Get matched with top water heater pros in Amherst, OH
There are 20 highly-rated local water heater pros.
TRUSTED BY AMHERST, OH HOMEOWNERS
4.7 
162 Verified Reviews for Water Heater Service pros in Amherst, OH
*The Angi rating for Water Heater Service companies in Amherst, OH is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Water Heater Service companies in Amherst, OH is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.
Last update on June 14, 2025
Water heater pros in Amherst
Emergency services offered. 40 years in business. Prices are quoted upfront. Family owned. State Certified Plumbing Contractor. Additional DBA's: Andy Wyatt Plumbing, The New Plumbing Co., Inc., Wyatt Plumbing & Heating, Inc., Wyatt Works Plumbing Solutions & Wyatt Works. Consider it done.
"Perfect. Mike was on time, courteous, forthright, knowledgeable, informative, professional and Covid-19 appropriate (we’re older). Efficiently diagnosed plumbing leak specifically caused by dishwasher. Didn’t try to upsell me on anything—a pleasure to have in the house. Decided to have him do an upgrade on a toilet mechanism (my idea, not his). Very satisfied overall."
James S on May 2020
Emergency services offered. 40 years in business. Prices are quoted upfront. Family owned. State Certified Plumbing Contractor. Additional DBA's: Andy Wyatt Plumbing, The New Plumbing Co., Inc., Wyatt Plumbing & Heating, Inc., Wyatt Works Plumbing Solutions & Wyatt Works. Consider it done.
"Perfect. Mike was on time, courteous, forthright, knowledgeable, informative, professional and Covid-19 appropriate (we’re older). Efficiently diagnosed plumbing leak specifically caused by dishwasher. Didn’t try to upsell me on anything—a pleasure to have in the house. Decided to have him do an upgrade on a toilet mechanism (my idea, not his). Very satisfied overall."
James S on May 2020
At Mr. Rooter Plumbing every customer’s individual needs are important. Whether it’s a simple sink clog or a damaged sewer line, you can count on a Mr. Rooter plumber to take care of your plumbing needs – day or night – with never an overtime charge. Our professional service, quality products and honest, up-front pricing make Mr. Rooter the best value in plumbing services nationwide. Mr. Rooter is ready for all emergency plumbing issues, from clogged drains and sewage backups to frozen pipes and leaking water heaters. You can count on an expert diagnosis from Mr. Rooter with our camera inspection tools. Then we’ll fix it right the first time, whether it takes HydroScrub drain cleaning or trenchless pipe repair, with courteous smiles on our faces. There's a reason they call us Mr. Call your local Mr. Rooter today.
"When installing a new refrigerator, the knob to turn the water off fell off in the service man’s hand and water was going everywhere. We had to turn the water off to the whole house. In a panic I found Home Advisor and after inputting my info, Amy from Mr. Rooter called within five minutes. After looking at her schedule, she said a tech would show up in 30-60 minutes. Don’t remember the time exactly, but Mike D. showed up in about 35-45. After inspecting the problem, he gave me an estimate. He said that there was a slow leak that had messed up the drywall and he had to cut it out. He installed all new pipes, bought a 2x4 because the new box was smaller than the old box and basically redid the entire site. Mike was so nice and explained everything he did. He realized that I was stressed and made every effort to make this process as easy as he could. If the service men would have brought the new refrigerator inside, Mike D. would have installed it for me. (They came back later and there were no issues installing the new fridge). When I first got the estimate I thought it was high, but I had no choice. In retrospect, I received much more value for my money. I will hire Mr.Rooter and Mike D. for any future plumbing projects."
MARGE L on August 2019
At Mr. Rooter Plumbing every customer’s individual needs are important. Whether it’s a simple sink clog or a damaged sewer line, you can count on a Mr. Rooter plumber to take care of your plumbing needs – day or night – with never an overtime charge. Our professional service, quality products and honest, up-front pricing make Mr. Rooter the best value in plumbing services nationwide. Mr. Rooter is ready for all emergency plumbing issues, from clogged drains and sewage backups to frozen pipes and leaking water heaters. You can count on an expert diagnosis from Mr. Rooter with our camera inspection tools. Then we’ll fix it right the first time, whether it takes HydroScrub drain cleaning or trenchless pipe repair, with courteous smiles on our faces. There's a reason they call us Mr. Call your local Mr. Rooter today.
"When installing a new refrigerator, the knob to turn the water off fell off in the service man’s hand and water was going everywhere. We had to turn the water off to the whole house. In a panic I found Home Advisor and after inputting my info, Amy from Mr. Rooter called within five minutes. After looking at her schedule, she said a tech would show up in 30-60 minutes. Don’t remember the time exactly, but Mike D. showed up in about 35-45. After inspecting the problem, he gave me an estimate. He said that there was a slow leak that had messed up the drywall and he had to cut it out. He installed all new pipes, bought a 2x4 because the new box was smaller than the old box and basically redid the entire site. Mike was so nice and explained everything he did. He realized that I was stressed and made every effort to make this process as easy as he could. If the service men would have brought the new refrigerator inside, Mike D. would have installed it for me. (They came back later and there were no issues installing the new fridge). When I first got the estimate I thought it was high, but I had no choice. In retrospect, I received much more value for my money. I will hire Mr.Rooter and Mike D. for any future plumbing projects."
MARGE L on August 2019
Full service plumbing company individually owned and operated since 1997. Efficient, competitive pricing, quality driven, high end materials, courteous, prompt, and responsive. We are BBB Accredited with an A+ rating and we are Angie's List Super Service Award Winners for 9 consecutive years: 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, and 2014.
"Great. There was some confusion on scheduling but it was resolved. He came in and took care of my problem with my waterline to my refrigerator and ice maker. He was reasonable in pricing and I would use him again should I need to."
Toni M on July 2024
Full service plumbing company individually owned and operated since 1997. Efficient, competitive pricing, quality driven, high end materials, courteous, prompt, and responsive. We are BBB Accredited with an A+ rating and we are Angie's List Super Service Award Winners for 9 consecutive years: 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, and 2014.
"Great. There was some confusion on scheduling but it was resolved. He came in and took care of my problem with my waterline to my refrigerator and ice maker. He was reasonable in pricing and I would use him again should I need to."
Toni M on July 2024
If you are in need of home improvement or repair in Chagrin Falls, whether these changes include just one item or an entire list, call Neatnics the Chagrin Falls home repair and handyman company. Cost is determined by the job. All Chagrin Falls home repair, home improvement work is guaranteed by Neatnics and as the name implies, we take extra care to maintain the cleanliness of your home while serving your home improvement needs, and always leave the work areas as clean or cleaner then when we arrived. Neatnics trucks show up at your home fully equipped with clean, modern professional tools and equipment, along with service technicians that are clean cut, courteous, professionals who know how to use them. Our technicians take great pride in their work and know the value of a satisfied customer.
"The project went extremely well. Adam and crew show up and work. They are very neat, and keep the workplace clean. Adam explains everything that they will be doing and goes over the expense of everything, in advance. I highly recommend this company."
Susan P on November 2024
If you are in need of home improvement or repair in Chagrin Falls, whether these changes include just one item or an entire list, call Neatnics the Chagrin Falls home repair and handyman company. Cost is determined by the job. All Chagrin Falls home repair, home improvement work is guaranteed by Neatnics and as the name implies, we take extra care to maintain the cleanliness of your home while serving your home improvement needs, and always leave the work areas as clean or cleaner then when we arrived. Neatnics trucks show up at your home fully equipped with clean, modern professional tools and equipment, along with service technicians that are clean cut, courteous, professionals who know how to use them. Our technicians take great pride in their work and know the value of a satisfied customer.
"The project went extremely well. Adam and crew show up and work. They are very neat, and keep the workplace clean. Adam explains everything that they will be doing and goes over the expense of everything, in advance. I highly recommend this company."
Susan P on November 2024
Our happy and satisfied customers recommend us to their friends and family all the time. We are proud of our reputation and we feel it has been well earned. We are also happy that we can help you feel good knowing that you are working with a reputable company that stands behind its products and services. We also can do same day services for those in unforeseen circumstances that require immediate attention and get you back to a normal day
"Steve did an amazing job on installing our new front door. He was very efficient and the new door works perfectly. Made a huge difference on the appearance of our house. "
Bernard K on May 2025
Our happy and satisfied customers recommend us to their friends and family all the time. We are proud of our reputation and we feel it has been well earned. We are also happy that we can help you feel good knowing that you are working with a reputable company that stands behind its products and services. We also can do same day services for those in unforeseen circumstances that require immediate attention and get you back to a normal day
"Steve did an amazing job on installing our new front door. He was very efficient and the new door works perfectly. Made a huge difference on the appearance of our house. "
Bernard K on May 2025
Straightforward Remodeling is your trusted handyman, plumbing, gutters and remodeling contractor in the Ohio area. We pride ourselves on being timely and efficient, paying attention to detail to meet your needs every step of the way. For a free estimate, give us a call today!
"Cody was very professional, knowledgeable about his work, and could answer all questions about the water heater that he installed. He picked up the water heater from a store, showed up on time, did an excellent job, and cleaned up after himself. Couldn't be happier!"
Luda S on March 2023
Straightforward Remodeling is your trusted handyman, plumbing, gutters and remodeling contractor in the Ohio area. We pride ourselves on being timely and efficient, paying attention to detail to meet your needs every step of the way. For a free estimate, give us a call today!
"Cody was very professional, knowledgeable about his work, and could answer all questions about the water heater that he installed. He picked up the water heater from a store, showed up on time, did an excellent job, and cleaned up after himself. Couldn't be happier!"
Luda S on March 2023
West Shore Home offers a risk-free home improvement experience, so you never have to worry that you are sacrificing on quality, convenience, or expertise. We specialize in shower and bath replacements, and walk-in tubs. We offer fully customizable, limited lifetime-guaranteed solutions installed in as little as one-day. All of our installers are in-house employees, so we can guarantee the quality of the whole project from start to finish. We get it done the way you want - fast, easy, smart and right. Our team is following all CDC guidelines so we can provide you with the fast and convenient home improvements. We are also offering free virtual design consultations! Schedule your free consultation today.
"Great customer service and very nice salesman Cory"
Jim B on March 2025
West Shore Home offers a risk-free home improvement experience, so you never have to worry that you are sacrificing on quality, convenience, or expertise. We specialize in shower and bath replacements, and walk-in tubs. We offer fully customizable, limited lifetime-guaranteed solutions installed in as little as one-day. All of our installers are in-house employees, so we can guarantee the quality of the whole project from start to finish. We get it done the way you want - fast, easy, smart and right. Our team is following all CDC guidelines so we can provide you with the fast and convenient home improvements. We are also offering free virtual design consultations! Schedule your free consultation today.
"Great customer service and very nice salesman Cory"
Jim B on March 2025
Zaber Construction LLC is the reliable choice if you need an in-ground pool! We provide high quality work as well as incredible customer service to our customers.
"Chad was phenomenal! He communicated every step of the way what he would be doing (and it's crazy I even have to point this out, but he always showed up when he said he would), went above and beyond in lending assistance and expertise to other tradesmen on the project, kept the necessary inspections rolling, he and his crew cleaned up daily, the list goes on and on! I don't take recommendations lightly and I would most certainly put my name behind Chad's work any day of the week! We are so happy with our inground pool and will hire him again for any project without hesitation. He was a true blessing with what could have been a more stressful project!"
Stephanie S on January 2023
Zaber Construction LLC is the reliable choice if you need an in-ground pool! We provide high quality work as well as incredible customer service to our customers.
"Chad was phenomenal! He communicated every step of the way what he would be doing (and it's crazy I even have to point this out, but he always showed up when he said he would), went above and beyond in lending assistance and expertise to other tradesmen on the project, kept the necessary inspections rolling, he and his crew cleaned up daily, the list goes on and on! I don't take recommendations lightly and I would most certainly put my name behind Chad's work any day of the week! We are so happy with our inground pool and will hire him again for any project without hesitation. He was a true blessing with what could have been a more stressful project!"
Stephanie S on January 2023
With 48 years of experience serving the area, we are your solution for all your tub and shower needs. Family owned and operated, we take great pride in providing our customers with the highest quality products to fit their needs, our extreme professionalism, timeliness and superior customer service on every customized job. We make sure to develop a lasting relationship, so that the next time service is needed, there will be no question on who to call. Check out our 5 star reviews from happy customers! Call us today, so we can discuss your needs and make a plan that fits your budget and gives you the Bathroom of your dreams! Satisfaction guaranteed! We are a Service & Provider company.
"Gorgeous work!! Friendly and confident workers. We are SUPER happy with our new bathtub and shower wall. We loved our sales rep, and the installer was great too. They were both very understanding of our hectic home with three kiddos ?? we only had a shower stall in our main bathroom before the install, so we are really enjoying the deep soaker bathtub with kids! A lot less splashing on the floor. So thankful for all of the hard work put into this for us!!"
Lexy W on April 2025
With 48 years of experience serving the area, we are your solution for all your tub and shower needs. Family owned and operated, we take great pride in providing our customers with the highest quality products to fit their needs, our extreme professionalism, timeliness and superior customer service on every customized job. We make sure to develop a lasting relationship, so that the next time service is needed, there will be no question on who to call. Check out our 5 star reviews from happy customers! Call us today, so we can discuss your needs and make a plan that fits your budget and gives you the Bathroom of your dreams! Satisfaction guaranteed! We are a Service & Provider company.
"Gorgeous work!! Friendly and confident workers. We are SUPER happy with our new bathtub and shower wall. We loved our sales rep, and the installer was great too. They were both very understanding of our hectic home with three kiddos ?? we only had a shower stall in our main bathroom before the install, so we are really enjoying the deep soaker bathtub with kids! A lot less splashing on the floor. So thankful for all of the hard work put into this for us!!"
Lexy W on April 2025
Active Rooter Plumbing, Drain Cleaning and Sewer Cleaning service 440-541-8234 is your local licensed plumbing and drain cleaning service. We are your local plumbers located in Lorain County Ohio and providing plumbing, drain cleaning and sewer cleaning services in Lorain, Amherst, Elyria, Oberlin, Lorain County and surrounding areas. We are your personal plumbers providing drain cleaning, plumbing services, sewer cleaning and high pressure sewer jetting services. Call 440-541-8234 today for your next appointment Active Rooter Plumbing and Drain Cleaning only uses licensed plumbers and provides competitive pricing to address all your plumbing, drain cleaning, sewer cleaning or any other service that you need. We are based in Northeast Ohio and serve Lorain County and surrounding areas. You can count on our expertise and technology to do your drain cleaning and plumbing services job right. Ask us about our free estimates and quality service at prices you can afford.
"They were great! Came in and knocked it out! Now I've got a clean drain all the way to the street:) Less expensive then anyone else I called! Highly recommend!"
Joe R on September 2024
Active Rooter Plumbing, Drain Cleaning and Sewer Cleaning service 440-541-8234 is your local licensed plumbing and drain cleaning service. We are your local plumbers located in Lorain County Ohio and providing plumbing, drain cleaning and sewer cleaning services in Lorain, Amherst, Elyria, Oberlin, Lorain County and surrounding areas. We are your personal plumbers providing drain cleaning, plumbing services, sewer cleaning and high pressure sewer jetting services. Call 440-541-8234 today for your next appointment Active Rooter Plumbing and Drain Cleaning only uses licensed plumbers and provides competitive pricing to address all your plumbing, drain cleaning, sewer cleaning or any other service that you need. We are based in Northeast Ohio and serve Lorain County and surrounding areas. You can count on our expertise and technology to do your drain cleaning and plumbing services job right. Ask us about our free estimates and quality service at prices you can afford.
"They were great! Came in and knocked it out! Now I've got a clean drain all the way to the street:) Less expensive then anyone else I called! Highly recommend!"
Joe R on September 2024
FAQs for water heater service projects in Amherst, OH
The average cost to install a new water heater is around $1,300, but you can expect to pay between $875 and $1,750, depending on the kind of water heater, the size of the unit, and the professional chosen to complete the work. Tankless water heaters can push your price higher, as installation is more complicated, with prices as high as $3,500. The location and accessibility of your water heater will play a role in the project cost, as those sitting in tight spaces like a crawl space will drive up your labor costs.
Tankless water heaters are more expensive than those with a storage tank, but they come with some impressive benefits that most homeowners find worth the higher investment. Most importantly, they provide unlimited hot water, so you’ll never run out like you would with a storage tank. Tankless heaters are also more efficient, so comparing gallon-for-gallon, you’ll spend less on hot water with a tankless heater. Tankless water heaters are also smaller, require less maintenance, and tend to last longer than storage tank water heaters.
It usually takes a professional water heater installer between two and three hours to remove an existing water heater and install a new tank heater. However, it could take four to five hours if they have to work in a small utility closet or another tight area, like a crawl space. Tankless water heaters have a more complicated installation process, so they will take a bit longer. Additionally, a gas water heater requires a connection to a gas line, and that alone can add about an hour to the installation timeline compared to installing an electric water heater.
It is very difficult and dangerous to install your own water heater, so we strongly recommend against tackling this as a DIY project. Not only will you need to wire your water heater, but you’ll also need to connect plumbing to the intake and outlet. Sweating copper pipes and connecting wiring properly are skills most DIYers don’t have, and even if you do feel confident you can do it, working with water and electricity always leaves the potential for electrocution. Hiring a local water heater installer is well worth the investment.
In most municipalities, a license is not mandatory for water heater installation or replacement. However, we strongly recommend hiring a licensed plumber or water heater installer to handle the work. Licensed installers are far less likely to make a mistake during the installation, which means paying for the experience decreases your risk of a leak and other issues. You can use our state licensing tool to find out if a contractor you’re considering in your area holds a plumber’s license.
Get our Angi-powered app
