Top-rated water heater pros.

Get matched with top water heater pros in Butlerville, IN

Enter your ZIP and get matched with up to 5 pros

Find Water heater pros in Butlerville

Avatar for Greenwell Plumbing Heating & Air

Greenwell Plumbing Heating & Air

1840 Scott Rd
4.50(
100
)
Approved Pro

Greenwell Plumbing Heating & Air

1840 Scott Rd
4.50(
100
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
240 local quotes requested
31 years of experience

We're your neighborhood plumbing, heating, and air company. We've been providing "Simply Dependable" services in Southern Indiana since 1972. We can take care of all your plumbing and HVAC needs, 24 hours a day, when you need us we will be there!!! We are proud of our service tech's and do monthly training and product awareness with our service team. Tech's are clean, drug-tested, and uniformed, we use shoe covers and floor runners when working on your home. We clean up after every job.

"They got the old sump pump removed and installed the new one. They even disposed of the old stuff which I greatly appreciated. They were wonderful and would call on Greenwell Plumbing again."

Sharon J on May 2025

We're your neighborhood plumbing, heating, and air company. We've been providing "Simply Dependable" services in Southern Indiana since 1972. We can take care of all your plumbing and HVAC needs, 24 hours a day, when you need us we will be there!!! We are proud of our service tech's and do monthly training and product awareness with our service team. Tech's are clean, drug-tested, and uniformed, we use shoe covers and floor runners when working on your home. We clean up after every job.

"They got the old sump pump removed and installed the new one. They even disposed of the old stuff which I greatly appreciated. They were wonderful and would call on Greenwell Plumbing again."

Sharon J on May 2025


Cincinnati Refrigeration

7721 Bridgetown Rd
5.00(
1
)
Approved Pro

Cincinnati Refrigeration

7721 Bridgetown Rd
5.00(
1
)
Approved Pro
5 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Cincinnati Refrigeration is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers' interests and make their concerns the basis of our business.

"Cincinnati Refrigeration did a great job at a great price. Highly recommend! "

Sharon H on July 2025

Cincinnati Refrigeration is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers' interests and make their concerns the basis of our business.

"Cincinnati Refrigeration did a great job at a great price. Highly recommend! "

Sharon H on July 2025


Avatar for ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

Headquarters: 4580 Bridgeway Avenue
4.47(
319
)
Approved Pro

ImproveIt! Home Remodeling, Inc.

Headquarters: 4580 Bridgeway Avenue
4.47(
319
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
1663 local quotes requested
36 years of experience

Since 1989, ImproveIt Home Remodeling, Inc., has specialized in helping homeowners improve the beauty, comfort and energy-efficiency of their homes. Our mission is simple: to provide each and every homeowner complete satisfaction through every step of the remodeling process. We don't just stand behind our work with lifetime product and labor warranties; we strive to deliver total satisfaction and complete peace-of-mind. During our 29 years, we are honored to have been named one of the top 50 remodelers by Remodeling Magazine, and to have won 21 Consumers Choice Awards. BBB accredited with an A+ Rating, we have helped over 50,000 customers. We serve communities across Central Ohio (Columbus, Dayton and Cincinnati) and Kentucky (Louisville and Lexington). Choose Improveit Home Remodeling to transform your bathroom or save on high utility bills with our Energy-star rated SolarTech replacement windows.

"They claimed that they were finished and left nails sticking out of the wall. When I tried to call the supervisor I found out that the number was not connected. This is good customer service? I now realize that I paid to much for the sloppy work."

Sherri M on August 2025

Since 1989, ImproveIt Home Remodeling, Inc., has specialized in helping homeowners improve the beauty, comfort and energy-efficiency of their homes. Our mission is simple: to provide each and every homeowner complete satisfaction through every step of the remodeling process. We don't just stand behind our work with lifetime product and labor warranties; we strive to deliver total satisfaction and complete peace-of-mind. During our 29 years, we are honored to have been named one of the top 50 remodelers by Remodeling Magazine, and to have won 21 Consumers Choice Awards. BBB accredited with an A+ Rating, we have helped over 50,000 customers. We serve communities across Central Ohio (Columbus, Dayton and Cincinnati) and Kentucky (Louisville and Lexington). Choose Improveit Home Remodeling to transform your bathroom or save on high utility bills with our Energy-star rated SolarTech replacement windows.

