Get matched with top water heater pros in Jay, FL

Q: What are the signs that a water heater is failing or needs to be replaced?

• <div>Several signs indicate your water heater may be failing or in need of replacement. Key indicators include:<ul><li>Age: A water heater older than ten years is approaching the end of its typical lifespan.</li><li>Water Quality: If you notice rusty or discolored water from your hot water faucets, or a foul odor similar to rotten eggs or sulfur, it can signal internal corrosion.</li><li>Unusual Noises: Banging, rumbling, or popping sounds from the tank often mean sediment has built up, causing the unit to overheat.</li><li>Leaks: Any water pooling around the base of the tank or visible leaks are clear signs of failure.</li><li>Performance Issues: A decline in performance, such as water not getting hot enough, taking longer to heat up, low water pressure, or decreased efficiency, suggests the unit is struggling.</li><li>Visible Damage: Obvious rust and corrosion on the exterior of the tank can indicate a more serious internal problem.</li></ul>While these signs often point to replacement, some issues may be fixable. It's best to consult a professional plumber to diagnose the problem before investing in a new unit.</div>

Q: What size water heater does my house need?

• <div>If you're replacing a broken water heater, now is a great time to make sure you're selecting a unit that has the right capacity for your household. According to the<a href="https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/sizing-new-water-heater"> U.S. Department of Energy</a>, a small 50-gallon to 60-gallon tank is sufficient for households with one to three people. A medium-sized 80-gallon tank is considered ideal for three to four people. A larger tank may be needed if your household has four to six people.</div>

Q: What are the pros and cons of electric water heaters?

• <div>Every type of water heater has its advantages and disadvantages. Understanding those can help you decide the best type for your situation and budget. Pros<ul><li>Safer than gas or propane</li><li>Doesn&rsquo;t require extensive venting systems</li><li>Lower upfront costs</li><li>Simpler to operate</li><li>No pilot light</li><li>Easier installation</li><li>More efficient heating than gas models</li><li>Available as point-of-use (POU) and whole-house units</li></ul>Cons<ul><li>Slower to heat water</li><li>Longer recovery time</li><li>Possibly higher operating costs</li><li>Doesn&rsquo;t work during a power outage</li><li>Costs can increase without a 240-volt connection</li></ul></div>

Q: Can a water heater element be replaced without draining the tank?

• <div>No, you&rsquo;ll need to drain the tank before changing a water heater element, as the water heater element sticks through the side of the tank and uses a gasket to prevent water from pouring out. However, you don&rsquo;t always need to drain it completely. If you&rsquo;re only replacing the upper heating element, you can drain the tank until the water line is below the element. If you&rsquo;re replacing the lower element, you&rsquo;ll need to drain the whole thing. </div>

Q: How can I cut down my water bill?

• <div>A single shower consumes an average of over 17 gallons, while brushing your teeth with the water running uses up to four unnecessary gallons. Watering the lawn spreads hundreds of gallons of water across the yard each time. Limiting water usage in these areas can significantly cut down your water bill. </div>

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 5 pros

Need a pro for your water heater service project in Jay, FL?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

Verified Reviews for Water Heater Service pros in Jay, FL

*The Angi rating for Water Heater Service companies in Jay, FL is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Water Heater Service companies in Jay, FL is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.

Last update on February 04, 2026

Reviewed in February 2026
Had the right equipment and excellent workers. Very satisfactory. Would recommend highly.
Landworx Construction
Request a quote
Reviewed in January 2026
I hired this company to pressure wash my white fence and they were very professional and used their time wisely all the way through the job! Will definitely hire again!
Scrubby Dubby
Request a quote
Reviewed in December 2024
Hired them to put a sealant on my metal awning roof on my back porch. They came and were proficient at doing the job and promised that if there were any leaks, they would come back and correct them. I had a couple leaks about a month after they came back and applied some tape on the underside to...
Williamson Homes, Inc.
Request a quote
Reviewed in September 2024
out standing service definitely recommended.
All In Heating and Air LLC
Request a quote
Reviewed in July 2024
Travis was recommended by a friend to do our flooring. He quickly answered our phone calls and stayed in constant contact. He worked around our schedule and completed the job perfectly and in under the quoted time frame! He was Very reasonable priced and the flooring he completed was done...
DUNCAN & SONS
Request a quote
Reviewed in September 2023
Mr. Gibbs did a wonderful job on our leaky water heater. I thought I could do a DIY myself and obviously fell short. I reached out to Bayshore Enterprises because it was in my area and I needed help fast as I am a single mom with two little girls. Mr.Gibbs was clear and transparent and gave me a...
Bayshore Enterprises, LLC
Request a quote
Reviewed in August 2023
I recommend them for anyone.
Eddings Construction
Request a quote
Reviewed in June 2023
Carnley Electric is great to work with. They are reliable and do great work.
Carnley Electric, Inc.
Request a quote
Reviewed in August 2022
Great. Have been using this company since it started and have not been disappointed. Service is impeccable and customer centric. Also have had them do pressure washing.
PanHandle Window Wash
Request a quote
Reviewed in March 2022
While talking to the owner, he was professional and a pleasure to deal with. He answered or returned calls promptly when I needed to contact him, and the delivery of the container was fast. A very trustworthy and honest company. I will definitely use again and I recommend them for your haul...
Merkels Hauling Service
Request a quote

