
Get matched with top roofers in Penn Yan, NY
There are 6 highly-rated local roofers.
Need a pro for your roofing project in Penn Yan, NY?
TRUSTED BY PENN YAN, NY HOMEOWNERS
4.5
Average homeowner rating64
Verified roofing services reviews
Verified Reviews for Roofing pros in Penn Yan, NY
Last update on September 26, 2025
Find Roofers in Penn Yan

Proctor Roofing
Proctor Roofing
Proctor Roofing, your trusted roofing experts in Rochester. With years of experience and a team of skilled professionals, we are committed to providing top-quality roofing services. From repairs to installations, we've got you covered. Contact us today for all your roofing needs.
"Most overpriced roofing company around. It's laughable the quotes I was given by these guys vs. the other roofers I spoke with. Combine that with the fact I was warned about how they are quick to go the half-a** route when encountering a problem vs. actually doing the right thing and solving the problem. I've heard many accounts of this company just throwing up flashing and tar over a problem area of a roof instead of taking off the bad old roof and fixing it the correct way. People please get MANY MANY quotes for MANY different companies and you will quickly see that Proctor is a rip-off artist."
Tobias S on February 2025
Proctor Roofing, your trusted roofing experts in Rochester. With years of experience and a team of skilled professionals, we are committed to providing top-quality roofing services. From repairs to installations, we've got you covered. Contact us today for all your roofing needs.
"Most overpriced roofing company around. It's laughable the quotes I was given by these guys vs. the other roofers I spoke with. Combine that with the fact I was warned about how they are quick to go the half-a** route when encountering a problem vs. actually doing the right thing and solving the problem. I've heard many accounts of this company just throwing up flashing and tar over a problem area of a roof instead of taking off the bad old roof and fixing it the correct way. People please get MANY MANY quotes for MANY different companies and you will quickly see that Proctor is a rip-off artist."
Tobias S on February 2025

Graves Brothers Home Improvement
Graves Brothers Home Improvement
Graves Brothers Home Improvement has been locally-owned and operated in Upstate N.Y. since 1977. As one of the fastest growing businesses in the region, they offer their residential and commercial clients Roofing, Siding, Windows, and other Home Improvement services. Graves is a nationally-recognized contractor that has been repeatedly named a Top 100 company in the region as well as one of the top 500 home improvement companies in the United States, annual Angie’s List certification holder, countless product certifications, and more. Graves Brothers services Upstate and Western New York and the Finger Lakes Region from their facilities in Rochester, Buffalo, and Syracuse.
"The positive: Graves Brothers will provide a quote for PARTIAL Siding projects where most companies won't talk to you unless you need a FULL Siding project. The installation team was quick and did a nice job. The Cons: Deceptive Sales. Your Typical Residential Home Services contactor. I had a complete east side siding replacement quoted. There is a 24" "Jog wall" between the exterior garage wall and the living quarters wall. Their quote included photos that show this wall in one of the views. A second photo shows the entire length of the wall outlined that includes this jog wall, but they did not replace the siding on this wall. A conversation BEFORE the project work started questioned if I intended on having the wall replaced and it was agreed that it should have been part of the proposal. The installers DID NOT replace the siding on this wall. I asked for a simple $500 credit and was willing to settle for a $350 credit which was more than fair. The Salesman insisted that seeing the wall was not assigned a "wall number" therefore it was not included in their proposal. Graves Brothers displayed ZERO interest in coming to a mutual agreement on the discrepancy. Update 7/19/2024: After continued conversations, the Sales Rep finally conceded that after speaking with his installers, that the work WAS included in the initial estimate and should have been completed. I gave Graves Brothers the option of discounting the price or returning to finish the work. They chose to finish the work which is scheduled this week. IMO, Speaking to his installation team should have been done PRIOR to him taking a flat stance with me that they were right and I was wrong. Give Graves Brothers Home Improvements a 3-Star rating for (finally) doing what was right. The installation was done well and the installers were professional, courteous and cleaned up well. Just make sure you document all conversations and get them in writing up front."
Darrin O on July 2024
Graves Brothers Home Improvement has been locally-owned and operated in Upstate N.Y. since 1977. As one of the fastest growing businesses in the region, they offer their residential and commercial clients Roofing, Siding, Windows, and other Home Improvement services. Graves is a nationally-recognized contractor that has been repeatedly named a Top 100 company in the region as well as one of the top 500 home improvement companies in the United States, annual Angie’s List certification holder, countless product certifications, and more. Graves Brothers services Upstate and Western New York and the Finger Lakes Region from their facilities in Rochester, Buffalo, and Syracuse.
