & Baths

4.83(
2,970
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
27 years of experience

We are the premier home improvement company in Madison, Green Bay, Milwaukee & throughout Wisconsin with years of experience and countless home improvement projects to prove it. We’re locally owned and operated so we know what works best in this climate and we choose quality products designed with Wisconsin area homeowners in mind. Whether you need replacement windows, vinyl siding, bathrooms, or metal roofing our professional installers will leave your home looking great.

"Every step of the way was completed with care and transparency. It was wonderful being able to support a business created from my wife's home state. The work they did on both the patio door and out bathroom remodel was phenomenal-to include the issue with shipping. (manufacture sent the wrong glass panel that was too long for our project- so not a mad city problem themselves). They were quick with the whole process - patio door being done in half a day and the bathroom in two days of actual work time. Even the wait for the correct panel piece went by fast and smooth. We love the work they did to our home and love the Lifetime Warranty even more! They were professional, clean, and thorough with the work they did!"

Wilfredo N on December 2025

We are the premier home improvement company in Madison, Green Bay, Milwaukee & throughout Wisconsin with years of experience and countless home improvement projects to prove it. We’re locally owned and operated so we know what works best in this climate and we choose quality products designed with Wisconsin area homeowners in mind. Whether you need replacement windows, vinyl siding, bathrooms, or metal roofing our professional installers will leave your home looking great.

"Every step of the way was completed with care and transparency. It was wonderful being able to support a business created from my wife's home state. The work they did on both the patio door and out bathroom remodel was phenomenal-to include the issue with shipping. (manufacture sent the wrong glass panel that was too long for our project- so not a mad city problem themselves). They were quick with the whole process - patio door being done in half a day and the bathroom in two days of actual work time. Even the wait for the correct panel piece went by fast and smooth. We love the work they did to our home and love the Lifetime Warranty even more! They were professional, clean, and thorough with the work they did!"

Wilfredo N on December 2025


Avatar for Integrity Plumbing LLC

Integrity Plumbing LLC

4.96(
84
)
Approved Pro

Integrity Plumbing LLC

4.96(
84
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers
16 years of experience

Integrity Plumbing LLC of Fredonia, WI is a licensed and insured business offering expert plumbing solutions at competitive rates. Owned by Jim Guarino, our business is dedicated to provide prompt plumbing services, quality workmanship, and satisfaction to our valued commercial and residential customers in Sheboygan County and beyond.

"Very professional, courteous. Did a great job. Generally, good communication about scheduling and timing of the job. "

Robert C on December 2025

Integrity Plumbing LLC of Fredonia, WI is a licensed and insured business offering expert plumbing solutions at competitive rates. Owned by Jim Guarino, our business is dedicated to provide prompt plumbing services, quality workmanship, and satisfaction to our valued commercial and residential customers in Sheboygan County and beyond.

"Very professional, courteous. Did a great job. Generally, good communication about scheduling and timing of the job. "

Robert C on December 2025


Avatar for High Quality Contracting Inc

High Quality Contracting Inc

4.91(
176
)
Approved Pro

High Quality Contracting Inc

4.91(
176
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
26 years of experience

**Call us today for your FREE ROOFING consultation!** For over 20 years, High Quality Contracting Inc has been a leading home contractor in southeastern Wisconsin. Our dedication to craftsmanship and quality has made us an A+ BBB accredited company and an Angie'sList Super Service Award recipient for decades. We focus on customer relationships to help not only build your dream home but to help build a history of trust you can count on when you need it most. We treat your home as if it were our own, ever conscious of the work we are doing and the impression we leave with you. High Quality Contracting Inc provides services in all forms of home improvement construction and building new homes from the ground up. We offer the following discounts which can not be combined with any other discount. Only one discount per customer per job. * We offer a 5% discount on labor for jobs over $2,500.00 for AngiesList subscribers. ( Must be claimed at the time of the consultation) * We offer a 5% discount on labor for Seniors. ( Must be claimed at the time of the consultation) * We offer a 10% Military discount on labor for active or veterans who show their DD214 at the time of the consultation. We offer one free consultation. We look forward to assisting you with your next project.

"High quality is exactly what we received when building our new home! Nick really made the whole process stress-free and enjoyable. He made sure to be available whenever and went above and beyond to make sure our dream home was perfect. We highly recommend Nick and his team!"

