Top-rated bathtub restoration pros.

Get matched with top bathtub restoration pros in Shelby, NY

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your bathtub restoration project in Shelby, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

Verified Reviews for Bathtub Restoration pros in Shelby, NY

*The Angi rating for Bathtub Restoration companies in Shelby, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Bathtub Restoration needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Bathtub Restoration companies in Shelby, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Bathtub Restoration needs.

Last update on November 27, 2025

Find Bathtub restoration pros in Shelby

Avatar for Bath Fitter of Buffalo

Bath Fitter of Buffalo

4.72(
130
)

Bath Fitter of Buffalo

4.72(
130
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers

Bath Fitter of Buffalo is your local expert in bathroom remodeling, specializing in custom bathtub and shower solutions designed to fit your space perfectly. With over 40 years of experience and millions of installations completed nationwide, we’ve built a reputation for quality, reliability, and lasting results. Our exclusive PermaFit™ system allows us to install premium tubs and showers over your existing setup, often in as little as one day, with no messy demolition. From bathtub replacements and shower installations to tub-to-shower conversions and walk-in showers, every project is backed by our lifetime warranty and handled start to finish by our own factory-trained installers—never subcontractors. Whether you’re looking to modernize your bathroom, improve accessibility, or simply refresh your space, Bath Fitter Buffalo delivers seamless, low-maintenance designs that homeowners across Western New York trust.

"Amazing job covering a 45 year old bathtub and ceramic tile. Justin was prompt, organized, totally professional, answered all my questions. Completed the whole job in just one day. Was able to raise our shower head to a comfortable height for my taller children. Very pleased with the results."

Mark T on June 2023

Bath Fitter of Buffalo is your local expert in bathroom remodeling, specializing in custom bathtub and shower solutions designed to fit your space perfectly. With over 40 years of experience and millions of installations completed nationwide, we’ve built a reputation for quality, reliability, and lasting results. Our exclusive PermaFit™ system allows us to install premium tubs and showers over your existing setup, often in as little as one day, with no messy demolition. From bathtub replacements and shower installations to tub-to-shower conversions and walk-in showers, every project is backed by our lifetime warranty and handled start to finish by our own factory-trained installers—never subcontractors. Whether you’re looking to modernize your bathroom, improve accessibility, or simply refresh your space, Bath Fitter Buffalo delivers seamless, low-maintenance designs that homeowners across Western New York trust.

"Amazing job covering a 45 year old bathtub and ceramic tile. Justin was prompt, organized, totally professional, answered all my questions. Completed the whole job in just one day. Was able to raise our shower head to a comfortable height for my taller children. Very pleased with the results."

Mark T on June 2023

Avatar for New York Flooring and Interior

New York Flooring and Interior

5.00(
6
)

New York Flooring and Interior

5.00(
6
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

New York Flooring is a reputable company that has been serving the Rochester area for over 20 years. Specializing in floor refinishing, custom staining, installation as well as flooring repairs. We take pride in our work, Costumer satisfaction is our priority.

"Wonderful! We love our floors in our new home"

Jan C on June 2024

New York Flooring is a reputable company that has been serving the Rochester area for over 20 years. Specializing in floor refinishing, custom staining, installation as well as flooring repairs. We take pride in our work, Costumer satisfaction is our priority.

"Wonderful! We love our floors in our new home"

Jan C on June 2024

Avatar for Ricky Parker Construction LLC

Ricky Parker Construction LLC

5.00(
1
)

Ricky Parker Construction LLC

5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Ricky Parker LLC is a full service construction company. No job is too small, none too large. From a stairway to a deck, a deck to a house or a home built from foundation to roof, Ricky Parker Construction adheres to the exacting standards of its founder and General Manager. Any job the company undertakes Ricky Parker will be proud of, the client will be please with and the neighborhood will notice .

Ricky Parker LLC is a full service construction company. No job is too small, none too large. From a stairway to a deck, a deck to a house or a home built from foundation to roof, Ricky Parker Construction adheres to the exacting standards of its founder and General Manager. Any job the company undertakes Ricky Parker will be proud of, the client will be please with and the neighborhood will notice .

