Top-rated gutter repair and replacement pros.

Get matched with top gutter repair and replacement pros in Shelter Island, NY

There are 34 highly-rated local gutter repair and replacement pros.

Need a pro for your gutter repair and replacement project in Shelter Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.7
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon100
    Verified gutter repairs and replacements reviews

Find Gutter repair and replacement pros in Shelter Island

Avatar for D & S Roofing Corp

D & S Roofing Corp

1814 Deer Park Ave
4.88(
165
)
Approved Pro

D & S Roofing Corp

1814 Deer Park Ave
4.88(
165
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
70 local quotes requested

D&S Roofing Corp. has been serving all of Long Island since 1939. We are family owned & operated for four generations. D&S Roofing Corp. is a full-service roofing company in residential, commercial, industrial, institutional, and apartment complex roofing. We have factory-certified mechanics and a full office staff to service client needs. D&S Roofing Corp. uses only quality materials and provides the finest workmanship on every job from repair to installation. We do not use subcontractors and do not use dumpsters. D&S is licensed, bonded, and certified. Additional DBAs - D&S Roofing and Siding, Doman Roofing & Siding Corp.

"I contacted Dominick with a concern and within 5 minutes, he called me back and said he would stop by this week and he would call before he got here to make sure someone was home. He came the next day and fixed a problem that wasn’t part of the roof he replaced. To say D&S roofing is my go to for any issues, is an understatement. They treat you like family and do the right thing! I would highly recommend them to anyone who needs service, whether it’s roofing or gutters!"

Christina R on July 2025

D&S Roofing Corp. has been serving all of Long Island since 1939. We are family owned & operated for four generations. D&S Roofing Corp. is a full-service roofing company in residential, commercial, industrial, institutional, and apartment complex roofing. We have factory-certified mechanics and a full office staff to service client needs. D&S Roofing Corp. uses only quality materials and provides the finest workmanship on every job from repair to installation. We do not use subcontractors and do not use dumpsters. D&S is licensed, bonded, and certified. Additional DBAs - D&S Roofing and Siding, Doman Roofing & Siding Corp.

"I contacted Dominick with a concern and within 5 minutes, he called me back and said he would stop by this week and he would call before he got here to make sure someone was home. He came the next day and fixed a problem that wasn’t part of the roof he replaced. To say D&S roofing is my go to for any issues, is an understatement. They treat you like family and do the right thing! I would highly recommend them to anyone who needs service, whether it’s roofing or gutters!"

Christina R on July 2025



Best Cut Woodworks

1 The Mastics
5.00(
1
)

Best Cut Woodworks

1 The Mastics
5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Colors have the incredible ability to transform spaces, evoke emotions, and create a unique atmosphere. At Best Cut Woodworks, we specialize in providing expert interior painting services that breathe new life into your home, reflecting your personal style and aspirations.  Our Approach to Interior Painting Painting is an art, and we approach it with creativity, precision, and a dedication to perfection. Our skilled painters understand the nuances of color, texture, and technique, ensuring that every brushstroke contributes to the overall aesthetic of your space. Why Choose Our Interior Painting Services? Expertise: Our team of experienced painters brings years of expertise to the table, ensuring a flawless finish and attention to detail. Customization: We believe that your home should be a reflection of you. That's why we work closely with you to choose the perfect colors that align with your style and preferences. Quality Materials: We use high-quality paints and materials to guarantee long-lasting and beautiful results. Efficiency: We understand the importance of time, and we work efficiently to complete projects within agreed-upon timelines. Attention to Detail: From preparing the surfaces to the final coat, we meticulously execute each step to achieve a smooth and even finish. we are currently looking to take on more painting, interior and exterior! we also offer all phases of home construction and remodeling , and outdoor services to! such as; lawn maintenance and fence installs and creation. find us on Facebook for builds and projects for sale on ebay! (amazon coming soon)

"Alex Understood the project I wanted with my deck and it came out better than expected! Since then I also had him back for my fencing, flooring, Painting and other jobs like he made me a custom made door. He always out does himself and gets the job done effectively. I highly recommend Alex to complete any project you have in mind. He will get it done to your expectations!"

