Top-rated gutter repair and replacement pros.

Get matched with top gutter repair and replacement pros in York, NY

There are 8 highly-rated local gutter repair and replacement pros.

Need a pro for your gutter repair and replacement project in York, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY YORK, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.5
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon36
    Verified gutter repairs and replacements reviews

Verified Reviews for Gutter Repair And Replacement pros in York, NY

*The Angi rating for Gutter Repair And Replacement companies in York, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Gutter Repair And Replacement needs.

*The HomeAdvisor rating for Gutter Repair And Replacement companies in York, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Gutter Repair And Replacement needs.

Last update on December 05, 2025

Find Gutter repair and replacement pros in York

Avatar for Catalino Gutter Systems

Catalino Gutter Systems

4.99(
72
)
•Approved Pro

Catalino Gutter Systems

4.99(
72
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
30 local quotes requested

30 years experience serving the greater Rochester area, we specialize in seamless gutter systems. Full installation, repair, replacement and maintenance, including ice removal. We offer excellent customer service, top quality material and workmanship at affordable, competitive prices to residential and commercial customers. Fully insured. Your satisfaction is our top priority.

"Jeremy and his team did a great job. During the estimate, Jeremy took the time to listen to my concerns and had great suggestions. Beth quickly sent the estimate, and we were scheduled within a couple of weeks. There was great communication during the entire process. Jeremy and team showed up at the agreed time and they were great. We quickly had new gutters with the facia wrapped. They replaced 5" gutters with 6" where the old ones were failing to keep up with the volume of water. We couldn't be happier with the new gutters, the service we received, and a very fair price."

Jim P on December 2024

30 years experience serving the greater Rochester area, we specialize in seamless gutter systems. Full installation, repair, replacement and maintenance, including ice removal. We offer excellent customer service, top quality material and workmanship at affordable, competitive prices to residential and commercial customers. Fully insured. Your satisfaction is our top priority.

"Jeremy and his team did a great job. During the estimate, Jeremy took the time to listen to my concerns and had great suggestions. Beth quickly sent the estimate, and we were scheduled within a couple of weeks. There was great communication during the entire process. Jeremy and team showed up at the agreed time and they were great. We quickly had new gutters with the facia wrapped. They replaced 5" gutters with 6" where the old ones were failing to keep up with the volume of water. We couldn't be happier with the new gutters, the service we received, and a very fair price."

Jim P on December 2024

Avatar for MaxMastersLLC

MaxMastersLLC

5.00(
2
)

MaxMastersLLC

5.00(
2
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. Our team has quality experience in this industry, and we make sure our customers are happy before we leave. Call or click to schedule an estimate today! Additional phone (585) 478-9766.

"I was very happy with their professionalism and the quality of the completed job. My roof was very reasonably priced. The workers cleaned up everything daily. If I owned another property then I would hire them again. 100% recommendation"

Charles S on May 2023

We guarantee your satisfaction, and we won’t leave until the job is done right. Our team has quality experience in this industry, and we make sure our customers are happy before we leave. Call or click to schedule an estimate today! Additional phone (585) 478-9766.

"I was very happy with their professionalism and the quality of the completed job. My roof was very reasonably priced. The workers cleaned up everything daily. If I owned another property then I would hire them again. 100% recommendation"

Charles S on May 2023

Avatar for VIP Gutters

VIP Gutters

5.00(
2
)

VIP Gutters

5.00(
2
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Thank you for making the VIP choice. We’re a local Veteran owned Seamless Gutter Installation Company. We specialize in both 5” & 6” gutters. Our gutters come with a 30 year warranty and we stand behind our work with a 5 year workmanship guarantee. If you need leaf guards and are tired of constantly cleaning your gutters, we’re your #1 choice in gutter guard protection. Not only do we know gutters, we know what products really work to keep the leaves and critters out. Our gutter guards come with a lifetime warranty and 100% clog free guarantee. No nonsense and no high pressure sales tactics, just quality gutters, quality workmanship and VIP service. Call us today to set up your free estimate.

"It was wonderful. The gutters are gorgeous. They worked really hard. They were very easy to talk to. I would recommend them to anybody."

Laurie G on July 2022

Thank you for making the VIP choice. We’re a local Veteran owned Seamless Gutter Installation Company. We specialize in both 5” & 6” gutters. Our gutters come with a 30 year warranty and we stand behind our work with a 5 year workmanship guarantee. If you need leaf guards and are tired of constantly cleaning your gutters, we’re your #1 choice in gutter guard protection. Not only do we know gutters, we know what products really work to keep the leaves and critters out. Our gutter guards come with a lifetime warranty and 100% clog free guarantee. No nonsense and no high pressure sales tactics, just quality gutters, quality workmanship and VIP service. Call us today to set up your free estimate.