"They claimed that they were finished and left nails sticking out of the wall. When I tried to call the supervisor I found out that the number was not connected. This is good customer service? I now realize that I paid to much for the sloppy work."

Sherri M on August 2025


Milburn Mechanical Services, LLC

3209 W County Rd 850 S
5.00(
2
)
Approved Pro

Milburn Mechanical Services, LLC

3209 W County Rd 850 S
5.00(
2
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
14 local quotes requested
6 years of experience

At Milburn Mechanical Services LLC, we are your premier choice for all you HVAC needs. We have provided high quality work and friendly customer service for years. Choose the best not the rest. We will not let you down. Great work at a great price. A+ quality. Call today!

"Good quality work and very professional!"

Jeff W on November 2021

At Milburn Mechanical Services LLC, we are your premier choice for all you HVAC needs. We have provided high quality work and friendly customer service for years. Choose the best not the rest. We will not let you down. Great work at a great price. A+ quality. Call today!

"Good quality work and very professional!"

Jeff W on November 2021


Avatar for BL Ohio

BL Ohio

3195 Dayton-Xenia Rd
No reviews yet

BL Ohio

3195 Dayton-Xenia Rd
No reviews yet
26 years of experience

For over 25 Years BL has specialized in All Source Services, From The Footer To The Ridge, with pricing that always beats the big box stores and with quality that out paces your local handyman! (Trust us, we've seen some of the worst, cleaned up after some of the worst) Don't leave your project unfinished! Don't let the big box companies tell you that, that service is for another contractor, or it will cost you thousands more! (Big Box Guys, frequently have left massive holes in Clients walls, huge messes on the floor and walls, holes in your yard, and just generally incomplete work, left for you to hire another company. Over 350 services and projects performed this year alone! No advertising required, just providing Top Tier Quality Standards is enough! Make BL your only call! No matter the client, Landlord, Homeowner, or Business Owner, we will work with you fully in house on your project or service! All Forms Of Payment Accepted Buy Now Pay Later Options Available!

For over 25 Years BL has specialized in All Source Services, From The Footer To The Ridge, with pricing that always beats the big box stores and with quality that out paces your local handyman! (Trust us, we've seen some of the worst, cleaned up after some of the worst) Don't leave your project unfinished! Don't let the big box companies tell you that, that service is for another contractor, or it will cost you thousands more! (Big Box Guys, frequently have left massive holes in Clients walls, huge messes on the floor and walls, holes in your yard, and just generally incomplete work, left for you to hire another company. Over 350 services and projects performed this year alone! No advertising required, just providing Top Tier Quality Standards is enough! Make BL your only call! No matter the client, Landlord, Homeowner, or Business Owner, we will work with you fully in house on your project or service! All Forms Of Payment Accepted Buy Now Pay Later Options Available!


Avatar for Strong Man Construction

Strong Man Construction

No reviews yet

Strong Man Construction

No reviews yet

Thanks for choosing Strong Man Construction. Your Construction Contractor here to meet your needs. Handyman and property/ landlord services avaliable. From New Construction to remodeling old homes, We'll make your property great again! Call today to set up your free estimate.

Thanks for choosing Strong Man Construction. Your Construction Contractor here to meet your needs. Handyman and property/ landlord services avaliable. From New Construction to remodeling old homes, We'll make your property great again! Call today to set up your free estimate.