"The positive: Graves Brothers will provide a quote for PARTIAL Siding projects where most companies won't talk to you unless you need a FULL Siding project. The installation team was quick and did a nice job. The Cons: Deceptive Sales. Your Typical Residential Home Services contactor. I had a complete east side siding replacement quoted. There is a 24" "Jog wall" between the exterior garage wall and the living quarters wall. Their quote included photos that show this wall in one of the views. A second photo shows the entire length of the wall outlined that includes this jog wall, but they did not replace the siding on this wall. A conversation BEFORE the project work started questioned if I intended on having the wall replaced and it was agreed that it should have been part of the proposal. The installers DID NOT replace the siding on this wall. I asked for a simple $500 credit and was willing to settle for a $350 credit which was more than fair. The Salesman insisted that seeing the wall was not assigned a "wall number" therefore it was not included in their proposal. Graves Brothers displayed ZERO interest in coming to a mutual agreement on the discrepancy. Update 7/19/2024: After continued conversations, the Sales Rep finally conceded that after speaking with his installers, that the work WAS included in the initial estimate and should have been completed. I gave Graves Brothers the option of discounting the price or returning to finish the work. They chose to finish the work which is scheduled this week. IMO, Speaking to his installation team should have been done PRIOR to him taking a flat stance with me that they were right and I was wrong. Give Graves Brothers Home Improvements a 3-Star rating for (finally) doing what was right. The installation was done well and the installers were professional, courteous and cleaned up well. Just make sure you document all conversations and get them in writing up front."
Darrin O on July 2024

Pro Stars Contractor Inc
Pro Stars Contractor Inc
As a family owned and operated company, Pro Stars has been successfully helping thousands of families improving residential and commercial needs. We’ve been covering all of Rockland County, Orange County, Westchester County, Dutchess and Hudson Valley, Buffalo NY, Rochester NY, Syracuse NY, along with parts of New Jersey and Connecticut for many years supplying the highest quality of work for roof repair, siding, and gutter systems while also providing comfortable monthly payments that suits your budget. Our team is committed to achieving the highest standards in the industry.
"Awesome job. Very pleased with the job, price and clean up. Very professional. Wonderful experience. Would recommend to everyone."
Sherry C on April 2024
As a family owned and operated company, Pro Stars has been successfully helping thousands of families improving residential and commercial needs. We’ve been covering all of Rockland County, Orange County, Westchester County, Dutchess and Hudson Valley, Buffalo NY, Rochester NY, Syracuse NY, along with parts of New Jersey and Connecticut for many years supplying the highest quality of work for roof repair, siding, and gutter systems while also providing comfortable monthly payments that suits your budget. Our team is committed to achieving the highest standards in the industry.
"Awesome job. Very pleased with the job, price and clean up. Very professional. Wonderful experience. Would recommend to everyone."
Sherry C on April 2024

F & M Contracting
F & M Contracting
FM Construction has built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. We service both residential and commercial properties. We give you the peace of mind you need to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started!
"The guys from F&M contracting we’re very personable and understood what I needed done and the job turned out amazing.."
Eugenia A on April 2025
FM Construction has built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. We service both residential and commercial properties. We give you the peace of mind you need to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started!
"The guys from F&M contracting we’re very personable and understood what I needed done and the job turned out amazing.."
Eugenia A on April 2025
Swarey Builders, LLC
Swarey Builders, LLC
Swarey Builders, LLC is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers' interests, and make their concerns the basis of our business.
"On time, quality work, I would hire them again if I need it."
Willie S on August 2023
Swarey Builders, LLC is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers' interests, and make their concerns the basis of our business.
"On time, quality work, I would hire them again if I need it."
Willie S on August 2023
FV Drywall
FV Drywall
We take great pride in offering the best possible experience with our expertise, quality, and customer service. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our clients; we take great care to work and communicate with everyone in a professional manner. It is our mission to exceed our clients expectations by providing excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction, from the start of each project to its completion. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.
"The owner had outstanding communication. They always showed up when scheduled. Very polite & friendly. Crew were hard workers. I was happy with the prompt service, price and work preformed."
Patti S on April 2023
We take great pride in offering the best possible experience with our expertise, quality, and customer service. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our clients; we take great care to work and communicate with everyone in a professional manner. It is our mission to exceed our clients expectations by providing excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction, from the start of each project to its completion. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.
"The owner had outstanding communication. They always showed up when scheduled. Very polite & friendly. Crew were hard workers. I was happy with the prompt service, price and work preformed."
Patti S on April 2023
VELUX America
VELUX America
Start with skylights! At VELUX, our mission is clear: we're dedicated to transforming your space with natural light and fresh air with skylights. Whether you're looking to replace old skylights or install brand-new ones, we will guide you every step of the way. Why Choose VELUX? =================== When it comes to skylights and roof windows, VELUX is the global leader. Here's why you should trust us to transform your home: 1. Innovation and Quality: VELUX skylights are renowned for their innovation and unmatched quality. They're designed to let in abundant natural light while keeping your space leak-free and energy-efficient. 2. Huge Product Selection: You’ll have access to a wide range of skylight options, from fixed to vented skylights. And we are here to help tailor the selection to suit your specific needs and style preferences. 3. Expertise: We take pride in what we do at VELUX, and our team is highly trained to guide you through the entire process. From selecting the perfect product for your space to providing valuable recommendations, we're committed to making sure your skylight project is a complete success. 4. Professional Installation Partners: We don't stop at product selection and recommendations; we also match you with a VELUX-trained installer who will handle the installation of your skylights with precision and expertise.
Start with skylights! At VELUX, our mission is clear: we're dedicated to transforming your space with natural light and fresh air with skylights. Whether you're looking to replace old skylights or install brand-new ones, we will guide you every step of the way. Why Choose VELUX? =================== When it comes to skylights and roof windows, VELUX is the global leader. Here's why you should trust us to transform your home: 1. Innovation and Quality: VELUX skylights are renowned for their innovation and unmatched quality. They're designed to let in abundant natural light while keeping your space leak-free and energy-efficient. 2. Huge Product Selection: You’ll have access to a wide range of skylight options, from fixed to vented skylights. And we are here to help tailor the selection to suit your specific needs and style preferences. 3. Expertise: We take pride in what we do at VELUX, and our team is highly trained to guide you through the entire process. From selecting the perfect product for your space to providing valuable recommendations, we're committed to making sure your skylight project is a complete success. 4. Professional Installation Partners: We don't stop at product selection and recommendations; we also match you with a VELUX-trained installer who will handle the installation of your skylights with precision and expertise.
Hartski Enterprises
Hartski Enterprises
Welcome to Hartski Enterprises, where we pride ourselves on transforming homes with exceptional craftsmanship and premium-quality materials. From our experience in home improvement and renovation, we understand that your home is one of your most significant investments. Our mission is to deliver not just projects but peace of mind, ensuring every homeowner we serve receives the best products, meticulous attention to detail, and a finished result that exceeds expectations. At Hartski, our approach begins with a commitment to quality materials. We believe that the foundation of every successful project lies in using products that are durable, reliable, and designed to withstand the test of time. Whether it's energy-efficient windows, robust siding, or stunning flooring, we select materials that enhance your home’s aesthetic appeal and functional value. Our focus on quality extends beyond aesthetics; we prioritize products that improve your home's safety, comfort, and long-term performance. Equally important to us is craftsmanship, the art of bringing those materials to life. Our team of skilled professionals are passionate about what they do, bringing years of expertise and a meticulous eye for detail to every project. At Hartski, craftsmanship is more than a skill—it’s a promise. We take pride in delivering precision and care at every stage, from initial consultations to the final walk-through. We understand that every homeowner’s needs and preferences are unique. That’s why we take a personalized approach to every project, working closely with our clients to understand their vision and goals. Whether it’s a simple repair, a major renovation, or a custom addition, we tailor our craftsmanship and material choices to suit your style, budget, and lifestyle. Our team collaborates with you to ensure that every detail aligns with your expectations, delivering results that are as functional as they are beautiful.
"Excellent! But and on and his team extended a concrete pad that was poured too short. It is so good to have people who love their work and take pride in doing business with a customer honoring attitude."
Patricia F on September 2025
Welcome to Hartski Enterprises, where we pride ourselves on transforming homes with exceptional craftsmanship and premium-quality materials. From our experience in home improvement and renovation, we understand that your home is one of your most significant investments. Our mission is to deliver not just projects but peace of mind, ensuring every homeowner we serve receives the best products, meticulous attention to detail, and a finished result that exceeds expectations. At Hartski, our approach begins with a commitment to quality materials. We believe that the foundation of every successful project lies in using products that are durable, reliable, and designed to withstand the test of time. Whether it's energy-efficient windows, robust siding, or stunning flooring, we select materials that enhance your home’s aesthetic appeal and functional value. Our focus on quality extends beyond aesthetics; we prioritize products that improve your home's safety, comfort, and long-term performance. Equally important to us is craftsmanship, the art of bringing those materials to life. Our team of skilled professionals are passionate about what they do, bringing years of expertise and a meticulous eye for detail to every project. At Hartski, craftsmanship is more than a skill—it’s a promise. We take pride in delivering precision and care at every stage, from initial consultations to the final walk-through. We understand that every homeowner’s needs and preferences are unique. That’s why we take a personalized approach to every project, working closely with our clients to understand their vision and goals. Whether it’s a simple repair, a major renovation, or a custom addition, we tailor our craftsmanship and material choices to suit your style, budget, and lifestyle. Our team collaborates with you to ensure that every detail aligns with your expectations, delivering results that are as functional as they are beautiful.
