Top-rated handymen.

Get matched with top handymen in Fishers Island, NY

There are 21 highly-rated local handymen.

Need a pro for your handyman service project in Fishers Island, NY?

Select your specific project to find the pro for you.

TRUSTED BY FISHERS ISLAND, NY HOMEOWNERS

  • Average homeowner rating star icon4.4
    Average homeowner rating
  • Verified reviews icon330
    Verified handyman services reviews

Find Handymen in Fishers Island

Avatar for All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration

All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration

144 Simonson Avenue
4.81(
220
)
Approved Pro

All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration

144 Simonson Avenue
4.81(
220
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
2872 local quotes requested

The Professional Team of All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration is capable of handling, as well as carrying everything necessary to provide immediate on-site furniture disassembling, assembling and all repairs, on wood, leather, vinyl, fabric, upholstery, restorations of antiques, metal, stone, and mechanisms. Methods and products are chosen to make their repairs permanent, invisible and to return furniture to its original or even better condition. On-site or in-shop services offered to all: Manufactures, Stores, Vendors, Warehouses, Designers, Hotels, Restaurants, Construction, Moving, Insurance Companies as well as Individual Customers. We have been at the forefront of the Antique and Modern Repair & Restoration.

"Dmytro is a pro!! He worked very hard to get my recliner back in shape!! Great job Dmytro! Thanks again."

Nancy B on September 2025

The Professional Team of All Furniture Services® Repair & Restoration is capable of handling, as well as carrying everything necessary to provide immediate on-site furniture disassembling, assembling and all repairs, on wood, leather, vinyl, fabric, upholstery, restorations of antiques, metal, stone, and mechanisms. Methods and products are chosen to make their repairs permanent, invisible and to return furniture to its original or even better condition. On-site or in-shop services offered to all: Manufactures, Stores, Vendors, Warehouses, Designers, Hotels, Restaurants, Construction, Moving, Insurance Companies as well as Individual Customers. We have been at the forefront of the Antique and Modern Repair & Restoration.

"Dmytro is a pro!! He worked very hard to get my recliner back in shape!! Great job Dmytro! Thanks again."

Nancy B on September 2025



Avatar for Neversweat Property Management

Neversweat Property Management

5.00(
3
)
Approved Pro

Neversweat Property Management

5.00(
3
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
74 local quotes requested

Neversweat Property Management specializes in the care and maintenance of properties in the picturesque East End of Long Island. Our dedicated team offers a comprehensive range of services, including property management, seasonal house care, and handyman repairs. With a passion for excellence and a commitment to property owners, we ensure that each property thrives, allowing our clients to enjoy peace of mind and the full experience of East End living. At Neversweat, we take care of your property as if it were our own, making your investment our responsibility.

"Everything went great, went over and above to make sure that we were pleased with the job."

Carlos F on November 2023

Neversweat Property Management specializes in the care and maintenance of properties in the picturesque East End of Long Island. Our dedicated team offers a comprehensive range of services, including property management, seasonal house care, and handyman repairs. With a passion for excellence and a commitment to property owners, we ensure that each property thrives, allowing our clients to enjoy peace of mind and the full experience of East End living. At Neversweat, we take care of your property as if it were our own, making your investment our responsibility.

"Everything went great, went over and above to make sure that we were pleased with the job."

Carlos F on November 2023


Avatar for Paradise Handyman Services

Paradise Handyman Services

5.00(
4
)
Approved Pro

Paradise Handyman Services

5.00(
4
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
205 local quotes requested

We are there for your home remodeling and repair needs. We also specialize in building storage compartments and shelving, garage remodeling, and junk removal.

"Yes, execllent job done"

Robin S on February 2025

We are there for your home remodeling and repair needs. We also specialize in building storage compartments and shelving, garage remodeling, and junk removal.

"Yes, execllent job done"

Robin S on February 2025


Avatar for Magic Improvement, LLC

Magic Improvement, LLC

220 Broadway Green Long
4.99(
50
)
Approved Pro

Magic Improvement, LLC

220 Broadway Green Long
4.99(
50
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
28 local quotes requested
20 years of experience

We are extremely passionate about the work that we do. You can depend on us to provide a high quality service at a fair and honest price. We understand that the future of our business depends upon our reputation and that is why customer service is by far our highest priority. If you are looking for a professional you can trust, please call today to schedule a no-obligation estimate!

"Magic improvement. Magically improved my old bathroom. They respect your home, always clean after. Listen to you . One of his Angels crew , name Rimo worked at my bathroom. Very hard worker. Professional. All the job was done Professionallly. Just wanna mention! All the reviews about Angel was. true. Lucky to have him.. see you next year for next project at my house~~~~"

Helen Y on October 2025

We are extremely passionate about the work that we do. You can depend on us to provide a high quality service at a fair and honest price. We understand that the future of our business depends upon our reputation and that is why customer service is by far our highest priority. If you are looking for a professional you can trust, please call today to schedule a no-obligation estimate!

"Magic improvement. Magically improved my old bathroom. They respect your home, always clean after. Listen to you . One of his Angels crew , name Rimo worked at my bathroom. Very hard worker. Professional. All the job was done Professionallly. Just wanna mention! All the reviews about Angel was. true. Lucky to have him.. see you next year for next project at my house~~~~"

Helen Y on October 2025




Our House Property Management

77 Gould Street
No reviews yet

Our House Property Management

77 Gould Street
No reviews yet
4 years of experience

Our House Property Management can take care of all your vacation home management needs. No request is too big or too small and we would be happy to discuss your specific property management needs. Our most popular service offerings include weekly property inspections, package collection, project coordination, starting/running vehicles and pantry stocking. Having a property manager is not a luxury, it’s a sensible decision to ensure your home is always in top shape and give you peace of mind while you’re out of town.

Our House Property Management can take care of all your vacation home management needs. No request is too big or too small and we would be happy to discuss your specific property management needs. Our most popular service offerings include weekly property inspections, package collection, project coordination, starting/running vehicles and pantry stocking. Having a property manager is not a luxury, it’s a sensible decision to ensure your home is always in top shape and give you peace of mind while you’re out of town.



J&R PAUTE CARPENTRY LLC

171 Bellport Avenue
4.50(
6
)

J&R PAUTE CARPENTRY LLC

171 Bellport Avenue
4.50(
6
)
Customers say: Super punctual
138 local quotes requested

Construcción works, interior exterior, remodeling,decks, woodenfloors Remodeling basements general works. Our mission is to be a provider that brings back the personal touch with our customers. We will build a relationship that will last a lifetime after you see our quality work. As a locally owned and operated business, we feel invested in our clients and constantly strive for customer satisfaction. Call or message us to schedule an estimate today!

"Hector and his crew were highly recommended by a friend of ours. We are so happy with the quality of the work and the professionalism. They were prompt and left our home clean. We highly recommend Hector's company and plan to use him for another job."

John K on August 2025

Construcción works, interior exterior, remodeling,decks, woodenfloors Remodeling basements general works. Our mission is to be a provider that brings back the personal touch with our customers. We will build a relationship that will last a lifetime after you see our quality work. As a locally owned and operated business, we feel invested in our clients and constantly strive for customer satisfaction. Call or message us to schedule an estimate today!

"Hector and his crew were highly recommended by a friend of ours. We are so happy with the quality of the work and the professionalism. They were prompt and left our home clean. We highly recommend Hector's company and plan to use him for another job."

John K on August 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 202
Handyman Services questions, answered by experts

Pros save time and ensure quality by handling complex tasks and repairs efficiently.

Discuss design preferences and material choices before work begins for cohesive results.

Whether a scullery is worth it depends on how much you like to cook and entertain. If you frequently host gatherings—a scullery is likely worth the money. If you’re looking for ROI, it’s not so clear. It may not add significant value to your home, as it doesn’t increase square footage and may repurpose space that a buyer would have preferred to remain as-is (like a laundry room). 

Yes, many repair services include blade sharpening as part of the maintenance package.

You can tackle hanging Christmas lights yourself with the right tools, accessories, and a trusted friend or neighbor. You’ll need to purchase a ladder ($100 to $300), clips ($10 to $20), hooks ($10 to $15), and lights ($25 to $100 per string).

Otherwise, you should hire a trusted holiday light installer near you. You’ll pay an average price of $200 to $650, but you’ll have peace of mind knowing that the job is done correctly and safely.

By submitting this question, I acknowledge and agree that Angi may publicly display my name, city, state, and question on the website for professionals and others to see.

The Fishers Island, NY homeowners’ guide to handyman services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.