Top-rated .

Get matched with top in Shelter Island, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon223
    Verified reviews

Verified Reviews for pros in Shelter Island, NY

*The Angi rating for companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for companies in Shelter Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their needs.

Last update on December 12, 2025

Find in Shelter Island

Avatar for Suburban Exterminating

Suburban Exterminating

4.63(
234
)
•Approved Pro

Suburban Exterminating

4.63(
234
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers
167 local quotes requested

Suburban Exterminating provides pest control and exterminating services throughout Long island. From Ants to Termites, our exterminator experts will protect your family and home. Call us today!

"good but expensive "

Vincent P on December 2025

Suburban Exterminating provides pest control and exterminating services throughout Long island. From Ants to Termites, our exterminator experts will protect your family and home. Call us today!

"good but expensive "

Vincent P on December 2025

Avatar for Exterminex Pest Control Inc

Exterminex Pest Control Inc

4.79(
300
)
•Approved Pro

Exterminex Pest Control Inc

4.79(
300
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers
558 local quotes requested

Residential & Commercial Pest Control. Exterminex Pest Control,Inc is your leading commercial/residential provider of pest management.From ants to raccoons we are your one stop shop.Our service area includes Nassau,Suffolk and the entire New York metro area. In addition to traditional chemical methods we offer a Go-Green Program which uses non-chemical approaches as the primary tool to control pests.

"They were fast and knowledgeable"

Robert O on May 2025

Residential & Commercial Pest Control. Exterminex Pest Control,Inc is your leading commercial/residential provider of pest management.From ants to raccoons we are your one stop shop.Our service area includes Nassau,Suffolk and the entire New York metro area. In addition to traditional chemical methods we offer a Go-Green Program which uses non-chemical approaches as the primary tool to control pests.

"They were fast and knowledgeable"

Robert O on May 2025

Avatar for Unified Pest Services

Unified Pest Services

5.00(
2
)

Unified Pest Services

5.00(
2
)
22 years of experience

Getting rid of any unwanted pests. We have the experience and dedication to get the job done right! Specializing in pest control services; We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won't leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Call or click for your FREE estimate today!

"It was good, they did a good job."

Kelvin V on February 2023

Getting rid of any unwanted pests. We have the experience and dedication to get the job done right! Specializing in pest control services; We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won't leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service! Call or click for your FREE estimate today!

"It was good, they did a good job."

Kelvin V on February 2023

Mosquito Management Inc

No reviews yet

Mosquito Management Inc

No reviews yet

We offer multiple service options for Mosquito, Flea and Tick control. Options include all organic and combinations of insecticide and organic products. All services applied in a manor safe for children and pets.

We offer multiple service options for Mosquito, Flea and Tick control. Options include all organic and combinations of insecticide and organic products. All services applied in a manor safe for children and pets.

Avatar for Precision Exterminating

Precision Exterminating

5.00(
11
)

Precision Exterminating

5.00(
11
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

We invite you to experience a tradition of customer satisfaction that will exceed your greatest expectations. Our professionalism and quality workmanship will accurately reflect your taste and lifestyle. From conception to completion, we work with you until the job is done. We strive to take care of all of our clients unique needs. We are ethical, honest, and easy to communicate with. Call us today, you will be pleased you did.

"David comes to treat my apartment every week. He is respectful, friendly and thorough. I truly appreciate his work but also his attitude. I trust him to always do the right thing and happy to have him continue providing service well into the future!"

Wendel K on October 2024

We invite you to experience a tradition of customer satisfaction that will exceed your greatest expectations. Our professionalism and quality workmanship will accurately reflect your taste and lifestyle. From conception to completion, we work with you until the job is done. We strive to take care of all of our clients unique needs. We are ethical, honest, and easy to communicate with. Call us today, you will be pleased you did.

"David comes to treat my apartment every week. He is respectful, friendly and thorough. I truly appreciate his work but also his attitude. I trust him to always do the right thing and happy to have him continue providing service well into the future!"

Wendel K on October 2024

Avatar for Pest Champions LLC

Pest Champions LLC

No reviews yet

Pest Champions LLC

No reviews yet
7 years of experience

We, at Pest Champions LLC, provide our customers prompt and professional pest control services. We offer a one stop shopping to customize treatment plans to meet our client's needs. Free consultations for both residential households and commercial businesses in Connecticut. Our services include: interior/exterior pest control; rodent control and prevention; termite inspection, prevention, and elimination; tick control; and commercial/residential fertilization. B#3395

We, at Pest Champions LLC, provide our customers prompt and professional pest control services. We offer a one stop shopping to customize treatment plans to meet our client's needs. Free consultations for both residential households and commercial businesses in Connecticut. Our services include: interior/exterior pest control; rodent control and prevention; termite inspection, prevention, and elimination; tick control; and commercial/residential fertilization. B#3395

Alternative Resolution For Pest Control

No reviews yet

Alternative Resolution For Pest Control

No reviews yet
13 years of experience

Alternative Resolution is a dedicated and reliable company. We strive to achieve total satisfaction with every service provided, guaranteeing excellent quality service. Alternative resolution is the company that gets the job done. Fully licensed and insured.

Alternative Resolution is a dedicated and reliable company. We strive to achieve total satisfaction with every service provided, guaranteeing excellent quality service. Alternative resolution is the company that gets the job done. Fully licensed and insured.

Jove Pest Control, Inc.

No reviews yet

Jove Pest Control, Inc.