Brenda S on September 2024

Colors have the incredible ability to transform spaces, evoke emotions, and create a unique atmosphere. At Best Cut Woodworks, we specialize in providing expert interior painting services that breathe new life into your home, reflecting your personal style and aspirations.  Our Approach to Interior Painting Painting is an art, and we approach it with creativity, precision, and a dedication to perfection. Our skilled painters understand the nuances of color, texture, and technique, ensuring that every brushstroke contributes to the overall aesthetic of your space. Why Choose Our Interior Painting Services? Expertise: Our team of experienced painters brings years of expertise to the table, ensuring a flawless finish and attention to detail. Customization: We believe that your home should be a reflection of you. That's why we work closely with you to choose the perfect colors that align with your style and preferences. Quality Materials: We use high-quality paints and materials to guarantee long-lasting and beautiful results. Efficiency: We understand the importance of time, and we work efficiently to complete projects within agreed-upon timelines. Attention to Detail: From preparing the surfaces to the final coat, we meticulously execute each step to achieve a smooth and even finish. we are currently looking to take on more painting, interior and exterior! we also offer all phases of home construction and remodeling , and outdoor services to! such as; lawn maintenance and fence installs and creation. find us on Facebook for builds and projects for sale on ebay! (amazon coming soon)

"Alex Understood the project I wanted with my deck and it came out better than expected! Since then I also had him back for my fencing, flooring, Painting and other jobs like he made me a custom made door. He always out does himself and gets the job done effectively. I highly recommend Alex to complete any project you have in mind. He will get it done to your expectations!"

Brenda S on September 2024



James nill inc

No reviews yet

James nill inc

No reviews yet

James Nill Inc., specializes in providing top-notch roofing services for all your needs. Whether you require repairs, a new roof replacement, leak repairs, gutter work or new installations, our team of experts is here to ensure your satisfaction. With years of experience in the industry, we take pride in providing top-notch craftsmanship and exceptional customer service. Whether you need minor repairs or a complete roof overhaul, we have the skills and expertise to get the job done efficiently and effectively. Trust us to protect your home or business with our reliable and durable roofing solutions

James Nill Inc., specializes in providing top-notch roofing services for all your needs. Whether you require repairs, a new roof replacement, leak repairs, gutter work or new installations, our team of experts is here to ensure your satisfaction. With years of experience in the industry, we take pride in providing top-notch craftsmanship and exceptional customer service. Whether you need minor repairs or a complete roof overhaul, we have the skills and expertise to get the job done efficiently and effectively. Trust us to protect your home or business with our reliable and durable roofing solutions


Marcor Construction Solar

135 DALE ST
No reviews yet

Marcor Construction Solar

135 DALE ST
No reviews yet
17 years of experience

Marcor specializes in Solar removal & reinstalls, pest guard installations and repairs, inverter troubleshooting and more. Marcor is a roofing and solar company in 1. One phone call for all your needs. Marcor Construction has been around for 15 years. Our Solar techs have been i the industry for 10+ years.

Marcor specializes in Solar removal & reinstalls, pest guard installations and repairs, inverter troubleshooting and more. Marcor is a roofing and solar company in 1. One phone call for all your needs. Marcor Construction has been around for 15 years. Our Solar techs have been i the industry for 10+ years.


Oscar’s complete landscaping

Located In:
5.00(
8
)

Oscar’s complete landscaping

Located In:
5.00(
8
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We specialize in all phases of landscaping, hardscaping, lawn maintenance, fertilization, masonry, pool services, housecleaning and more. We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service. As an added bonus, your first week of lawn maintenance is free! Call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Eric, Oscar and crew were an absolute pleasure to work with. They are true craftsman and did a fantastic Job on my driveway. They completed the job very quickly, cleaning up at the end of each day. I give Dream Pro Care my highest recommendation!"

Ron L on October 2024

We specialize in all phases of landscaping, hardscaping, lawn maintenance, fertilization, masonry, pool services, housecleaning and more. We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we provide, while delivering great customer service. As an added bonus, your first week of lawn maintenance is free! Call -or- click to schedule a free estimate today!