April H on December 2024

**Call us today for your FREE ROOFING consultation!** For over 20 years, High Quality Contracting Inc has been a leading home contractor in southeastern Wisconsin. Our dedication to craftsmanship and quality has made us an A+ BBB accredited company and an Angie'sList Super Service Award recipient for decades. We focus on customer relationships to help not only build your dream home but to help build a history of trust you can count on when you need it most. We treat your home as if it were our own, ever conscious of the work we are doing and the impression we leave with you. High Quality Contracting Inc provides services in all forms of home improvement construction and building new homes from the ground up. We offer the following discounts which can not be combined with any other discount. Only one discount per customer per job. * We offer a 5% discount on labor for jobs over $2,500.00 for AngiesList subscribers. ( Must be claimed at the time of the consultation) * We offer a 5% discount on labor for Seniors. ( Must be claimed at the time of the consultation) * We offer a 10% Military discount on labor for active or veterans who show their DD214 at the time of the consultation. We offer one free consultation. We look forward to assisting you with your next project.

"High quality is exactly what we received when building our new home! Nick really made the whole process stress-free and enjoyable. He made sure to be available whenever and went above and beyond to make sure our dream home was perfect. We highly recommend Nick and his team!"

April H on December 2024


Avatar for Top Bros Construction & Remodeling Inc.

Top Bros Construction & Remodeling Inc.

4.97(
64
)
Approved Pro

Top Bros Construction & Remodeling Inc.

4.97(
64
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
25 years of experience

Top Bros Construction & Remodeling Inc. is a family owned business by two brothers that love to create customers imaginations into realities. We as Top Bros Construction do all kind of interior remodeling in people's homes. From remodeling your bathrooms into master bathrooms or having the nicest kitchen you ever picture. We also install all hard surface floors starting from vinyl planks, laminate, vct tile, hardwood, engineer hardwood, ceramics. We refinishing and varnish hardwood floors as well as stairs and handrails. Were love to help our customers go thru the whole experience in a great matter of order and completion.

"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Absolutely Stunning Refinish – Highly Recommend! I couldn't be happier with the way our hardwood floors turned out! We had some old, torn-up floors that honestly looked like they were beyond saving—but the transformation is unbelievable. After the refinishing, they look like brand new floors, absolutely gorgeous, with a smooth, rich finish that completely elevates the look of our home. Not only was the quality of the work exceptional, but the price was also more than fair—especially considering the results. On top of that, they were incredibly professional: they showed up 15 minutes early, ready to work, and clearly take pride in what they do. It’s rare to find that kind of reliability and craftsmanship these days. If you're thinking about getting your hardwood floors redone, do it—and call these folks. I can't recommend them enough!"

shane m on July 2025

Top Bros Construction & Remodeling Inc. is a family owned business by two brothers that love to create customers imaginations into realities. We as Top Bros Construction do all kind of interior remodeling in people's homes. From remodeling your bathrooms into master bathrooms or having the nicest kitchen you ever picture. We also install all hard surface floors starting from vinyl planks, laminate, vct tile, hardwood, engineer hardwood, ceramics. We refinishing and varnish hardwood floors as well as stairs and handrails. Were love to help our customers go thru the whole experience in a great matter of order and completion.

"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Absolutely Stunning Refinish – Highly Recommend! I couldn't be happier with the way our hardwood floors turned out! We had some old, torn-up floors that honestly looked like they were beyond saving—but the transformation is unbelievable. After the refinishing, they look like brand new floors, absolutely gorgeous, with a smooth, rich finish that completely elevates the look of our home. Not only was the quality of the work exceptional, but the price was also more than fair—especially considering the results. On top of that, they were incredibly professional: they showed up 15 minutes early, ready to work, and clearly take pride in what they do. It’s rare to find that kind of reliability and craftsmanship these days. If you're thinking about getting your hardwood floors redone, do it—and call these folks. I can't recommend them enough!"

shane m on July 2025


Avatar for HAHN'S WATER WELL PUMP SERVICE INC

HAHN'S WATER WELL PUMP SERVICE INC

5.00(
18
)
Approved Pro

HAHN'S WATER WELL PUMP SERVICE INC

5.00(
18
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
27 years of experience

Looking for reliable well and pump services? Look no further! Hahn's Water Well Pump Service Inc is your trusted choice in Milwaukee. As a family owned and operated business, we prioritize quality and customer satisfaction. Contact us today for all your well and pump needs!

"Ben was very responsive, answering the phone every time we called (never went to voice-mail), showed up on time, completed the work in a timely manner and delivered results. We would highly recommend him."

Sue L on July 2022

Looking for reliable well and pump services? Look no further! Hahn's Water Well Pump Service Inc is your trusted choice in Milwaukee. As a family owned and operated business, we prioritize quality and customer satisfaction. Contact us today for all your well and pump needs!

