4.6 
404 *The Angi rating for Roofing companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Roofing needs.
*The HomeAdvisor rating for Roofing companies in Fishers Island, NY is a rating based on verified reviews from our community of homeowners who have used these pros to meet their Roofing needs.
Last update on March 22, 2026
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 1983
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"They did and awesome job. I will recommend them to anyone,that needs work on there roof."
+19
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2018
Free estimates
Credit card accepted
"Nick was nice and fixed the roof right away."
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2016
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"Best roofing contractor I've had the pleasure to work with. Sav-A-Roof did my house with great skill, fast, clean and fair priced. Thanks again to John and the staff at Sav-A-Roof"
+48
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2005
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"I highly recommend Double A to anyone in need of roofing services. They are reliable, efficient, and dedicated to providing exceptional quality service."
+1
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2012
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"We have been having a problem with pigeons hanging around all day on/under our solar panels. I originally had a handyman who was going to install mesh around the edges of the panels and yesterday (the day he was supposed to come) found out he didn't have insurance/license so I canceled. I then went into a Zoom meeting and heard the darn pigeons cooing and fluttering all over the roof and got so upset. I came to Angi and found Best Choice Roofing (aka Best Way) - he called me back right away and in less than an hour he was here. The first thing he did was hand me his business card with his License # on it. Very professional. He got up on the roof, then in a few minutes came down and gave me an estimate. Once I accepted, he called his team to assist and he started on the roof. They were super clean - blew out my gutters, blew everything out from under the solar panels, and made sure to blow the porch and front of my house to remove any debris. I had peace of mind that they were licensed and insured. Today I am happy to announce, I have not heard ONE PIGEON! I know this company usually does more like roofing and gutter-type projects, but I will be letting any of my neighbors with solar panels/pigeons know who to call. Great crew. Thanks so much!"
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2015
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"A+ Reliable Roofing is the perfect name for this company along with dependable. Nick called when he was supposed to. He came when he said he would. He knew exactly what he was doing and he completed the two jobs I had in a very reasonable amount of time. I would absolutely hire him again and recommend him to anybody. He was also extremely pleasant and helpful."
+5
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2010
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"Genti of Proper Construction was a pleasure to deal with. He replaced rotted cedar shake on a very steep incline on one of my dormers. The job was done quickly, efficiently and at a terrific value. Would highly recommend and use again."
+1
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2015
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"Steve from Landstar Construction was honest and gave me a very fair price. The finished job was excellent and I was extremely happy with my new roof. I highly recommend Landstar Construction for your roofing needs."
+3
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
In business since 2020
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
"That did a nice Job! Very efficient. Pleasant to work with! They repaired a leak in my roof!"
Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas
Approved
Super Service Award Winner
In business since 2024
Free estimates
Emergency services offered
Premium Renovations NY is a trusted, family-owned company proudly serving Long Island since 2016 We specialize in roofing, siding, decking, gutters, and chimney services for residential and commercial properties. From roof repairs and replacements to vinyl and cedar siding, custom decks, gutter installations, and chimney maintenance, our experienced team delivers high-quality work with honest pricing and fast response times. Fully licensed and insured, we serve Suffolk and Nassau County with reliable craftsmanship and free estimates. Contact us today at 631-294-6009 for dependable service and lasting results.\n\n
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
If you need a new flat roof, learn about tar and gravel roof costs and what can affect your total to make sure you budget accurately.
Did you know there are different types of roof inspections? This guide will help you weigh roof inspection costs to figure out what’s worth it.
The average cost of roof repair for U.S. homeowners averages between $386 and $1,875. Learn what factors can affect roof repair costs.
Sealing your roof can help preserve its life span—you just have to choose the right coating. This guide will help you budget for your total roof coating cost.
A new metal roof can add a unique touch to your home’s curb appeal and help maximize efficiency. Learn about metal roof costs and what affects your total.
Copper is a luxury roofing material that’s highly desirable and maximizes curb appeal. Learn about copper roof costs and price factors in this guide.