Find Water heater pros in Jay

Hiller Plumbing, Heating, Cooling, & Electrical

4.5(

)

Water Heater - Install or ReplaceWater Heater - Repair or ServiceTankless Water Heater - Install+1 more

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

In business since 1990

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

Hiller Plumbing, Heating, Cooling, & Electrical, established in 1990, stands for quality and reliability. With our 'Happy You'll Be or the Service is Free' guarantee, we are dedicated to customer satisfaction in Pensacola and the surrounding communities. Our plumbers provide emergency repairs, sewer line service, and expert installation or repair of water heaters. Our HVAC specialists ensure your comfort with preventative maintenance, air conditioning and furnace repairs, for year-round comfort. Our licensed and insured electricians offer prompt emergency response, custom upgrades, and safe, thorough electrical fixes for both residential and commercial properties. Hiller is your trusted provider for all your home service needs.

17 neighbors recently requested a quote

Recommended by94%of homeowners

Request Quote

Perdido Heating and Air

4.9(

)

Water Heater - Install or ReplaceTankless Water Heater - RepairTankless Water Heater - Install+1 more

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1976

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Service person was professional and clearly knew what he was doing. We are extremely pleased!
"

13 neighbors recently requested a quote

Recommended by77%of homeowners

Request Quote

R&M Clearwater and Air, Inc.

4.5(

)

Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2013

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"They were efficient ,professional ,pleasant"

Response time2 days

Response rate90%

52 neighbors recently requested a quote

Request Quote

J & M Plumbing and Gas, Inc.

4.7(

)

Water Heater - Install or ReplaceTankless Water Heater - InstallTankless Water Heater - Install - For Business+1 more

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2020

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Had them replace heating elements in my water heater. They were on time, very courteous and very reasonable."

Response time1 day

8 neighbors recently requested a quote

Recommended by100%of homeowners

Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2021

Free estimates

"I spoke to Robert to schedule installation of my water heater. He responded very quickly. I was surprised at how fast he was able to get the job done (the next day). He showed up when he said he is very kind, courteous and respectful! I will recommend him to anyone that is in need of plumbing work. Thank you Robert!!"

1 neighbors recently requested a quote

Request Quote

Inline Plumbing & Gas LLC

4.9(

)

Water Heater - Install or ReplaceTankless Water Heater - InstallTankless Water Heater - Install - For Business

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2019

Credit card accepted

Offers commercial services

"Excellent experience from start to finish! They replaced our kitchen faucet, and the entire process was quick, professional, and hassle-free. The plumber arrived on time, explained everything clearly, and did a great job with the installation. The new faucet looks perfect, and they left the area spotless when they were finished. I really appreciated the quality of the work and the friendly customer service. I would definitely recommend this company to anyone needing plumbing work and will use them again in the future!"

6 neighbors recently requested a quote

Recommended by50%of homeowners

Tankless Water Heater - InstallTankless Water Heater - Install - For BusinessTankless Water Heater - Repair+3 more

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2019

Free estimates

Customers say: Quick response

"Chris came and gave me a Quote to remove 2 old hot water heaters and install a new one. Job was done in a timely manner and left the area clean and for a reasonable price. Would recommend him to do a water heater replacement."

Recommended by100%of homeowners

Request Quote

Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Gulf Breeze

4.4(

)

Tankless Water Heater - InstallTankless Water Heater - RepairWater Heater - Install or Replace+3 more

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 1989

Emergency services offered

Warranties offered

"Had my water heater serviced. Very quick scheduling, arrived on time and worked diligently to get the job done. Very communicative on the repair process and pricing."

Recommended by66%of homeowners

Water Heater - Install or ReplaceTankless Water Heater - Install

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2022

Free estimates

Offers commercial services

"⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Excellent service from start to finish. Brandon was very helpful with the estimate, communication, and coordination of the job. His partner and his son arrived on time to replace our gas water heater. They were courteous, professional, and very thorough. During the installation, they discovered an unexpected leak at the main water line and were able to take care of that for us as well. They even made several trips to Home Depot to get the parts they needed, and they cleaned the garage completely before leaving. Brandon continued to keep me informed afterward regarding the permit and inspection, and the final inspection passed without any issues. The price was very competitive and the best of the estimates I received. Overall, I was very pleased with the service, communication, and quality of the work. I would definitely recommend Brandon and his team."