Erie Construction Midwest - Toledo

3.87(
77
)

Erie Construction Midwest - Toledo

3.87(
77
)
Customers say: Quality work
1975 years of experience

Trusted, Bonded and Insured, Erie Construction has grown to become one of the nation's largest home remodeling companies. We offer best-in-class products aimed at improving the value of your home while saving money on your home energy bills. We've been truly dedicated to the products we offer, and we're happy to back them up with warranty's to match. Since opening our first location in 1975, Erie Construction has serviced over 100,000 customers, with over 50,000 returning to us for additional projects. Read what our customers have to say about us at GuildQuality: http://www.guildquality.com/erieconstruction You can always schedule your free estimate by dropping us a line at 1-800-536-4200 or visiting us online at http://www.erieconstruction.com Erie Construction services locations in nearly 26 states to bring the highest quality home products to you.

"Very high pressure sales. For your own sake have cameras rolling during sales pitch. Don’t let them make you believe that the installation is done by Erie. Totally subcontracted. Talked us into choosing them even though they were 7k higher than other roofers with the promise of higher quality service that didn’t happen, job site was a mess had to inspect gutters they were not cleaned. They came back out cleaned said it was done got back up on ladder gutters still full and found damaged siding on back of chimney. After filling with BBB repairs and cleanup were done just not worth the higher price. Price started at $26 a square for metal and $15. For fiberglass after 4 hours of sales it came down to $21 metal and $10.5 a square foot fiberglass. I surely have buyers remorse hopefully this review helps someone in their decision. Also suggest reading this [*** Link removed ***] prior to reading all the A+ ratings on BBB Also make sure proper permits were pulled they did not pull one till after the install when I questioned it. Good Luck"

Scott C on January 2023

Trusted, Bonded and Insured, Erie Construction has grown to become one of the nation's largest home remodeling companies. We offer best-in-class products aimed at improving the value of your home while saving money on your home energy bills. We've been truly dedicated to the products we offer, and we're happy to back them up with warranty's to match. Since opening our first location in 1975, Erie Construction has serviced over 100,000 customers, with over 50,000 returning to us for additional projects. Read what our customers have to say about us at GuildQuality: http://www.guildquality.com/erieconstruction You can always schedule your free estimate by dropping us a line at 1-800-536-4200 or visiting us online at http://www.erieconstruction.com Erie Construction services locations in nearly 26 states to bring the highest quality home products to you.

"Very high pressure sales. For your own sake have cameras rolling during sales pitch. Don’t let them make you believe that the installation is done by Erie. Totally subcontracted. Talked us into choosing them even though they were 7k higher than other roofers with the promise of higher quality service that didn’t happen, job site was a mess had to inspect gutters they were not cleaned. They came back out cleaned said it was done got back up on ladder gutters still full and found damaged siding on back of chimney. After filling with BBB repairs and cleanup were done just not worth the higher price. Price started at $26 a square for metal and $15. For fiberglass after 4 hours of sales it came down to $21 metal and $10.5 a square foot fiberglass. I surely have buyers remorse hopefully this review helps someone in their decision. Also suggest reading this [*** Link removed ***] prior to reading all the A+ ratings on BBB Also make sure proper permits were pulled they did not pull one till after the install when I questioned it. Good Luck"

Scott C on January 2023

Hardware World

5.00(
1
)

Hardware World

5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Hardware World is an online hardware and sundry goods retailer. We ship to all 50 states and also some orders can be shipped internationally. We are A+ accredited by BBB and maintain excellent ratings from real customers on ResellerRatings.com. We also maintain 5 star ratings from real customers on Amazon.com

Hardware World is an online hardware and sundry goods retailer. We ship to all 50 states and also some orders can be shipped internationally. We are A+ accredited by BBB and maintain excellent ratings from real customers on ResellerRatings.com. We also maintain 5 star ratings from real customers on Amazon.com

Avatar for WNYSurfaceMagic

WNYSurfaceMagic

2.40(
5
)

WNYSurfaceMagic

2.40(
5
)
2010 years of experience

Looking for the Bathtub and Bathroom Refinishing and Resurfacing services in Buffalo NY, then we are the best option you can ever reach out to. We have experience of more than 10 years in doing the same business so you can completely rely on our bathtub, bathroom, tiles refinishing and resurfacing practices. At WNYSurfaceMagic, we use high quality material and products to accomplish the task which stays for a long time. So why wait, go for a resurfacing or refinishing and save easily over 50% of the replacement cost.