Local Handyman Services

105 E Main St
No reviews yet

Local Handyman Services

105 E Main St
No reviews yet
Emergency services offered

We are Bethany and Jason, operating LHS a professional handyman service based in the greater Indianapolis area and serving Central Indiana. We offer : * Project Management / Client Representation Sourcing contractors, inspecting & facilitating quality control, objective private bidding & estimating * Rough / Finish Carpentry fabrication & repair * Appliance Removal & Install (refrigerator, freezer, ice maker, plumbed-in coffee bars, trash compactors, dishwashers, range hoods/microwaves & associated ducting, house filtration systems, instant hot & beverage dispensers, drawers (microwave, dishwasher, refrigerator, warming in-cabinet drawers), in-cabinet wine chillers (humidors & cosmetics coolers as well), electric & gas ranges & ovens, dumb waiters and ADA mobility / stairlifts, laundry transportation systems, central vacuums * Media / Entertainment System mounting & wiring * Washers & Dryers Removal & install * Whole House Ventilators in-home smoke free / cigar lounge ventilators, dryer vent cleaning (no other ducts, just three & four inch) * Millwork (door/window removal & install, lead work & repair, customization) * Drywall installation & repair * General Maintenance * Plumbing appliances & fixtures (toilet, faucet, garbage disposal, wet bar / sinks & vanities, porcelain bidet, shower valve, pot filler: remove/install/repair) ...as a working shortlist. We specialize in bathroom remodels involve adding/deleting windows, multiple output bath fixtures such as: rainwater systems, omnidirectional body sprayers, also steam systems & saunas. Clients not only receive a detailed explanation, walk through, & introduction to their new system or appliance, but a portfolio of the beginning state, end state, work performed, applicable warranties for service, fittings, & appliances will all be explained with the necessary implied maintenance schedule, contact numbers, & next steps in the event of an emergency.

We are Bethany and Jason, operating LHS a professional handyman service based in the greater Indianapolis area and serving Central Indiana. We offer : * Project Management / Client Representation Sourcing contractors, inspecting & facilitating quality control, objective private bidding & estimating * Rough / Finish Carpentry fabrication & repair * Appliance Removal & Install (refrigerator, freezer, ice maker, plumbed-in coffee bars, trash compactors, dishwashers, range hoods/microwaves & associated ducting, house filtration systems, instant hot & beverage dispensers, drawers (microwave, dishwasher, refrigerator, warming in-cabinet drawers), in-cabinet wine chillers (humidors & cosmetics coolers as well), electric & gas ranges & ovens, dumb waiters and ADA mobility / stairlifts, laundry transportation systems, central vacuums * Media / Entertainment System mounting & wiring * Washers & Dryers Removal & install * Whole House Ventilators in-home smoke free / cigar lounge ventilators, dryer vent cleaning (no other ducts, just three & four inch) * Millwork (door/window removal & install, lead work & repair, customization) * Drywall installation & repair * General Maintenance * Plumbing appliances & fixtures (toilet, faucet, garbage disposal, wet bar / sinks & vanities, porcelain bidet, shower valve, pot filler: remove/install/repair) ...as a working shortlist. We specialize in bathroom remodels involve adding/deleting windows, multiple output bath fixtures such as: rainwater systems, omnidirectional body sprayers, also steam systems & saunas. Clients not only receive a detailed explanation, walk through, & introduction to their new system or appliance, but a portfolio of the beginning state, end state, work performed, applicable warranties for service, fittings, & appliances will all be explained with the necessary implied maintenance schedule, contact numbers, & next steps in the event of an emergency.


Avatar for Sears Appliance Repair

Sears Appliance Repair

Unknown
2.33(
3
)

Sears Appliance Repair

Unknown
2.33(
3
)
69 years of experience

Sears Home Services is America’s #1 appliance services provider. Our thousands of experts based throughout the U.S. deliver guaranteed quality and workmanship. We work on most makes and models whether they were purchased at Sears or not. We take care of your house so you can enjoy your home. Only Sears offers 3 unique ways to save on appliance repairs! 1. Standard Repair Service + 90 Day Guarantee • Cost is provided after technician diagnoses the problem • 90 day guarantee on parts and labor* 2. Flat Repair Cost + Extended Repair Coverage • $249.99 or $299.99 pre-set price (depending on type of appliance) • 1 year of coverage up to $500 for any additional repairs (includes parts)** 3. Flat Repair Cost + Multiple Appliance Coverage • $129.99 for your initial repair with purchase of Home Warranty Appliance Plan • 1 year of repair coverage for up to 10 appliances with 11 subsequent monthly payments of $49.99*** Book your appointment with a Sears expert technician today! * 90 Day Guarantee: The limited warranty provides that if within 90 days from the date of your Sears in-home repair your appliance fails to operate for reasons related to the original repair service when used normally in accordance with manufacturer guidelines, we will replace any parts that failed due to defects in the material or workmanship and perform any labor related to the original repair free of charge. Excludes damage caused due to service provided by any party other than Sears. This warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may have other rights that vary by state. ** Appliance must be less than 10 years old to qualify for Service Smart Agreement. Covers up to $500 in parts and labor. Limitations apply. *** Limitations apply”