"Ben was very responsive, answering the phone every time we called (never went to voice-mail), showed up on time, completed the work in a timely manner and delivered results. We would highly recommend him."

Sue L on July 2022


Avatar for RNR

RNR

5.00(
25
)
Approved Pro

RNR

5.00(
25
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
9 years of experience

Our mission is to be a provider that brings back the personal touch with our customers. We will build a relationship that will last a lifetime. We feel invested in our clients and strive for customer satisfaction. We do roofing/roof repair, vents and gutters, general contracting, porches and decks, fencing and landscaping. We won't leave until the job is done right! Call or click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Fantastic!! Highly recommend RNR!! We are Very happy with their great job!! When another project comes up they are going to be our first call! Excellent company!!"

Shelly C on May 2025

Our mission is to be a provider that brings back the personal touch with our customers. We will build a relationship that will last a lifetime. We feel invested in our clients and strive for customer satisfaction. We do roofing/roof repair, vents and gutters, general contracting, porches and decks, fencing and landscaping. We won't leave until the job is done right! Call or click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Fantastic!! Highly recommend RNR!! We are Very happy with their great job!! When another project comes up they are going to be our first call! Excellent company!!"

Shelly C on May 2025


Avatar for Matrix Basement Finishing

Matrix Basement Finishing

4.73(
255
)
Approved Pro

Matrix Basement Finishing

4.73(
255
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
16 years of experience

We are a locally owned and operated basement finishing specialist servicing the Chicagoland area. Our focus is providing clients with a clear, upfront vision of expectations through a design/build approach. Our free design service provides potential customers with a collaborative consultation geared towards budget, wants, needs and lifestyle.

"Matrix Basement Solutions did an outstanding job finishing our basement! From start to finish, the entire process was smooth, organized, and professional. Scheduling was always on time, and we truly appreciated the clear communication throughout the project. Our project manager, Ben Gibbons, was awesome—knowledgeable, attentive, and always willing to answer questions. He made sure every detail was handled and kept the project running seamlessly. The subcontractors were also fantastic. Their workmanship was excellent, they were respectful of our home, and they completed everything with great care. We are extremely happy with our new basement and couldn’t be more pleased with the results. We highly recommend Matrix Basement Solutions to anyone looking for quality work."

Nicole H on December 2025

We are a locally owned and operated basement finishing specialist servicing the Chicagoland area. Our focus is providing clients with a clear, upfront vision of expectations through a design/build approach. Our free design service provides potential customers with a collaborative consultation geared towards budget, wants, needs and lifestyle.

"Matrix Basement Solutions did an outstanding job finishing our basement! From start to finish, the entire process was smooth, organized, and professional. Scheduling was always on time, and we truly appreciated the clear communication throughout the project. Our project manager, Ben Gibbons, was awesome—knowledgeable, attentive, and always willing to answer questions. He made sure every detail was handled and kept the project running seamlessly. The subcontractors were also fantastic. Their workmanship was excellent, they were respectful of our home, and they completed everything with great care. We are extremely happy with our new basement and couldn’t be more pleased with the results. We highly recommend Matrix Basement Solutions to anyone looking for quality work."

Nicole H on December 2025


Avatar for Accurate Basement Repair

Accurate Basement Repair

4.99(
37
)
Approved Pro

Accurate Basement Repair

4.99(
37
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
25 years of experience

Accurate Basement Repair, LLC, offers a comprehensive, cost-effective repair for your foundation restoration, and waterproofing needs. We do interior drain tile, steel brace wall reinforcements, full excavation, exterior drain tile, crawl space repair, wall rebuilds, underpinning/piering, egress windows, garage foundation repair, and drain tile testing. We are fully licensed, bonded, and insured. We are not a franchise. Accurate Basement Repair, LLC, has Wisconsin's only nationally certified structural repair and waterproofing specialists on staff, and we have over 20 years of experience. Our high quality and well-maintained equipment provides the lowest impact to exterior and interior spaces, and we provide outstanding customer service before, during, and after the repair process. Accurate Basement Repair, LLC, is proud to have an A+ rating with the BBB and over 700 5-star reviews on Google! We are Wisconsin's #1 resource for foundation restoration and waterproofing.

"The senior project specialist was Jimmy. He did a great job of keeping us informed at all stages of the project (interior drain tile installation). Nanod was the plumber who did the final installation of the sump pump set-up and discharge configuration. Nanod did an outstanding job on the route of the discharge piping , having assessed that the originally considered discharge configuration might have adversely affected our neighbor."

