Top-rated cabinet makers.

Get matched with top cabinet makers in Newcomerstown, OH

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your cabinet making project in Newcomerstown, OH?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

Find Cabinet makers in Newcomerstown

Avatar for High Point Cabinets

High Point Cabinets

7907 Nonpariel Road
4.97(
74
)
Approved Pro

High Point Cabinets

7907 Nonpariel Road
4.97(
74
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers
135 local quotes requested

As a multi-year Super Service Award winner, we provide high-quality custom cabinets, one customer at a time, built in the heart of Amish country using Amish craftsmanship. All of our cabinets are 100% handcrafted. Throughout each stage of our process we pay careful attention to detail. The end result is the perfect fit for your home. We are a true custom builder. Our clients are able to choose from a wide variety of high quality woods, stains, finishes, patterns, profiles and more. We work hard to ensure our customers get the right cabinets for their unique tastes and preferences. We provide a complete turnkey process that begins with the initial meeting, progresses to sketches and drawings, then to CAD drawings, then construction and finally installation. We are here to help and guide you through every step from start to finish. We offer a 10 year guarantee on our cabinets, excluding normal wear and tear.

"They were very easy to work with, provided helpful feedback and did very good work."

Robert L on October 2025

As a multi-year Super Service Award winner, we provide high-quality custom cabinets, one customer at a time, built in the heart of Amish country using Amish craftsmanship. All of our cabinets are 100% handcrafted. Throughout each stage of our process we pay careful attention to detail. The end result is the perfect fit for your home. We are a true custom builder. Our clients are able to choose from a wide variety of high quality woods, stains, finishes, patterns, profiles and more. We work hard to ensure our customers get the right cabinets for their unique tastes and preferences. We provide a complete turnkey process that begins with the initial meeting, progresses to sketches and drawings, then to CAD drawings, then construction and finally installation. We are here to help and guide you through every step from start to finish. We offer a 10 year guarantee on our cabinets, excluding normal wear and tear.

"They were very easy to work with, provided helpful feedback and did very good work."

Robert L on October 2025


Avatar for David Black Construction

David Black Construction

5952 Basket Switch Rd.
4.80(
32
)
Approved Pro

David Black Construction

5952 Basket Switch Rd.
4.80(
32
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
35 years of experience

Welcome to David Black Construction! Our company has been in business for over 33 years doing all sorts of residential & commercial remodeling jobs. From simple handyman jobs, interior & exterior painting to building decks & additions, we have the experience to take care of any home improvement project! We accept PayPal, Visa/Mastercard payment available on our secure website!

"Very thorough and responsive as well."

Peter D on August 2023

Welcome to David Black Construction! Our company has been in business for over 33 years doing all sorts of residential & commercial remodeling jobs. From simple handyman jobs, interior & exterior painting to building decks & additions, we have the experience to take care of any home improvement project! We accept PayPal, Visa/Mastercard payment available on our secure website!

"Very thorough and responsive as well."

Peter D on August 2023


Fry's Woodworking

9615 Pleasant Hill Road NW
5.00(
1
)

Fry's Woodworking

9615 Pleasant Hill Road NW
5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Here at Fry's Woodworking we are David and Kyle a father/ son team that specializes in custom kitchen, bath cabinets, and vanity's. We have 20+ years experience always striving for the highest quality possible. also striving to help our customers have the best experience possible.

"Dave was very easy to work with and his communication was great letting me know how things were going and what time frame the bookshelf was going to be done. The bookshelf turned out beautiful and just as we had ordered it! Would hire them again for custom work."

Coleen T on December 2023

Here at Fry's Woodworking we are David and Kyle a father/ son team that specializes in custom kitchen, bath cabinets, and vanity's. We have 20+ years experience always striving for the highest quality possible. also striving to help our customers have the best experience possible.

"Dave was very easy to work with and his communication was great letting me know how things were going and what time frame the bookshelf was going to be done. The bookshelf turned out beautiful and just as we had ordered it! Would hire them again for custom work."

Coleen T on December 2023


Avatar for J. Lehman Cabinetry & Flooring

J. Lehman Cabinetry & Flooring

587 US-224
No reviews yet

J. Lehman Cabinetry & Flooring

587 US-224
No reviews yet
7 years of experience

Hand crafted fine amish cabinetry and flooring company featuring custom curated designs at an affordable price. JL Cabinetry & Flooring was founded in 2018 with a passion to provide one of a kind, high quality, and well designed cabinetry, flooring, and furniture. Our ideology is to design economical woodworks that meet our high standards. Located in Sullivan, Ohio, we are a shop composed of a compact team of Amish craftsmen with over 35 years of experience. After extensive research done by our product developers, we have partnered with a handful of great manufacturers to bring more variety and designs directly to our customers.

Hand crafted fine amish cabinetry and flooring company featuring custom curated designs at an affordable price. JL Cabinetry & Flooring was founded in 2018 with a passion to provide one of a kind, high quality, and well designed cabinetry, flooring, and furniture. Our ideology is to design economical woodworks that meet our high standards. Located in Sullivan, Ohio, we are a shop composed of a compact team of Amish craftsmen with over 35 years of experience. After extensive research done by our product developers, we have partnered with a handful of great manufacturers to bring more variety and designs directly to our customers.