"Eric, Oscar and crew were an absolute pleasure to work with. They are true craftsman and did a fantastic Job on my driveway. They completed the job very quickly, cleaning up at the end of each day. I give Dream Pro Care my highest recommendation!"

Ron L on October 2024


PROBROS

5.00(
1
)

PROBROS

5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

PROBROS Custom Aesthetics, for all your home remodeling needs. We do it all from building complete custom homes, interior remodeling that includes but is not limited to; Kitchen remodels, Bathroom remodels, Flooring, Roofing, Deck installation, and much more. Here at PROBROS we value each of our jobs as a unique and creative way for our homeowners to express themselves, all for an affordable price while maintaining a high quality finished product. With a dedicated team with over 20 years of experience, we have been around a long time and like to stay ahead of the competition, giving the best prices available and giving a reliable trusted service. There is no home renovation service that is too big or too small for us.

"The team did a great job on our deck in our backyard"

Fred C on March 2023

PROBROS Custom Aesthetics, for all your home remodeling needs. We do it all from building complete custom homes, interior remodeling that includes but is not limited to; Kitchen remodels, Bathroom remodels, Flooring, Roofing, Deck installation, and much more. Here at PROBROS we value each of our jobs as a unique and creative way for our homeowners to express themselves, all for an affordable price while maintaining a high quality finished product. With a dedicated team with over 20 years of experience, we have been around a long time and like to stay ahead of the competition, giving the best prices available and giving a reliable trusted service. There is no home renovation service that is too big or too small for us.

"The team did a great job on our deck in our backyard"

Fred C on March 2023


VT SEAMLESS GUTTER and SIDING Inc.

No reviews yet

VT SEAMLESS GUTTER and SIDING Inc.

No reviews yet
3 years of experience

Our mission is to be a provider that brings back the personal touch with our customers. We will build a relationship that will last a lifetime after you see our quality work. As a locally owned and operated business we feel invested in our clients and constantly strive for customer satisfaction. Call or message us to schedule an estimate today!

Our mission is to be a provider that brings back the personal touch with our customers. We will build a relationship that will last a lifetime after you see our quality work. As a locally owned and operated business we feel invested in our clients and constantly strive for customer satisfaction. Call or message us to schedule an estimate today!


homexpertsplus.com

1488 Deer Park Avenue
No reviews yet

homexpertsplus.com

1488 Deer Park Avenue
No reviews yet
Emergency services offered

Homexpertsplus.com, is a General Construction company from Suffolk County, New York. We speciallize in Total Home Renovations, as well as roofing, siding, windows & doors, kitchens, bathrooms, we accept all major credit cards and offer 100% financing.

Homexpertsplus.com, is a General Construction company from Suffolk County, New York. We speciallize in Total Home Renovations, as well as roofing, siding, windows & doors, kitchens, bathrooms, we accept all major credit cards and offer 100% financing.

...
Showing 1-10 of 201
Gutter Repair and Replacement questions, answered by experts

If you are experiencing minor issues with your gutters, such as a small leak or cracks in one or two sections, it makes more sense to repair the issue than to replace your entire gutter system. However, you may need to replace your gutters if they’re frequently detaching from your home or if you notice a buildup of mold or mildew in your basement.

Common problems include rust, leaks, and clogged downspouts. Regular cleaning prevents most issues.

Sagging gutters stress your downspout, so have your gutters fixed before you secure your downspout.

Costs depend on damage extent, the material type, accessibility, and the labor required for repairs.

How you stop water from leaking between your gutters and fascia depends on the cause of the leak. Some leaks can be fixed simply by cleaning out clogged gutters or downspouts. Other leaks require you to seal holes or cracks in your gutters. Meanwhile, some leaks are a structural issue that requires replacing, changing, or adjusting your gutter system.

By submitting this question, I acknowledge and agree that Angi may publicly display my name, city, state, and question on the website for professionals and others to see.

The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to gutter repairs and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.