No reviews yet
27 years of experience

JOVE Pest Control provides the best in customer service and extermination to individual comes and commercial properties. We have been providing excellent service for the last 11 years and are certified and liscensed in NY and NJ.

JOVE Pest Control provides the best in customer service and extermination to individual comes and commercial properties. We have been providing excellent service for the last 11 years and are certified and liscensed in NY and NJ.

Legend Pest Control

2.00(
1
)

Legend Pest Control

2.00(
1
)
Customers say: Super punctual
10 years of experience

Our focus is to provide a Legendary service experience to all our customers by resolving the inconvenient nuisance of their problems utilizing safety practices and procedures. We serve our customers promptly and efficiently by finding the best and most effective way to treat their pest problems. We offer both Commercial and Residential pest control services.

"In June 2018, we contacted Legend Pest Control from Elizabeth NJ. The co-owners are Karina and Alcides Ramos. We chose them because my husband had met Karina at a Chamber of Commerce meeting and we wanted to support local business. Al came to the house, did an assessment, answered all my questions, suggested a plan, and gave us what sounded like a fair price. Over the next weeks, we received treatment on three separate occasions for our problem. At one point we discovered we had not prepared properly for a particular portion. We agreed that I misunderstand and Al maybe could have explained it different. The problem was corrected before the final treatment. When our treatments were finished, Al told us that we might still see some "straggler activity" but that is was normal. In December 2018, we called Al with definite live activity. He told us to "monitor" and let him know. In June 2019 we again experienced an infestation. We notified Al who said he would come by in three days. At this point we contacted two other pest control companies. We told them our story, and they explicitly said that in December 2018 the problem should have been addressed. They said there is no such thing in this instance of "straggler activity" of live bugs. They both agreed that the current level of our problem was due to the length of time the problem had gone unaddressed. We cancelled our appointment to have Al re-assess and chose to give our business to another company. We also contacted Legend Pest Control asking for a partial refund due to the significance of them giving us incorrect information and not re-assessing when we called in December 2018. We received an email back that was unprofessional, and contained incorrect facts and did not address the chief complaint of their mistake. We responded again clarifying the facts. At this point, Legend Pest Control has chosen to ignore us, not take any responsibility for a mistake they made, and refused any type of partial refund to compensate."

Linda O on August 2019

Our focus is to provide a Legendary service experience to all our customers by resolving the inconvenient nuisance of their problems utilizing safety practices and procedures. We serve our customers promptly and efficiently by finding the best and most effective way to treat their pest problems. We offer both Commercial and Residential pest control services.

"In June 2018, we contacted Legend Pest Control from Elizabeth NJ. The co-owners are Karina and Alcides Ramos. We chose them because my husband had met Karina at a Chamber of Commerce meeting and we wanted to support local business. Al came to the house, did an assessment, answered all my questions, suggested a plan, and gave us what sounded like a fair price. Over the next weeks, we received treatment on three separate occasions for our problem. At one point we discovered we had not prepared properly for a particular portion. We agreed that I misunderstand and Al maybe could have explained it different. The problem was corrected before the final treatment. When our treatments were finished, Al told us that we might still see some "straggler activity" but that is was normal. In December 2018, we called Al with definite live activity. He told us to "monitor" and let him know. In June 2019 we again experienced an infestation. We notified Al who said he would come by in three days. At this point we contacted two other pest control companies. We told them our story, and they explicitly said that in December 2018 the problem should have been addressed. They said there is no such thing in this instance of "straggler activity" of live bugs. They both agreed that the current level of our problem was due to the length of time the problem had gone unaddressed. We cancelled our appointment to have Al re-assess and chose to give our business to another company. We also contacted Legend Pest Control asking for a partial refund due to the significance of them giving us incorrect information and not re-assessing when we called in December 2018. We received an email back that was unprofessional, and contained incorrect facts and did not address the chief complaint of their mistake. We responded again clarifying the facts. At this point, Legend Pest Control has chosen to ignore us, not take any responsibility for a mistake they made, and refused any type of partial refund to compensate."

Linda O on August 2019

...
Showing 1-10 of 202
Pest Control questions, answered by experts

Spider mites don’t have too much in common with actual spiders, but these insects can absolutely destroy a lawn. Spider mites feed on grass roots and blades and are extremely effective at draining nutrients from plants, which can quickly kill grass. These mites are ravenous, so talk to a pest control pro at the first sign of spider mites in your lawn.

If a small hive is far enough from your home and doesn’t seem to pose a threat to the health of anyone, then you can opt to leave it alone. They are still pollinators; if you have a garden, they’ll tackle some gardening work for you and produce helpful results without harming you.

Fleas are not likely to go away on their own without intervention. This pest lives for around 100 days or up to one year as an adult, so long as it has access to a host. Female fleas lay up to 50 eggs per day, meaning these bugs can quickly spread in your home. Instead of waiting in hopes that they’ll go away on their own, you should hire an exterminator to prevent an infestation from worsening.

Groundhogs usually keep their cool despite being easily spooked. However, there are exceptions—they might get defensive or territorial if they feel threatened or overly concerned. If they sense a threat to their babies, they could get feisty, too. These wild animals are not meant to be kept as pets. If you find babies or an injured groundhog, contact your local animal rescue or wildlife service for guidance.

To keep deer from eating your trees, you can either put up barriers or install a deer repellant. Barriers that protect trees from deer include tree wrap or fencing. You can also plant deer-resistant trees to prevent deer from eating or scraping against your trees or garden with plants that deer don’t like to be around.

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"