"Excellent! But and on and his team extended a concrete pad that was poured too short. It is so good to have people who love their work and take pride in doing business with a customer honoring attitude."
Patricia F on September 2025
Roofing Pups, Roofing & Siding - NY
Roofing Pups, Roofing & Siding - NY
Whether it’s roofing or siding, decks, gutters, roof snow/ice removal, or storm damage, Roofing Pups is your partner to make your home more beautiful, because your house is more than just a house, it’s your home. At our company, we don’t just replace roofs; we cultivate relationships. Your family’s safety is paramount, and we cherish them as much as you do. The value we offer in terms of safety and quality is unparalleled. Invest in the peace of mind that comes from knowing your family is safe.
"Still leaks"
Dwain C on February 2025
Whether it’s roofing or siding, decks, gutters, roof snow/ice removal, or storm damage, Roofing Pups is your partner to make your home more beautiful, because your house is more than just a house, it’s your home. At our company, we don’t just replace roofs; we cultivate relationships. Your family’s safety is paramount, and we cherish them as much as you do. The value we offer in terms of safety and quality is unparalleled. Invest in the peace of mind that comes from knowing your family is safe.
"Still leaks"
Dwain C on February 2025
Baity property maintenance
Baity property maintenance
Some of the services offered include painting, clean out, roofing, drywall, and much more
Some of the services offered include painting, clean out, roofing, drywall, and much more
The Penn Yan, NY homeowners’ guide to roofing services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Sealing your roof can help preserve its life span—you just have to choose the right coating. This guide will help you budget for your total roof coating cost.
The cost of replacing a flat roof is much lower than an angled one. Learn about the factors that can affect flat roof replacement costs and ways to save on a quality replacement.
Discover the most significant factors regarding aluminum roofing cost to help you make informed decisions about your investment in one for your home.
Rotted or damaged fascia boards will no longer shield your roof’s rafters. Use this guide to learn how to replace a fascia board on your own, to keep your roof system running well.
Understanding how architectural shingles versus 3-tab shingles differ can help you complete your roofing project successfully. We’ll break down each option.
Wondering how to choose between standing seam versus corrugated metal roofing? Here’s everything you need to know to decide which is right for you.
- Branchport, NY Roofers
- Dundee, NY Roofers
- Pulteney, NY Roofers
- Gorham, NY Roofers
- Middlesex, NY Roofers
- Rushville, NY Roofers
- Stanley, NY Roofers
- Romulus, NY Roofers
- Ovid, NY Roofers
- Prattsburgh, NY Roofers
- Wayne, NY Roofers
- Geneva, NY Roofers
- Hector, NY Roofers
- Hammondsport, NY Roofers
- Fayette, NY Roofers
- Interlaken, NY Roofers
- Canandaigua, NY Roofers
- Naples, NY Roofers
- Greene, NY Roofers
- Waterloo, NY Roofers
- Junius, NY Roofers
- Watkins Glen, NY Roofers
- Phelps, NY Roofers
- Clifton Springs, NY Roofers
- Aurora, NY Roofers
- King Ferry, NY Roofers
- Union Springs, NY Roofers
- Springport, NY Roofers
- Seneca Falls, NY Roofers
- Shortsville, NY Roofers
- Insulation in Penn Yan
- Roof Cleaning in Penn Yan
- Home Warranties in Penn Yan
- Skylights in Penn Yan
- Home Inspection in Penn Yan
- Chimney Sweep in Penn Yan
- Sunrooms and Patios in Penn Yan
- Mold Testing and Remediation in Penn Yan
- Garages in Penn Yan
- Metal Fabrication and Restoration in Penn Yan
- Gutter Cleaning in Penn Yan
- Chimney Repair in Penn Yan
- Unfinished Carpentry in Penn Yan
- Roof Ice and Snow Removal in Penn Yan
- Solar Panels in Penn Yan
- Chimney Caps in Penn Yan
- Siding in Penn Yan
- Modular and Mobile Home Remodel in Penn Yan
- Gutter Repair and Replacement in Penn Yan
- Animal Removal in Penn Yan
- Water and Smoke Damage Repair in Penn Yan