Looking for the Bathtub and Bathroom Refinishing and Resurfacing services in Buffalo NY, then we are the best option you can ever reach out to. We have experience of more than 10 years in doing the same business so you can completely rely on our bathtub, bathroom, tiles refinishing and resurfacing practices. At WNYSurfaceMagic, we use high quality material and products to accomplish the task which stays for a long time. So why wait, go for a resurfacing or refinishing and save easily over 50% of the replacement cost.

Avatar for American Tubs....

American Tubs....

2.33(
3
)

American Tubs....

2.33(
3
)
Customers say: Terrific value
2012 years of experience

American Tubs designs and manufactures a complete line of premium quality Walk-In Bathtubs that are ideal for people with Limited Mobility, Seniors, Disabled and people with pain, arthritis, stress and other debilitating conditions.

American Tubs designs and manufactures a complete line of premium quality Walk-In Bathtubs that are ideal for people with Limited Mobility, Seniors, Disabled and people with pain, arthritis, stress and other debilitating conditions.

Avatar for Noah Home Comfort

Noah Home Comfort

No reviews yet

Noah Home Comfort

No reviews yet
2019 years of experience

We are a family owned and operated Handyman service. We specialize in all aspects of home repair, remodel and service. From mounting a flat screen on the wall, painting, plumbing and electrical to paver patios and bathroom remodels. No job too BIG no job too small… we do it all. We believe in building lasting relationships with every client we have the please of working for. Make a great choice. Contact us today.

We are a family owned and operated Handyman service. We specialize in all aspects of home repair, remodel and service. From mounting a flat screen on the wall, painting, plumbing and electrical to paver patios and bathroom remodels. No job too BIG no job too small… we do it all. We believe in building lasting relationships with every client we have the please of working for. Make a great choice. Contact us today.

2 THUMBS UP CONSTRUCTION

No reviews yet

2 THUMBS UP CONSTRUCTION

No reviews yet
2007 years of experience

Tired of all those huge companies obercharging? We complete a vast area of jobs. Multi faceted work scope. We complete new builds to small repairs. Ground up and roof to foundation and mostly eveything in between. As a courtesy we offer 10% off for veterans and senior citizens. Chilling procedures are usually 50 to 60% of the jobs down upon quotes acceptance, depending on job nature. We offer a sliding scale for labor warranty.

Tired of all those huge companies obercharging? We complete a vast area of jobs. Multi faceted work scope. We complete new builds to small repairs. Ground up and roof to foundation and mostly eveything in between. As a courtesy we offer 10% off for veterans and senior citizens. Chilling procedures are usually 50 to 60% of the jobs down upon quotes acceptance, depending on job nature. We offer a sliding scale for labor warranty.

Bathtub Restoration questions, answered by experts

If you don’t caulk your bathtub, then there won’t be a watertight seal between your bathtub and the wall tile surrounding it. As a result, water can seep into the wall and the floor and cause the perfect breeding grounds for mold and mildew. Not only does this require costly repairs, but mold can be harmful to those breathing it. 

It’s substantially less expensive to reglaze a tub than to replace it. The average cost of reglazing a bathtub is between $400 and $700, but that range may be higher based on where you live and the type of tub you have. Meanwhile, if you want to replace the bathtub, you’re looking at $2,000 to $9,400, with the average close to $5,700.

You're more likely to accidentally crack your plastic tub rather than successfully fixing a hole. You can fix hairline cracks and larger stress cracks with a plastic tub crack repair kit from a home improvement store. You'll need to clean out the tub, apply either the epoxy resin or filler putty compound into the crack, let it dry, and then sand it out.

Depending on your budget, you might consider a new tub as part of your bathroom remodel costs. It could be a good opportunity to update everything after considering all of the bathroom remodel ideas out there.

A chipped bathtub could leak over time if you don’t take care of the issue. A tiny chip isn’t a big deal but may eventually grow into a larger crack. As the months go by, the tub’s barrier against moisture becomes weakened, making it prone to leaking. Large chips can also cause the tub to rust and even crack in half.

A peeling bathtub is not a good thing. It’s a sign that the finish is coming off, and continued exposure to water and cleaning products can continue to damage the finish and eventually the underlying structure of the tub. What starts as a few chips or flakes can worsen into large chunks peeling off.

The Shelby, NY homeowners’ guide to bathtub restorations

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles