Top-rated water heater pros.

Get matched with top water heater pros in Elroy, WI

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Verified Reviews for Water Heater Service pros in Elroy, WI

*The Angi rating for Water Heater Service companies in Elroy, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Water Heater Service companies in Elroy, WI is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Water Heater Service needs.

Last update on November 22, 2025

Find Water heater pros in Elroy

Avatar for AppliancePartsPros.com

AppliancePartsPros.com

4.73(
287
)

AppliancePartsPros.com

4.73(
287
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Since 1999, we've helped millions of do-it-yourselfers save money and fix their broken appliances quickly by providing quality appliance parts and free repair advice. We are only an online appliance parts retailer that offers a 365 day warranty and fast shipping. We also offer technical advice and diagnosis totally free 6 days a week. If you are interested in repairing your own appliance, please call us at 1-877-477-7278 or click live chat on our web site. We will help diagnose the problem and provide you with all the necessary information for the repair free of charge. It's better with the Pros!™ Avoid costly service calls - visit us at http://www.appliancepartspros.com

"Beware of shipping issues with this company. Ordered an ice maker installation kit on 10/10/25. Shipping was due no later than 10/20 according to company and FedEx tracking. FedEx tracking showed the package at their facility for 8 days without moving beginning on 10/15. Called FedEx 3 times. Each time they said they cannot find package and I have to contact shipper. Shipper has to make a claim, they will not mark it as lost. Called Appliance Parts Pros twice. Each time they say FedEx has to mark package lost before they will do anything. They also state they have to wait 14 days from them before doing anything because of their contract with FedEx. I don't care about their contract, I want what was ordered and paid for. Just going in circles with them and FedEX. If they shipped after 14 days it would be 22 days from that point, 32 days from the date of order if they shipped it that day. There was a deadline for installing this part before tenants arrive. They did not care, would not m"

Ron R on October 2025

Since 1999, we've helped millions of do-it-yourselfers save money and fix their broken appliances quickly by providing quality appliance parts and free repair advice. We are only an online appliance parts retailer that offers a 365 day warranty and fast shipping. We also offer technical advice and diagnosis totally free 6 days a week. If you are interested in repairing your own appliance, please call us at 1-877-477-7278 or click live chat on our web site. We will help diagnose the problem and provide you with all the necessary information for the repair free of charge. It's better with the Pros!™ Avoid costly service calls - visit us at http://www.appliancepartspros.com

"Beware of shipping issues with this company. Ordered an ice maker installation kit on 10/10/25. Shipping was due no later than 10/20 according to company and FedEx tracking. FedEx tracking showed the package at their facility for 8 days without moving beginning on 10/15. Called FedEx 3 times. Each time they said they cannot find package and I have to contact shipper. Shipper has to make a claim, they will not mark it as lost. Called Appliance Parts Pros twice. Each time they say FedEx has to mark package lost before they will do anything. They also state they have to wait 14 days from them before doing anything because of their contract with FedEx. I don't care about their contract, I want what was ordered and paid for. Just going in circles with them and FedEX. If they shipped after 14 days it would be 22 days from that point, 32 days from the date of order if they shipped it that day. There was a deadline for installing this part before tenants arrive. They did not care, would not m"

Ron R on October 2025

Avatar for Your Chicagoland Remodeling

Your Chicagoland Remodeling

4.95(
111
)

Your Chicagoland Remodeling

4.95(
111
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers

Chicago Remodeling is a premiere remodeling company with decades of experience in creating the most stunning remodeling projects at an affordable cost. We believe in intelligent design that is both cost effective and effective for all your requirements. Our crew is made of some of the most renowned names from various parts of the remodeling industry, giving you a veritable super crew to hire for any kind of remodeling work.

"Chris and his partner removed cabinet, added a waterline and did electrical work to install a new dishwasher. I'm very pleased and would definitely hire this company again."

ValErie T on October 2018

Chicago Remodeling is a premiere remodeling company with decades of experience in creating the most stunning remodeling projects at an affordable cost. We believe in intelligent design that is both cost effective and effective for all your requirements. Our crew is made of some of the most renowned names from various parts of the remodeling industry, giving you a veritable super crew to hire for any kind of remodeling work.

"Chris and his partner removed cabinet, added a waterline and did electrical work to install a new dishwasher. I'm very pleased and would definitely hire this company again."

ValErie T on October 2018

Avatar for Carew Heating & A/C

Carew Heating & A/C

5.00(
25
)

Carew Heating & A/C

5.00(
25
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers

Hours listed are office hours. Service & repair hours are daily 24 hours. Additional email - [email protected].

Hours listed are office hours. Service & repair hours are daily 24 hours. Additional email - [email protected].

Avatar for Water Doctors

Water Doctors

4.89(
95
)

Water Doctors

4.89(
95
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Since 1982, Water Doctors has carried the highest quality water treatment systems available. We address water problems through a large product family designed to meet your needs. From water softners to iron filters to reverse osmosis systems, we address all water conditioning needs.

"It was smooth and no issues."

Jim S on June 2019

Since 1982, Water Doctors has carried the highest quality water treatment systems available. We address water problems through a large product family designed to meet your needs. From water softners to iron filters to reverse osmosis systems, we address all water conditioning needs.

"It was smooth and no issues."

Jim S on June 2019

Avatar for Property Image LLC

Property Image LLC

4.91(
34
)

Property Image LLC

4.91(
34
)
Customers say: Terrific value
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Property maintenance company working with commercial and residential customers. 8 - 12 Employees. Licensed and insured. Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Online work order system for all customers. Hourly rates. Per job pricing available too.

Property maintenance company working with commercial and residential customers. 8 - 12 Employees. Licensed and insured. Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Online work order system for all customers. Hourly rates. Per job pricing available too.

Bob Beer Plumbing

4.67(
12
)

Bob Beer Plumbing

4.67(
12
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers

Owner operated.

"This company was subcontracted, and they have been terrible. Entire project was delayed because he didn't come out on more than 2 occasions when he said he would. Sent his son out to do the work. Instead of running the hot water line from the shower to the sink, he used the old track and secured the hot water pipe around the entire room, charging more money for the job with the extra pipe being ran. The hot water pipe was ran along an exterior wall. The pipe began freezing. We did heat wrap but ended up having to put a blow dryer in there. The cold water pipe did not freeze at all. The room temperature was roughly 60 degrees. The proximity of the hot water pipe to the wall caused it to freeze. Multiple calls, texts, and voicemails were completely ignored by Bob. Contractor wasn't exactly responsive either. It's now almost a year later and they still have not fixed anything. I keep getting told, when it gets cold. It's been in the 40s already and no fix... "

Alisa M on November 2025

Owner operated.

"This company was subcontracted, and they have been terrible. Entire project was delayed because he didn't come out on more than 2 occasions when he said he would. Sent his son out to do the work. Instead of running the hot water line from the shower to the sink, he used the old track and secured the hot water pipe around the entire room, charging more money for the job with the extra pipe being ran. The hot water pipe was ran along an exterior wall. The pipe began freezing. We did heat wrap but ended up having to put a blow dryer in there. The cold water pipe did not freeze at all. The room temperature was roughly 60 degrees. The proximity of the hot water pipe to the wall caused it to freeze. Multiple calls, texts, and voicemails were completely ignored by Bob. Contractor wasn't exactly responsive either. It's now almost a year later and they still have not fixed anything. I keep getting told, when it gets cold. It's been in the 40s already and no fix... "

Alisa M on November 2025

Avatar for High Tech Home Warranties

High Tech Home Warranties

4.37(
35
)

High Tech Home Warranties

4.37(
35
)
Customers say: Terrific value
2008 years of experience

We are a one stop shop for all your home warranty needs. Our upbeat and friendly support team is always at your fingertips to respond to questions about your warranty 365 days a year! Emergency claims will be addressed within 24 hours from time claim is submitted and non-emergency claims will be addressed within 48 hours Monday - Friday 8:30 am - 6:00 pm. During nights and weekends non-emergency claims will not receive a call back until the next business day. Our service call deductibles range from $65 - $75.

"I had a bad computer board in my oven. they said they would not cover it because they found a roach. This is Florida we have some roaches. i do not have a bug problem. It has nothing to do with a bad computer board. This company looks for a way to deny claims. i had one other claim and they tried to deny it as well. Save yourself some agravation and stay away. They must post their own positive reviews. They took my $65.00 fee and did nothing"

marc g on August 2018

We are a one stop shop for all your home warranty needs. Our upbeat and friendly support team is always at your fingertips to respond to questions about your warranty 365 days a year! Emergency claims will be addressed within 24 hours from time claim is submitted and non-emergency claims will be addressed within 48 hours Monday - Friday 8:30 am - 6:00 pm. During nights and weekends non-emergency claims will not receive a call back until the next business day. Our service call deductibles range from $65 - $75.

"I had a bad computer board in my oven. they said they would not cover it because they found a roach. This is Florida we have some roaches. i do not have a bug problem. It has nothing to do with a bad computer board. This company looks for a way to deny claims. i had one other claim and they tried to deny it as well. Save yourself some agravation and stay away. They must post their own positive reviews. They took my $65.00 fee and did nothing"

marc g on August 2018

Avatar for Merrill Sheet Metal Works Inc.

Merrill Sheet Metal Works Inc.

4.55(
11
)

Merrill Sheet Metal Works Inc.

4.55(
11
)
Customers say: Quick response
1913 years of experience

Merrill Sheet Metal Works Inc. has been serving the greater Merrill area for over ONE HUNDRED years. Hallmarks of our small business include the utmost integrity and product knowledge spanning decades of service. We make heating and cooling silent, invisible and efficient. Our area of problem solving is reducing high energy consumption, correction of hot & cold areas as well as indoor air quality concerns. We also love to keep your family toasty in the winter by servicing your fireplace. Please call us today to set up an appointment!

Merrill Sheet Metal Works Inc. has been serving the greater Merrill area for over ONE HUNDRED years. Hallmarks of our small business include the utmost integrity and product knowledge spanning decades of service. We make heating and cooling silent, invisible and efficient. Our area of problem solving is reducing high energy consumption, correction of hot & cold areas as well as indoor air quality concerns. We also love to keep your family toasty in the winter by servicing your fireplace. Please call us today to set up an appointment!

Avatar for US Water, LLC

US Water, LLC

5.00(
4
)

US Water, LLC

5.00(
4
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We offer water treatment, water testing, well pump services and well, septic, and home inspections. Affordable pricing. Friendly, experienced team. Our business has been proudly serving our customers since 2000. We KNOW Wisconsin water. We strive to provide the best water treatment services possible to central, eastern, western, and northern Wisconsin. We can help with water hardness/scaling and resolve problems from nitrates, coliform bacteria, arsenic, lead, tannin and much more. Our experience and knowledge about Wisconsin water is complemented by our use of the highest-quality water treatment products available. We have combined two generations of expertise into a dedicated, friendly, knowledgeable staff. Please contact us to set up a FREE water test and let us help you get safe, clean, great tasting water from every tap in your home. We are also proud to offer complete home inspections with our experienced state-licensed home inspector. We offer flexible scheduling and quick turnaround on our home inspections.

We offer water treatment, water testing, well pump services and well, septic, and home inspections. Affordable pricing. Friendly, experienced team. Our business has been proudly serving our customers since 2000. We KNOW Wisconsin water. We strive to provide the best water treatment services possible to central, eastern, western, and northern Wisconsin. We can help with water hardness/scaling and resolve problems from nitrates, coliform bacteria, arsenic, lead, tannin and much more. Our experience and knowledge about Wisconsin water is complemented by our use of the highest-quality water treatment products available. We have combined two generations of expertise into a dedicated, friendly, knowledgeable staff. Please contact us to set up a FREE water test and let us help you get safe, clean, great tasting water from every tap in your home. We are also proud to offer complete home inspections with our experienced state-licensed home inspector. We offer flexible scheduling and quick turnaround on our home inspections.

Showing 1-10 of 37
Water Heaters questions, answered by experts

It takes between one and three hours to replace a hot water heater element, depending on whether you hire a pro or do the work yourself. For example, a professional plumber with all the necessary tools and experience can often finish the job in one to two hours, whereas DIY will take two to three hours because it'll involve more preparation and troubleshooting.

Replacement should be considered when repair costs exceed half the price of a new unit, if the heater is more than 10-15 years old, or if consistent issues hinder its effective functioning despite multiple repairs.

It usually takes a professional water heater installer between two and three hours to remove an existing water heater and install a new tank heater. However, it could take four to five hours if they have to work in a small utility closet or another tight area, like a crawl space. Tankless water heaters have a more complicated installation process, so they will take a bit longer. Additionally, a gas water heater requires a connection to a gas line, and that alone can add about an hour to the installation timeline compared to installing an electric water heater.

While many older homes don’t need hot water heater expansion tanks, they’re necessary in most newer homes and are required by building codes. These tanks are required by code in areas where there are backflow preventers or pressure regulators on the incoming water pipe between the public water pipes and the water heater. However, tankless water heaters don’t require expansion tanks.

Every type of water heater has its advantages and disadvantages. Understanding those can help you decide the best type for your situation and budget. 

Pros

  • Safer than gas or propane

  • Doesn’t require extensive venting systems

  • Lower upfront costs

  • Simpler to operate

  • No pilot light

  • Easier installation

  • More efficient heating than gas models

  • Available as point-of-use (POU) and whole-house units

Cons

  • Slower to heat water

  • Longer recovery time

  • Possibly higher operating costs

  • Doesn’t work during a power outage

  • Costs can increase without a 240-volt connection

The Elroy, WI homeowners’ guide to water heater services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles

What do you need done? We’ll find top pros.
  • 🌱 "Mow a small front yard"
  • 🛠 "Fix a leaking pipe under the sink"
  • 🏠 "Repair shingles on an asphalt roof"