+22

27 neighbors recently requested a quote

Request Quote

Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Niceville

3.8(

108

)

Water Heater - Install or ReplaceTankless Water Heater - InstallTankless Water Heater - Repair+3 more

Serving Jay, FL and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1989

Emergency services offered

Warranties offered

"Great job servicing my water heater"

178 neighbors recently requested a quote

Recommended by64%of homeowners

Request Quote

Showing 1-10 of 39

Water Heaters questions, answered by experts

Several signs indicate your water heater may be failing or in need of replacement. Key indicators include:

Age: A water heater older than ten years is approaching the end of its typical lifespan.
Water Quality: If you notice rusty or discolored water from your hot water faucets, or a foul odor similar to rotten eggs or sulfur, it can signal internal corrosion.
Unusual Noises: Banging, rumbling, or popping sounds from the tank often mean sediment has built up, causing the unit to overheat.
Leaks: Any water pooling around the base of the tank or visible leaks are clear signs of failure.
Performance Issues: A decline in performance, such as water not getting hot enough, taking longer to heat up, low water pressure, or decreased efficiency, suggests the unit is struggling.
Visible Damage: Obvious rust and corrosion on the exterior of the tank can indicate a more serious internal problem.

While these signs often point to replacement, some issues may be fixable. It's best to consult a professional plumber to diagnose the problem before investing in a new unit.

If you're replacing a broken water heater, now is a great time to make sure you're selecting a unit that has the right capacity for your household. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, a small 50-gallon to 60-gallon tank is sufficient for households with one to three people. A medium-sized 80-gallon tank is considered ideal for three to four people. A larger tank may be needed if your household has four to six people.

Every type of water heater has its advantages and disadvantages. Understanding those can help you decide the best type for your situation and budget.

Pros

Safer than gas or propane
Doesn’t require extensive venting systems
Lower upfront costs
Simpler to operate
No pilot light
Easier installation
More efficient heating than gas models
Available as point-of-use (POU) and whole-house units

Cons

Slower to heat water
Longer recovery time
Possibly higher operating costs
Doesn’t work during a power outage
Costs can increase without a 240-volt connection

No, you’ll need to drain the tank before changing a water heater element, as the water heater element sticks through the side of the tank and uses a gasket to prevent water from pouring out. However, you don’t always need to drain it completely. If you’re only replacing the upper heating element, you can drain the tank until the water line is below the element. If you’re replacing the lower element, you’ll need to drain the whole thing.

A single shower consumes an average of over 17 gallons, while brushing your teeth with the water running uses up to four unnecessary gallons. Watering the lawn spreads hundreds of gallons of water across the yard each time. Limiting water usage in these areas can significantly cut down your water bill.

The Jay, FL homeowners’ guide to water heater services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles

Haley Nothstein
•
Jul 10, 2026Jul 10, 2026
How Much Does a Water Heater Gas Valve Replacement Cost? [2026 Data]
Learn about the different factors that go into water heater gas valve replacement costs to see if you should DIY the project or call a pro.
Scott Dylan Westerlund
•
Jul 10, 2026Jul 10, 2026
How Much Does It Cost to Flush a Water Heater? [2026 Data]
A water heater flush costs $160 on average but can vary based on the unit size, type, labor, location, and more. Keep reading to learn how much you could pay.
Allie Ogletree
•
Aug 3, 2026Aug 3, 2026
How Much Does a Tankless Water Heater Cost? [2026 Data]
Tankless water heater costs depend on the size of your water heater, location, fuel type, and more. Keep reading to calculate your expenses.
Taylor Sansano
•
Jul 9, 2026Jul 9, 2026
Water Heater Frozen? How to Defrost a Water Heater
Worried your water heater might freeze this winter? Learn to spot the warning signs and how to safely thaw your tank or tankless system out if necessary.
Kelly Reilly
•
Jul 9, 2026Jul 9, 2026
The Pros and Cons of Hybrid Water Heaters
Hybrid water heaters will have you weighing high initial costs versus long-term savings. Is it the right option for you? Explore the pros and cons of hybrid water heaters.
C.E. Larusso
•
Jul 20, 2026Jul 20, 2026
How Long Do Water Heaters Last?
The average lifespan of water heaters is 6 to 15 years for conventional models and up to 20 for tankless ones, but it can be less if they are not properly maintained.