Matthew D.
Did a complete paint job floor to ceiling including the ceiling. Made the store look spectacular. Also customized a sliding barn door&Installed wood pannel for an accent wall.
Keller Painting
Get matched with top garage floor coating pros in Shelter Island, NY
There are 1 highly-rated local garage floor coating pros.
Need a pro for your garage floor coating project in Shelter Island, NY?
Select your specific project to find the pro for you.
TRUSTED BY SHELTER ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS
4.5 Average homeowner rating
23 Verified garage floor coating services reviews
Verified Reviews for Garage Floor Coating pros in Shelter Island, NY
Last update on October 11, 2025
- Keller Painting
- Pam B.
Eddy and Louie are great! Very personable, respectful, knowledgeable and reliable. They cleaned up after themselves and actually left the garage floor in better shape than when they arrived. Very quick - 3 1/2 hours to install 2 garage doors and 2 openers. Highly recommended!
Connecticut Garage Door Service, LLC - Eric F.
We had bought a new house and wanted to put in a number of upgrades. Although Floor Decorwasn't the cheapest bid, I was impressed by the owner's, Mike Phoenix's, patience and honesty. The contractors he used were all top notch and had been working with Mike for a long time. We had one...
- Sharon C.
The garage doors are old, clunky and difficult to open. Gaps on the sides produce cold air in the garage and also the rooms above. Since we're planning house renovations in the future, the thought of purchasing new doors wasn't something we were thrilled about, but I contacted the company...
Automatic Door
Find Garage floor coating pros in Shelter Island
Allied Construction Corp
26 Pagnotta Dr
Allied Construction Corp
26 Pagnotta Dr
Customers say: True professional
34 local quotes requested
36 years of experience
**We are now specializing in Kitchen Remodeling**At this time we are unable to take on Bathroom Remodeling projects**Our first priority has always been the satisfaction of our customers, and we take great pride in both the quality of our work and the quality of the customer service we extend to each and every one of our clients, regardless of the size of their project. When trusting Allied Construction Corporation with your home remodeling project, you are trusting a crew of dedicated and talented home remodeling experts to take you through every single step of the process, and to keep you up to date on developments. We always treat your project – and your home – with the utmost level of care and respect. We strive to ensure that every last detail of your work order is performed with the same level of quality we would apply to our own home. Our work over the years has proven to yield exceptionally high return on investment, making your home not only the haven you envisioned but also more valuable. What is more, we provide extremely affordable home remodeling services, making it possible for you to see your vision come to life without breaking the bank. We also offer Angie's List members a 10% Discount on all Labor. We have been on the Discovery Channel. (References upon request). Additional Phone: 516-500-8170 Additional email: [email protected].
"RUN FAR AWAY FROM ALLIED AND TOM. Tom took my money and did not complete the renovations as per our contract. He lied about having a licensed electrician to do electrical work, it was just one of his workers who's not licensed. I paid for a dumpster and when it was delivered by tom it was already half full from another allied job and I was asked to pay the full amount of $950. Tom didn't listen to anything I said regarding the work I requested and he changed my design and did work that was cheaper for him. I was priced for one of my ceiling's to be ripped out and reinstalled with new sheetrock, Tom waited until I was away on business then he installed sheetrock on top of the bad sheetrock and told me he ripped out the old sheetrock and installed the new sheetrock, I found out when my EC cut holes to install lights and we found 2 layers of sheetrock preventing the lights from being able to be installed. Allied construction is a cheap, sneaky company who will steal your money and breach your contract. Do not hire these people Tom is a lair. Tom wore a gun in my house on his hip and told me "I use this to get paid by customer who don't want to pay". Tom left live 120v wires hanging out of the walls and ceiling, he removed a banister and didn't replace it for 3 weeks making my home very unsafe for me and my 9 year old son."
Adam C on May 2025
**We are now specializing in Kitchen Remodeling**At this time we are unable to take on Bathroom Remodeling projects**Our first priority has always been the satisfaction of our customers, and we take great pride in both the quality of our work and the quality of the customer service we extend to each and every one of our clients, regardless of the size of their project. When trusting Allied Construction Corporation with your home remodeling project, you are trusting a crew of dedicated and talented home remodeling experts to take you through every single step of the process, and to keep you up to date on developments. We always treat your project – and your home – with the utmost level of care and respect. We strive to ensure that every last detail of your work order is performed with the same level of quality we would apply to our own home. Our work over the years has proven to yield exceptionally high return on investment, making your home not only the haven you envisioned but also more valuable. What is more, we provide extremely affordable home remodeling services, making it possible for you to see your vision come to life without breaking the bank. We also offer Angie's List members a 10% Discount on all Labor. We have been on the Discovery Channel. (References upon request). Additional Phone: 516-500-8170 Additional email: [email protected].
"RUN FAR AWAY FROM ALLIED AND TOM. Tom took my money and did not complete the renovations as per our contract. He lied about having a licensed electrician to do electrical work, it was just one of his workers who's not licensed. I paid for a dumpster and when it was delivered by tom it was already half full from another allied job and I was asked to pay the full amount of $950. Tom didn't listen to anything I said regarding the work I requested and he changed my design and did work that was cheaper for him. I was priced for one of my ceiling's to be ripped out and reinstalled with new sheetrock, Tom waited until I was away on business then he installed sheetrock on top of the bad sheetrock and told me he ripped out the old sheetrock and installed the new sheetrock, I found out when my EC cut holes to install lights and we found 2 layers of sheetrock preventing the lights from being able to be installed. Allied construction is a cheap, sneaky company who will steal your money and breach your contract. Do not hire these people Tom is a lair. Tom wore a gun in my house on his hip and told me "I use this to get paid by customer who don't want to pay". Tom left live 120v wires hanging out of the walls and ceiling, he removed a banister and didn't replace it for 3 weeks making my home very unsafe for me and my 9 year old son."
Adam C on May 2025
Cocos Custom Building LLC
66 Radburn Drive
Cocos Custom Building LLC
66 Radburn Drive
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
447 local quotes requested
Coco’s Custom Building LLC specializes in setting and finishing Modular Homes, fabricating and installing structural steel, and all phases of residential and commercial construction. This includes extensions, dormers, basements, siding, exterior trim and roofing. We have 25 years of experience. We take pride in giving our customers a professional quality finish on all of our projects for a reasonable price. We work extremely hard to ensure that our customers hard earned money doesn’t go to waste.
"Excellent. On time and on budget"
Brian D on January 2025
Coco’s Custom Building LLC specializes in setting and finishing Modular Homes, fabricating and installing structural steel, and all phases of residential and commercial construction. This includes extensions, dormers, basements, siding, exterior trim and roofing. We have 25 years of experience. We take pride in giving our customers a professional quality finish on all of our projects for a reasonable price. We work extremely hard to ensure that our customers hard earned money doesn’t go to waste.
"Excellent. On time and on budget"
Brian D on January 2025
JL Remodeling
124 Queens Lane
JL Remodeling
124 Queens Lane
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
JL Remodeling has built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. We service both residential and commercial properties. We give you the peace of mind you need to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started! HOLIDAYS DISCOUNT APPLY
"Super honest and efficient, hard working and knowledgeable"
Alex C on December 2024
JL Remodeling has built an excellent reputation for customer satisfaction by providing quick estimates, great attention to detail, and competitive pricing. We service both residential and commercial properties. We give you the peace of mind you need to give your home the attention it deserves. Call us today and let's get started! HOLIDAYS DISCOUNT APPLY
"Super honest and efficient, hard working and knowledgeable"
Alex C on December 2024
Paradise Handyman Services
Paradise Handyman Services
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
We are there for your home remodeling and repair needs. We also specialize in building storage compartments and shelving, garage remodeling, and junk removal.
"Yes, execllent job done"
Robin S on February 2025
We are there for your home remodeling and repair needs. We also specialize in building storage compartments and shelving, garage remodeling, and junk removal.
"Yes, execllent job done"
Robin S on February 2025
PRO COAT NY
PRO COAT NY
1 years of experience
Welcome to PROCOAT NY, your premier destination for top-quality epoxy flooring solutions. Specializing in flake, metallic, and resin epoxy systems, we offer a wide range of options to suit both commercial and residential needs. Our expert team is dedicated to delivering exceptional results, backed by years of experience and a commitment to excellence. With PROCOAT NY, you can expect personalized service, free consultations, and flooring solutions that exceed your expectations.
Welcome to PROCOAT NY, your premier destination for top-quality epoxy flooring solutions. Specializing in flake, metallic, and resin epoxy systems, we offer a wide range of options to suit both commercial and residential needs. Our expert team is dedicated to delivering exceptional results, backed by years of experience and a commitment to excellence. With PROCOAT NY, you can expect personalized service, free consultations, and flooring solutions that exceed your expectations.