Hilltop Cabinet

1553 Tater Ridge Road
5.00(
2
)

Hilltop Cabinet

1553 Tater Ridge Road
5.00(
2
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Hilltop Cabinets, located in West Union, Ohio, has been building premium, high quality cabinetry since 1998. For nearly 20 years, we've mastered our craft using age-old techniques - and developing a few of our own.

Hilltop Cabinets, located in West Union, Ohio, has been building premium, high quality cabinetry since 1998. For nearly 20 years, we've mastered our craft using age-old techniques - and developing a few of our own.


Avatar for J Display Case

J Display Case

Cincinnati Oh
5.00(
84
)

J Display Case

Cincinnati Oh
5.00(
84
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We are a custom acrylic fabrication shop with stock designs also shown on our website. Our quality is the finest in the acrylic industry. Display cases, wall cabinets, display covers and bases for antiques, model ships, collectibles, and turntables. Safely packaged and shipped to your door. We ship to all of the US states and cities in 48 contiguous states. Email or call us for a free quote 1 800-971-6276.

"I have been a customer/consumer for many years. The products are manufactured to the very highest quality possible. Packing & shipping are the Industry Standards. Customer Service is the benchmark of the business. Every company should use J Display Case as their Business Model ! Kudos !!!"

Art W on August 2024

We are a custom acrylic fabrication shop with stock designs also shown on our website. Our quality is the finest in the acrylic industry. Display cases, wall cabinets, display covers and bases for antiques, model ships, collectibles, and turntables. Safely packaged and shipped to your door. We ship to all of the US states and cities in 48 contiguous states. Email or call us for a free quote 1 800-971-6276.

"I have been a customer/consumer for many years. The products are manufactured to the very highest quality possible. Packing & shipping are the Industry Standards. Customer Service is the benchmark of the business. Every company should use J Display Case as their Business Model ! Kudos !!!"

Art W on August 2024


JJL Handyman Services

46627 County Road 495
1.00(
1
)

JJL Handyman Services

46627 County Road 495
1.00(
1
)
15 years of experience

JJL Handyman Service is a company that keeps well trained professionals at its side for just about any situation that arises in a household. We specialize in Home remodel and repair but have well trained professionals with YEARS (usually 10-20 years+) of experience in a vast multitude of services as well. They all have been highly screened and references all checked out, all background are clean and they are all top of the line in their chosen fields. They are all kind, prompt, and reliable and most of all honest hard working individuals looking for customer satisfaction. This is a dependable company who is available when you need us. I have people on call 24/7. And we even offer a 10% referral discount on your current project if you refer 3 people. Our prices are reasonable, our people are top of the line and we treat you right. Who could ask for more?

JJL Handyman Service is a company that keeps well trained professionals at its side for just about any situation that arises in a household. We specialize in Home remodel and repair but have well trained professionals with YEARS (usually 10-20 years+) of experience in a vast multitude of services as well. They all have been highly screened and references all checked out, all background are clean and they are all top of the line in their chosen fields. They are all kind, prompt, and reliable and most of all honest hard working individuals looking for customer satisfaction. This is a dependable company who is available when you need us. I have people on call 24/7. And we even offer a 10% referral discount on your current project if you refer 3 people. Our prices are reasonable, our people are top of the line and we treat you right. Who could ask for more?




Showing 1-10 of 45
Cabinet Making questions, answered by experts

Sealing a cabinet after staining is optional but recommended for best results. Wood sealer keeps out moisture, which protects against scratches, warping, chipping, discoloration, and mildew. Sealer not only preserves the appearance of wood furniture but, like staining, enhances it by accentuating the wood’s natural color and grain.

Whether it’s better to stain or paint old cabinets depends on your situation, as each option has pros and cons. Paint offers a smooth, modern look, while stain highlights the natural wood grain for a charming, rustic look. Painting cabinets may cost about 15% more than staining cabinets. While paint tends to be more durable against damage because of its thick coating, stained cabinets hide inevitable dings and scratches better than paint.

To successfully build a shelf unit with plywood, you’ll need sheets that are at least 0.25 inches thick. Any thinner and your shelves will be flimsy and less likely to last. Expect to pay around $300 for a professional to build a basic shelving unit, or up to $1,300 for custom built-in shelves.

Using a shim or another type of self-leveling feet on the bottom edge of your cabinet bases will help to level them out if you’re installing them on a less-than-level surface. To make this process easier, you can add your shims before attaching the bases to your cabinets while they’re still light and easy to move around.

There are a few key differences between custom and semi-custom cabinets. While custom cabinets offer complete customization, semi-custom cabinets are less personalized, offering fewer paint color, finish, and hardware choices. In addition, custom cabinets typically take longer to install due to the build time, whereas semi-custom cabinets are prefabricated and therefore faster to install. 

The Newcomerstown, OH homeowners’ guide to cabinet making services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"