Michael S on February 2024

Accurate Basement Repair, LLC, offers a comprehensive, cost-effective repair for your foundation restoration, and waterproofing needs. We do interior drain tile, steel brace wall reinforcements, full excavation, exterior drain tile, crawl space repair, wall rebuilds, underpinning/piering, egress windows, garage foundation repair, and drain tile testing. We are fully licensed, bonded, and insured. We are not a franchise. Accurate Basement Repair, LLC, has Wisconsin's only nationally certified structural repair and waterproofing specialists on staff, and we have over 20 years of experience. Our high quality and well-maintained equipment provides the lowest impact to exterior and interior spaces, and we provide outstanding customer service before, during, and after the repair process. Accurate Basement Repair, LLC, is proud to have an A+ rating with the BBB and over 700 5-star reviews on Google! We are Wisconsin's #1 resource for foundation restoration and waterproofing.

"The senior project specialist was Jimmy. He did a great job of keeping us informed at all stages of the project (interior drain tile installation). Nanod was the plumber who did the final installation of the sump pump set-up and discharge configuration. Nanod did an outstanding job on the route of the discharge piping , having assessed that the originally considered discharge configuration might have adversely affected our neighbor."

Michael S on February 2024


Avatar for Mad City Windows & Baths

Mad City Windows & Baths

4.74(
624
)
Approved Pro

Mad City Windows & Baths

4.74(
624
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
24 years of experience

To learn about Mad City Windows and its history, you need to start back in 1998 when our family-owned company first opened its doors and changed the face of home remodeling in Wisconsin. From the beginning, our business has been built on a foundation of friendship and trust and, in return, local homeowners have come to know they can place their trust in us. In order make certain that we consistently earn that trust, we are dedicated to ensuring the expert, seamless delivery of high-quality products and remodeling solutions to homeowners throughout our service area. Today, we expand our home remodeling expertise across Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa and Illinois. With over 50,000 completed projects, we take our 2+ decades of experience to serve the communities of Minnesota, Iowa and Illinois. They can expect our highest standard of service and professionalism.

"High pressure sales person which ended up with a mismatch of the rest of my bathroom. They refuse to make it right. . I would recommend that you go with a different company. "

Karen P on November 2025

To learn about Mad City Windows and its history, you need to start back in 1998 when our family-owned company first opened its doors and changed the face of home remodeling in Wisconsin. From the beginning, our business has been built on a foundation of friendship and trust and, in return, local homeowners have come to know they can place their trust in us. In order make certain that we consistently earn that trust, we are dedicated to ensuring the expert, seamless delivery of high-quality products and remodeling solutions to homeowners throughout our service area. Today, we expand our home remodeling expertise across Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa and Illinois. With over 50,000 completed projects, we take our 2+ decades of experience to serve the communities of Minnesota, Iowa and Illinois. They can expect our highest standard of service and professionalism.

"High pressure sales person which ended up with a mismatch of the rest of my bathroom. They refuse to make it right. . I would recommend that you go with a different company. "

Karen P on November 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 1183
Bathtub Replacement questions, answered by experts

The cost of installing a new bathtub is considerably more expensive than refinishing an existing one, so if you’re looking to upgrade your tub on a budget, you might be better off refinishing it for now. Additionally, if your tub has only minor damage, refinishing it will make it look new again without the extra demolition and time. 

Completing a full standard bathroom remodel offers the best value, providing an average 70% return on investment. However, some of the best bathroom upgrades don’t involve a full rip-out and remodel. If you want to save money while still making a splash, you can increase resale value by upgrading to a walk-in shower, resurfacing a tub, retiling, or adding or upgrading cabinets and vanity units.

All bathtub materials have advantages and disadvantages. Cast iron is the most durable option, but these heavy tubs are expensive and not always suitable for bathtubs on upper floors. Acrylic is a good option for those on a budget. However, copper has many unique benefits if you want something that wows and requires minimal maintenance.

A standard bathtub can be used for soaking, but they tend to be shallower (between 15 and 18 inches deep). A soaking tub is designed to be deep enough to totally submerge yourself in the water (about 20 and 24 inches deep). Additionally, most soaking tubs are freestanding, while regular bathtubs come in various styles with drop-in, surround, and wall-mounted options available.

You can put a structure under your bathtub for support. Many modern tubs come with a built-in support structure underneath. Almost any type of mortar or floor-leveling compound is acceptable for new bathtubs that don’t include a support structure.

You can also install spray foam under an existing bathtub to eliminate or reduce squeaking or sagging. However, spray foam isn’t rigid enough for primary tub support.

The Colgate, WI homeowners’ guide to bathtub replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"