Visionary Stone Works
Visionary Stone Works
Experienced Stone Mason/Tile Setter & Carpenter Available in Suffolk/Nassau Long Island! Are You Need Top-Tier Craftsmanship for Your Construction Project? Look No Further! With Over A Decade of Experience Working on High End Luxury Living Spaces and Massive Commercial Projects in New York City. I Specialize in Transforming Spaces with Precision and Creativity. From Stunning Kitchen Countertops and Luxurious Master Bathrooms to Rough Carpentry, Finish Molding and Elegant Outdoor Spaces. I Bring Your Visions to Life. Services Offered: Kitchens & Bathrooms Stone Steps & Patios Fireplaces & Bars Finish Molding & Decking Vinyl & Laminate Flooring Anything Masonry, Stone, Tile, Wood & More What Sets Me Apart? My Commitment to Perfection and Fair, Negotiable Prices. Whether It's Revamping Your Indoor Spaces or Creating an Inviting Outdoor Oasis, I'm Your Go-To Professional.
Experienced Stone Mason/Tile Setter & Carpenter Available in Suffolk/Nassau Long Island! Are You Need Top-Tier Craftsmanship for Your Construction Project? Look No Further! With Over A Decade of Experience Working on High End Luxury Living Spaces and Massive Commercial Projects in New York City. I Specialize in Transforming Spaces with Precision and Creativity. From Stunning Kitchen Countertops and Luxurious Master Bathrooms to Rough Carpentry, Finish Molding and Elegant Outdoor Spaces. I Bring Your Visions to Life. Services Offered: Kitchens & Bathrooms Stone Steps & Patios Fireplaces & Bars Finish Molding & Decking Vinyl & Laminate Flooring Anything Masonry, Stone, Tile, Wood & More What Sets Me Apart? My Commitment to Perfection and Fair, Negotiable Prices. Whether It's Revamping Your Indoor Spaces or Creating an Inviting Outdoor Oasis, I'm Your Go-To Professional.
AMCM Services
33 Whalers Dr
AMCM Services
33 Whalers Dr
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
With two decades of expertise, our contracting and remodeling business specializes in revitalizing homes with a rich history. From renovations to antique house restoration, we bring a wealth of experience to every project. Trust us to seamlessly blend modern comfort with timeless charm, creating spaces that stand the test of time.
"This team is wonderful and can virtually do anything you need done. Beautiful finished carpentry. Very talented and reliable. We have worked with this team for 20 years over multiple properties.We do not hesitate to recommend enthusiastically. Wonderful design aesthetic. Excellent practical can-do approach. Very nice people. good prices. Terrific results and value for money."
Frank A on December 2023
With two decades of expertise, our contracting and remodeling business specializes in revitalizing homes with a rich history. From renovations to antique house restoration, we bring a wealth of experience to every project. Trust us to seamlessly blend modern comfort with timeless charm, creating spaces that stand the test of time.
"This team is wonderful and can virtually do anything you need done. Beautiful finished carpentry. Very talented and reliable. We have worked with this team for 20 years over multiple properties.We do not hesitate to recommend enthusiastically. Wonderful design aesthetic. Excellent practical can-do approach. Very nice people. good prices. Terrific results and value for money."
Frank A on December 2023
Ridge Remodeling
130-30 232nd St
Ridge Remodeling
130-30 232nd St
Free onsite estimate
Effective and efficient
Effective and efficient
Dylan Ray Contracting, LLC
Based In
Dylan Ray Contracting, LLC
Based In
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
Dylan Ray Contracting is a trusted and reliable company providing excellent construction services to residential clients across Long Island. Whether you need home remodeling, kitchen and bathroom renovations or a home extension, you can rely on us. Our combined expertise in all phases of construction makes us confident to guarantee that you will receive nothing but exceptional craftsmanship when you choose us. No job is too big or too small for our dedicated company.
"Excellent work!!"
William B on November 2023
Dylan Ray Contracting is a trusted and reliable company providing excellent construction services to residential clients across Long Island. Whether you need home remodeling, kitchen and bathroom renovations or a home extension, you can rely on us. Our combined expertise in all phases of construction makes us confident to guarantee that you will receive nothing but exceptional craftsmanship when you choose us. No job is too big or too small for our dedicated company.
"Excellent work!!"
William B on November 2023
LAJ Contracting Corp
100 Jefferson Ave
LAJ Contracting Corp
100 Jefferson Ave
Free onsite estimate
"LAJ Contracting NY Corp. is a 100% insured company. We have more than 20 years of experience in the construction industry. We specialize in in a various of different services like remodeling, carpentry, flooring, bathroom, kitchen, windows, drywall, painting, plumbing and much more."
"LAJ Contracting NY Corp. is a 100% insured company. We have more than 20 years of experience in the construction industry. We specialize in in a various of different services like remodeling, carpentry, flooring, bathroom, kitchen, windows, drywall, painting, plumbing and much more."
FAQs for garage floor coating projects in Shelter Island, NY
The cost of an epoxy floor is $2,430 on average, ranging from $730 to $5,300. Factors that impact the overall cost include the total square footage, the type of epoxy, and any decorative options.
The epoxy flooring cost in a one-car garage is $720 to $2,900. However, that cost jumps to $1,100 to $4,300 for a two-car garage, which is 360 square feet on average. Adding decorative flakes to your flooring costs roughly $10 per 250-pound bag, but if you want metallic epoxy, that’ll cost you between $5 and $12 per square foot.
An epoxy floor can last between 10 and 20 years, depending on the material and its frequency of use. Factors like heavy foot traffic, sunlight exposure, and the weight of vehicles on it impact the overall longevity.
To ensure your floor lasts as long as possible, clean it often, as debris buildup can scratch the epoxy. Remember never to use any kind of rough pads, only a soft mop, to avoid scratches as well. In addition, if your epoxy coating needs repair, it’s best to repair it as quickly as possible to avoid more significant damage.
The cost to convert a carport into a garage averages about $22,000, ranging from about $15,000 and $55,000. Additional cost factors to consider include size, time of year, and how much of the carport you can reuse. Other cost factors include the kinds and amounts of materials used, such as:
Add insulation: $1 per square foot
Add drywall: $1–$3 per square foot
Add window: $450–$2,000 per window
Add outlets: $75–$500
Add garage door: $250–$11,200
Enclose framing: $5–$13 per square foot
Replace roofing: $1,000–$2,000
The cost to build a detached garage for two cars costs about $26,400 on average. Prices range from $19,200 to $33,600, depending on your location, the garage size, height, materials, and site prep required. Additional cost factors include any plumbing, electrical wiring, and insulation. If you need to build a concrete foundation for a new detached garage, you can expect to pay $1,000 to $8,600 for this essential addition.
The average cost to remodel a garage is around $18,000, ranging from $1,500 to $50,000, depending on size, materials, location, and other factors like plumbing and electrical. Garage remodels that include changing the roof and walls add significant expenses to the project. Plus, you can expect to pay about $1,400 for the building conversion permits. For a simple remodel, like painting interior walls and recoating the garage floor, it will cost about $2 to $5 per square foot.
The Shelter Island, NY homeowners’ guide to garage floor coating services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
Garage floor replacement costs $2,200 on average but can vary depending on several factors. Review our guide for a more accurate estimate.
How much does it cost to insulate a garage? Discover insulation options, prices, and expected and unexpected circumstances that affect the project cost.
Pole barns are a relatively affordable type of barn, but installation costs can add up depending on size. Use this handy guide to budget your pole barn costs.
Thinking about repurposing your garage? Use these garage conversion ideas to transform your area and get the most use and added home value possible.
Sealing your concrete helps it last longer—and look better. Learn how to seal concrete yourself to save money and keep it looking and performing like new.
If you’re considering buying or building a home with a one-car garage size, it’s helpful to learn everything you need to know about this garage setup.
- Shelter Island Heights, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Greenport, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Southold, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Peconic, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Sag Harbor, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Bridgehampton, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Orient, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Cutchogue, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Wainscott, NY Garage floor coating pros
- East Hampton, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Southampton, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Water Mill, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Mattituck, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Amagansett, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Laurel, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Jamesport, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Aquebogue, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Hampton Bays, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Old Saybrook, CT Garage floor coating pros
- Westbrook, CT Garage floor coating pros
- Old Lyme, CT Garage floor coating pros
- Lyme, CT Garage floor coating pros
- Clinton, CT Garage floor coating pros
- Niantic, CT Garage floor coating pros
- Riverhead, NY Garage floor coating pros
- East Quogue, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Ivoryton, CT Garage floor coating pros
- Montauk, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Fishers Island, NY Garage floor coating pros
- Essex, CT Garage floor coating pros