Sears Home Services is America’s #1 appliance services provider. Our thousands of experts based throughout the U.S. deliver guaranteed quality and workmanship. We work on most makes and models whether they were purchased at Sears or not. We take care of your house so you can enjoy your home. Only Sears offers 3 unique ways to save on appliance repairs! 1. Standard Repair Service + 90 Day Guarantee • Cost is provided after technician diagnoses the problem • 90 day guarantee on parts and labor* 2. Flat Repair Cost + Extended Repair Coverage • $249.99 or $299.99 pre-set price (depending on type of appliance) • 1 year of coverage up to $500 for any additional repairs (includes parts)** 3. Flat Repair Cost + Multiple Appliance Coverage • $129.99 for your initial repair with purchase of Home Warranty Appliance Plan • 1 year of repair coverage for up to 10 appliances with 11 subsequent monthly payments of $49.99*** Book your appointment with a Sears expert technician today! * 90 Day Guarantee: The limited warranty provides that if within 90 days from the date of your Sears in-home repair your appliance fails to operate for reasons related to the original repair service when used normally in accordance with manufacturer guidelines, we will replace any parts that failed due to defects in the material or workmanship and perform any labor related to the original repair free of charge. Excludes damage caused due to service provided by any party other than Sears. This warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may have other rights that vary by state. ** Appliance must be less than 10 years old to qualify for Service Smart Agreement. Covers up to $500 in parts and labor. Limitations apply. *** Limitations apply”



Solar Wolf Energy

2.00(
2
)

Solar Wolf Energy

2.00(
2
)
10 years of experience

Solar Wolf is a full service solar company with a great reputation and an old world belief to our customers. To under-promise and over-deliver, period. We have 18 years experience in construction, remodeling, roofing, solar water heaters, solar pv systems, battery back-up systems and much more. See what Solar Wolf Energy can do for you!

Solar Wolf is a full service solar company with a great reputation and an old world belief to our customers. To under-promise and over-deliver, period. We have 18 years experience in construction, remodeling, roofing, solar water heaters, solar pv systems, battery back-up systems and much more. See what Solar Wolf Energy can do for you!

Showing 1-10 of 43
Water Heaters questions, answered by experts

The size needed for your expansion tank is determined by the size of your home's water heater. Expansion tanks are available in 2-gallon and 4.5-gallon sizes. A 2-gallon tank will be appropriate for water heaters up to 50 gallons. An adequately sized tank should have a volume that equals 2% to 5% of the water volume within the system. A plumber can evaluate your home's water pressure, water heater size, and other factors to provide suggestions for picking out the best expansion tank.

The lifespan of your water heater depends on the type of water. For traditional water heaters, you can expect it to last between 8 and 12 years if gas or 10 to 15 years if electric. Tankless water heaters can last up to 20 years with proper maintenance. The total number of years you’ll get out of your water heater depends on the maintenance it receives and how much it’s used.

The cost to install a new water heater depends on the type and its size, but homeowners pay between $900 and $1,800 on average. By contrast, you’ll pay much less for certain repairs, like replacing a broken gas valve, which costs between $150 and $550 on average.

The average cost to replace a water heater is $1,325. How much your replacement heater costs depends on the type, size, and complexity of installation. Gas and electric heaters may cost a similar amount out of pocket, but one type may cost more to operate than the other, depending on the cost of utilities in your area.

Not all types of water heaters require a venting system. Electric tankless water heaters don’t use natural or propane gas, so no venting is required. Instead, they use electric burners to heat water quickly and efficiently. However, any system that does use gas or propane will require ventilation.

The Butlerville, IN homeowners’ guide to water heater services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.