"It was wonderful. The gutters are gorgeous. They worked really hard. They were very easy to talk to. I would recommend them to anybody."

Laurie G on July 2022

Avatar for TESTA ROOFING L.L.C

TESTA ROOFING L.L.C

5.00(
18
)

TESTA ROOFING L.L.C

5.00(
18
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers

Roofer owned Roofer operated! Owner onsite at all times. Testa Roofing is a true craftsman roofing company that focuses on quality over quantity. With only one job going on at a time you can be rest assured that your project will be the main focus from start to finish.

"Nick and his crew was great. Nick was very easy to talk to and explained the process in advance. His crew started promptly on time. His crew consisted of skilled, well-coordinated and very hard working individuals. In this teardown job, they were able to do a seamless transition from one part of the roof that had an underlayment of cedar shingles to another part of the roof that had plywood underlayment. Tim was there all the time to supervise the work and Nick stopped by from time to time as well. They texted pictures along the way so we could see what was happening. We are very happy with the new roof. It looks great and they did a quality job. They put our lightening arresters back up when they were done too."

Elaine K on August 2025

Roofer owned Roofer operated! Owner onsite at all times. Testa Roofing is a true craftsman roofing company that focuses on quality over quantity. With only one job going on at a time you can be rest assured that your project will be the main focus from start to finish.

"Nick and his crew was great. Nick was very easy to talk to and explained the process in advance. His crew started promptly on time. His crew consisted of skilled, well-coordinated and very hard working individuals. In this teardown job, they were able to do a seamless transition from one part of the roof that had an underlayment of cedar shingles to another part of the roof that had plywood underlayment. Tim was there all the time to supervise the work and Nick stopped by from time to time as well. They texted pictures along the way so we could see what was happening. We are very happy with the new roof. It looks great and they did a quality job. They put our lightening arresters back up when they were done too."

Elaine K on August 2025

J.P.S General Contracting

3.00(
2
)

J.P.S General Contracting

3.00(
2
)

"We take pride in our work" is our company moto and it's not just a slogan, it's our way. From old to new construction. Specializing in exteriors and interiors...shingle and metal roofing, vinyl siding, painting/staining, electrical, insulation, drywall, bathroom and kitchen remodeling, doors and windows, seamless gutters and gutter cleaning, pressure washing. Licensed and insured for every job big or small. If your looking for a piece of mind, rest assured "Jack of all trades" we do it all and we do it right, Satisfaction Guaranteed!

"Very professional, great guy. I would highly recommend them."

William C on May 2021

"We take pride in our work" is our company moto and it's not just a slogan, it's our way. From old to new construction. Specializing in exteriors and interiors...shingle and metal roofing, vinyl siding, painting/staining, electrical, insulation, drywall, bathroom and kitchen remodeling, doors and windows, seamless gutters and gutter cleaning, pressure washing. Licensed and insured for every job big or small. If your looking for a piece of mind, rest assured "Jack of all trades" we do it all and we do it right, Satisfaction Guaranteed!

"Very professional, great guy. I would highly recommend them."

William C on May 2021

Avatar for Honey Do Lists LLC

Honey Do Lists LLC

5.00(
2
)

Honey Do Lists LLC

5.00(
2
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Honey Do lists LLC is family owned and operated since 2002. We specialize home exterior improvements, seamless gutters (installs and repairs), gutter leaf covers, aluminum fascia wraps, soffits, and so much more! We offer a diverse range of services tailored to meet the unique needs of every customer. We take a personalized approach to each project. We work closely with our clients to understand their vision, preferences, and budgetary requirements. We strive to exceed expectations by delivering exceptional service, great quality work, and professionalism on every job. We treat all our clients home just like our own. Read more below on all the services we offer and contact us with any questions or to schedule a free estimate today!

"Fantastic company to work with."

Jeffery R on April 2024

Honey Do lists LLC is family owned and operated since 2002. We specialize home exterior improvements, seamless gutters (installs and repairs), gutter leaf covers, aluminum fascia wraps, soffits, and so much more! We offer a diverse range of services tailored to meet the unique needs of every customer. We take a personalized approach to each project. We work closely with our clients to understand their vision, preferences, and budgetary requirements. We strive to exceed expectations by delivering exceptional service, great quality work, and professionalism on every job. We treat all our clients home just like our own. Read more below on all the services we offer and contact us with any questions or to schedule a free estimate today!

"Fantastic company to work with."

Jeffery R on April 2024

Avatar for Long Construction NY LLC

Long Construction NY LLC

4.85(
26
)

Long Construction NY LLC

4.85(
26
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers

We are a family owned and operated company that values honesty, integrity, and stands behind our work. We offer years of industry experience. We specialize in asphalt shingle roofing installation, replacement, and repairs. Our services are customized to the individual project, paying close attention to the details of each project that we are involved with. We look forward to building long-term relationships with our clients, and guarantee your satisfaction. Send us a message or call to request a free quote!

"We were thrilled with our experience working with Long Construction, which far exceeded our expectations. In particular, John O'liver played a crucial role in coordinating with my insurance company to ensure that my roof was installed and covered after the deductible. John is not only exceptionally knowledgeable about insurance processes but also incredibly personable—qualities that are rare to find in Monroe County. Working with him was a pleasure, and I would highly recommend Long Construction to any friends needing roofing services, especially if they have the chance to work with John and Bob. The entire experience with Long Construction was remarkable, and astonishingly, they completed the new big roof installation in just one day."

Ray H on August 2024

We are a family owned and operated company that values honesty, integrity, and stands behind our work. We offer years of industry experience. We specialize in asphalt shingle roofing installation, replacement, and repairs. Our services are customized to the individual project, paying close attention to the details of each project that we are involved with. We look forward to building long-term relationships with our clients, and guarantee your satisfaction. Send us a message or call to request a free quote!

"We were thrilled with our experience working with Long Construction, which far exceeded our expectations. In particular, John O'liver played a crucial role in coordinating with my insurance company to ensure that my roof was installed and covered after the deductible. John is not only exceptionally knowledgeable about insurance processes but also incredibly personable—qualities that are rare to find in Monroe County. Working with him was a pleasure, and I would highly recommend Long Construction to any friends needing roofing services, especially if they have the chance to work with John and Bob. The entire experience with Long Construction was remarkable, and astonishingly, they completed the new big roof installation in just one day."

Ray H on August 2024

Excel Property Maintenance

No reviews yet

Excel Property Maintenance

No reviews yet
14 years of experience

My business never sub-contracts our work to anyone else. I have two other, knowledgeable employees. Any jobs over $200 is required to put down a 50% deposit and the balance will be due upon completion and satisfaction of the job.

My business never sub-contracts our work to anyone else. I have two other, knowledgeable employees. Any jobs over $200 is required to put down a 50% deposit and the balance will be due upon completion and satisfaction of the job.

...
Showing 1-10 of 95
Gutter Repair and Replacement questions, answered by experts

Any small amount of standing water can be damaging to your gutters. It’s recommended that a ¼ inch puddle or more should be addressed. Failure to keep water from pooling in your gutters can result in clogs, algae growth, and pests that damage your gutters over time. 

You may have a clogged gutter. Downspouts can also clog if your gutter collects too much debris. Hire a professional gutter cleaner, and if you still have problems, install a gutter guard (which prevents debris from entering your gutter system) and a downspout extension (which helps drain water further away from your foundation, so it doesn't pool near your house). Follow these tips to keep your gutter downspouts clean.

Buried downspouts can freeze during cold weather as cold water runs through them. If you’ve discovered your downspouts are frozen, you can carefully pour hot water down the top of the downspout to defrost them. If that doesn’t work, you may need to dig your downspout back up. Avoid trying to break the ice from the exterior using a hammer as this can cause cracks and damage to your downspout.

To avoid freezing the future, consider adding a heating cable to the exterior, which can adjust heat based on the surrounding temperature.

Water should not be dripping behind your gutters. Rain dripping between your gutters and the fascia might indicate that the gutters are misaligned with the fascia board or there are loose screws in the gutters, allowing water to pass through. Start by checking for these issues and make repairs ASAP.

When it comes to which gutter material is better, the choice really boils down to what you're looking for in a gutter system. If saving money is the most important factor, then your best option is to go for aluminum gutters. If longevity and durability are more important to you, then copper gutters could be the best fit. If you want to customize the color of your gutters, aluminum takes the cake, but if you're looking for a more natural appearance, copper might be a better choice.

The York, NY homeowners’ guide to gutter repairs and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles